Creon And Achilles Essay

1498 words - 6 pages

Both Creon of Sophocles? Antigone and Achilles of Homer?s The Iliad end up allowing the body of their enemy a proper burial. During the time following the death of Hector, Achilles is in a position very similar to that which Creon deals with in Antigone. Both men show similar flaws, and face similar struggles. The difference between the two men is only subtly discernible until the telling moment when each man is faced with pressure to change his stance on the fate of the fallen warrior. Each man?s initial reaction is quite telling of his character, and the motives behind each man?s decision (although the motives are debatable) also help to expose his true nature. In the end, there seems to be a quality within each man which lies above the flaws, failures or triumphs. By suggesting such a quality, Sophocles and Homer glorify or debase characters such as Creon and Achilles.Rage, anger and revenge are exhibited by both Achilles and Creon. Achilles shows his rage in Book I of The Iliad when he speaks out against Agamemnon and refuses to fight, as well as in Book XXII when he avenges the death of Patroclus by the slaughter of Hector. Book XXIV, however, is the book in which Achilles situation most closely parallels that of Priam. To most objectively compare their characters, it is important that the situations we see them responding to are as similar as possible. In Antigone, the battle is over and all that remains are the remains of those fallen in battle. We have very little knowledge of how Creon behaved during the battle, and therefore should not overemphasize the detailed account of Achilles actions during battle that is supplied in earlier books of The Iliad. Creon initially exposes his rage and vengeance with the decree that Eteocles will be buried and Polynices will not. Creon says this of Polynices ?No, he must be left unburied, his corpse/ carrion for birds and dogs to tear/ an obscenity for the citizens to behold!? (231). A similar rage can be found in Achilles treatment of the body of Hector. Not only did Achilles deny the body a proper burial, but he dragged the dead body around tied to his chariot (XXIV-18). Later examples of rage are more plentiful in Creon?s case, as he rages against those who question the wisdom of his decision to let Polynices rot. Creon?s strongest rage is his rage against Antigone for attempting to bury Polynices. ?--she?ll never escape/ she and her blood sister, the most barbaric death (545). This ardent anger is left unparalleled by the actions of Achilles. Achilles shows only one additional spark of anger during the his conversation with Priam. Impatient for the return of his son?s body Priam says to Achilles ?Give him back to me, now, no more delay--/ I must see my son with my own eyes? (XXIV-650). To this Achilles responds angrily ?No more, old man, don?t tempt my wrath, not now!? (XXIV-656), ?So don?t anger me now. Don?t stir my raging heart still more./ Or under my own roof I may not spare your life, old...

Find Another Essay On Creon and Achilles

Oedipus as King of Thebes: Antigone by Sophocles

1827 words - 7 pages alternative choices. Hector had the choice of serving as a humble warrior seeking only to battle when necessary and Achilles had the choice of ignoring Agamemnon and not participating in the war. Another example of the ability of man to descend into destruction by way of his desire to achieve greatness can be cited in the Antigone by Sophocles. The character flaw that describes Creon as a firm ruler, which is his ability to stand on the side of the

How does Ignorance and Pride Play a Part in Man’s Destruction?

2242 words - 9 pages The choices we make define the destiny of our lives. Since the beginning of time, man has always been an imperfect being full of flaws. Man is faced with different situations that can end up bringing disgrace to himself and his family if the situations are not well handled. In the texts Book II of the Aeneid by Virgil, Antigone by Sophocles, Oedipus the king by Sophocles, and Book XXII from the Iliad by Homer; Creon, the Trojan people, Hector

Oedipus Rex: An Emotional Battlefield

2127 words - 9 pages flaws abound in the play. In his condemnation of Tiresias and Creon, Oedipus is controlled by his emotions. However, the heroism of Oedipus is also an essential theme of the drama, though it is often downplayed. Despite this, careful analysis can uncover many instances in which Oedipus exhibits his heroism by attempting to control his emotions and discover the truth of his origins. In his finest moments, Oedipus is in complete command of his emotions

Burial at Thebes

1648 words - 7 pages occurred to those that broke it. The crime Creon commits in not allowing burial for an enemy is one already familiar to classical audiences. In Homer’s Iliad much is made of the failure of the great Greek hero Achilles to treat the body of Hector correctly. Even the God’s darling is made to relent (Homer, trans Rieu, E. V. (1950), p on) so when Creon defies the Gods, their messenger, Tiresias, and his own elders, punishment would inevitably

Are Humans Animals, Or Are They Something More?

1167 words - 5 pages ;In Antigone, Creon is about as close to an animal as you can get. He refuses to bury his own nephew, Polynices. Even if Creon didn’t want him buried in Thebes, he could at least have his body sent back to his city to be buried. Then, after he finds out that Antigone buried Polynices, he sentences her, and her sister Ismene to death. He just assumes that Ismene helped Antigone, even though Ismene tried to talk Antigone out of burying Polynices

Oedipus as King of Thebes

1162 words - 5 pages enticing wrong, fueled by pride. The Journey that Oedipus, Creon, Hector and Achilles take even though they walk different roads, are all linked by one common flaw, pride. However the decision to fall for the lust of hubris and partake of it consequences according to Sophocles and Virgil, remains in the hands of men. That it is to say, good/greatness and evil stem from the same source that is the ability to want or do more. They stem from the same

Antigone- Bastion of Virtue

1653 words - 7 pages society is compelled to obey. For the prosecution, because Antigone disobeyed the sovereign, she broke the social contract, and deserves her guilt. The argument's reliance on a moral subjectivism stands out as its Achilles heel. Since virtuous actions performed our citizenry lead Thebes towards eudaimonia, any force to the contrary, even the actions of Creon (the sovereign), would deter from societies' happiness. Like Socrates professed in word

Iliad and Oedipus

1167 words - 5 pages then divided between Agamemnon and Achilles, the victors of the battle. In their exchange with each other, the two men refer to the women as prize and they become the property of the victors. The complete control of the victors over the women of the defeated side is made apparent from the fact that the father of Chrysies is willing to pay a ransom for her but Agamemnon is insistent that, “ The girl-I won’t give up the girl. Long before that, old

Shakespeare's Hamlet

1283 words - 6 pages is Creon in Oedipus Rex and Horatio in Hamlet. Their tragic flaw is that they are both ultimately and utterly doomed and no amount of guidance will steer them away from what has been predestined by fate. They are ultimately doomed to be their own Achilles heel. In Hamlet religion is not directly mentioned but a distinction is made between Heaven and Hell and good vs. evil. Hamlet is constantly battling his inner demons while trying to deal

Roman Myth

2690 words - 11 pages Greek literature. The poem narrates the account of the last year of Trojan War. The poem defines the return of Achilles from war, the death of Patroclus at the hands of the Trojan warrior Hector and Achilles' revenge from Hector. The poem concludes with the burial of Hector. The poem is about the annihilation of families during the war and the misfortunes, which were brought to those who were involved in the war. Theorists believe that Iliad

Oedipus rex by Sophocles

3002 words - 12 pages necessary and healthy activity for man to practice. In this sense Oedipus seems to be the ideal person as he uses a great deal of sound reasoning. He uses this sound reasoning to accurately judge the situation and continue on his path to identity such as when he states to the chorus leader that if the killer did not flinch at murder, then he will not flinch at the words of Oedipus' threats (175). He also uses his reason when he tells Creon that he

Similar Essays

Heroes: Achilles And Antigone Essay

1131 words - 5 pages the devotion to her family and the gods over devotion to the laws of man. When Antigone attempts to find aid from her sister Ismene she is denied. Ismene believes that there is nothing they can do because Creon has ordered them to do nothing. Antigone refuses this argument and goes alone because she believes she has a duty to her brother to bury his body and bring peace to his soul. After looking at Achilles and Antigone it is clear that there

Qualities Illustrated In Archaic And Classical Greek Novels

1582 words - 7 pages , “It’s not wrong to save your friends when they are beaten to the brink of death” (18). Patroclus proved his virtue by returning to the battle earlier than Achilles. In Antigone, Creon chose advisors because …I knew you as always loyal to the throne – at first, when Laius was king, and then again when Oedipus saved our city and then again when he died and you remained with steadfast truth to their descendants (167) Oedipus showed loyalty to his

Antigone Higher Law Vs. Laws O Essay

926 words - 4 pages admit he is anything but absolutely correct in this matter. It seems that Creon falls under the category of other Greek figures (Achilles, Odysseus, etc.) whose pride and stubborn nature proves to be their undoing. The true lesson to be learned from this play may be spoken by Teiresias, "It is a fool who is governed by self-will."

Antigone Individual Vs. Laws O Essay

900 words - 4 pages plays final stanza, the chorus sings what appears to be a moral tragedy . " Is wisdom to hold the god's in awe. This is the law." The Chorus' simple message seems to lack as a full explanation for Creon's fall. Creon's true downfall is his own pride or hubris. Creon falls under the category of other Greek figures (Achilles, Odysseus etc.),whose pride and stubborn nature proves to be their undoing. Maybe the true moral to this story is best stated by Teiresias when he said "It is a fool who is governed by self-will."