Criminal Justice Rehabilitation Philosophy Essay

1778 words - 7 pages

Criminal Justice Rehabilitation PhilosophyCJA/234November 4, 2013




Criminal Justice Rehabilitation PhilosophyThere are many different types of rehabilitation techniques that have taken place since the origin in the 19th century. The ideas of rehabilitating through punishment were first demonstrated in the penitentiaries constructed during the Jacksonian era of the 19th century. The practice of reforming an inmate for his/her wrongdoing began by simply placing the individual in solitary confinement and making them think about what they did, why they did it and how not to do it again. Rehabilitation is defined as punishment intended to reform a convict so that he/she can lead a productive life free from crime (Smith) it can also be described as the process of helping a person to readapt to society or restore someone to a former position or rank (Campbell). During this time, criminals were basically responsible for rehabilitating themselves through a thought process as well as silence. It was thought to help with their transformation into a well-behaved individual by separating them from the things that caused them to initially commit the crime. It had become the means of justifying an individual for punishment. As time progressed, other procedures of rehabilitation were introduced in a way that would tailor specifically to the convict and not the crime. Reformatories attempted to rehabilitate convicts through vocational and educational training. Convicts were introduced into a system of classifications that allowed for their individualized treatment. They progressed through graded stages based on their conduct and performance in programs. They could even work toward early release. Reformatories, although developed around the concept of rehabilitation, continued to advocate physical punishment for nonconformity (Campbell). Failure to successfully rehabilitate inmates using physical punishments and labor lead to the medical model of intervention as a form of rehabilitation. New "scientific" disciplines like psychiatry, psychology, and criminology proposed that the causes of crime and deviance could be linked to biological, physiological, or psychological defects of the individual (Campbell). The emergent Federal Bureau of Prisons in the 1930s endorsed the medical model in its approach to rehabilitation, thus legitimizing its use in corrections. It was during that time that the classification of prisoners became more refined, and the medical model provided clinical orientation to the diagnosis and treatment of offenders (Welch, 1996, p. 75). The medical model led to the introduction of therapeutic personnel, such as psychiatrists, psychologists, and clinical social workers, into prison settings (Campbell). However, the medical model did not prove to be of service and was no longer highly favored due to a number of factors. For starters, the...

Find Another Essay On Criminal Justice Rehabilitation Philosophy


1173 words - 5 pages periods of 2008 to 2010. There has always been a problem with striking the balance between Retributive and Reparative nature of the justice system with punishment seen as primary. The main objective of the Criminal Justice systems should be tilted to the direction of rehabilitation and community integration rather than punishment or retributive. The young offender should be re-educated rather than condemned because as the society is partly

Does Juvenile Justice System Work? Essay

605 words - 3 pages because there are a great number of children with mental illnesses and substance abuse problems within the justice system. We as people cannot ignore the fact that this population is unaccounted for and treated like the normal population as far as rehabilitation. This population of juveniles needs the proper attention and rehabilitation. The Juvenile Justice Systems main goal is rehabilitation and differentiating themselves from The Criminal

Strategies of Youth Justice Policies

2368 words - 9 pages , as their discretion played a central role in defining the juvenile, as care proceedings replaced criminal hearings. Welfare in youth justice assumes interventions directed to the ‘needs’ of the young through treatment and rehabilitation rather than responding to their ‘deeds’ and accepting full criminal responsibility. From the justice perspective, an offender is presumed capable of forming the mens rea required for a crime so should be

Police Work

665 words - 3 pages World War, the idea of rehabilitation came out. It emphasizes the fact that the offender can be changed. For that reason, in 1972 the community service order was introduced in England and Wales (Cromwell Community College, 2013). Nowadays, the aim of the punishment is to reduce criminal activities and also to reduce the social and economic costs of crime. In 2005 was emerged the idea of combating the anti-social behaviour in order to decrease the

Punitive, Rehabilitative, and Restorative Punishment

786 words - 3 pages America. Philosophy of punishment In the Middle Ages punishment was created so society could take revenge against the offender. During the late 1700’s the Enlightenment or better known as, Age of reason, affected views on law and criminal justice. Cesare Beccaria was a philosopher of the Enlightenment approach and he favored it extremely. He tried to figure out what the best legal system a country could have. Punishment was to be thought of

Social Policy Within Criminal Justice: A Swinging Pendulum

3210 words - 13 pages legislative actions have controlled the course of the criminal justice system and has had both positive and negative outcomes. The conflict of punishment vs. rehabilitation is one that has been of primary concern ever since the early days of social work. The dominance of one over the other is the direct result of public perceptions and fear of crime and swings back and forth like a pendulum. Even while one approach may rule the order of the day, the other

Who bears the primary responsibility for the conditions in prison and the conduct of prisoner;, the society, the criminal justice system or the prisoners themselves?

1295 words - 5 pages show that who have less schooling is more likely to be a criminal (Eitzen, Timer 58). This is reasonable because it is incontestable that education affects people's point of views about dealing with the problems in life.According to law every individual is primarily responsible for his decisions and this is what the justice system is based on. This is the common idea, but factors explained above should be taken into consideration because according

Kant's Perspective on Crime, Punishment, and Justice

1818 words - 7 pages murderer as he receives the same sentence he inflicted on his victim. I believe that this philosophy is very severe and intense. I believe that punishment based on revenge does not respect the humanity of the people being punished. Kant stated, “Crime cannot remain un-avenged; if punishment does not strike the criminal, then his descendant must suffer it” (Kant, 1996). I believe this is very extreme. I believe all crime should be punished, but only

Juvenile Justice

3128 words - 13 pages of juveniles to the adult criminal system where judges are not familiar with the needs of juveniles.In addition to being unnecessary in light of the elimination of transfer hearings in the juvenile justice system, the automatic trial provision contradicts the traditional philosophy of the juvenile justice system. The fundamental principle upon which the founders based the juvenile justice system is that juveniles are different from adults and

Making Wrongs Right

1172 words - 5 pages and deterrence. Many criminal justice systems will order both jail time and drug rehabilitation for drug related activity.The largest question to be asked and answered is which punishment method works best. After this is answered, the information about the benefits and consequences of the punishment method for society and the offender can be presented. California law has implemented a three strikes out program where an offender is given three


2455 words - 10 pages evidence in Policing in the 21st Century: Reconnecting police and the people. Other policy documents will be looked at in other to compare their similarities. Crime control, bureaucratic models the philosophy of deterrence and rehabilitation are convincing in explaining the politics of this policy document. Due process and the other models of criminal justice has had very little or no influence in writing of this policy. The argument will be that

Similar Essays

Criminal Rehabilitation In The United States Justice System

2028 words - 9 pages stingy spending on the prisons, which can be seen from the billions of dollars that are thrown at prisons to keep U.S. citizens locked up. This dangerous and inefficient system must be reformed for the benefit of U.S. citizens that are involved in them whether through paying taxes or being in these prisons. Although the fear of punishment deters crime, United States criminal justice systems should focus on rehabilitation. In its past, the United

Rehabilitation Or Retribution? Essay

967 words - 4 pages [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] Rehabilitation or Retribution?The expectations of society for the criminal justice system are to punish and rehabilitate individuals who have committed crime. Punishment and rehabilitation are two acknowledged objectives of the criminal justice system, Retribution, which is based on "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" philosophy, simply means punishment and vengeance for what evils have done. While

Drug Courts: The Return Of Rehabilitation

2340 words - 9 pages AbstractFor the past decade rehabilitation has been the missing element in the criminal justice system. Our president declared a War on Drugs and in a war we don't consider what to do with those taken prisoner. Much like prisoners the offender has been caught in a system that only punished and released. Little thought and money was diverted into making that individual a part of society or helping them with their addiction. But it appears; with

Is Rehabilitation Effective? Essay

2649 words - 11 pages follows:Ø To restore to good health or useful life, as through therapy and education.o To restore to good condition, operation, or capacity.o To reinstate the good name of.o To restore the former rank, privileges, or rights of.Ø The restoration of someone to a useful place in society.The rehabilitation goals of the criminal justice system are to successfully rehabilitate criminal offenders, and reduce the high recidivism rate that