This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Criminal Law And The War On Drugs

1778 words - 7 pages

Criminal Law and The War on Drugs

     "These records of wars, intrigues, factions, and revolutions, are so many collections of experiments, by which the politician or moral philosopher fixes the principles of his science, in the same manner as the physician or natural philosopher becomes acquainted with the nature of plants, minerals, and other external objects, by the experiments which he forms concerning them." (David Hume.)2

 

"Our long armed and hairy ancestors had no idea of redress beyond vengeance, or of justice beyond mere individual reprisal."3

 

To determine what constitutes criminal law, is, as one learned judge has opined, "a work of art, it is something that may be easier to recognize than define ..."4 I shall venture to say, that, when a person commits a crime that person commits a breach of faith with the community in which that person lives. In such an event the community, as a collective whole, in a self protective act, will assert itself against the criminal.5 Criminal law is a method of enabling men to live together in a community in spite of the possibility that their desires may conflict. Historically, punishment has been the manner by which the community attempts to deter crime;6 and, generally, the criminal offense has been, throughout history, gauged and matched to a suitable punishment. As to what individual acts the community has considered to be a crime and as to what punishment it has meted out, makes for an interesting historical study, which I do not now have the time to carry out.7

 

Of course, it is no longer the sovereign who defines crime, that is now the function of our democratically elected assemblies. However, such an assembly cannot make an act into a crime, as our Supreme Court here in Canada has stated, unless "we can properly look for some evil or injurious or undesirable effect upon the public against which the law is directed. That effect may be in relation to social, economic or political interests; and the legislature has had in mind to suppress the evil or to safeguard the interest threatened."8

 

And further, it cannot be "neither a static catalogue of offences nor order of sanctions. The evolving and transforming types and patterns of social and economic activities are constantly calling for new penal controls and limitations and that new modes of enforcement and punishment adapted to the changing conditions are not to be taken as being equally within the ambit of parliamentary power is, in my opinion, not seriously arguable."9

 

In the relatively recent case of RJR - Macdonald v. Canada (1995), the Supreme Court of Canada, it was determined that the exercise of the power to make an act a criminal one, a test is to be applied; one "of substance, not form."10 To be fully fledged criminal law, the act prohibited "must pose a significant, grave and serious risk of harm to public health, morality, safety or security ..."

 

And, so, how does...

Find Another Essay On Criminal Law and The War on Drugs

Underdeveloped Countries and the War on Drugs

3729 words - 15 pages Underdeveloped Countries and the War on Drugs With the presidential election peering around the corner, it is time to bring back an age-old topic which has been troubling United States citizens for decades, the War on Drugs. Politicians have long quarreled over what sort of action should be taken to combat the world’s drug problems, and it is time that this issue surfaces again. Despite increased efforts from every government

Pablo Escobar and the War on drugs

4154 words - 17 pages . The fact that the demand for illicit drugs has increasingly haunted our nation for quite some time; and since 1972 when the war on drugs was formally declared by President Richard Nixon, and was later intensified by Ronald Regan and George Bush, the problem of solving the war on drugs become progressively worse. Many people will argue that as far as the drugs are concerned it has had a greater impact and has caused more family turmoil and

The War on Drugs

1794 words - 7 pages Throughout U.S governmental history, policies have been known to affect the way of life and every aspect. The topic it choose to research is about “The War on Drugs”, the impact policies have on society and if it does help the public or tend to extent social inequality. This topic is very important to me in the sense that, I look at the community I live and see how drugs have affected people lifes, broken up families and also destroyed the

the war on drugs

709 words - 3 pages Since the reign of Nixon in the presidential office the drug war practices have led to the conviction of millions of Americans – excessively poor people and people of color – while this drug war is continually failing in the reduction of drug use and drug related disease and overdose. The major problem with the war on drugs is the way authorities – like government officials – are handling the situations brought upon through the drug war. A

The War on Drugs

3630 words - 15 pages to understand why they helped. In the late 1800s Coke-a-Cola marketed their drink, or tonic, as having healing properties and claimed that if was a cure all. But, as time wore on we began to see the negative side and decided to control it for fear of what would happen, which lead to Prohibition and the war on drugs. We saw a threat and had to act for fear that it would become a problem that could no longer be contained. People who once used

The War on Drugs

3377 words - 14 pages The War on Drugs To fully understand the significance and the seriousness of a War one must first fully understand the reasons that caused it in the first place. In this specific case the solution begins with several important yet seemingly simple questions…What is marijuana? How is it used? And why is it so coveted and widely distributed in Jamaica as well as the rest of the world?… All these questions help clarify the reasoning behind the

The War on Drugs

2969 words - 12 pages only way you can help yourself get better is by wanting to get better. If you are an addict if a drug and say your parents find out about it, the first thing they do it put you in rehab. And the first thing you want to do when you get out of rehab is to do exactly what you were doing when your parents found out, getting high. You yourself have to make an effort, or no good will come.The war on drugs is growing, and something incredible has to be

Economics Theory and Crime. Why do criminals commit crime. Why is law enforcement failing in the war on drugs

568 words - 2 pages smaller in scale than average lawful businesses in other markets. Studies by Reuter and Rubenstein seem to confirm that indeed "criminal firms are relatively small... and decentralized, exactly the opposite of what we see in movies and novels." Rather than being organized, the criminal market is more of a "network of individuals that cooperate ...and do things for each other to their own mutual [economic] interest."Examining the "War on Drugs

The War on Drugs and Its Impact on Latin America

2000 words - 8 pages intervention in the day-to-day policies and politics of Latin America. Mexico’s war on drugs was officially decreed by then President Felipe Calderon, but has existed in some form since long before that. In the 1920s a law was drafted that deemed drugs and drug trafficking to be of the highest priority for national security. Throughout time, Mexico has a history of very strict drug enforcement laws, stemming from the issue being one of

Stop the War on Drugs

1972 words - 8 pages the cause of many problems that plague our society. The War on Drugs has failed in many different aspects in our society, and the War on Drugs must be stopped.The War on Drugs is not an actual war. It is the policies and laws that the government uses to try to limit drug production and use. These policies include laws that ban drug paraphernalia, harsher penalties, mandatory sentences, and increased police power. The United States spends billions

The Failed War on Drugs

1342 words - 6 pages In 2010 the U.S federal government spent 15 billion dollars on the War on Drugs. This equals a rate of nearly 500 dollars per second and does not include state spending or housing costs for those jailed in this failed War. Despite all the money spent and harsh drug sentencing policies, drug use in America has been on the rise for several decades. With increased drug use comes increased drug related crime, increased HIV infections and of course

Similar Essays

The War On Drugs: Failures Of The Drug Law

1751 words - 7 pages business over thirteen billion (Nanedlman 1988). Another way that the war on drugs is establishing more widespread violent activities is the daunting and corrupting conduct of the dug dealers. These forbidden markets mostly attract criminal minded people and usually these people resolve their disputes violently amongst themselves rather than reporting to the legal authorities. During the drug ban, intense confrontations occur between gangs and

The Market For Illegal Drugs And The War On Drugs

1212 words - 5 pages In 2009, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, while on a state visit to Mexico said something no other political figure had been courageous enough to admit at that point – that the war on drug is a failure. In her own words, she said: “Clearly, what we have been doing has not worked… our insatiable demand for illegal drugs fuels the drug trade and our inability to prevent weapons from being illegally smuggled across the border to arm these

The War On Drugs Essay

1524 words - 6 pages , 2007. 13-14, 169. Print. Ojmarrh, Mitchell. "INEFFECTIVENESS, FINANCIAL WASTE, AND UNFAIRNESS: THE LEGACY OF THE WAR ON DRUGS." Journal of Crime & Justice (2009). 1-19. Print. Whitmore, Allison M. "The Need to Know: Why Multiple State Drug Possession Offenses Should Not Automatically Amount to an Aggravated Felony." New England Journal on Criminal & Civil Confinement 36.2 (2010): 359-79. Print. Willis, Katie. "Measuring the Effectiveness of Drug Law Enforcement." Trends & Issues in Crime & Criminal Justice 406 (2011): 1-7. Print. Witt, Jon. Soc: A Matter of Perspective. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2009. 397- 412 Print. Canadian Edition.

The War On Drugs Essay

581 words - 2 pages . There are just as many kids, and that is exactly what they are, using drugs that have taken the program than the kids that had not participated. It seems that the more the government tried to educate against drug, the more negative attitudes arose against the police and law enforcement. And with that escalates the positive attitudes towards using drugs and alcohol, as well as a rise in criminal behavior. As a result in the drug war, education