Criminal Law: Should There Be A Crime Of Corporate Manslaughter?

2580 words - 10 pages

INTRODUCTION.The evolution of corporate criminal liability perhaps reaches its apex in the prosecution of manslaughter. The criminal law, although designed to determine the responsibility of natural persons is remodelled when the employer is not a person. Presumably this predicates the dilemma, which legislators confront in determining the limits of the criminal sanction and whether or not a corporation can be ascribed guilt in manslaughter.Current State of the Law.The current law in Australia is such that, although corporations are deemed legal persons, they cannot be convicted of an offence which is only punishable by imprisonment e.g. murder. In Australia, the acknowledgement of corporate responsibility for workplace killing is significantly inhibited by the Tesco principle, which holds that a corporation can only be charged with an offence where the persons who made the error of judgement represent the "guiding mind or will " of the corporation. In light of this and the reluctance of some jurisdictions to statutorily override it, the law at present for the purposes of manslaughter, only goes so far as to recognise categories of corporate defendants, such as senior executives and directors falling within the operation of the rule .NSW Manslaughter Provisions & OHS.NSW maintains a proactive approach to maintaining safety standards through the combined operation of civil remedies, industry specific statutes and the Occupational Health & Safety Act 2000 . This approach ameliorates the reactionary effect of provisions responding only to death or injury. In light of this the Act imposes performance-based obligations on employers to maintain safety management systems and posits a duty on the employer to consult employees on workplace safety . Since NSW has no industrial manslaughter offence, the common law of manslaughter is the zenith of reactionary measures.The Criminal Code Act 1995.The Commonwealth code provides greater tangibility to corporate criminal liability, in specifically outlining that corporations can be convicted of crimes punishable only by imprisonment, and holding that corporations with a poor "corporate culture" may be just as culpable as senior officers and managers falling under Tesco.The code defines "corporate culture" to include attitude, policy, rules, courses of conduct etc and establishes it as basis for the imputation of guilt . Sarre postulates that as a result of this basis, corporations merely showing documentary evidence of good practice, will not easily be allowed to escape scrutiny, where an underlying lack of compliance can be elucidated . In such a situation failure to comply with maintaining safety systems constitutes the deficient culture, for which the common law otherwise steeped in 'identification' would fail to impose criminal liability . Indeed advocates of the code argue that it allows a truly corporate mens rea to be uncovered in criminogenic corporate cultures, and thus need not be reliant on the...

Find Another Essay On Criminal Law: Should there be a crime of corporate manslaughter?

Comparison of characteristics and perceptions of the Qld Criminal Justice System, Aboriginal Customary Law and Islamic Criminal Law according to crime and punishment procedures

2946 words - 12 pages jail sentence, fine or community service. Imposition of punishment under Queensland Criminal Law is a person who inflicts harm should receive harm through jail sentence or fined. As a crime is considered an offence against the community, it is logical that retribution proceedings against the offender should be instigated in the name of the community. A normal penalty for a breach of the criminal law is a jail sentence or a fine. A fine is a

Should Cyberbullying Be A Crime? Essay

1588 words - 7 pages accountable when a tragedy occurs, but these reactions could have an effect on one’s freedom of speech and further clog our criminal justice system” (Forbes). Teachers, society, and parents need to address incidents, not the criminal justice system. Resorting to criminal laws in the fight against cyberbullying is as alarming as an innocent teen being told she is ugly and/or should go kill herself. Those who believe cyberbullying shouldn’t be a crime, feel

Should Cyber-Bullying be a Criminal Offense?

983 words - 4 pages there is clear evidence. Law officers shouldn’t be hesitant about being involved with anything. They are here to protect us citizens for a reason, not to be hesitant and not be involved with something so damaging. If an investigation is requested about cyberbullying an investigation should be done. Either way cyber-bullying shouldn’t even have to be at a criminal level to be noticed more seriously. Officers can be able to handle the situation only at

Should there be a MMR vaccine

1769 words - 7 pages IntroductionIn this case study I am going to evaluate if the MMR vaccine should be used and whether it is safe for children to be vaccinated. Since 1988, there has been a big controversy about the safety of the MMR vaccine and its perceived link to bowel disease and autism. The MMR vaccine safeguards patients from deadly diseases such as Measles, Mumps and Rubella, reducing the risks of children transmitting the deadly disease and lowering the

Areas in Need of Reform in Law Governing Manslaughter

738 words - 3 pages The law governing involuntary manslaughter is satisfactory to a certain extent, however there is some need of reform by parliament. In the following essay the above statement will be discussed and the definition and different elements of the crime will be analysed. Involuntary manslaughter is the unlawful killing of a person where the defendant does not have the intention, either direct or oblique, to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm, and

Should There Be a Limit on the Amount of Homework Teachers Give to Students’?

2016 words - 9 pages ). Students should not be given an excessive amount of homework because the pressure of having to complete excessive amounts of homework every night is quite daunting for most students. Knowing how much homework is the right amount correlates with age and grade. An 8th grade student should not be given a myriad of homework that would keep her awake past midnight completing assignments. In any case, there should be a limit on the amount of homework all

Should there be a capital ppunishment in Kazakhstan?

994 words - 4 pages the Majilis Vladislav Kosarev believes that capital punishment should be applied to terrorists and murderers. He also noted that the faction of the Communists against the humanization of criminal legislation (Rustam Omarov). So, some people want to people who have committed violent crimes should die and it supports by deputy of the Majilis. 1. Society is helped and supported by Capital punishment as it lowers the crime rate. Although it is evident

The "Stand Your Ground Law" Should Not be a Law

755 words - 4 pages not know, and they are trying to find out, but there in fact is some data. The Wall Street Journal showed that there was a doubling of homicides that were justifiable between 2005 and 2011 in states where the law had passed. Their data shows that white men who shoot/kill black men consists of just 3.1% of all homicides, but cross-racial killing consisted of 15.6% of justifiable homicides. The “Stand Your Ground” law should not be a law because

Should there be a change to the current speed limitations?

777 words - 3 pages points should be accounted for. The desired outcome should be little, if any change at all in the current limitations.A maximum speed limit is posted or set by a state statue to inform motorists of the highest speed considered to be safe and reasonable under normal road, traffic, and weather conditions. Every state has a basic speed statue requiring drivers to drive their vehicles at a speed that is reasonable under these conditions. This law

There Should be a Financial Incentive for People to Recycle

988 words - 4 pages responsible. Often people are spurred to action if there is enough incentive to act. There should be a financial incentive for people to recycle which would increase the number of citizens who recycle and decrease the amount of recyclable items in the landfill. To re-purpose an item takes less energy than to make a new item using raw materials, in addition, recycling is good for the economy. When aluminum cans are recycled it takes ninety five percent less

Should There be a Playoff in College Football ?

1226 words - 5 pages every year because the BCS is belleved not to be a fair way in determining the number one team at the end of the football season.When I first started this paper my original topic was, what if Rutgers was one of two teams that went undefeated this college season; should they play for the National Championship game in January? This did not happen and they ended up falling to Cincinnati on November 18th. For this topic I had already made a K&W

Similar Essays

Should There Be A Law Against Paparazzi?

509 words - 2 pages How about creating a law against the use of telephoto lens and parabolic listening devices? How about creating a new crime—One that will penalize those persisting and persuading photographers, the Paparazzi also known to celebrities as stalkarazzi who follow the rich and famous for the thousand dollars snapshot that reveals some special, intimate moment or an embarrassing one. Should there be a law rebuking such act? Should there be strict laws

New Ideas For Corporate Fraud/Should There Be More Government Oversight Of Corporate Finances?

975 words - 4 pages EXECUTIVE SUMMARY         There is not enough government oversight of corporate finances. The attached report recommends that all companies be required to implement fraud prevention programs, be audited using a new approach to detect material fraud, have a fraud specialist participate in the audit and have certain individuals within the corporation attend annual anti-fraud training.         Based on the number of cases the FBI has

“Corporate Criminal Liability For Manslaughter Has Finally Been Given Statutory Form And Rightly So.” Discuss

4525 words - 18 pages relating to corporate manslaughter to be riddled with controversy. Despite the fact that academics and policy makers have increasingly clamoured for a major overhaul of this area of law, it has taken two Law Commission papers and a 'decade of wrangling, bartering, debate and delay', for corporate criminal liability to finally have been given statutory form in the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007. The first part of this essay

Assignment: Punishment Research Paper Statistics Show That There Is A High Rate Of Criminal Recidivism In The United States. This Raises The Question, "Does Punishment Deter Crime?"

993 words - 4 pages ethics and law, "Let the punishment fit the crime" is the principle that the severity of penalty for a misdeed or wrongdoing should be reasonable and proportional to the severity of the infraction. The concept is common to most cultures throughout the world. Its presence in the ancient Jewish culture is shown by its inclusion in the law of Moses, specifically in Deuteronomy 19:17-21, which includes the punishments of "life for life, eye for eye