Criminal Record Discrimination Harms Society Essay

903 words - 4 pages

The rise of the information age has made it increasingly easy and cost effective to conduct criminal background checks on prospective employees. According to Adams (2011), this ease of access is due to the fact that investigators no longer have to sift through actual court records. But does this type of discrimination actually do any good for a company, and what is the greater cost to society when so many companies are engaging the same type of discrimination?
Cost and Benefit
According to a survey by the Society for Human Resource Management (2010), 73% of the companies surveyed conduct background checks on all prospective employees, and an additional 19% indicated that they conduct ...view middle of the document...

A consequence of the widespread use of pre-employment background checks is disproportionate discrimination against minority racial groups. Although it is illegal to deny a person an employment opportunity based on racial background under the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the effective result of background checks is racial discrimination. According to Carson (2010):
Minorities are more likely to have criminal records than non-minorities, not because they tend to commit crimes more often than non-minorities, but because of racial profiling and other factors such as prosecutorial discretion, receiving jail time rather than bail, higher bails for similar charges, less advantageous proposals during plea bargaining, longer sentences, and higher receipt of the death penalty. (p.223-224)
When criminal records are most prevalent in specific racial groups, and most companies use a criminal record as a barrier to employment, it becomes clear that members of such racial groups are disproportionately denied employment based on a factor that does not accurately depict criminal behavior over that of other races.
To further compound the problems associated with background checks, evaluating a criminal record without placing weight on the age of the offense does not account for those that are likely to never offend again. Research by Blumstein and Nakamura (2009) concluded that the longer a first time offender does not reoffend, the less likely that person will ever offend again. According to the research by Blumstein and Nakamura (2009), people convicted of robbery are just as likely to commit another crime as the rest of the never convicted population if they do not reoffend within 7.7 years. For burglary convictions, 3.8 years was the average to consider an offender “redeemed”, and 4.3...

Find Another Essay On Criminal Record Discrimination Harms Society

Discrimination and The Fairness of All Marylanders Act of 2014

1038 words - 5 pages discrimination against transgender people. It sounds ethical and just, however, it consists of major flaws. The bill is too vague, which allows certain individuals to take improper advantage of the law. The bill must undergo adjustments in order to make it suitable for the society. Works Cited Kunkle, Fredrick. "Maryland Senate passes bill banning discrimination against transgender people." Washington Post. The Washington Post, 4 Mar. 2014. Web. 7

Racial Discrimination the U.S. Labor Market

2828 words - 11 pages . Pager (2003) gives us an example of how applicants can be discriminated against. It this experiment, black and white men of similar qualifications responded to a job ad. Pager (2003) suggests that a white individual with a criminal record has a higher chance of receiving an interview callback than a black individual without a criminal record. We can also see blacks beings discriminated against during pre-employment in United States

The struggles minorities have faced because of racism are segregation, violence, and poverty

825 words - 3 pages Research at Morgan State University says that "African Americans remain targets of hate attacks because of the consistent portrayal of African Americans as being violent and criminal." Many people are making these racist and frequently inaccurate judgments, which are becoming a setback for minorities.The two largest minority groups in the United States are African Americans and people of Hispanic origin. In a study done by the Society for the Study of

Homosexuality and the Existence of Discrimination

1634 words - 7 pages common is to be able to live their life free from hatred and discrimination. Over the years, homosexuality has been a significant topic of discussion in our society. Although progress towards altering public perception of homosexuality has been made in the last thirty years, significant homophobia remains pervasive in society. Homosexuality can be traced back to ancient times and a brief history shows many of the struggles that gay men and

Defining Racism and the Difficulties of Proving Discrimination

759 words - 3 pages even before coming into contact with the criminal justice system. It maybe that racial discrimination in American society has been responsible for conditions that lead to higher rates of offending by minorities, but that possibility does not bear on the question of whether the criminal justice system discriminates against minorities.Thus the question of whether the criminal justice system is racist must not be confused with that of whether

Speech on discrimination against released prisoners

654 words - 3 pages a released prison. The people think they are good for nothing, better off dead. None seems to be willing to give them a chance. There seem to be no one who can help them.This group of people are in fact suffering from discrimination lead by the government against them. The government was the first to require applicants to fill in their criminal records in application forms. Many private companies then follow suit. Many employers, seeing there is

Sociopaths in White Collars

1844 words - 8 pages can either rapidly or slowly cause people with ADP to show their true colours allowing employers to handle the situations easier. Law enforcements can be notified and apprehend the criminal early so judiciaries can ensure that the criminal is incarcerated and will not cause harm to other persons in the business and society. Works Cited "Antisocial Personality Disorder." Complete Human Diseases and Conditions. Ed. Neil Izenberg and Steven A

A Critical Evaluation of the Complexities of Crime and Social Harm

2271 words - 9 pages power to define and enforce, dependant on specific contexts and is a constant process of negation. Criminologists believe that the definition of crime has been constructed by the powerful elites within society to help keep social control, however as these powerful elites from within society are ‘creating rules’ it is extremely easy for them to make prosecution very difficult, almost impossible if they were to get involved in ‘criminal’ or ‘harmful

Gender inequality

1007 words - 5 pages getaway toward achieving welfare, better economy, security and even healthcare in every society. There is no doubt investing in human capital is a cornerstone to build a prosperous society and plays a great role to decline poverty in country. But due to the dissuasive culture and traditional and also institutional discrimination female in developing countries receive less education than male. A research by UNICEF has shown, more than 155 million

disguised discrimination

1729 words - 7 pages for racial discrimination cannot even be brought to the courts. Consequently the proportion of African American men with some sort of criminal record approaches 80% in some major U.S. cities Alexander reported. As a result they become ostracized, part of what she calls "a growing and permanent under caste." This mass incarceration of drug offenders has created a substantial and desperate need for the rapid production of prisons. This is what

A Critical Analysis of Crime and Social Harm

863 words - 4 pages negation. Criminologists believe that the definition of crime has been constructed by the powerful elites within society to help keep social control, however as these powerful elites from within society are ‘creating rules’ it is very easy for them to make prosecution very difficult, almost impossible if they were to get involved in ‘criminal’ or ‘harmful’ activates. An example of this would be the trading in artifax, where during international wars

Similar Essays

Expungement Essay

1495 words - 6 pages comparison to rape and murder, such as marijuana possession and other misdemeanors. Supporters for expungements, such as certain state and federal legislatures, recognized the difficulty and hardships persons with criminal records faced to obtain employment when reintegrating with society, leading to the creation of expungement laws. Furthermore, supporters state “exonerees and persons with a criminal record need wide ranging assistance based on

How Can A Criminal Record Affect Your Life?

949 words - 4 pages such, even if no subsequent criminal behavior is ever committed.We live in a society that encourages us to constantly improve ourselves. We are told to make changes when life choices have not worked out. We are educated to better ourselves, to be more responsible and productive and to become more useful members of society in general. But how to do that when a criminal record is forever telling the world of your past? It is particularly in terms

The Criminal Justice System In Usa

1687 words - 7 pages The Criminal Justice System in the United States of America was established with noble intentions. The basis of the system can be traced back from the first book of the Bible Genesis, and the story of Cain and Able. The criminal justice system was established to be morally suitable for a growing diverse society. Moral dilemmas within the system arise from concerns related to principles of officials’ right and wrong behavior. These principles

Racial Profiling Of The Black Male

944 words - 4 pages ‘crime patterns’, and their critics, who contend that blacks and Hispanics are unfairly targeted by the police. If police officers and crime stoppers did not try to stop those that look like a threat to society, everyone would be very unsafe. No one ever thinks about how many times the police racially profiled a criminal and was correct. The police are here to get criminals off of the streets and have the right to do their jobs. In the true