Critical Analysis

1784 words - 8 pages

The abundance of west versus east comparisons has always been at war. From what utensils is the most effective way to eat, to which entity is it better to follow. Chinese Conflict Preferences and Negotiating Behavior: Cultural and Psychological Influences, by Kirkbride, Tang, and Westood (1991), is no different. This article submits a comparison of differences in conflict management and negotiation styles by westerners and easterners.
Kirkbride, Tang, and Westwood have presented a compelling comparison between Anglo-American methodologies of negotation and conflict management to Chinese methodologies. For the purpose of their article, Anglo- Americans embody Canada, Britain, American, ...view middle of the document...

The authors have positioned themselves in which they believe that the cultural factors, stemmed from tradition, history, and philosophy steers the style in which Chinese people engage in conflict resolution and negotiations. I believe that the comparison is partial. The Chinese people analyzed are all directly influenced and under the power of China. Other Chinese people such as Hakka or Macanese, who are under the influence of India and Portugal respectively may have shown staggering results and should have also been investigated.
This paper will be structured by the material and arguments submitted by the author followed by my analysis.
Kirkbride, Tang, and Westwood (1991) established comparison by studying the Chinese values, harmony, collectivism, conformity, power-distance, holism, contextualism, time, face, shame, reciprocity, and guanxi instilled to Chinese people through history, tradition, and philosophy.
The first key value is harmony and collectivism. This embodies the individual to adapt to the “collectivity, to control their own emotions, to avoid confusion, competition and conflict, and to maintain inner harmony (Kirkbride, Tang, & Westwood, 1991)”. That is to say, this argument is stressed on Chinese people maintaining the unity and continuous relationship with other participants for a harmonious process. The comparison is that “Anglo-American culture gear towards characteristics of individualism and egocentrism (Kirkbride, Tang, & Westwood, 1991)”. As such, the authors suggest that in order to maintain peace, Chinese people are likely to “avoid antagonisms and conflict in order to seek harmonious and collectivity (Kirkbride, Tang, & Westwood, 1991)”.
Kirkbride, Tang, and Westwood seem to imply that Chinese people are likely to sucum to their negotiatiors, more specifically Westerners. This perspective illustrates Chinese people as docile in which Easteners will accept whatever is forced upon them as long as it maintains peace. Kirkbride, Tang, and Westwood do not seem to recognize that a negotiation does not symbolize a win-lose scenario (Fontana, 2012).
Following harmony and collectivism is conformity, hierarchy, and power-distance. This value pertains to following the status quo. Individuals are expected to act in a prescribed manner, instilled by societal norms, tojustify how they interact with others (Kirkbride, Tang, & Westwood, 1991). Kirkbride, Tang, and Westwood (1991) suggest that Chinese people’s consideration towards maintaing a positive relation, steers them away from conflict.
The authors did not provide a comparison for this value. I propose that no comparison was given because the value of respecting status quo applies in the western work environment. For example, if a superior order you to fulfill a worksheet, meant to be completed by him, the normality is to “just do it”. This is similar to the Chinese people in upholding the status quo and knowing their place.
The third value is...

Find Another Essay On critical analysis

Okalahoma critical analysis

1036 words - 4 pages Okalahoma critical analysis The original production of Oklahoma opened at the St. James Theatre, New York, on Wednesday March 31, 1943. The top ticket price was $4.80. It ran on Broadway for over five years, besting the previous record holder Hellzapoppin by more than two years. For fifteen years, from 1946 until 1961, Oklahoma held the record as the longest running show in Broadway history. When Okalahoma closed on Broadway May

Critical Analysis Essay

1388 words - 6 pages Humor Analysis Essay Prompt Intro to Lit. Faduma Abdi Critical Analysis Essay “The secret to humor is surprise-Aristotle.” The two stories I'm going to talk about “The Weather of New England” by Mark Twain and “The Dog That Bit People” by James Thurber are both strange humorous essay with a twist. Both stories have a central conflict, in “The Dog That Bit People

being critical on critical analysis - 7egn - research

1281 words - 6 pages Being Critical As an academic writer, you are expected to be critical of the sources that you use. This essentially means questioning what you read and not necessarily agreeing with it just because the information has been published. Being critical can also mean looking for reasons why we should not just accept something as being correct or true. This can require you to identify problems with a writer's arguments or methods, or perhaps to refer

Critical Analysis of “The Awakening”

1231 words - 5 pages Critical Analysis of "The Awakening" PAGE \* Arabic 1 Critical Analysis of "The Awakening"Mariusz PerkowskiUniversity of PhoenixCritical Analysis of "The Awakening"The Awakening by Kate Chopin demonstrates life dilemmas of women during the late nineteenth century. Period of time in the history that has many similarities to the position of women is society these days. While in our culture we have taken big steps toward changing the stereotypes

Critical Analysis on Schindler's List

1403 words - 6 pages Critical Analysis on Schindler's List In this assignment, I will present a critical analysis on Schindler's List. Schindler's List is a masterpiece, which was directed by arguably, the greatest director of all time, Steven Spielberg. Steven Spielberg is Jewish, so to recall the most tragic and horrific event in Jewish history or you may say the history of man-kind takes a lot of guts and determination. However

Critical analysis of young goo

1217 words - 5 pages Critical Analysis of Young Goodman Brown Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story of Young Goodman Brown is a reflection of the Puritan faith as well as man's conflict between good and evil. This analysis will emphasize on the theme of Young Goodman Brown as well Hawthorne's usage of symbolism and allegories throughout the story. Literary critic D.M. McKeithan says that the theme of the story is sin and the terrible effect sin has on

Critical Analysis of Shakespeare's Hamlet

676 words - 3 pages Critical Analysis of Shakespeare's Hamlet What is mans' purpose in life? Is there a purpose? If there isn't, then is it wise to end it, despite the fact that there might be nothing better? In Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, Hamlet struggles with these and other issues. He states that the question of life is "To be, or not to be...?" Is existence really worth the troubles of life? In this monologue, Hamlet is wondering what is his

Critical Analysis Of Robinson Crusoe

688 words - 3 pages Summary and Full Analysis." ClassicNotes. 2001. (24 Sept. 2001) "Critical Analysis of Robinson Crusoe." 1999. (24 Sept. 2001)

Critical Analysis of White Heron

2071 words - 8 pages Critical Analysis of White Heron The White Heron is a spiritual story portraying great refinement and concerns with higher things in life. A 9 year old girl once isolated in the city found fulfillment in a farm surrounded by nature. Too those less unfortunate, money charm and other attractions can be intoxicated; Sylvia did not bite. She could have helped her situation and found a way to wealth but in the end she realized that it wouldn’t

Critical Analysis of an Incident

2326 words - 9 pages followed by an analysis of the incident using The What ? Model of Structured reflection suggested by Driscoll (2000). A rationale is given for the selection of this particular incident and also for the selection of the chosen model as a framework. It will show how the model has been used to reflect on the incident, what has been learnt, and the outcome on both current and future practice. Reflection is an active process of witnessing

Critical Analysis of Walter Mosley

2520 words - 10 pages Critical Analysis of Walter Mosley      “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you do or say may be used against you in a court of law.” Although no one wants to hear these words, they are words that are known across the country and are uttered every day. Walter Mosley takes this concept of “by the book” law enforcement and jazzes it up in The Devil in a Blue Dress, a novel based on Ezekiel Rawlins, a character stuck between the

Similar Essays

Critical Analysis

2087 words - 9 pages Introduction This critical analysis I will be evaluating my chosen organization that I have experienced at the restaurant “X” and discuss how the motivation perspectives are affected within my work experience. Additionally, I will deliberate how those concepts relate to the issues and how they influenced/ motivated me to succeed. In the following paragraphs, I will describe two team concepts: team characteristics and process and managing team

Critical Analysis

1410 words - 6 pages Comparative Analysis Growing up you expect a lot of things. You expect your family to always support you, you expect to have a lot of friends, you expect to get married, you may expect to go to college, or expect a well paying job that you love. These things are not always guaranteed though. The media fills our heads with these high expectations for perfect glamorous lifestyles the will never actually be a reality for most of us. Terrance

Critical Discourse Analysis

2416 words - 10 pages Critical Discourse Analysis Jan blommaert and Chris Bulcaen makes a brief introduction to the study of Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). CDA intends to use social-theoretical method in discourse analysis and is primarily linguistically based (Blommaet & Bulcaen, 2000, p.447). It intends to analyze the structural relationships of dominance, discrimination, power and control through a textual study (Blommaet & Bulcaen, 2000, p.448). Based on the

Critical Analysis: Parenting Styles

1408 words - 6 pages Critical Analysis: Parenting Styles Taylor Duran Colorado Christian University April 12, 2014 Critical Analysis: Parenting Styles Broadly defined, parenting styles are the strategies that parents utilize while raising their child/children. According to Darling (1999), "Parenting style captures two important elements of parenting: parental responsiveness and parental demandingness" (p. 2). There are four main types of parenting styles, based on