This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis Of A Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages

Introduction and Purpose of the Study
Activities are executed as projects in organizations by governments and industries as a means to take advantage of the formality of processes and best practices associated with being characterized as a project (Geraldi, Maylor, & Williams, 2011, p. 966). According to Geraldi, Maylor, and Williams (p. 967), despite the promotion of “best practices” by professional program management associations that use of their methods lead to positive project outcomes, improved performance is not consistently realized. The authors argue that the associations’ one size fits all approach to best practices is insufficient for project success and thus conducted ...view middle of the document...

, 2011, p. 967). The case is made that while previous research recognizes that projects can both be complex and be conducted in a complex environment, however the research is disjointed because there is not a common taxonomy. Thus, they continue, research needs to be conducted to describe the concept of complexity. Once described, a typology can be developed that provides academics and practitioners a common language to identify and study the existence and implications of complexity in the context of projects (p. 968). This typology can then support tests of the hypothesis that complexity is IV associated with project success. Thus the need for the SR is well established.
The authors used narrative synthesis to review twenty-five articles to develop a framework containing five dimensions of project complexity and nearly 200 individual dimension indicators. They then concluded the framework was a comprehensive typology of complexity that could support future research such as testing the hypothesis of complexity as an IV to project success (Geraldi et al., 2011, p. 984).
A well-developed systematic review is transparent, replicable (Briner & Denyer, 2012, p. 120) and conducted with sufficient rigor that the study is trustworthy (Gough et al., 2012). Transparency in research is the extent to which the process of developing the knowledge is open to scrutiny (Gough et al., 2012, p. 157). Rigor is the extent to which a study undertakes internal and external quality assurance processes (p. 38) such as those associated with internal project management and external formal quality procedures (p. 81) and thus is an indicator of the study’s quality. The assessment will be conducted using the questions in Briner and Denyer’s (2012, p. 121) protocol structure by mapping the questions to the sections of the common stages (Gough et al., 2012, p. 8). Developing the SR review question will be the first phase assessed.
Review Question
The research question (RQ) was not explicitly stated nor is there evidence an advisory group was used to develop the research question. It could be argued that since the quality and relevance of a study is judged in relation to its question (Gough et al., 2012, p. 160) and a good relevant question is developed using an advisory group, that there may be a weakness in both the transparency and rigor of this phase. However, the objective and the relevancy of research to develop the complexity topology to advance further studies was established earlier.
Search Strategy.
The authors’ search strategy is transparent but lacks robustness. The authors clearly specify the search starts using the two bibliographic databases, and two relevant journals and the search terms. They used a six step filtering process to excluded articles at each step, from the first step that used initial search terms to the final step that excluded article that did not explicitly provide a complexity framework or definition (Geraldi et al., 2011,...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

Critical Analysis of a Published Article

1197 words - 5 pages The main point of this article is facts about arranged marriage. This article has addressed to the audience of British society apart to British Asians. Because the writer, intended to present them the real meaning, about the arranged marriages and how it works. In addition, it gives a clear method to the part of British people who an arranged marriage is different from their viewpoints. The writer gave this article an obvious title, which

Critical Evaluation of a Research Article

766 words - 3 pages Adoption is a frequent occurrence in the United States but few articles are written about the aftermath of being adopted. Whether the adoption is a familial or stranger adoption, questions arise about the best age to tell children they are adopted and what children and parents feel about the experience. The article I chose to evaluate researches these subjects. The article I chose is A Phenomenological Exploration of Adoption by Diana L

This gives a critical analysis of Cary Barbor's article "Finding Real Love"

768 words - 3 pages Cary Barbor's article Finding Real Love is somewhat of a self-help article about intimacy. Cary starts out the article by explaining that her articles main idea is four mental health professionals discussing how people destroy their intimate relationships and what they can do to fix them.The first subject talked about in Barbor's article is on the first decision we make about a relationship, which is the partner we choose. Dr. Ayala Malach says

A Critical Analysis of the Article "Progressive Wal-Mart. Really." by Sebastian Mallaby

1216 words - 5 pages victims because of low prices. Mallaby argues when Wal-Mart opens store people apply for job proving that not everyone “believes the pay and benefits are unattractive” (621). Although Wal-Mart create jobs, that does not mean it’s a great job; it could be the only job. Wal-Mart employees are losing gains when they work unpaid overtime. In her article, “Up Against Wal-Mart” Karen Olsson states that Wal-Mart makes more than 6.6 billion in profits

Analysis of a Boxing Article

1271 words - 5 pages Analysis of a Boxing Article The headline does what headlines do. It grabs the readers attention, and suggest what we expect to find when we read on. “NO ONE IS FORECED TO FIGHT” is a sharp phrase that goes straight to the point. The bias of the editorial is clear from the headline, and we expect to read something in favor of the boxers right to box, especially since they are not “FORCED”. As expected it is told with

A Critical Analysis of a Journal Article: Effects of Welfare Reform on Illicit Drug Use of Adult

1617 words - 7 pages feasible. Researchers, Corman et al, employed a method of available data and content analysis for their research. Both of these methods operate in an unobtrusive fashion, allowing for efficiency and economic savings. However, relying on available data and content analysis could have placed the study at risk of poor validity, as the researchers were dependent upon others to gather and report accurate data to the appropriate organizations

Ne Product Development - Critical Analysis of Article in IJOPM

2700 words - 11 pages practically no customer support (hence eliminating the need to assess and evaluate its requirements during design stage). On the other extreme are vending machines, which require extensive support throughout the life of the product. The strength of the article (Goffin and New, 2001) lies in compiling some of the important benefits, which a company can gain in including customer support in NPD. Including customer support at design stage can affect

Critical Analysis of Schulman's Article 'Gay Marriage and Marriage'

946 words - 4 pages is irrelevant what sexual orientation a person is, they are still human and they deserve equal treatment and protection under the law. In conclusion his article is highly ineffective due to his illogical arguments. While many of his hypotheses may be readily accepted by the audience, his attempt to reason others his approach is faulty. While his goal of empowering others with his same beliefs might be effective, he still misses with persuasion

A Critical Review of Qualitative Methodological Approaches

1546 words - 6 pages unsuccessful behaviours of the executive coach and seeks to make recommendations as to the direction for coaching practice and training. Works Cited Brocki, J. M., & Wearden, A. J. (2006). A critical evaluation of the use of interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) in health psychology. Psychology & Health, 21(1), 87-108. Gee, J. P. (1999). An introduction to discourse analysis : theory and method. New York: Routledge. Gee, J. P

A Critical Review of “Deep Practice”

951 words - 4 pages highly likely that his conclusions are the result of his sampling method. In addition, his anecdotal evidences are, academically speaking, insufficient to support his thesis. The evidence could have been collected through empirical experiment, by using surveying methods. However, since the book apparently emerged from a New York Time article that he published in March 2007, the collection of empirical evidence was probably ruled out because of

A Critical Review of Francis Schaeffer

3352 words - 14 pages society has moved away from the principle teachings of the Bible. He believes that the problems in society are because individuals are ignoring the Christian principles that this world was built upon. He warns that this shift can have a catastrophic effect on how the world will look in the future. Purpose of Text The main purpose of Schaeffer's book is to explain to the world that society is heading down a damaged path. Society is continually

Similar Essays

Critical Article Review

636 words - 3 pages Connell in “The Northern Theory of Globalisation” (2007) examines how the theory of globalisation has been constructed and discusses the issues surrounding the ‘Northern’ focus of globalisation theories. One of the main concerns addressed in the article is whether globalisation occurs through the adoption of a dominant culture or through the interaction between different cultures. Although both views are arguably valid, Connell (2007: 379

A Critical Review Of The Article "In Praise Of Cultural Imperialism" By David Rothkopf

702 words - 3 pages In the article, In Praise of Cultural Imperialism, David Rothkopf illustrates a progressive new world order where information is the new global currency and the United States, "the indispensable nation," is the bank. In his article, Rothkopf contrasts the victimizing tendencies of 'cultural barriers', which are the unmistakably causing ethnic, religious, ideological, tribal or nationalistic conflicts, to the uniting tendencies of western

A Review Of The Article "Introducing Percents In Linear Measurement To Foster An Understanding Of Rational Number Operations" A Critical Reading

550 words - 2 pages science classes. This article does a fine job of showing a new way of approaching a difficult subject and how some students respond receptively to it. If teachers can make it a habit of showing a variety of ways to do problems when they see not all the children are grasping a subject then we can give them a better chance at succeeding in other subjects.

Critical Review Of The Article: Repeated Viewing And Co Viewing Of An Animated Video: An Examination Of Factors That Impact On Young Children's Comprehension Of Video Content

1293 words - 5 pages studies. It should also be understood, first, that children of this age (4-6) are highly influenced by the things they see and hear around them, and therefore, are at a critical age in their learning. The questions being asked in this particular experiment were, why do children repeatedly watch the same videos?, does this repeat viewing enhance their learning and understanding?, and does having a co-viewer enhance the experience in terms of