This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis Of Mc Closkey’s Arguement In "On Being An Athiest"

1523 words - 7 pages

In this response, the author would like to state he is a Christian and finds the chapter to be very difficult to read. The chapter, “On Being an Atheist”, can be very convincing if the reader is not strong in their beliefs. Being a new Christian for over a year, the author of this response wants to make a statement that the spiritual warfare Christians believe in, has taken place this week. Atheist believes in no God. Therefore, they would not believe such spiritual warfare exists.

The author of this response would like to state that the arguments could not be proofs. Nothing can be 100% proven. To state something is a proof when it does not prove anything but cause arguments, is a fallacy. McCloskey believes the arguments individually cannot make a case for God. In lesson 18, the cumulative case was presented. The Cumulative case takes the Cosmological, Teleological, and Moral Arguments and puts them altogether. The Cosmological case makes claim for a creator. The Teleological case is the intelligent and the Moral case is the personal and morally prefect. Altogether, this makes the Cumulative case state; a personal, moral, intelligent creator of the universe is the best explanation for the universe we experience. The second half comes from the Best Explanation Approach. It states, the existence of God is the best explanation for the effects we observe in the universe. This also comes from lesson 18.

McCloskey’s claim, that the “mere existence of the world constitutes no reason for believing in such a being.” It is this author’s opinion; God could not exist because of the existence of the world. The cause of the universe must be necessary. “Many versions of the cosmological argument do, of course, begin by claiming that the universe as a whole is contingent and requires a cause” (Evans 1982, 54). Premise 1 says that some contingent beings exist and premise 2 says if any contingent being exists, then a necessary being must exist, concluding that there is a necessary being. This author sees this as everything in existence has a creator. Nothing could just appear on its own. Therefore, there has to be a cause. Biblically the Christian believes that God is the Creator. For in Genesis 1:1 it says, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth” ( NASB n.d.). The author of Genesis clearly states there is a cause for all existence and that the cause is God.

McCloskey claims that the cosmological argument “does not entitle us to postulate an all-powerful, all-prefect, uncaused cause.” The argument does not state there is a God, but it makes a claim that something caused everything to come into existence. The view of a theist is that there is a God and this argument gives “key elements of the theistic conception of God” (1982, 59). With the conclusion of this argument, many views of God can be determined. “If someone accepts the conclusion, the proper attitude for him to adopt...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis of McCloskey’s Arguement in "On Being an Athiest"

Analysis of Koppelman's Arguement in Support of Same Sex Marriage

1110 words - 5 pages marriage focuses on marriage before beginning sexual activity. In the instance of an unplanned pregnancy before marriage, a shotgun wedding is deemed appropriate. Chances are the couple is not financially ready to support a child. In states that try to enforce these ideals, divorce rates are the highest. Same-sex marriage defies these complex ideals. For same-sex couples, the need for a shotgun wedding is superfluous, as there are no instances

Critical Analysis of an Incident

2326 words - 9 pages Introduction The intention of this written essay is to demonstrate an understanding of my views on the art and science of reflection and the issues surrounding reflective practice. It is based on a significant incident from my own area of clinical practice as a state registered paramedic within the U.K. There is a discussion appraising the concept of reflection both generally, and in my particular area of practice. This is

An Arguement for Advertising on School Property

667 words - 3 pages to help fund dying programs. David Gard for The Star – Ledger in New Jersey on January 6th, 2011 writes about how Governor Chris Christie signed a bill into law that would allow advertisements on school buses in order to boost revenue for school districts at a time of cost-cutting. In the article, Connie Wagner from Assemblywomen states: “With schools everywhere at a loss for state aid, and cuts being felt as classes get underway again, this

An Arguement for the Existance of God

1208 words - 5 pages . Some believe that belief in the existence of God is not rational; however, I believe that belief in the existence of a greater being called God can be a rational belief. For something to be rational it must be based on fact or logical reasoning rather than emotions or feelings. Belief in the existence of God because it makes you feel better about what you do in your life is not rational because it is based on feelings, but belief in the

Critical Analysis on an extract of The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee William

1198 words - 5 pages relationships needing to work both ways, this confirms Tom's freedom as displayed in the earlier lines of the extract, where "Tom smashes his glass on the floor." whereby his action of breaking away earns him a reaction from Laura, bidding him goodbye. Even though the audience is happy that Tom is able to follow his passion now, it is inevitable that sympathy is also evoked as this is at the expense of being cut away from his family and ties, thus the

Critical Analysis of an Article on HIV/AIDS Prevention Issues for Women

1135 words - 5 pages Introduction: This review is about the main points, gaps and critique of the article. The main information provided in this review will help you gain new insight on women HIV/AIDS prevention issues. As a society, we focus on individualist ways of prevention. We try to enforce and educate individuals on HIV/AIDS prevention on an individual level but it’s more complex because women have a lower status compared to men, this disempowerment can lead

An Arguement for Cell Phone Use in Schools

942 words - 4 pages For some schools, students take French classes or Spanish classes by using cellphones to call classmates and to speak with them in that language. Some schools do not allow phones during school for they have either banned or have limited the use of cellphone. Just about year beginning of school in fall, students would pack technologies in the

A Critical Analysis on the Imagery in Act II of Shakespeare's Macbeth

1181 words - 5 pages deeper insight into his major themes which are evil, guilt and remorse, and chaos and disorder. These themes are intertwined throughout the entire play, however for a thorough analysis of Shakespeare's imagery, it is sufficient to take a closer look at Act 2 of Macbeth.Macbeth is a confused man, who falters in thought about whether or not to murder King Duncan. A question to ponder throughout the play is, 'whether or not Macbeth is an evil man

Reveiw of Jan Goodwin's The Price of Honor: an in-depth critical analysis of Goodwin's book about women and Islam

1386 words - 6 pages cause of the current situation. "The politics...are not hard to understand: Iran is the world's fifth-largest oil producer, and because of America's economic embargo, all of that oil is sold to Europe and Asia instead of the United States" (Goodwin, 120). She believes that the worse the women are being treated is in direct correlation to each countries economic situation. Depending on the reader's goal, Goodwin's heavy emphasis on foreign policy

Critical Analysis of George Orwell's essay "Shooting an Elephant"

609 words - 2 pages Critical Analysis of "Shooting an Elephant"In George Orwell's essay "Shooting an Elephant," the author's character develops from the pressure to make a decision and the horrifying results which follow. A potential existed for Orwell to display confidence and high morals, but this potential was destroyed when he pulled the trigger. The death of the elephant signifies the weakness of Orwell's character.Orwell is ashamed to had submitted to the

Critical analysis of essay of Reza Banakar's essay "In Search of Heimate: A Note on Franz Kafka's Concept of Law"

830 words - 4 pages In the essay "In search of Heimate: A Note on Franz Kafka's Concept of Law", the writer Reza Banakar reviews Kafka's intrepretation of the legal system within his writings. Banakar concocts a passionate arguement for the fact that in the story of The Trial, law is not only a concept but an experience that leaves a indiviual feeling trapped. He also gives a well thought out testimony to support the claim that The Trial bridges the concept of

Similar Essays

Mc Closkey's On Being An Athiest Essay

1900 words - 8 pages McCloskey in "On Being an Atheist" argues in favor of atheism and attempts to discredit theism. He uses many tactful approaches in disputing theism such as the arguments for God as a whole failing to establish a case for God. Focusing on the Cosmological argument, McCloskey claims that the existence of all that we see fulfills no grounds for there to exist a God or necessary being. He furthers the argument by stating that the cosmological

An Analysis Of Religion By An Athiest

2490 words - 10 pages to hell upon death. In hell the soul rests under excruciating pain. Hell is the worst possible place that anyone could imagine. While heaven is depicted as being serene and beautiful, hell is depicted as a world full of pain and suffering. When one’s soul enters hell, the soul lives an eternal life of pain and suffering for their sins. “The sacred and transcendent” are those areas in religions that are not tangible or visible. Rather, “the

Critical Analysis Of Peter Knight's Arguement On Secret Societies

1106 words - 5 pages ). Unfortunately again he made these claims without presenting any valid data and only what he believes is grounds for him to make his argument. A Warrant in the Toulmins Model of Argumentation is the reason why the reader should support the claim that is being made. An arguments warrant is the chain of reasoning that connects the grounds or data to the claim being made. (The Toulmin Model of Argumentation.). The warrant in Knights article are

The Necessary Proofs For The Belief In God Explained In “On Being An Athiest,” By H.J. Mc Closky

1607 words - 7 pages The article “On Being an Athiest,” by H.J. McClosky, was very interesting. McClosky basically lets us know that as atheists they do not believe in God and why they do not believe in the God that theists do. According to McCloskey, there are three proofs for a theist to believe in God; the cosmological, teleological, and the argument from design. McCloskey refers to the arguments for God as proofs, and he suggests that we cannot establish a