This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis Of Pruitt And Kim’s Theory Of Reconciliation

905 words - 4 pages

Over the span of recorded history, humankind has inflicted horrors upon itself. Attempts at ending these brutal conflicts usually involved a great deal of violence; problem solving entailed an “off with his head” approach. We would like to think that we are better than that today, but look no further than newspaper headlines to see that human behavior has not come very far since the Middle Ages. Nevertheless, there has been a positive development in modern day problem solving that Pruitt and Kim (2004) call “reconciliation” (p. 218). Simply put, this is the process of relationship repair. The importance of this theory cannot be understated. Reconciliation of divided people and societies is vital to preventing the reoccurrence of violence and building long-term, sustainable peace (Sustainable reconciliation, 2013). If people do not reconcile, conflicts will continue to arise time after time after time.
Pruitt and Kim (2004) maintain that there is a consensus among theorists that there are two requirements necessary for reconciliation to be effective and sustainable. The first requirement is that the parties must deal with the pains of the past and together develop a shared future. The second requirement is that there should be at a minimum the following set of elements: truth, forgiveness, justice and peace (p. 218). In my additional reading on the subject, I found that there is certainly a consensus regarding the first requirement. As to the second requirement, I assert that the authors are basing some of their arguments on several unsupported assumptions.
Pruitt and Kim (2004) make an assumption that there is consensus [emphasis added] among theorists that truth, forgiveness, justice and peace must [emphasis added] be included in the ingredients toward reconciliation (p. 218). I disagree with this assumption. There are other preeminent reconciliation theorists who contradict their view. For example, Luc Huyse (2003), a renowned reconciliation scholar, states that there are “four pillars of reconciliation . . . healing, justice, truth-telling, and reparation” (p. 32). David Bloomfield, who is another distinguished reconciliation theorist, posits:
Reconciliation’s basic problem is that no-one agrees how to define it or do it . . . It has become customary for almost every text on the subject to begin with an acknowledgement of the lack of consensual understanding, and use, of the term. (Bloomfield, 2006, p. 4.)
John Paul Lederdach, Professor of International Peacebuilding at the University of Notre Dame, says that reconciliation requires “peace, justice, truth, and mercy” (p. 12). Therefore, for Pruitt and Kim to declare that there is a consensus is a faulty assumption.
Pruitt and Kim (2004) also make the assumption, “Forgiveness plays such a crucial role in reconciliation that these two concepts are often used interchangeably” (p. 220). They say that forgiveness can be achieved when leaders on one or both sides express...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis of Pruitt and Kim’s Theory of Reconciliation

Analysis of Gregory the Great’s Letters to understand papal reconciliation of spiritual and temporal aspects of warfare

1490 words - 6 pages Christians, or material and economic concern for the property of the Church. Being the spiritual ambassador to the secular affairs is very clearly a difficult task. A close reading of Gregory’s letters to military officers and the soldiers themselves in the period between September 591 and September 592, shows that successful reconciliation of political and spiritual goals is possible most of the time. Gregory’s correspondence, compared against

Critical analysis of Hard and soft HRM

923 words - 4 pages . Critical Report The first policy of note is the zero hours contract policy that CareKind operates. This has been implemented due to the changing requirements of those clients who require care. Applicants for positions within CareKind are informed of this policy prior to being offered a position. They are also asked if they have a preference for the hours they work and if possible and the work is available, their requests are accommodated. The

Critical Analysis of Sharks, Saints, and Samurai

1333 words - 6 pages that the results were verifiable and fair. By being honorable and following the tradition of the Samurai, both parties were able to engage in a joint analysis of the valuation and develop a win/win situation. Reading the Sharks, Saints, and Samurai article emphasized the importance of acting ethically during the negotiation process. I enjoyed the discussions about ethical negotiating practices employed by Nelson Mandela, Hunt Wesson, and the

Critical Analysis of Pride and Prejudice

807 words - 3 pages Mr. Darcy's prejudice is strongly rooted in him, but Elizabeth is able to break down some of his distaste for her, which eventually causes him to fall in love with her. Mr. Darcy, towards those he considers of lower status and regard, he is an aloof, condescending man. He holds the stupidity and silly behavior of the Bennet family with great contempt, all except for Elizabeth and Jane. Jane gains his respect, because she is a proper

A critique of the Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa

3284 words - 14 pages included forty-two Afrikaners, seventy English South Africans and Forty-six Xhosa individuals. (pp. 307) The result of the testimony was explicitly demonstrated that the conflict still remained between the black majority and white minority and the TRC failed to achieve the reconciliation between black and white communities. The quantitative analysis revealed that the Afrikaner and the English participants perceived the TRC to be less effective in

Uncertain Reconciliation between Indigenous and Non-Indigenous people of Australia

682 words - 3 pages Reconciliation between Aboriginal People and Non-Aboriginal people to some extent is important towards Australia’s future. Given the past injustices involving land rights, the stolen generation and Government Policies, it illustrates that Australia has some way to go ahead of the full reconciliation between Indigenous and Non-Indigenous Australians and that without reconciliation our future is uncertain. The Aboriginals were denied their land

Resolutions of Forgiveness, Repentance and Reconciliation in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1423 words - 6 pages Stephen Orgel, in the Oxford World Classics Introduction of The Tempest, says that the resolutions of forgiveness, repentance and reconciliation through the harmony of marriage that Prospero has undertaken to achieve are not completely met. This is true as not all injuries are forgiven, and certain characters fail to repent for their wrongs. The marriage does not completely achieve its role of reconciliation, as we have to question its origins

Critical Analysis of Rant

1508 words - 7 pages Rant: The Oral Biography of Buster Casey is widely known as one of the Chuck Palahniuk’s most complicated reads, a mind-blowing “out-there” novel in what is typically considered a very extreme bibliography. The unconventional narrative style, plethora of contradicting narrators, and indecipherable subject matter all combine into one oral biography of a complex, incomprehensible man by the name of Buster “Rant” Casey—a man who liked to be bitten

Critical Analysis Of Nature

1102 words - 5 pages As human beings we take everything for granted. We think not of the struggle that nature endures to blossom into something that we can find divine. Nor do we think about the hours and passion that a writer may have put into that piece of literature we pick up and read. We are expectant creatures who complain when it’s too hot outside, not even thinking that, that warmth is keeping us alive, or we get mad when it rains too much, not appreciating

Critical analysis of Macbeth

8212 words - 33 pages Second Witch: "When the hurlyburly's done, / When the battle's lost and won."On a heath the Three Witches decide to meet again after a battle being fought nearby. Thunder, storms and the desolate heath, paint a gloomy picture, setting the tone of this play and defining an imagery of nature at war with itself, a recurring theme in this play...The play begins upon a heath. Thunder and lighting rake the air. Three Witches ask themselves when they

Critical Examination of Malthusian Theory of Population

1292 words - 5 pages Thomas Robert Malthus, very popularly known as Malthus, was a professor of History and Political Economy at Haileybury College of the East Indian Company. He was a philosopher of 19th century. He lived his life from 1766 to 1834 AD. After writing an essay on the Principle of Population in 1805 AD, he became popular in the history of population studies. In his essay which later on became a very famous theory by the name "Malthusian Theory." In

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Man He Killed, Reconciliation, And Dreamers

489 words - 2 pages Analysis of The Man He Killed, Reconciliation, and Dreamers In the chosen poems, Thomas Hardy, Walt Whitman, and Sigfried Sassoon each have a common viewpoint: war brings out the worst in man, a feeling buried deep inside the heart. Even with this clotting of the mind due to the twisting ways of war, a flicker of remorse, a dream of someplace, something else still exists within the rational thought. These poems express hope, the hope

The Explication Of Kim’s Pairing Problem And It’s Effect On Substance Dualism

1240 words - 5 pages also useless. I will be explicating what casual relations are, and the pairing problem to clarify that the pairing problem does render dualism unintelligible. I will further contemplate a possible objection to this position and a possible reply. In conclusion, I agree with Kim’s approach, the pairing problem succeeds in making dualism unintelligible by showing that minds have no way of interacting with physical objects due to the fact that they

Critical Theory Of Technology Essay

1089 words - 5 pages While critical social theorists have included discussion of technology as part of their frameworks of analysis, historically, one must look to the philosophical tradition for exhaustive thought pertaining to technology. Feenberg, trained as an academic philosopher, seeks to bridge this divide between social theory and philosophy. In giving credence to both the philosophical perspectives of Heidegger and Husserl and the critical sociological

The Consequence Of Reconciliation Essay

1094 words - 5 pages Mark Twain, an American author and journalist, once said, “Forgiveness is the fragrance that the violet sheds on the heel that has crushed it”. In this quote, Twain’s words depict the idea that positive outcome will result from the forgiveness, and ultimately the reconciliation, of two parties after an unpleasant circumstance. Likewise, in his novel, Cry, the Beloved Country, Alan Paton portrays the reconciliation of both father and son in the