This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis Of The Article "Caught Up" By Maria G. Rendón

1649 words - 7 pages

Michelle Pham
Travis Beaver
Sociology 308
March 5, 2014
“Caught Up”: A Critical Analysis
“Caught Up” by Maria G. Rendón divides neighborhood mechanisms in order to understand what causes the chain of high school non-completion in poverty-stricken, urban neighborhoods. The study questions the researched claim—and stereotype—that young men who grow up in poor neighborhoods have no care for graduating, and in general, education; however, many studies have disproven this theory and the bigger question becomes how urban neighborhoods are tied to the rate of poor students not graduating. Rendón thus attempts to identify and understand the neighborhood mechanisms that contribute to the high rates of high school non-completion. In order to find these answers, she focuses her study on young Latino men in the Los Angeles area, drawing on interviews from forty-two young men between the ages of seventeen and twenty-three. As a part of her research methods, she meets each one approximately three times over the course of a year. Rendón finds out that urban violence has a large, if not the largest, impact on young men. This, in turn, leads to major consequences such as high school non-completion. Because young men typically turn to their peers, she finds that young men are typically “caught up” in male peer group dynamics. In support of the findings, all of Rendón’s evidence stems from her interviews of all the boys she had spoken to about their experience with high school non-completion.
Rendón focuses on high school non-completion amongst the Latino male youth urban population alone. By narrowing her target of study, she is able to clearly focus on the complex understanding of one class—a class in terms of Weber in which is determined by life chances in the market. This particular class is relatively all on the same level—they were born on the lower level of the economic scale and equally had a worse chance of a good education and a worse chance of a good neighborhood in opposition to a rich class. In Weber’s “Class, Status, Party”, Weber claims that though class and status are similar, there is still a strong distinction between the two categories, as status is an individual trait and evaluation of esteem and honor. Typically, those in a status have more common interests than those who are in the same class. Like so, Rendón claims that, individually, many of the young Latino men follow the same class—they are all young men who are relatively poverty-stricken in urban neighborhoods. Their life chances are all the same as their income and choice of neighborhood are similar. However, like Weber, Rendón claims that an individual’s situation depends on the individual himself as well as the extra-curricular he chooses to partake in and the family he is surrounded by. Even if two young men are born in the same class, if one chooses a buffer in his life in order to achieve graduation, then his “status” would appear differently than a boy who willingly falls to...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis of the Article "Caught Up" by Maria G. Rendón

Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages their methods lead to positive project outcomes, improved performance is not consistently realized. The authors argue that the associations’ one size fits all approach to best practices is insufficient for project success and thus conducted systematic research (SR) to determine if something else is the cause of project success. The current paper will present a critical analysis of the 2011 article, “Now, let’s make it really complex

Article Analysis: How the Media Keeps Us Hung Up on Body Image by Shari Graydon

1615 words - 6 pages Everyone care about beauty and media comes in the way to for its interest by using body image as a tool which only exists in people’s mind. It is unbelievable that how media is blamed for its actions. In the article, “How the Media Keeps Us Hung Up on Body Image” by Shari Graydon, the author claims that women are suffering from unhealthy and harmful disorders due to media influence. As strength, Graydon raises the attention of

Critical Analysis of a Published Article

1197 words - 5 pages easily keep up the reader’s concentration. That is why I have chosen this article. Because it is a very interesting article and it has many, truthful stories which all based to arrange marriages. The other interested point that I preferred this article is how the author clarified the meaning of the arranged marriage and forced marriage. This could give extra interest to this article and may augment the reader's understanding again and again. The

A critical review of the article "In Praise of Cultural Imperialism" by David Rothkopf

702 words - 3 pages In the article, In Praise of Cultural Imperialism, David Rothkopf illustrates a progressive new world order where information is the new global currency and the United States, "the indispensable nation," is the bank. In his article, Rothkopf contrasts the victimizing tendencies of 'cultural barriers', which are the unmistakably causing ethnic, religious, ideological, tribal or nationalistic conflicts, to the uniting tendencies of western

dont get caught by the fish trap

919 words - 4 pages --they can access all yours accounts and rob you blind. The same scam can be used with any financial site, no matter how real it looks.According to the Anti-Phishing Working Group, up to 5% of recipients respond to these bogus messages.By the way, did you notice how the message claims that updating your account will help you avoid future problems? Sneaky, huh? And don't be fooled by the threat to terminate your account if you fail to reply by a

Critical Analysis of the "Rape of the Lock" by Pope

1659 words - 7 pages social frivolities, he uses these various modes of behavior to call attention to the behavior itself. Pope compares and contrasts. He places significant life factors (i.e., survival, death, etc.) side by side with the trivial (although not to Belinda and her friends: love letters, accessories). Although Pope is definitely pointing to the 'lightness' of the social life of the privileged, he also recognizes their sincerity in attempting to be polite

Ne Product Development - Critical Analysis of Article in IJOPM

2700 words - 11 pages advanced operation management theory by suggesting methodologies in evaluating customer support requirement during NPD. The involvement of field engineers and after-sales support staff is crucial in determining the different importance of various aspects of support. In addition, the research also identified that companies use customer support as a means to gain competitive advantage and increase revenues. The case opens up areas in for further

Critical Analysis of Schulman's Article 'Gay Marriage and Marriage'

946 words - 4 pages is irrelevant what sexual orientation a person is, they are still human and they deserve equal treatment and protection under the law. In conclusion his article is highly ineffective due to his illogical arguments. While many of his hypotheses may be readily accepted by the audience, his attempt to reason others his approach is faulty. While his goal of empowering others with his same beliefs might be effective, he still misses with persuasion

"The Case" A Critical analysis of the article "Making His Case" by Karen Tumulty, "Attacking Iraq, Think Again," by Mark Strauss, & a speech on Oct 8, 2002, by Pres Bush

1022 words - 4 pages The debate about the relationship between the United States and Iraq is a hot topicthese days, and there are many differences of opinion to consider. In comparing the speech given by President George Bush, "Saddam Hussein is a Threat to Peace," to an article written by journalist Mark Strauss entitled, "Attacking Iraq, (Think Again)," we see that these two agree on some points, but disagree on more. There are three topics that both men address

A Critical Analysis Of "the Parting" By Michael Drayton

801 words - 3 pages A Critical Analysis of "The Parting" by Michael Drayton By looking at a poem which has a specific form, for example the sonnet, consider to what extent its particular techniques enhance its meaning.      The parting by Michael Drayton is a sonnet. It is a poem about the break up of the relationship between the author and his partner. I feel that the meaning of the poem is greatly enhanced by its form, and

Critical Analysis of The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson

3102 words - 12 pages own life by pleading to Mr. Summers to include her daughter and husband in the drawing to better her chances of living (Friedman 192). ."..when the chips are down, everybody wants just one thing -- to save his own skin" (Cervo 2). This is a horrifying notion in itself; the ritualistic killing of one of their own. In the story, however, this horror is greatly amplified by the way it is set up. For one, the horrifying context of the stories

Similar Essays

A Critical Analysis Of The Article "Progressive Wal Mart. Really." By Sebastian Mallaby

1216 words - 5 pages victims because of low prices. Mallaby argues when Wal-Mart opens store people apply for job proving that not everyone “believes the pay and benefits are unattractive” (621). Although Wal-Mart create jobs, that does not mean it’s a great job; it could be the only job. Wal-Mart employees are losing gains when they work unpaid overtime. In her article, “Up Against Wal-Mart” Karen Olsson states that Wal-Mart makes more than 6.6 billion in profits

Analysis Of The Autobiography "Tapestry" By Maria Palotta Chiarolli

1285 words - 5 pages Tapestry, by Maria Palotta-Chiarolli, is a culture-rich and informative book. It was interesting and engaging, and the book's style allowed me to glimpse at the depth of Palotta-Chiarolli's strong beliefs. I was able delve into her and her family's personalities and experiences through the use of various discourses including feminism, racism and sexual freedom.The book style is a clever and informative one. What once seemed annoying and

Critical Analysis Of The Film Step Up 2: The Streets

943 words - 4 pages Arts, who wanted to compete in an underground dance contest "Streets". The movie was directed by Jon M. Chu, who is also known for directing of "G.I. Joe: Retaliation." The film "Step Up 2" has grossed more than fifteen million dollars while its budget was just twenty-two millions; as a result, it surpassed the original movie and was quite successful. Some films do not need unimaginable special effects, sophisticated storyline, and world

The Feminization Of The Community Corrections Work Force Critique Based Upon The Conceptual Article By Jo G. Holland

699 words - 3 pages Article Critique PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2 Running head: ARTICLE CRITIQUEArticle Critique: The Feminization of the Community Corrections Work Force January 17, 2012This is a critique of an article that has been written in a historical context by Jo G. Holland and published in Corrections Today titled; "The Feminization of the Community Corrections Work Force". This article discusses issues related to women in the male dominated correctional