This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis On Susan Rose Ackerman's Article "Bribes, Patronage And Gift Giving, As Well As Richard Friman And Peter Andreas' Article "International Relations And The Illicit Global Economy

1195 words - 5 pages

Corruption is not a new phenomenon in today's society, but it is an increasing problem. It is an ailment that causes many problems for countries, as well as international relations. When one thinks of corruption they do not think of the consequences that it brings along with it. However, in Susan Rose-Ackerman's' article "Bribes, Patronage, and Gift Giving" along with Richard Friman and Peter Andreas in their article "International Relations and the Illicit Global Economy" they provide two different types of corruption, and the negative effects it brings along with it. Although their approach to the topic is different their main emphases is the same, corruption is harmful.In Susan Rose-Ackerman's article she distinguishes between bribes, tips, gifts, and prices in a model that imposes the existence of a quid pro quo, and the presence or absence of an agent or a principal. According to Ackerman agency principal relationships in the public sector gives rise to corrupt opportunities. Therefore, Ackerman believes that one way to reduce corruption is to eliminate the agency principal relationship. If citizens dealt directly with the principal then bribes or "gifts" to the agent would be avoided. When an explicit exchange is taking place with a principal it is seen as a price, and with an agent it is seen as a bribe. On the other hand, if no quid pro quo is expected by the principal it is recognized as a gift and as a tip by the agent. However, if a gift is large enough to have an impact on the recipient's behaviour a quid pro is implicit.In this article Ackerman is arguing that in many societies there is no distinction between the public and private roles. Especially in developing countries where gift giving and patronage are accepted practices. In developing countries the line between market and family, and between the public and the private sector is often indistinct. She believes that although personal ties in the market can be functional they are not always compatible with efficiency. It can facilitate corruption and undermine the attempts to improve the operation of the state. Nevertheless, in societies with rooted interpersonal networks Ackerman believes that the citizens may care little about market and public sector efficiency. They believe they should give to their friends and family with expectations of a gift in return.Trade in patrimonial systems is a culture trading system that appears legitimate within that society. However, what Ackerman is arguing in this article is that societies based on personal relationships will have difficulty developing a large-scale capitalist enterprise, or supporting active cross-border trade. Since loyalty to family dominates loyalty to the state they will also have difficulty establishing modern bureaucracies. Thus, it is obvious that the costs for informal transfers in developing countries outweigh the benefits. She disputes that since the cause for so much corruption in these developing countries is due...

Find Another Essay On Critical analysis on Susan Rose-Ackerman's article "Bribes, Patronage and Gift Giving, as well as Richard Friman and Peter Andreas' article "International relations and the Illicit global Economy

This is an Article analysis for an Economics class. Examines the US economy and inflation

627 words - 3 pages If someone earns a sum of money, and saves it rather than spends it, then, in no way can a person be losing wealth if not for inflation, which prompts the prices of all goods and services to rise. One may see this as a trend among businesses to maximize their profits. In reality, the root cause of the problem is not with businesspeople, but the Federal Reserve System continuously adding more money into the economy. The article I have chosen to

"Famine, Affluence and Morality", article by Peter Singer

700 words - 3 pages to famine relief. Singer rejects the distinction between the obligatory and the supererogatory, and he is claiming that there is no line between justice and charity. He writes, "The traditional distinction between duty and charity cannot be drawn, or at least, not in the place we normally draw it. Giving money to the Bengal Relief Fund is regarded as an act of charity in our society..." (792). This suggests that famine relief belongs on the

Rhetorical and Fallacies in the Article “The Media Violence Myth” by Richard Rhodes

1410 words - 6 pages two are in agreement regarding the subject of violence in the media. To the left-leaning, primary audience, this strategy is most likely to be effective. Because the affiliated readers already scorn those who support censorship, the idea of Grossman being less aesthetically (and thus logically) sensible than Sohn acts as an affirmation of their beliefs; Rhodes is jumping on the bandwagon and giving his audience what it wants to hear. However, a

A critical appraisal on the article by John A. Cross titled, Megacites and small towns: Different perspectives on hazard vulnerability

1154 words - 5 pages towns are more vulnerable tohazards compared to megacities, due to their lack of resources, money, government interest andnumerous other factors. At first glance, the article seemed well researched and discussed,but further consideration proved otherwise. John Cross's failure to consider recent eventssurrounding hazard vulnerability such as changing population demographics, the emergence ofnew un-natural hazards and the current discussions on hazard

Public investment and its efffect on economy - 2nd year Economics honours - Article

788 words - 4 pages 1.Introduction: This paper looks at the empirical record whether big infrastructure and public capital drives have succeeded in accelerating economic growth in low-income countries. It looks at big long-lasting drives in public capital spending, as these were arguably clear and exogenous policy decisions. On average the evidence shows only a weak positive association between investment spending and growth and only in the same year, as lagged

Critical Thinking Article Summary and Critique for MGT350

664 words - 3 pages AbstractThe purpose of critical thinking is to achieve understanding, evaluate view points, and solve problems. One can say that critical thinking is the questioning or inquiry to understand, evaluate, or resolve.This paper will summarize the article "Critical Thinking Crucial to Global Success" by A Chaedar Alwasilah. The article examines the ineptness of the various methods and techniques of teaching language in Indonesia.This analysis will

Critical Analysis of Peter Coclanis’ Article: Atlantic World or Atlantic/World?

1549 words - 6 pages colonies. He states that: roughly 75 percent of one of its most important (and certainly celebrated) economic resources, American silver, ended up in China during the early modern period and when the Spanish real functioned as the international trading currency over much of Asia. Here he supplies the reader with contextual evidence enhancing his main argument, something that is rare within his paper. Coclanis goes on to mention the influence of

Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages second provides the current author’s reflection on his approach to his dissertation. Critical Analysis The purpose of Geraldi’s et al. (2011, p. 967) SR is to increase understanding of the context in which work is accomplished, the nature of an organization’s response within that context, and its impact on project success. Moreover, they sought to understand the conceptual model that treats complexity as an independent variable (IV) to a

Critical Analysis of a Published Article

1197 words - 5 pages , because his marriage has been successful and still he lives with his partner. This winning marriage, organized before even writer come to this planet. In addition, this is proving to the writer’s standpoint, as well as a clear message to those people traumatized in the arranged marriage. The article deems how a subjective British Asian for an arranged marriage is” In my point of view, first British Asian people are largest community who lives

Critical Article Review

636 words - 3 pages the local to the global, primarily whether globalisation establishes a system of cultural homogeneity or heterogeneity (Connell, 2007: 374). Nederveen Pieterse as cited by Connell (2007: 374) argues that we have developed a system of “structural hybridity” whereby a diverse range of local cultural values are combined in order to create a global culture. Through globalisation, we come to acknowledge and even adopt forms of clothing, food and

Critical analysis for theories of international relations

1809 words - 7 pages that the concept of critical theory draw information and knowledge from different aspects and factors such as the disciplines concerning humanities and even so-called social sciences. Apparently, it can be seen that the history of critical theory can be rooted to the foundations set forth by Marx. It can be seen that there are different concepts that are attached to the principle of critical theory relative of the international relations

Similar Essays

Analysis On Article 'the Long March' And Link To Poems Of Peter Skrznecki

1440 words - 6 pages surprised also as I never heard of the event before. I felt this article was based on a physical journey that was a true accomplishment and I felt it's consequences spanned further than any other material I had viewed.I think the author did a great job portraying the story using this text type, although I think the into duction of side plots or characters would have wrecked the reality of the story, I do feel that this type of article should be more

A Critical Analysis Of A Journal Article: Effects Of Welfare Reform On Illicit Drug Use Of Adult

1617 words - 7 pages Considerable research has previously been conducted to analyze the effects welfare reform has had on its intended purposes such as employment, caseloads, or familial cohesion. And while there have been a few studies that examined the correlation between women receiving welfare and drug use, the effects of reform in regards to illicit drug use, specifically women, had not been previously evaluated. As legislation passed the Personal

Critical Analysis Of Schulman's Article 'gay Marriage And Marriage'

946 words - 4 pages . Schulman's argument could be strengthened if he removes the statements regarding female sexuality in marriage as well as contraceptives. Finally he should actually discuss the view points of those who support homosexual marriage, not simply the views of those who are against it. Works Cited Shulman, Sam. "Sam Shulman -- Gay Marriage -- and Marriage." OrthodoxyToday.org |. Commentary Magazine, Nov. 2003. Web. 31 May 2010. .

Critical Thinking Article Summary And Critique

526 words - 2 pages resolve the problem, the author recommends updating the teaching methodologies with critical thinking as one of the focus of curriculum. The students need to be provided better opportunities to communicate, contribute and be encouraged to develop critical thinking. This change would help them face global challenges and competition in an effective manner.ReferencesCritical thinking crucial to global success, Jakarta Post (Indonesia), May 02, 2002