Critical Analysis:Robert Kolker, 'the "Truth" Of The Image.'

1249 words - 5 pages

In 2002, Robert Kolker claimed in his article 'The "Truth" of The Image', that the image 'is not the thing itself but a thing in itself' . The reading discusses documentary in terms of its representation of images creating a problematic relationship between the constructed image we are shown on screen and the real object. This essay will consider key themes and questions which arise from the reading, including the strengths and weaknesses of Kolker's argument, and will apply it to the documentary film Nanook of the North (Robert J. Flaherty 1922 USA).Documentary programmes initially appealed to the middle-classes and were intended functionally. They were used for propaganda purposes during the colonisation of nations and the First World War. Documentaries took on the form of illustrated lectures at this time, eventually being replaced post-war by straight documentaries without a lecturer . Documentary as a filmic genre had been defined by John Grierson in 1926 as 'the creative treatment of actuality' , which Brian Winston acknowledged as being problematic because the idea that 'creative treatment' and 'actuality' can co-exist as a genre is inexperienced and duplicitous .This idea is the basis for Kolker's argument. While language can carry a variety of meanings, visualisations allow us to feel closer to reality, as he says, 'when we approve of the reality of a film, we are really affirming our comfort with it' . Kolker emphasises the fact that once a camera or person intervenes, neutrality is lost and the photograph's objectivity is removed. When audiences see an image on screen, they want to associate it with the real thing so much that they perceive it as being the actual object. While we know that these images are mediated, it is hard to reconcile the artificiality when we see it. Kolker also highlights the fact that media is selective and manipulative, we only see what they want to show us, our responses are guided by them, and the world we see is mediated by them.Kolker appears to have a structuralist approach. James Monaco defined this theoretical approach as 'structuralism, with its offspring, semiotics, is a generalised worldview that uses the idea of language as its basic tool' . This affects Kolker's argument, as everything is seen as symbolic; representing something, therefore, he inadvertently ignores the audience and their ability to read things differently where meaning is negotiated rather than fixed. This causes problems for Kolker's argument, as meanings are not fixed, and always open to interpretation. In 2000, Stella Bruzzi offered a more informed view of documentaries. She acknowledges that documentary cannot give a real view as people know that they are being represented and is very critical of the debate that exists over documentary. She argues that this idealised notion of documentary being pure and real, is impossible, although reality cannot be denied and it doesn't lose validity because it becomes represented. Instead,...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis:Robert Kolker, 'The "Truth" Of the Image.'

The History of Image Comics Essay

682 words - 3 pages Have you ever got tired of reading long novels that are boring and have a predictable ending? Try something new and fresh with variety in books that are short, and always bringing action to the scene. Read material from the best authors and illustrators from around the world. Image Comics has been a successful publisher due to the foundation of the company, the quality of promotion, and the variety of comic books. When Todd McFarlane

The Evolution of Lilith’s Image Essay

1183 words - 5 pages evolution of Lilith’s image is evidence that reputation and representation don’t always match the historical background but they are constantly changing with social constructs. Works Cited Cotterell, Arthur. The Encyclopedia of Mythology. London: Lorenz, 1996. Print. "Epic of Gilgamesh." Epic of Gilgamesh. N.p., n.d. Web. 03 Nov. 2013. Dante Gabriel Rossetti, “Body’s Beauty” in The House of Life: A Sonnet-Sequence (Cambridge, MA

The Image of Chaucer's Squire.

527 words - 2 pages In the General Prologue of Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales, the author provides its readers with an introduction of the pilgrims. In the Prologue, Chaucer describes the pilgrims in a very visual way. When looking at the illustrations, which are located on The Geoffrey Chaucer Website, features, and characteristics, occur in both the text and the illustrations. In this paper, it will become clear which features and characteristics of the

The Truth of the Gospel

1723 words - 7 pages When people hear the word “gospel,” they typically associate it with the Bible, and for a variety of people this is the extent of their biblical knowledge. While numerous people instinctively turn their heads away at the mention of religion, their assumptions of the Gospels as boring, stuffy orders to obey God are often incorrect. Sure, most people would find more excitement and pleasure reading a Harry Potter book instead of the Bible, but

The Truth of Time Travel

539 words - 2 pages advanced world, compared to the Time Travelers encounters that far into the future. It is almost as if the time of the world reset itself. I saw an image of early people living simple, happy lives from our history. An example would be the Native Americans. Later into the novel, the Time Traveler noticed that the machine was no longer where he left it, but instead it had been taken. He then realized that it had been brought to a building where he

The Fatal Truth of Irony

1467 words - 6 pages to others that we are all copycats and we should strive to be more creative. The truth of the matter is that we are all different; each one of us brings something unique to this world. For some individuals it takes a considerable amount of time to find out that we are all one of a kind; for others they never come to this conclusion. Optimistically, after reading this story one will realize that the need to stand out and not be a part of the masses

Changing the Image of the Youth Minister

2631 words - 11 pages Changing the Image of the Youth Minister For the past twenty years, the average tenure of youth ministers has been disgustingly short. “Fifteen hundred Youth Pastors leave the ministry each month due to moral failure, getting a better paid position, spiritual burnout, or contention in their churches” (Krejcir 1). What factors are causing this? Do they have commitment issues? Do the senior pastors not trust them? Do they see the job as a

The Media's Distorted Image of the World

877 words - 4 pages Media – what does it bring us? In our everyday lives, people are exposed to all kinds of media. Many people around the world watch movies, read cartoons and glance at the television. Although they may not realize it, they are under the influence of the images that they see. In fact, these sources may make people have negative assumptions about Middle East. Every so often, there are stereotypical judgments and comments in the media

The Truth

1017 words - 4 pages The Truth How can we define truth when we don’t even know the interpretations of what truth is? What I found very interesting was this quote "Half of a truth is not the Truth". I believe that when we tell the truth we never tell 100% of the truth. We might be embarrassed about the whole truth or maybe we just don’t want to tell how we handled the situation so we remove our

The truth

560 words - 2 pages By: lori The Truth, the Whole Truth and Nothing But…Lies Textbooks in today's schools still tell the same story that has been handed down from generation to generation. Every year children dress up and put on plays about the famous story of the first Thanksgiving. No one knows the truth though or at least people pretend to not know the embarrassing truth of our "founding fathers." Textbooks today give the candy coated version of good

the truth

759 words - 4 pages the dog far away in case the dog bit us. I didn’t agree with my mother. I found some information via the internet. I though I found the truth of the rabies finally. First, the dog will not attach the people without any reason. The dog will attach the people when they feel danger. Second, even though we get the vaccination after the dog bite us, it is still useful to avoid the rabies. I think the media hypes up danger that doesn’t exist. I think

Similar Essays

A Convenient Appeal: The Image Of Urgency In An Inconvenient Truth

1336 words - 6 pages 2006 documentary film An Inconvenient Truth, Al Gore uses a combination of appeals to logic and emotion to stress the urgency of the global warming crisis to an audience of everyday individuals. Gore’s logical appeals emphasize the danger and significance of global warming in a cogent, engaging multimedia platform. Rather than monotonously expounding upon detail after detail, he uses interactive visual aids to clarify his claims. As Stefan

Image Of The Turks Essay

767 words - 3 pages The Image of the Turks Throughout history the Ottoman Empire was looked upon as having a barbaric and lustful people. This was the opinion of a majority of Western Europeans. Andrew Wheatcroft wrote The Ottomans to show exactly how the Europeans did look on the Turks. This paper shows how the feelings toward the Ottomans created stereotypes that lasted centuries. The Europeans looked upon the Turks as lower forms of human beings

The Truth Project: The Search Of Truth

1610 words - 7 pages ? Isaiah 6 gives us the solution: we must gaze into the face of God. This journey of seeking His face exposes us, exposes our culture, and turns us into world changers. This quest is only for those brave enough to explore the wondrous depths and layers of the Most High. It is the search for truth-- the most life-changing discovery an individual will ever uncover. Tour One: Veritology Doctor Del Tackett challenges your way of thinking with a question

Flexibility Of The Truth Essay

1893 words - 8 pages "Story-truth is sometimes truer than happening-truth." (171) When most people read this quote in Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried, they think story truth is emotional truth while happening truth refers to the facts and reality. But beneath the surface we see that the truth is never actually told. No matter how you tell a story the actual truth will never be revealed. The actual truth is for our own sense of self. Throughout the story