Critical Commentary On Urban Sustainability Essay

1573 words - 6 pages

Since the late 1980s, the notion of ‘sustainable development’ has transcended beyond the eminent United Nations report titled Our Common Future, to mainstream dialogue throughout the globe at all scales within government and public spheres. This form of development seeks to balance current environmental, social and economic needs of the population, “without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987, 43). Used interchangeably with ‘sustainability’ (Seghezzo, 2009), the concept has been fastened to a plethora of themes, including that of cities where ‘urban sustainability’ speaks to negligent urban expansion and resource depletion. However, as the idea of urban sustainability has begun percolating into widespread discussions, so to have the obstacles and conflicts surrounding sustainable development. The following sections will examine these complexities, beginning with the ambiguity of sustainable development, followed by interpretations of urban sustainability, and finally, the political ecology of sustainable development in an urban environment.
Sustainable Cities or Cities that Contribute to Sustainable Development
Critique of the term ‘sustainable development’ has primarily surrounded its wide scope of interpretation, which is regarded as both a strength, in its ability to foster multi-stakeholder cooperation, and a weakness, in that anybody can claim they are contributing to sustainability goals (Dale, 2001; Robinson, 2009). Satterthwaite’s article entitled “Sustainable Cities or Cities that Contribute to Sustainable Development” (1997), alludes to the ambiguity of the term and explores the predicament rather than benefit this creates for achieving a city that harmonizes the environmental, economic, and social needs described in Our Common Future.
As the wordplay in Satterthwaite’s title suggests, the various interpretations of ‘sustainable’ and ‘development’ will dictate a city’s actions, due to the strategic selection of what is being sustained in a sustainable city. For instance, Satterthwaite (1997) suggests that a sustainable city may be construed in an entirely social manner, leading to the sustaining –or rather preservation – of existing social structures within the city. Consequentially, the achievement of the United Nation’s ‘sustainable development’ is compromised, since the economic and environmental aspects are left out of the scenario (Satterthwaite, 1997). This example also exposes the anthropocentrism embedded in ‘sustainability’, as human needs are often emphasized over environmental concerns. However, in this context, the oppression of nature is to be expected since ‘sustainable development’ is ultimately a Western construct designed for human benefit and because of this, will never remedy the ecological crisis society has created (Seghezzo, 2009).
A city contributing to sustainable development invokes a different set...

Find Another Essay On Critical Commentary on Urban Sustainability

Sustainable Development Essay

2259 words - 9 pages the decision makers from the other. Subsequently, design codes are vital in achieving the sustainability standards required on the Upton site. Moreover, social sustainability was considered by the Upton scheme. Taking into account the surrounding communities of Upton Grange and Duston village, a critical mass of local population will be created to support and sustain amenities and a viable public transport system. Furthermore, Upton’s design

defined urbanization Essay

9210 words - 37 pages - banisation are: • The potential conflicts between economic growth and environmental sustainability: ways must be found to achieve pro-poor economic development but also to re- duce the environmental impact of economic growth and urban production both on towns and cities themselves, and on the global environment. • Urban economic development is often threatened by changes in national and global economies. Even when economic growth

Sustainable Sanitation for Urban Slum

4880 words - 20 pages lack of community demand (Kvarnstorm and McConville 2007). Therefore, it is critical to learn from the past lesson and identify potential approaches to provide sustainable sanitation for urban slum dwellers.According to Bracken et al., (2005) sustainability with regards to sanitation requires to encompass:"Collection, storage, transport, and treatment of human excreta, grey water, solid waste and storm water, and the safe disposal or reuse of end

Sustainable Sanitation for Urban Slum Population

4880 words - 20 pages lack of community demand (Kvarnstorm and McConville 2007). Therefore, it is critical to learn from the past lesson and identify potential approaches to provide sustainable sanitation for urban slum dwellers.According to Bracken et al., (2005) sustainability with regards to sanitation requires to encompass:"Collection, storage, transport, and treatment of human excreta, grey water, solid waste and storm water, and the safe disposal or reuse of end

Urban Transition - The Plague in Disguise

2624 words - 11 pages known for giving many challenges on the fellow citizens. Firstly, it could cause overpopulation, which in turn can cause high unemployment rates. Secondly, it increases the chances of no basic access to land and health services to urban poor residents of slum areas in the cities. Lastly, urban transition can result in lower sustainability due to increasing amount of migrations. The trend of moving to bigger city in search for a “better” living

How Urbanization is Defining the New Generation

830 words - 4 pages that all educational bodies share. Topics like environmental sustainability, civic engagement and future planning are lacking in many urban curriculum, despite the overwhelming need to educate current generations on their future. Lack of focus on critical thinking and real world applications of education, decrease motivation to participate in school. This issues is often paired with discrimination based on race, ethnicity, gender, and other


1263 words - 6 pages importance of sustainability (Orlitzky & Benjamin, 2001; Orlitzky, Schmidt, & Rynes, 2003). However, the employee involvement in sustainability initiatives, and the effect of sustainability strategies on employee outcomes are not yet fully discovered. Given the emphasis on employee participation in corporate sustainability initiatives, understanding its effect on the employee related outcomes is critical. The impact of sustainability strategies on


889 words - 4 pages studios will facilitate critical inquiry into complex planning problems that may be physical, spatial, cultural, ecological and economic in nature. The program focus is on sustainable urban development; the restructuring, regeneration and revitalization of existing metropolitan areas. This objective shall be accomplished by providing a combined multicultural and ecological framework of study. The skills of defining problems, analyzing situations

The Trade-offs Between Environmental and Economic Objectives in the Urban Context

1818 words - 8 pages non-existent . The implementation of national and local policies for urban sustainable development in order to create sustainable cities becomes a priority in the world as a whole. The international community is more often emphasizing that dealing with the issues of environmental sustainability should not be happening exclusively at the international level, on the contrary, these political decisions should be practiced and implemented at the local

Making Sustainability Work

1023 words - 5 pages , it is also critical to disclose sustainability information externally as well. The global reporting initiative began with Ceres and UNEP whose mission was “developing globally applicable guidelines for reporting on the economic, environmental, and social performance of corporations, governments, and NGOs (Epstein, 2008).” This initiative contains three main elements: sustainability reporting guidelines, protocols, and sector supplements. When

Brownfield Redevelopment for Sustainable Communities within Canada

1789 words - 8 pages process involves a great deal of research, technology and laborious methods to stop and reverse the sites environmental damage (Hardisty, 242). Nevertheless, once completed, brownfield redevelopment sites have numerous benefits that support sustainability. However, since it is unfeasible for a human economy to have no impacts on the environment, we will consider the model presented by the Worldwatch Institute (Worldwatch Institute, 6). Within

Similar Essays

Critical Commentary On "Of Mice And Men" And "Equal Rites"

706 words - 3 pages gradually, setting the pace. "Of Mice and Men" too, has the setting introduced on its own. The similarity of its introduction to that of a live character is further emphasized by the fact that some elements of the background are personified: "The water is warm too, for it has slipped twinkling........the narrow pool".Both texts then have secondary characters introduced to the setting. In "Equal Rites" the quote "most unpleasantly armed starcruiser

Interpretation Of Urban Design Essay

1208 words - 5 pages only derived from completed structures. Unbuilt and demolished designs also contribute to telling an alternative commentary on the existing built environment (Childs, 2008). Identity of the Space The presence of strong urban design leads to branding, an identity or character for the place. Aelbrecht (2010), in his study noted that newly designed public realms are so focused on aesthetic aspects that it leaves little room for discussion of anything

Designing A Sustainable Backyard Garden Suburban

1727 words - 7 pages garden area, albeit a shrinking one, gives us the opportunity to implement a thoughtful design to make this a productive and sustainable place. According to Thiele (2013), sustainability demands the “satisfying current needs without sacrificing future well being through the balanced pursuit of ecological health, economic welfare, social empowerment, and cultural creativity.” The sustainable backyard garden design is aimed at achieving this on a

Making Sustainability Work In The Business World

996 words - 4 pages Protecting the environment has become an important issue in today’s society. There is no longer any doubt that businesses should consider their social responsibility and the impact of their activities on their stakeholders. In addition, firms are beginning to realize that corporate sustainability can prove to be a win win. There are multiple benefits of sustainability linked to costs, revenues, community relations, and more. The decision to