This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Evaluation Of Taylorism And Fordism

1465 words - 6 pages

Taylorism is also known as scientific management which named after Frederick W. Taylor. It is a production efficiency methodology that breaks works into small and simple segments which can be easily analysed and taught. Taylorism was first mentioned in 1920s and 20 years later. Henry Ford, who was the founder of the Ford Motor Company, used the scientific management in the form of assembly line production as a method on the T-model car production of his company. This kind of production method then was developed into a new efficient methodology which is called Fordism. In this essay, it is going to critically evaluate the main features of Taylorism and compare it to Fordism and other later-developed production methodology. Firstly, it will illustrate the main features of Taylorism by using some typical examples from contemporary times. Secondly, it is going to show the principal criticisms from other socialists and critique some of them by using some modern features. Finally, Fordism, Post-Fordism and McDonaldisation are going to be mentioned for some further analysis.
The main and first principle of Taylorism is that “management should reduce the industry knowledge to ‘rules, laws, and formulae.’”(Haralambos&Holborn 2004:635) The main cause of the division of industrial knowledge of three main parts is ‘inefficiency’ which is the waste of resources, especially the waste of time. According to Taylor, before implement the scientific management, workers and managers are the two groups seen by him as causing inefficiency of work. For workers, they try to work as slow as they can and are not interested to give their best; this kind of act of omission to work is human nature, in Taylor’s word, called ‘natural soldiering’. More importantly, another kind of soldiering is called ‘systematic’, which is apart from the individual nature but mainly due to group work and group control of output. According to Michael Rose, “He (Taylor) did so not because it shows any inherent ‘group instinct’ towards sociability and solidarity but because it ‘results from careful study on the part of the workmen of what will promote their best interests’.”(Rose 1975:33) Meanwhile, for the managers, the inefficiency is incompetence. Although managers understand the market very well and know how to operate the marketing stuff, they do not understand what is happening on shop floor and the production process as well. “Managers lacked information about workers’ abilities and the time which are reasonably required to perform industrial tasks.”(Rose 1975:33) Still, time is the main problem; the time of the production process is not set by the specific experts who understand the production and can maximum economic returns but the workers themselves who have the characteristic of natural and systematic soldiering.
According to Taylor’s solution, the essence of solving inefficiency is to introduce the work study and understand how the work can be done, what can be improved and to...

Find Another Essay On Critical Evaluation of Taylorism and Fordism

Critical Thinking -A Personal Response and Evaluation

1597 words - 6 pages PAGE PAGE 10 Critical Thinking- A Personal Response AbstractWe will compare and contrast the differing definitions of critical thinking and provide personal evaluation of how cognitive development, logic, and emotionality relate to our ability to think critically. An agreement to define critical thinking between scholars of philosophy and psychology remains difficult because of their differing thoughts on the subject matter. Critical thinking

Resource evaluation, notes and critical engagement

747 words - 3 pages Task 2: - Resource evaluation, notes and critical engagementThe method that I used for searching of resources will preferably through the sequence of first finding through academic books, then resources from the library and lastly from the internet. I always start researching from academic books because I believe that it is a more reliable and related resources to the question of the essay, or else the academic textbook won't even be given to us

Functionalism and Marxism. A Critical Evaluation

1396 words - 6 pages Functionalism and Marxism. A Critical Evaluation During the 18th and 19th centuries, political and industrial revolutions coupled with a philosophical movement which promoted a new scientific way of thinking (`The Enlightenment'), heralded the advent of several new scientific disciplines. These social sciences attempted to explain the rapid and fundamental changes which were shattering traditional ways of life in Britain and Europe. Sociology

A Critical Evaluation of An Inspector Calls

1166 words - 5 pages An Inspector Calls Critical Evaluation - The main goal of this essay is to write about the role of Inspector Goole in the play. Other details will also going into consideration. An Inspector Calls Critical Evaluation The main goal of this essay is to write about the role of Inspector Goole in the play. Other details will also going into consideration. An Inspector Calls is a play wrote by J.B Priestly. The first scene shows a

A Critical Evaluation of Small Business

9577 words - 38 pages A Critical evaluation of small business in South wale and UKAbstractTraditional training separates learning from the work context in which the newly acquired knowledge is to be applied. This requires the worker themselves to apply imparted theoretical knowledge to knowledge in practice, a process that is grossly inefficient. The ENRICH approach builds on organisational learning theory to intertwine working and learning. The ENRICH methodology

Compare and contrast the Human Relations School of thought with Taylorism

2172 words - 9 pages IntroductionSince the end of the 19th century, when factory manufacturing became widespread and the size of organisations increased, people have been looking for ways to motivate employees and improve productivity. This essay will focus on two of the earliest management approaches of Taylorism and the Human Relations School. First the central tenets of both models are outlined giving examples of how they are still applied in contemporary society

Critical Thinking and Decision Making Critical Thinking is defined as the systematic evaluation of arguments based on explicit rational criteria

626 words - 3 pages Critical Thinking and Decision MakingCritical Thinking is defined as the systematic evaluation of arguments based on explicit rational criteria (Browne and Stuart IX). Deductive reasoning is the first tool that reasonable people can use to improve their critical thinking skills. Critical thinking requires people to be able to find the faulty reasoning and deductions in an argument. Incorrect or inconclusive assumptions must be identified and

Geographical Dispersion: Outline this concept in relation to cultural production and discuss its connections with the concept of post-fordism

1023 words - 4 pages New York can employ artists in Japan to write Japanese comics for the Japanese market. Thus capitalising on a foreign market whilst remaining in the same place.Under fordist type approaches, this method would have been almost impossible, as a whole company would work under one roof or in close proximity to each stage of production. The concept of fordism relies on the ordering of the production process into a complex and rigid set of relationships


3103 words - 12 pages MKIB372A CRITICAL EVALUATION ON THE CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS OF MCDONALD'STABLE OF CONTENTSPage1. Executive Summary 32. Introduction 43. Internal Communications 53.1. Intranet system 53.2. Employee magazine 83.3 Other internal methods 104. External Communications 114.1. Official website 124.2. Social media 164.2.1 Facebook 165. Recommendations 206. References 22 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARYThe report provides a critical evaluation on several

A Critical Evaluation of Assisi by Norman MacCaig

1349 words - 5 pages A Critical Evaluation of Assisi Q: Choose a poem in which the poet has put across a definite point of view. By close reference to the poetic techniques used, show how successful the poet has been in making you share his/ her point of view. “Assisi” by Norman MacCaig is an intriguing and thought-provoking poem, which has put across a definite point of view to me which I believe is that all people should be treated equally and we should

A critical evaluation of an IS case study (Fedex)

1917 words - 8 pages FedEx A Critical Analysis of an IS Case StudyWhat is E-commerce? Commerce is the buying and selling of goods and services. Over the past few years' commerce has moved from traditional features of selling products, but one main feature stays the same, the people.This essay will discuss how the FedEx Corporation used e-business and IT to grab a competitive advantage within their market place, this can be achieved by following some IS strategies

Similar Essays

The Impact Of Taylorism And Fordism On The Us Motor Vehicle Industry

2160 words - 9 pages Scientific Management Intro : This paper takes a look at the ways in which the ideas of Fordism and Taylorism helped the success of the U.S motor vehicle industry. The motor vehicle industry has changed the fundamental ideas on the process of manufacturing and probably more expressively on how humans work together to create value. In my essay we will take a look at Frederick Taylors principles of scientific management and his contribution

Taylorism And Human Relations School Of Thought

2202 words - 9 pages IntroductionSince the end of the 19th century, when factory manufacturing became widespread and the size of organisations increased, people have been looking for ways to motivate employees and improve productivity. Classical schools of management thought was built up at that time by Frederick.W.Taylor. After that, management became a ture science. However, in 1930s, pactical problems caused by Taylorism led to its replacement by the human

Critical Analysis And Evaluation Of 1984, By George Orwell

1478 words - 6 pages last stage came in the dreaded Room 101, where Winston was made to face what he secretly feared most, rats. He betrays Julia and is subjugated physically, mentally, and emotionally. All that remains is for Winston to love Big Brother.Personal Evaluation of Book and AuthorGeorge Orwell is an excellent author. Before I was introduced with 1984, I read Animal Farm and this gave me a taste for his writing. In both Animal Farm and 1984 alike, Orwell's

Critical Evaluation Of Learning Resources Essay

1284 words - 5 pages Critical Evaluation of Learning Resources The learning resource that will be examined will be the online learning supplementary material for the "Critical Thinking in Adult Education 41909" on WebCT. WebCT is the major provider of e-learning systems for higher education institutions such as university. WebCT provides a highly flexible e-learning environment that empowers institutions the ability to achieve their unique objectives. University