Critical Reading On Patriarchal Confusion? London School Of Economics Assignment

1428 words - 6 pages

Critical Reading on Patriarchal Confusion?
Shiyuan Li
201701858
Abstract
Through a reading and analysis of Sarah Bulmer’s article, patriarchal confusion? (2013), I summarize Sarah’s objective of research on which her research is mainly based, and the key approach she adopted to scrutinize patriarchal confusion. Besides, I conclude several crucial concepts in Sarah’s work in order to interpret her principle argument and further suggestions about the sites of patriarchal confusion which might be fertile grounds for feminists’ interposition. This is followed by an evaluative examine into Sarah’s argument and I demonstrate several research weaknesses, namely the taken-for-granted coherence between feminism and homosexual pursuits and the absence of policy-makers’ perspective, after which I come up with my own argument and reflective opinions.
Keywords
Patriarchal confusion; heteronormative; case-study; interposition
Patriarchal confusion in the military
In patriarchal confusion? (2013), Sarah Bulmer places emphasis on the patriarchal confusion, occurring when queer identity and military identity come to an intersection, examined through ‘performativity’ of which the concepts are from Butler (1999). A well-established qualitative case-study approach is adopted in this essay for two key processes to capture the emerging complexities of patriarchal confusion: (1) by scrutinizing the process of the ban of discharging gay personnel being overturned in British armed forces, Bulmer investigates the conceptual aporia when the military intends to declare sexuality in private sphere; (2) by scrutinizing the interview of three military workers with different ranks and roles showing contrasting views on LGBT participation in 2008 London Pride, Bulmer undertakes an amplified analysis of their responses and offers a detailed inquiry about paradoxical military identities. A performative approach of which the crucial insight is that gender ought to be understood based on the alleged ‘matrix of intelligibility’, is taken in this study to reveal how gender identities are governed and reproduced. In the process of the legitimacy of LGBT inclusion, queer identity is regulated or disciplined by the military identity, through the legitimacy of ‘coming out’ behaviors and then marginalizing other activities, despite of the patriarchal confusion, originating from the attempt to distinguish sexual identity and military identity into private/public sphere, which still reinforces the heterosexual gender norm. Correspondingly in the LGBT personnel marching at London Pride event, when gender subjects are relying upon the intrinsic heterosexual norm to seek their self-recognition within the social realm, the patriarchal rule will continuously be reproduced and take place to marginalize the minority, even if patriarchal confusion has shown the paradoxical nature of heteronormative.
Through investigating different cases, the specific objective of this study is to demonstrate the...

Find Another Essay On Critical Reading on Patriarchal Confusion? - london school of economics - assignment

Events Management critical essay on Taste of London festival - Undergraduate Events management - Essay

1860 words - 8 pages festivals have changed, and they have become a variety of music, food and beverage. In this assignment I will be focusing on one specific annually (four days; twice a year) run festival that is held within multiple locations throughout the world but this assignment I will only be focusing on one event of the franchise, London, United Kingdom. The festival I’ve chosen to discuss within this assignment is The Taste of London food festival which is an

A Naive Opinion on the Nation's Economic Health (Based off of Reading Naked Economics)

584 words - 2 pages generally bad (and that scary word, economy, is on there every once in awhile); (2) I don't know what the main economic issues are; and (3) I better get started on that summer reading if I want to understand this class. My assumption that the US economy is in such bad shape, is solely based on the fact that I hear more complaints than praises of the system. It seems that people assume the economy should be working perfectly at all times--so when it

Essay on Condemnation of a Patriarchal Society in Yellow Wallpaper

899 words - 4 pages Condemnation of a Patriarchal Society in The Yellow Wallpaper        Charlotte Perkins Gilman was crafty. Taken at face value, her short work, The Yellow Wallpaper, is simply the diary of a woman going through a mental breakdown. The wallpaper itself is the arbitrary object on which a troubled mind is obsessively fixated. The fact that Gilman herself suffered from a nervous breakdown makes this interpretation seem quite viable. This

A critical reading of the western, referring to Jim Kitses "Notes on the Western"

2839 words - 11 pages genre means that the western will never really die, but manifest itself in other, more unrecognisable forms, such as the science fiction film. To help improve this, I will draw on other critical readings and look at The Magnificent Seven(1960), one of the great Westerns, itself a remake of Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai that then became the basis for the science fiction genre film Battle Beyond The Stars. Firstly it is important to make sense

Critical Appreciation Of Down And Out In London And Paris

952 words - 4 pages A Critical Appreciation of "Down and Out in Paris and London" by George Orwell "Down and out in London and Paris" is more than a work of fiction. It is semi-fictional in that it was the culmination of a number of years between 1928-31 spent in the slums of Paris and wandering around London as a tramp. This soon became a quest, by Orwell, to uncover the lives of the poor and to reveal the variety of characters and life to be found in the slums

Economics assignment containing questions on supply and demand concepts - Economics Assignment - Assignment

1789 words - 8 pages ASSIGNMENT: ECON 5100 ASSIGNMENT: On October 28, 2016, it was announced that in the UK, Uber drivers won a key employment case which classifies the drivers of Uber as workers rather than self-employed drivers. The consequences of this historic case mean that Uber drivers will now be entitled to holiday pay, paid rest breaks, and at least the national minimum wage. Question 1: For the moment, ignore the above announcement and assume that

THE IMPACT OF TECHNOLOGY ON THE CRITICAL THINKING OF TERTIARY STUDENTS IN SCHOOL X

1199 words - 5 pages declining.” Wolpert further stated that “reading for pleasure, which is one of the things that should help youths in their thinking and imagination has declined.” Students are rarely read books or any form of literature that would have helped to improve their critical thinking skills. Furthermore Kurland (2000) posits that critical thinking speaks to relying on reason rather than emotion; the influence of motives and bias are measured, and all

Cosmology Assignment on the Origin and Fate of the Universe - High School/Science - Assignment

1634 words - 7 pages Year? ?10? ?Cosmology? ?Assignment Origin? ?and? ?Fate? ?of? ?the? ?Universe David? ?Luong Mr? ?Kores Alfred? ?Deakin? ?High? ?School,? ?Science? ?-? ?Extended As? ?described? ?by? ?Aztec-History.com,? ?2015? ?the? ?Aztec? ?people? ?were? ?an? ?ethnic? ?group? ?that lived? ?around? ?central? ?Mexico? ?and? ?spoke? ?the? ?Nahuatl? ?language.? ?Nomadic? ?people? ?known as? ?Mexicas,? ?started? ?venturing? ?into? ?central? ?Mexico? ?and? ?started

Critical Review of Study on Development of CBA League - EAP 1015-15 GWU - Assignment

551 words - 3 pages The George Washington University This article called “Study on Development of CBA league” is written by Zhu Liang. It was published in Hubei Sports Science Journey. In his article, Zhu Liang points out five problems in CBA and proposes five suggestions correspondingly. This article provides an overall list and explanation of problems in CBA. On the whole, this article objectively provides views of development of CBA. The purpose of this

Critical Review of “Current Status of the Research on Construction and Demolition Waste Management” - Assignment

1894 words - 8 pages I. Introduction The article is written by Kambiz Ghafourian, Zainai Mohamed, Syuhaida Ismail, Roya Malakute and Maryam Abolghasemi (Razak school of engineering and advanced technology, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM), Kuala Lumpur) and is described in INDIAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY issued on September 2016. The authors of this research are academic researchers and they applied in waste management industry. II. Background

Conflicts of Race, Class and Gender Under the Hidden Patriarchal System on Dance Moms

4301 words - 17 pages (Seidman, 2012) the program is in need of examination in order to better understand and shift attention away from negative and unrealistic portrayals of women in a patriarchal society where females are powerless due to race, class or gender. REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE Gender, class and now race, and how these issues play a role in these women’s power negotiations as presented on this program, are the focus of this paper. There

Similar Essays

Change Management Of Financing And Economics School Assignment

2316 words - 10 pages CHANGE MANAGEMENT PLAN (FINANCE) 9 Change Management Plan (Finance) Proposal submitted for the implementation of an integrated (curative and preventive) health care services delivery model By Student’s Name Assignment 2 Contents Change management plan summary 3 Change management plan (finance) 3 Impact of the change 5 Capital investment decisions required as a result of the change 5 Financial risks that may arise from the change 5

Improving Reading Comprehension And Critical Thinking Skills In Middle School Students

1573 words - 6 pages incorporating reading skills in the media center. I also think that a questionnaire for parents to fill out might be helpful to find out their viewpoint on how well they think their child is grasping the idea of applying reading comprehension and critical thinking skills in school. I would also survey seventh and eighth graders at the school who are not taking a reading class. I would want to know how they are affected by not being required to

A Reading Of William Blake’s London

1712 words - 7 pages A Reading of William Blake’s London William Blake channels his general dissatisfaction of the organization of society during the late eighteenth century in his lyrical poem entitled “London” (1794). Blake uses vividly expressive language through the spoken observations of a symbolic character he created to narrate and recite social and political problems afflicting this metropolis in the late 1700’s and early 1800’s. The poem’s rhythmically

Reading Outside Of School Essay

1138 words - 5 pages students of this modern age have no time to delve into a book and be lost in its pages for hours on end. Part of it could be that students are overwhelmed by homework or they are too lazy. Another part of it could be that they have no motivation to read a book because without pictures, books are meaningless to them. In order to inspire students to enjoy reading for the rest of their lives, teachers and schools should allow the students to pick a