Critical Reflection Essay

1340 words - 5 pages

This critical reflection will compare the writings of Jane Arscott & Manon Tremblay, ?Il reste encore des travaux à faire: Feminism and Political Science in Canada and Québec? and Janine Brodie, ?Restructuring and the Politics of Marginalization?. These two articles pertain to the role of feminism and women?s issues in Canada. Janine Brodie takes on a more factual perspective; she explains that the present restructuring of the state is undertaken in order to accommodate itself with the market. She goes on to explain how this process has excluded women?s issues and in fact is detrimental to feminism. Jane Arscott and Manon Tremblay are more interested in the role of feminism in political science. Their interpretation of the current state agrees with the ideas explored by Janine Brodie, however they lean towards the possible academic solution the study of feminism in political science can offer.This paper will explore three different issues that are raised by both articles and how they compare to each other. Jane Arscott & Manon Tremblay argue that women?s issues are not considered ?properly political?. This is idea will be compared with Janine Brodie?s explanation on liberal empiricism as also discrediting women?s issues. Second comparison deals with the redistribution of the welfare state into the market. Related to the second comparison, the demise of the welfare has been fuelled by the debate over rationality between men and women and the effect a male-oriented economy has had on women?s issue. As much as the language is different in both articles, they certainly agree with feminist exclusion from the state.Jane Arscott & Manon Tremblay argue that women?s issues continue to be considered not ?properly political.? In the sense that women?s issues are not considered serious issues that warrant anything more then showing concern or give the impression that the state is trying to eliminate sexism, but in fact is merely a way to keep good relations with the public. Parallel to Jane Arscott & Manon Tremblay, Janine Brodie says that liberal empiricism assumes that conducting ?gendered-sensitive? research on the impact restructuring has on feminism will help to create government policies that will alleviate the problems of gender discrimination. Brodie sees a problem with this; liberal empiricism assumes ?that unequal gender impacts are accidental rather than integral to the current round of restructuring.? They both agree that the approaches to gender issues are not appropriate and are flawed from the outset. The negative impact through which liberal empiricism has on the restructuring of the state is underpinning the problem of women?s issues being taken seriously. Restructuring is more than an ?error? that can be corrected through research. Brodie attacks this notion by arguing that it creates a separation between women?s issues and the political. Arscott & Tremblay conclude that women?s relation to the state is an...

Find Another Essay On Critical Reflection Essay

Critical Journal Reflection Essay

1535 words - 6 pages This essay attempts to provide an insight into our lived and learnt experiences that have originated from both our Chinese/Malaysian and Australian backgrounds. We have applied our differing cultural backgrounds to different social situations illuminate some of the difficulties that may be faced when doing business with people come from differing cultural backgrounds such as ours. We have used the process of critical self reflection to comment

Reflection on a Critical Incident Essay

1770 words - 7 pages The reason for this essay is to reflect on a critical incident experience during my six week placement as a student nurse on an orthopedic ward. To explore an event as a critical incident is a value judgment, and the basis of that judgment is the significance attached to the meaning of the incident. Critical incidents are created or produced by the way we look at a situation. Tripp (1993) The incident chosen has made an impact on me due to

Critical reflection on an incident: Personal Development

1883 words - 8 pages This essay will focus on an incident that I have reflected on in my previous critical reflection. I shall use this as the basis for this essay and expand on and explore the issues that arise from the topics uncovered. During the break of a lecture on genograms, I was prompted to give input regarding a conversation that had arisen between two of my peers, upon hesitating I was quizzed by the one of them: "Why are you always so quiet . . . ". As

critical reflection

1108 words - 5 pages Feedback offers focus beyond the grade received and coupled with the skill of reflection, action to praise ourselves and continue performing our strengths whilst improving our weaknesses, is granted (Schon, 1991). Utilising Gibb’s (1998) reflective model, this assignment produces critical reflection on feedback from my presentation and other sources. The task of producing a presentation on our learning process is one which significantly

Critical Reflection

801 words - 4 pages In the book “self – taught: African American Education in Slavery and Freedom”, the author, Heather Andrea Williams, does a great job telling the story of the obstacles slaves faced in their attempts to become educated. Throughout the book, Williams gives numerous accounts of the experiences of these slaves and illustrates their determination to learn to read and write; as well as obtain a formal education. In my opinion, the most common theme

Critical reflection.

713 words - 3 pages 1. Evaluate the benefits and limitations of working collaboratively in developing unit outlines. I believe working collaboratively with other teachers in developing unit outlines can be highly beneficial to ensure the lessons involve a variety of different teaching strategies. As suggested by Yeager (2000), some teachers limit their lessons to a minute range of pedagogies that they have experienced and feel most comfortable with (Yeager 2000

critical reflection

1133 words - 5 pages According to Osmond & Darlington (2005, p.3), as a professional social worker that critical reflection could be a fundamental approach to contribute to their work. Besides, the best value of the critically reflective approach might have a chance to engage with different ideas, knowledge, feelings and theories. Thus, critical reflection is a necessary approach to every social work to contribute them to be professional. Previously, my definition

Critical Thinking Reflection

602 words - 2 pages Critical thinking is a significant and essential topic in recent education. The strategy of critical thinking skills helps identify areas in one's courses as the suitable place to highlight, expand and use some problems in exams that test students' critical thinking skills. Critical thinking means accurate thinking in the search of appropriate and dependable knowledge about the world. Another way to describe it is sensible

Critical Reflection on Dialogues

2162 words - 9 pages concerns, making decisions, caring and service, and evaluating outcomes. According to RNAO (2006), ongoing dialogue with clients and self-reflection are essential for nurses to develop their nursing skills and knowledge on client-centred care. As a nursing student, I reflected on written transcripts of interactions between patients and me, so that I could gain insights into client-centred care for further improvement. Therefore, the purpose of this

Reflection Upon A Critical Incident

2647 words - 11 pages Humanistic Psychology, vol. 23 no. 2 99-117 http://jhp.sagepub.com/content/23/2/99.abstract British National Formulary (2015) (BNF) 69 eBook http://www.pharmpress.com/product/9780857112330/bnfebook Bulman, C. Schutz, S. (2008) An Introduction to Reflection. In: Bulman, C. Schutz, S. (ed.) Reflective Practice in Nursing, 4th edition. Oxford, Blackwell Publishing Ltd, pp 6 – 8. Fook, J., White, S. and Gardner, F. (2006) Critical reflection

Critical Reflection - Good Will Hunting

704 words - 3 pages The film "Good Will Hunting" is the journey and story of a young man from South Boston, his troubled life and his opening up. Like Will Hunting (main character played by Matt Damon), many of us including myself have gone through stages in our life where we can relate to the emotions he felt in this film in some way.There are many key points in this film which show extremely important stages in Will Hunting's development. Such as when Will working

Similar Essays

A Critical Reflection Essay On Islam

908 words - 4 pages Islam being the fastest growing religion, has adhered a lot of positive as well as negative attention from the media. Due to this vast media influence stereotypes in Islam have increased from terrorism, Muslims have been discriminated merely due to the negative outlook that North America has portrayed upon them. The media tends to entwine the truth and to make Muslims seem perilous. Having that simple coherence of one another will be the start to

Postmodernism: Critical Reflection Jrcs,2010 Essay, Drama,

1421 words - 6 pages Critical reflection Within this semester we have been looking at Samuel Beckett's Eleutheria. Samuel Beckett was born 13 April 1906 and died 22 December 1989, he is of Irish decent and has had many occupations; novelist, playwright, poet, theatre director, essayist. Eleutheria is a play written in 1947 first written in French. It is said Samuel Beckett had never wanted this play to be published as he was ashamed of his creation. The play itself

Critical Reflection On Music And Self Identity Media Class Critical Essay Reflection

1603 words - 7 pages My fascination begun when long car rides to family holiday destinations required some sort of happy, relaxing sing along rock to liven the dull ‘are we there yet’ mood. This is when I came across the ‘Fleetwood Mac, Rumours’ album in the glove box of mum’s car. Amongst the mess of the pile of albums including Dragon, The Angels and The Who, I was drawn to this album and Stevie Nicks in particular. My mum’s admiration for the songstress as well as

Critical Reflection Essay On Clinical Experience Using Carper's Ways Of Knowing University Of Saskatchewan/ Nursing Year 3 Essay

1267 words - 6 pages Running head: CRITICAL REFLECTION JOURNAL 6 CRITICAL REFLECTION JOURNAL Critical Reflection Journal Using Carper’s Way of Knowing Chidera Achuonye University of Saskatchewan October 4, 2017 Submitted to: Jill Zdunich Critical Reflection Journal Using Carper’s Way of Knowing The Scenario It was my first shift on the postpartum ward. We were supposed to buddy with a nurse in taking care of our assigned patients. My patient had some morning