This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Analysis Of Schulman's Article 'gay Marriage And Marriage'

946 words - 4 pages

Marriage, for years has been argued that the rights to it or strictly only between a man and a women. Both sexes are assumed to marry someone of the opposite sex. What if, however, an individual wanted to marry someone of the same sex? Why is this debate so heavily heated amongst individuals? Is it that religion is a large structure base that those in society are guided by? Or is it that individuals do not understand that marriage is a union between two individuals who are in love? Whatever the case may be, there is always someone who has to argue that homosexual marriage is “wrong.”
Sam Schulman argues that homosexual marriage is about the duties or roles that these couples perform that would be different from that of heterosexual couples. In his article Gay Marriage -- and Marriage the author directs his argument towards those who are "passionately and instinctively opposed to the idea of homosexual marriage" (Schulman, 2003).
Schulman blames legalization of homosexual marriage as the cause for the possible permission of incest. However, this is like saying that if marijuana were to be legalized, it will lead to the acceptance of cocaine. Even when homosexuals do achieve their legal rights, currently only given to heterosexual married couples; it will not give rise to the legalization of incestuous relationships and incestuous marriages. Legalizing gay marriage will not pose any threat to the structure of society.
Society is created with both homosexual and heterosexual individuals. Previously when certain laws discriminated against others, such as law for women's rights to vote, these laws were changed. Changing the traditions of the country does not mean that it will lead to the legalization of other extreme issues. Each issue consists of its own dispute and discussion with no correlation to the other.
According to Kurtz “ are the proponents of poly­gamy, polyandry, and polyamorism, all ready to argue that their threesomes, foursomes, and other 'nontraditional' arrangements are entitled to the same rights as everyone else's" (As cited in Schulman, 2003). According to this logic, simply granting the right to homosexual couples to participate in a marriage will lead the legalization of other unconventional marriages. However, a knowledgeable person can see how ignorant this argument is.
This argument is similar to the previously mentioned statement regarding homosexual marriage leading to incestuous relationships or marriages. Just because rights are granted to one group, does not mean something extreme such as the legalization of polygamy and others will then occur.
The institution of homosexual marriage does not fight for the rights of one person to marry multiple people. Polygamy, polyandry, and polyamorism argue over the number of people allowed in a marriage. Legalizing and allowing homosexuals the right to marriage enables every American citizen access to equal rights as...

Find Another Essay On Critical Analysis of Schulman's Article 'Gay Marriage and Marriage'

Legalization of Gay Marriage Essay

1585 words - 7 pages Legalization of gay marriage has been a major controversial topic for a long time. Although, many people do not know what it means to be homosexual, most people do not know the actual definition of homosexuality and they do not know how difficult it is to be gay in this society. There are many reasons why people are against gay marriage and homosexuals all together. Most of the reasons are based on religious bias another big reason is being

Legalization of Gay Marriage Essay

1072 words - 4 pages Samantha ThorntonHD FS 276April 14, 2013Legalization of Gay Marriage"We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" (United States Declaration of Independence). How can a society that has progressed so beautifully still debate over whether a certain human being should be allowed equal

Legalization of Gay Marriage

1072 words - 4 pages Samantha ThorntonHD FS 276April 14, 2013Legalization of Gay Marriage"We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" (United States Declaration of Independence). How can a society that has progressed so beautifully still debate over whether a certain human being should be allowed equal

Solution of gay marriage

819 words - 3 pages religious opinion into matter, allowing homosexual marriage does not go against the constitution. Using the tactic of showing how homosexuals are discriminated against can be a solution. Raising awareness into the issue that denying it due to it being their natural born right due to the amendment and declaration of independence.Over the years, homosexuals have received a great deal of hate and discrimination. From having people spew out hatred through

Support of Gay Marriage

1785 words - 7 pages think that being gay can be fixed with therapy, medication or counseling, but in reality, this type of therapy usually makes the individual more likely to have suicidal thoughts and other problems. Being told that you aren’t good enough because of something you cannot control is inhumane. Rulings from older court cases are often used in present cases to provide support. A fact that most people either forget or do not know is that gay marriage is

Legalization of Gay Marriage - 972 words

972 words - 4 pages As of 2013 more than 45% of Americans say their views have changed significantly over time. According to Pew Research Center, 18 to 29 year olds are the most supportive of this legalization. The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) allows states to not recognize gay marriage created in other states that do allow it. DOMA was written so broadly that it touches more than a thousand federal laws and was struck down by the Supreme Court. Many same-sex

Issues of Gay Marriage

1192 words - 5 pages equality, liberty and justice for all. A government should not be able to prohibit any one person from declaring his or her love for someone else. Allowing the government to intervene in gay marriage represents class discrimination, denies marriage benefits, and rejects civil rights. One of the most widely known acts of discrimination would be the Loving vs. Virginia case. This case involves an interracial marriage, which was against the law in

Gay Marriage

2191 words - 9 pages The Supreme Court of the United States recently ruled that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage. Yet, same-sex marriage continues to be a highly debated issue. If we are discriminating against gay marriage then we are not the true land of the free. I believe men and women should be able to love freely and not be shamed by it. Marriage is a great factor in the United States. To some people it’s what we live for; is to get

Gay Marriage

790 words - 3 pages Breanna MahrtEnglish 110110/28/14SinsLegalization of Gay MarriageThe United States of America is the land of the free. It is a country full of different types of people, each with their own characteristics, ideas, and dreams. As American's, we take pride in our freedom and rights. However, currently in America people are denying rights to many citizens. Homosexuals, just like heterosexuals, want love, acceptance, commitment, and marriage. Gay

gay marriage

2102 words - 9 pages being more accepting to homosexuality, people will be more welcoming to homosexuality and then their communities will be less discriminatory and the argument of deteriorating the marriage institution will be meaningless. . “The problem with gay marriage, some opponents say, is that it will harm the society. This is a legitimate concern, and one that needs to be addressed. Marriage has played a very important role in society and it is a valuable

Gay Marriage

2037 words - 9 pages generation. This was very interesting to me and it is also surprising considering this is a civil rights issue and many of the older people lived through the civil rights era. I also found an article in the New York Times titled “Holder Sees Way to Curb Bans on Gay Marriage.” Eric J Holder, the United States district attorney, stated “that state attorneys general are not obligated to defend laws that they believe are discriminatory.” He claims that

Similar Essays

Gay Marriage And Adoption Essay

921 words - 4 pages idea of gay marriage conflicts with their idea of marriage; that somehow when two people of the opposite sex are in love it is less official. Marx (conflict theorist) states that the dominant ideology in our country is that marriage is the union of a man and a woman, therefore, two men or two women can not be married. This article is about engaging the homosexual community in the process of adopting each spouses children in the event that one of

Gay And Lesbian Marriage Essay

569 words - 2 pages Gay and Lesbian Marriage Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett argue profusely on the subject that is in almost every American’s mind, whether or not to civically let gays marry. Between Sullivan’s article “Let Gays Marry” and Bennett’s article, “Leave marriage alone, they pretty much sum up both sides of the argument. Andrew Sullivan, the editor of The New Republic and author of Virtually Normal: An argument about

Gay Marriage And Family Essay

584 words - 2 pages Making gay marriage legal, and give these marriage rights as traditional families will have a negative impact to society but especially to children.For five thousand years the overwhelming majority of the civilized world has defined marriage as the union of one man and one woman. And now, the family as we know it is about to end. Family is no longer the union of a mother, a father, and their children. Now, by San Francisco's Mayor unilateral

Gay And Lesbian Marriage Essay

554 words - 2 pages Gay and Lesbian MarriageGay and lesbian marriage is most likely the largest controversy that has been on the news in a while. It seems that for every one person for it there are another five against it. Many people seem to think said couples are only doing it for the tax breaks and other financial aids that most married couples are given. This writer's personal opinion is that if they love one another they should just be left alone to make their