This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critical Review Of Helping Students Meet The Challenges Of Academic Writing By Fernsten And Reda

1389 words - 6 pages

‘Helping students meet the challenges of academic writing’ by Fernsten and Reda is an interesting study how reflective writing practices can be useful for marginalized students, who are struggling with “negative writer self-identity. The possible causes according to Fernsten & Reda are, “issues such as race, class and gender that are marginalized factors for many basic writers”, in addition to the expectations of the dominant academic culture. However, even though Fernsten & Reda illuminated the ‘potential conflicts’ within the academic world, they have failed to provide conclusive evidence that supports their argument regarding their solution. Their reliance on dated research that provides a one sided historical perspective, may no longer accurately reflect current socio/economic issues. In addition, education has been evolving to an inclusive curriculum approach, as immigrated children enter the school system in record numbers. “Persons obtaining legal permanent status in the U.S from the year 2000-2010 are roughly eleven million” (Homeland Security,pg.10/2010). Fernsten & Reda’s confidence of their own limited teaching practices without legitimate comparables from an empirical study leads to their underlying assumptions about the true effectiveness of reflective writing strategies and the causes they believe are associated to a student’s socio/economic background.
Evidence given in Fernsten & Reda’s article, lists the numerous barriers students endure academically due to their socio/economic background. Factors include “negative self-identity of believing they are ineffectual and inept writers and internalize aspects of negative instructor discourses”. (Fernsten & Reda). Additional confirmation under the title, ‘History of basic writers in the USA’ supports this disconnect between the instructor and students. For example, “many assumed that those whose language differed from that of the dominant culture were less intelligent. Even today, that pre-1980’s stereotype used by some to describe struggling writers continues” (Fernsten & Reda). However, these perspectives based on historical events do not adequately present a well- rounded view on academic experiences, a marginalized student or instructor may currently endure. For example, “Setting and maintaining uniformly high

expectations for all students can combat marginalization. The schools included in a study by Ragland, Clubine, Constable, Smith, Council of Chief State School Officers and Texas University (2002) set measurable and high goals for all of its students, while minimizing formal categories and labels. This enables faculty and staff to focus on creating educational opportunities for the students and assess areas for improvement in student and teacher performance. Without tracking and labels, the focus is on the individual, where it belongs, regardless of race or socio-economic status”, ( Carbone II,Steven,2010)
Fernsten & Reda’s reasoning...

Find Another Essay On Critical Review of Helping Students Meet the Challenges of Academic Writing by Fernsten and Reda

The Use and Misuse of Academic Words in Writing by Andrea Marie Cons

1331 words - 5 pages area in which I currently work, and as more RFEP students are working alongside native speakers in the classroom and the workplace, these students will need writing skills similar to those demonstrated by their peers. My choice of article was also informed by my experience as a writing teacher for native-speaking students whose writing did not meet the expectations of their grade level. I anticipate using my TESOL degree to work primarily with

A Comparative Study on the Management of Academic Requirements by Accountancy and Accounting Technology Students in De La Salle Lipa Academic Yea

1791 words - 8 pages -making learners and teachers. It is usually an extension of a certain topic, mostly done by individual learners, groups, whole class. Major Examinations, according to Burke (n.d.), are said to be the determinants on how well or poor students perform on their course. There is also the danger of failing, for it may have a big impact on the general point average. This study is conducted to know the management of academic requirements by Accountancy

Limits and Challenges of the Feminist Critical Approach

3325 words - 13 pages ”(Showalter 146-147). Neither styles of literary criticism are perfect, but one she appears more critical of is the concept of the woman as the reader. Here, the role of women played within literature is that of a consumer, or as Showalter says, “woman as the consumer of male-produced literature”(146). This approach puts the focus of the analysis upon the fictional creations and understanding of women by male authors and thus male culture as a whole

Challenges and Drawbacks of Non Traditional Students

3079 words - 12 pages specifically at the idea of transformational leadership development in non-traditional seminary students. Since the 1980s, the most current influence in leadership development is the idea of transformational leadership. Instead of focusing on the transaction or exchange between leader and follower, the focus here is on the transformation of the follower by the leader. In this view, leadership is seen as a two-way relationship. The leader is seen as

The Importance of Writing Techniques: Comparing Chinese and English Academic Writing

1001 words - 5 pages There are many significant differences between Chinese academic writing and English academic writing. Most of the time, it is difficult to write essays in English for many multilingual students like me, not only because we have to translate Chinese to English, but also because of the different styles of academic writing we learned in China. However, after the first semester of the writing program, I acquired many basic concepts and tools about

The Challenges of Writing with Dyslexia

1283 words - 6 pages I haven’t done a lot of writing in the past. However, the writing I have done has just been for my school. I have never liked writing so I kept writing only to what I needed to write for school. But the kinds of writing I have done are reports, autobiographies, and writing about people from history. I never wanted to do my writing assignments like I was supposed to, which didn’t help me learn how to write. I also have the writing I did last

Critical Review of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets by JK Rowling

863 words - 4 pages Nicole Silvey American Literature 25 March 2014 Critical Review (Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets-J.K.Rowling) The good of Harry and his allies overpowers the bad in Voldemort “Ginny!” said Mr. Weasley, flabbergasted. “Haven't I taught you anything? What have I always told you? Never trust anything that can think for itself if you can’t see where it keeps its brain?” The good of Harry and his allies overpowers the bad in Voldemort

Critical Review of The Stranger by Albert Camus

1305 words - 5 pages explanation of life. The Absurd refers to this pointless quest for meaning in a universe devoid of purpose. Camus came to the conclusion that there is nothing beyond this world, and we are simply thrown into this existence with the only outcome being death, "since we are all going to die it is obvious the when and how don't matter" (114). Coming to terms with the Absurd is what accounts for the 'strangeness' experienced by every human being with the

Foundations of Academic Writing (FAW)

1366 words - 5 pages me many things. I have discovered that seemingly impossible tasks can be learned, and performed reasonably well through training and hard work. It is not easy by any account. Countless hours of hard labor are involved. There are disappointments on the way but one must learn to ignore them. On the writing side, what FAW coaches, the word processor put into practice. This marvel of technology has revolutionized the world of academic writing, but

The Value of Academic and Applied Psychology in Facing the Challenges of of Life in the Twenty-First Century

1545 words - 7 pages 120 Essay 2: Critically evaluate the value of academic and applied psychology in facing the challenges of life in the twenty-first century. (Increasing ageing population) This essay will be addressing the value of academic and applied psychology in facing the challenges of increasing ageing population in the 21st century. Ageing refers to the process of spiritual, mental and social changes in organisms; however, population ageing refers to

Critical Review of Wit by Margaret Edson

1319 words - 6 pages Kalekian gives Vivian eight months of experimental chemotherapy without clearly explaining the treatments and serious side effects. In addition, Kelekian’s fellow, Jason, as a former student of Dr. Bearing, shows no respect to Vivian. Jason does not consider Vivian as a patient or as his former professor, but a research object of cancer treatment. The play Wit introduces binaries between patients and doctors, students and professors, life and death

Similar Essays

Helping Students Meet The Challenges Of Academic Writing

2268 words - 9 pages A Critical Review of "Helping Students Meet the Challenges of Academic Writing", by Fernsten, Linda A.; Reda, Mary The authors make a plausible attempt to propose a psychological strategy that education professionals can use to encourage students, and overcome the challenges of academic writing. This paper will be focused on summarizing, critiquing, and interpreting the proposed concepts in my personal perspectives. This should allow the

An Investigation Into The Use Of Cooperative Learning Strategies To Foster Positive Social Behaviour And Satisfactory Academic Performance In Physical Education Among A Group Of Grade Nine Students. ...

1215 words - 5 pages mixed ability groups will be able to learn from each other by sharing ideas and if one student does not understand something another student would explain it to him/ her. Of critical importance are the stronger students assisting the weaker ones, thus encouraging peer teaching and a sense of unity and cohesiveness. Cooperative learning through its effective use can provide students with high quality corrective assistance through their peers

An Investigation Into The Use Of Cooperative Learning Strategies To Foster Positive Social Behaviour And Satisfactory Academic Performance In Physical Education Among A Group Of Grade Nine Students. ...

1215 words - 5 pages mixed ability groups will be able to learn from each other by sharing ideas and if one student does not understand something another student would explain it to him/ her. Of critical importance are the stronger students assisting the weaker ones, thus encouraging peer teaching and a sense of unity and cohesiveness. Cooperative learning through its effective use can provide students with high quality corrective assistance through their peers

Lemon Sky By Langford Wilson Answers To Study Questions. Good For Writing A Critical Review

2291 words - 9 pages pointed out that Carol was gorgeous, which led e to believe he was a normal teenager. I think Wilson did this so that we would like and sympathize with Alan's character without being distracted by the fact that he was gay. I also think that he didn't want this to be a "gay play." A playwright can run into difficulties when writing gay characters, especially the main character of a piece. There is this (unfortunate) human tendency to view that