Critically Evaluate The Argument That The So Called "Crisis In Masculinity" Paradoxically Furthers Forms Of Hegemonic Masculinity.

2586 words - 10 pages

The concept of "masculinity in crisis" has been put forth in recent debates regarding men and their masculinity. Critical analysis of men and thus of the gender of masculinity arose in the 1970s with the beginning of the men's movements. These movements established the notion that men (like women) are oppressed by their gender and that this oppression is a result of pressures and constraints put on men by society such as defined roles and expectations of men within the public sphere. In recent years, there is an increasing number of evidence supporting the fact that masculinity is in crisis. These prove include the threat of unemployment for men, their incapability in expressing their own feelings and responding to physical and psychological problems, the gay movement, worse health qualities, failure in school, higher rate of committing in violent crime and so on. It is now believed that masculinity qualities are being challenged by our society and feminism. Men are now being portrayed as trouble makers because statistics show that they have been doing worse than women in various areas. Nevertheless, people argue that this so-called "crisis in masculinity" is paradoxically further forms of hegemonic masculinity. This essay will establish the origin of the crisis in masculinity, which is believed to be the male liberation movement during 1970s. It will then look into what exactly the crisis in masculinity is and how this crisis has affected the performance of masculinity by men. It will also evaluate whether the crisis in masculinity furthers forms of hegemonic masculinity with evidence from supporting side. It will then be discussed with examples from different areas. One of the examples is from the Australian sports sector, which could be referred to the allegations of rape put forth against players of the Canterbury Bulldogs rugby league club followed by the media coverage of the rape allegations.In today's society, men are caught up in this traditional, poisonous perception of masculinity in which all men are created to be the superior gender with special power with privilege and are self-governing, unemotional, competitive, power oriented beasts. As women have been taking roles and forming groups to counter this stereotype and bring about in society a new face on women, some men have been taking new roles as well. When the feminist movements began to really take a hold of the people around the 60's and 70's, men interested in changing conceptions of gender roles would embrace these feminist groups and form their own male liberation movement. Many of the first creators of men's liberation in the early 1970's were psychologists. They wanted to help destroy the sex role stereotypes that regard "being a man" and "being a women" as separate states that must be achieved by proper behavior. The male sex role is both oppressive to women and harmful to men. A man with a fuller concept of humanity realizes that all women and men are potentially strong...

Find Another Essay On Critically evaluate the argument that the so-called "crisis in masculinity" paradoxically furthers forms of hegemonic masculinity.

Comparative Anaylsis of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

1652 words - 7 pages that men need to be educated in order to succeed and exert power and dominance over women. For men to be educated, they are able to attain good paying jobs to support their families. Although both articles discuss the importance of educating men, Tragos largely focuses on hegemonic masculinity in the context of exclusively white men. The article targets white men and women which insinuates that people of different race are to be minorized. In

Hegemonic Masculinity Practices Essay

1493 words - 6 pages subordination as complex with factors such as cultural consent, discursive centrality and marginalization playing a part in the process of domination and the creation of non-hegemonic masculinities. Demetriou (2001, 341-343) label non-hegemonic masculinities as internal hegemony (or masculine hegemony over other masculinities). Three forms of internal hegemony are identified: subordinate masculinity, marginalized masculinity and complicit masculinity

Masculinity and hegemonic masculinity - second year of university - essay

2780 words - 12 pages used to describe and to paint Napoleon as a masculine man. Hegemonic masculinity In the field of gender research, hegemonic masculinity is part of a gender order theory, elaborated by R.W. Connell's, which delineates multiple types of masculinity that can emerge depending on temporal placement, culture and the person in question. The concept of hegemonic masculinity has been identified as being the current form of practice that legitimizes

What is meant by 'masculinity in crisis' in recent debates about men and masculinity? Use a specific example from media or popular culture to support your argument

1242 words - 5 pages thus the media and academics have suggested that there is a 'crisis in masculinity.' The web-based article "Moral Lumbyism" puts forth the notion that masculinity is in crisis and in doing so refers to the "sex scandal involving players from different football codes."(http://www.ozconsevative.com/morallumbyism.html) However instead of questioning what has caused this crisis the article instead questions why the National Rugby League hired Catherine

'Whenever we look at texts from the end of the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth century what we see is masculinity in crisis'("portrait of the artist as a young man" James Joyce)

1625 words - 7 pages stages. He leads an unsettled life and the novel takes us through many of the processes of his growing up. His life can be divided in to five phases: Ignorance, sin, religion, reason and renaissance. Throughout the novel Stephen constructs his life around various aspects of these phases. Once he discovers sin he embraces this with everything within himself. He is comforted by the fact that he can sin so much and remain seemingly undiscovered and

Critically Examine the Argument that Nowa Huta Reflects with Amazing Clarity the Contemporary Contradictions in Poland

1496 words - 6 pages -Karpowicz). It was known as the Independent Self-Governing Trade Union Solidarity. An incredibly powerful political force which throughout the eighties made extensive social and economic reforms, when in 1989 Poland held its first free elections Solidarity won all but one of the seats enjoying a public approval rating of over 90%.The irony is that the labor union which helped to bring about the fall of the communist government found itself opposing the

Evaluate Aristotle's argument(s) for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life

1899 words - 8 pages Evaluate Aristotle's argument(s) for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life.In evaluating Aristotle's arguments for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life, I believe it is important to recognise the true problem at hand, which can be seen to be, does Aristotle succeed arguing that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life? I believe that overall Aristotle does not succeed in arguing this

Critically evaluate the claim that discourse analysis could become the dominant paradigm for psychology in the future

1189 words - 5 pages of discourse analysis (DA) and its application as the potential new dominant paradigm in modern psychology. Kuhn (1996), defined a paradigm a set of theoretical concepts and research, unified by a framework that describes what is/ isn’t accepted in a specific area of scientific research. Paradigms have two distinguished aspects, namely a set of core experiments that are exemplary and therefore likely to be reproduced and underpinning

Outline some of the forms male violence against women takes. What purpose does male violence against women serve? Critically evaluate feminist activism around violence

1934 words - 8 pages , and by under-valuing work which is traditionally female. In addition,'When we are prohibited from exercising our abortion rights by the terrorist tactics of so-called "right-to-lifers" who bomb abortion clinics, and the criminal actions of the government as it withdraws federal subsidies for abortion, we experience violence aimed at our reproductive choices and our sexuality.' (Davis 1990, p37).When the government cuts funding to child-care

Critically Discuss Hakim's Argument That Women's Heterogeneous Preferences Regarding Work And Family Are The Main Determinants Of Female Employment Patterns (Full Time And Part Time) In The UK

4570 words - 19 pages of unequal social policy, which contrasts even her own theory of liberal societies without constraints. The ‘disproportionate success’ of patriarchy and failure of ‘social engineering policies’ declared by Hakim, suggests that the so called unconstrained liberal societies are flawed with the contextual constraint of unequal social policies which favour men, over women, in employment (Hakim, 2000:9-10). Hakim assumes the

Critically evaluate the assertion that "auditing e-business is no different from auditing any other business"

1777 words - 7 pages Critically evaluate the assertion that "auditing e-business is no different from auditing any other businessFor me to be able to answer the question I must first understand what e-business is and how different it is to traditional business. An e-business is the delivery of information, products/services or payments via telephone line, computer networks or any other means. It is the application of technology towards the automation of e-business

Similar Essays

Hegemonic Masculinity In Sports Media Essay

2064 words - 9 pages stratified, as some forms of masculinity and femininity are preferable to others (Moss 2). Sociologists often consider the most lauded masculinity in a particular culture to be hegemonic, or dominant, and this image of maleness becomes the ideal for men in that society (Moss 2). Although the concept of masculinity is constantly evolving, one activity that is often intertwined with the hegemonic form is the practice of sport (Brandt and Carsens

Hegemonic Masculinity In American Society Essay

1529 words - 6 pages Masculinity is described as possession of attributes considered typical of a man. Hegemonic masculinity is a form of masculine character with cultural idealism and emphasis that connects masculinity to competitiveness, toughness, and women subordination. Masculinity hegemonic is the enforcement of male dominion over a society. Masculine ideology dates back to the time of agrarian and the industrial revolution in Europe when survival

Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages female.In analyzing Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity, it is important to compare these two feminist concepts prior. For, in order to understand crime, we have to understand both production and reproduction. Patriarchy and capitalism interact together to form our concept of the hegemonic male, as well as reveal our societal consciousness. This interaction leads to patterns of behavior that use human power, mostly male, to fulfill needs and

Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages female.In analyzing Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity, it is important to compare these two feminist concepts prior. For, in order to understand crime, we have to understand both production and reproduction. Patriarchy and capitalism interact together to form our concept of the hegemonic male, as well as reveal our societal consciousness. This interaction leads to patterns of behavior that use human power, mostly male, to fulfill needs and