Critically Assess The Pluralist And Marxist Views Of The State

1753 words - 7 pages

Whilst pluralism and Marxism are said to have developed from liberalism and socialism respectively (through criticising or expanding on those ideologies) thereby both appearing on the left of the left-right economic scale, a great part of their theories are indeed notably different, if not completely in contrast with each other. However, if we look closely at these theories, the one similarity, often overlooked by critics, is the fact that both offer a critique of the state despite the fact that their views are opposing. In order to understand these views of state, it is important to first understand the fundamental views of both pluralism and Marxism. Only then can these views be assessed and finally compared with each other, thereby ascertaining which view is more apt within modern society.

Pluralism is essentially a theory in favour of distributing power equally amongst individuals rather than having power remain within the hands of one individual (Heywood, 2003; Schwarzmantel, 1994; Dunleavy and O’Leary, 1987; Crowder, 1994). This theory is predominantly associated with Robert Dahl, who had researched how the state behaves and amongst whom power is exercised in New Haven (Heywood, 2007; Dahl, 1961). However, it has been argued that this theory is too idealistic, and that it is impossible for there to be an equal distribution of power because realistically power is likely to only be exercised by a minority, as in accordance with the elitist view (Heywood, 2007; Schwarzmantel, 1994).

Marxism tends to focus more on the rights of the working class as opposed to all of society in the way that pluralism does. After all, the ideas and theories of Karl Marx are most commonly interpreted as a critique of capitalism where the minority elite, or the bourgeoisie, control the working class, or the proletariat (Miliband, 1988; Schwarzmantel, 1994; Hay, 2006). However, Marxism had only developed after the death of Marx therefore the ideas which are attributed to him are bound to differ. All the same, there is one key issue from which Marxism developed that is said to be evident:
Marx himself believed that he had developed a new brand of socialism that was scientific in the sense that it was primarily concerned with disclosing the nature of social and historical development, rather than with advancing an essentially ethical critique of capitalism.
Heywood (2003:125)
So whilst Marxism is essentially a critique of capitalism, Marx initially criticised the Hegelian theory and so had developed his own views from there, where he had noticed that power was centralised and, furthermore, effectively abolished the chance of there ever being a classless society.

The pluralist view of the state came about as an objection to state sovereignty, out of fear that the state would remain totalitarian if power was only exercised within the state as opposed to distributed amongst society as a whole (Schwarzmantel, 1994; Smith, 2006). Pluralists ‘are said to have...

Find Another Essay On Critically Assess the Pluralist and Marxist Views of the State

Critically Assess The Impact Of The Financial Serv

1926 words - 8 pages Labour, and Labour made its views clear, already prior to the election, on the two tier system under the Financial Services Act 1986. It committed itself to getting rid of self-regulation and establishing a single statutory regulator for the investment services business. At the centre was a new act, The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) and the main operative provisions of the FSMA came into effect December 1 2001.¡&sect

Critically assess the literature that connects training and skills to enhanced levels of organizational performance

3644 words - 15 pages skills in order to enhance levels of organizational performance. However, the evidence is contradictory and will require more time for researching in order to find the best answers for the best organizational performance.The assignment attempts to critically assess the literatures that connect training and skills in order to enhanced levels of organizational performance. I begin my assignment by mentioning the concepts for both of skills and

Critically assess the Pecking Order Theory of Capital Structure

1785 words - 7 pages There is no universal theory of the debt-equity choice, and no reason to expect one. In this essay I will critically assess the Pecking Order Theory of capital structure with reference and comparison of publicly listed companies. The pecking order theory says that the firm will borrow, rather than issuing equity, when internal cash flow is not sufficient to fund capital expenditures. This theory explains why firms prefer internal rather than

Critically assess the role of terror and violence in the establishment of the Nazi dictatorship between 1933 and 1939

2382 words - 10 pages Critically assess the role of terror and violence in the establishment of the Nazi dictatorship between 1933 and 1939After Adolph Hitler was appointed chancellor on 30th January 1933, Germany witnessed the rapid transformation of the Weimar republic into the single - ruling Nazi Dictatorship. Between the years 1933 - 1939 Hitler was able to attain the legal framework needed to single handily rule Germany and remove all major aspects of

Identify and critically assess the application of key Indigenous protocols in the Australian Public Relations (PR) Industry.

2804 words - 11 pages 1 IntroductionThis report intends to identify and critically assess the application of key Indigenous protocols in the Public Relations (PR) Industry, and in doing so determine whether genuine attempts have been made in the PR sector to respond to Indigenous concerns which relate to the themes of•Representation and Identity•Social Justice, Human Rights and Indigenous Voices.These themes are vitally important to the increased

Critically assess the case of government support of small business, both in terms of business start - up and development

2982 words - 12 pages is very expensive and if more than 50% of the companies do not survive their first 5 years, lots of tax income is therefore wasted on nothing.Tax money which is saved by not supporting businesses can be used in the health system or other state institutions from which everybody can benefit and not just some companies. makingThe third constraint to government support is the decision of which business start - ups to support and which

Critically assess the arguments in favour of the decriminalization or legalization of marijuana use.

1322 words - 5 pages Critically assess the arguments in favour of the decriminalization or legalization of marijuana use.It is estimated that 40 percent of young people in Britain have tried marijuana and that it is an 'underground' economy worth globally £100 billion and $1-3 billion a year in this country alone. There is no denying that marijuana is now a massive part of modern British culture along with alcohol and tobacco. One hundred years ago, it was


2106 words - 8 pages IMPACTS OF TOURISM: PLANNING AND POLICY DEVELOPMENTCRITICALLY ASSESS THE KEY ARGUMENTS REGARDING THE OUTCOMES OF TOURISM IN LESS DEVELOPED SOCIETIES.One does not have to look at literature too see that the impacts of tourism has been immense in the world we live in. Tourism is one of the fastest growing industries, according to WTO (World Tourism Organization) revised estimates total international tourist arrivals worldwide come to almost 595

Title: Critically assess the concepts used by Emile Durkheim in his analysis of the social changes caused by rapid industrialization and modernization.

2098 words - 8 pages Distinguished himself from Marxist insistence on economic factor as the determinant of social change and Weber's famous view on the great influence of religion, Durkheim tries to explain social change by means of explaining the society itself apart from its individual members, through the analysis of the functional relationship between 'social facts'. By differentiating between social solidarity - one of the most important social fact that he is

Critically Assess the EC Competition Law’s Approach to Predatory Pricing

4693 words - 19 pages should be understood. This paper will start with the definitions and arguments on dominance and abuse. Besides entry barriers will be defined in this part. Later, it will highlight predatory pricing with views and comments. There are a few important cases in EC law about predatory pricing. The mains are; AKZO case , Tetra Pak case and France Telecom case . Only AKZO case and Tetra Pak case will be mentioned in this paper. Also, tests of AKZO case

Negative 'old' police attitudes and practices towards rape victims is still very much part of modern day policing. Critically assess the evidence available to support this statement.

1425 words - 6 pages evident today how some police forces continue to be strictly hierarchical organisations with deeply sexist views about women. It is clear to see that policing not only has a distinctive culture, but that the symbols of policing for example its formal organisational structures and informal practices are mainly male and white. One of the significant factors in fashioning policing from a military model is the requirement, on occasions, to use force

Similar Essays

Comparing Pluralist And Marxist Accounts Of Power In The Uk And Us

2186 words - 9 pages Comparing Pluralist and Marxist Accounts of Power in the UK and US Pluralism and Marxism both offer comprehensive theories about the location of power within the modern state. Both theories to some extent were based on Western governments; with Marxism being developed partly through Engels’ experiences in Manchester in the mid nineteenth century and Pluralism being developed through the studies in America in the mid

The Functionalist And Marxist Views On The Purpose Of Socialisation

2309 words - 9 pages The Functionalist and Marxist Views on the Purpose of Socialisation Functionalists and Marxists have very similar theories as to the socialisation process. I intend to show this and compare these similarities. There are many well-known functionalists but I am mainly focusing on the views of Talcott Parsons and Emile Durkheim in particular. There are many aspects of the socialisation process to cover both

Comparing The Marxist And Functionalist Views On The Role Of Education In Industrial Society

1928 words - 8 pages Comparing the Marxist and Functionalist Views on the Role of Education in Industrial Society The functionalists and the Marxists both believe that the education system benefits everyone, but both have different views on society. The Marxist views of the education system are that there are conflicts because there is an inequality between the working class and the higher classes. They believe that there are two different

The Pluralist View Of Mass Media

1987 words - 8 pages . Whereas BBC Radio One aims at an audience of British people with a traditional English culture, their views are put forward and music popular in this audience is played. Both of these networks are extremely popular but they are very different. Now this proves the pluralist view that the mass media is appealing to different groups of people. “Today’s society is composed of a great diversity of groups…pluralists argue that the