Critically Discuss The Various Existing Models Linking Organizational/ Business Strategy With Hrm Strategy

1913 words - 8 pages

In today’s rapidly changing globalised business environment, human capital has become one of the keys to competitive advantage. Consequently, any good business strategy must fully utilise the inimitable assets of people through their knowledge, skills and abilities. This highlights the need for strategic human resource management (SHRM). The key assumption of SHRM is that organisational performance is affected by employees through a set of human resource (HR) practices (Pan et al 2006).
A review of the literature linking HR practices to business strategy shows two conflicting perspectives in SHRM. The universalistic perspective suggests that there is a universal set of best practices that any business can adopt to improve organisational performance. Conversely, the contingency perspective suggests that business performance will improve when there is consistency or fit between business strategy and HR policies. This essay will discuss the theory and models behind each perspective and provide a critique on each of the opposing views.

Universalistic perspective
This approach maintains that all firms will see performance gains by identifying and implementing best practice irrespective of the product market situation, industry or location of the firm. Performance gains include improvements in employee behaviours and attitudes, reduced staff turnover, increased productivity, quality and customer service and of course increased profitability. This requires support from top-level managers to adopt these key HR practices, research the latest trends of best practice and reward correct implementation of these practices.
Redman (2006) suggests that making changes to individual practices will have a very limited effect whereas making changes together will have a more powerful effect. This leads onto the concept of looking for a ‘bundle’ of practices which need to be combined together (Huselid 1995). Although many researchers agree with the concept of bundling practices together, there has been little agreement about which HRM practices should be included. Consequently, some models have only a few key practices while others have a dozen or more. The most influential work to date is that of Jeffrey Pfeffer. Pfeffer originally devised a list of 16 practices in 1994 but subsequently narrowed them down to the following 7 in 1998:
1. Employment Security
2. Selective Hiring
3. Self-managed teams or team working
4. High pay contingent on company performance
5. Extensive training
6. Reduction of status differences
7. Sharing information

The HR practices in this bundle, and indeed any bundle should be consistent across workplaces and function together, otherwise known as internal fit. For example, it would be wrong to encourage team work but support individual performance related pay. Any perceived (and actual) inconsistencies between practices will reduce the effectiveness of the bundle and can lead to dissent and dissatisfaction. (Marchington et al...

Find Another Essay On Critically Discuss The Various Existing Models Linking Organizational/ Business Strategy With Hrm Strategy

Critically compare and contrast the ‘Best Fit’, ‘Best Practice’ and ‘Resource-Based View’, models of HRM strategy and explain how each approach is argued to contribute to improved organisational...

2484 words - 10 pages Critically compare and contrast the 'Best Fit', 'Best Practice' and 'Resource-Based View', models of HRM strategy and explain how each approach is argued to contribute to improved organisational performance.Strategy is the skill and planning that are involved in governing resources. In a business sense this relates to "a set of ideas, policies and practices which management adopt in order to achieve a people management objective" in studying

Training and Development, linked with performance management, are key area within an HRM strategy and are fundamental for the success or failure of an organization. Discuss.

1585 words - 6 pages important role within the organization. If the HRM department is just created just for the sake of having a HR department, then the organization will fail to enjoy the benefits that arise from this management concept. A HRM department has to be active within the organization and put forward any concerns where they are needed.Strategic concept of HRThe significance of aligning the SHRM (Strategic Human Resource Management) with the business

A Strategy for Organizational Change

1225 words - 5 pages A Strategy for Organizational Change The situation of AB Organisation is very complex and difficult, due to the unstable situation given in the external environment and in the internal structure of the company. The first step that the new Managing Director of the AB Organisation must take is to analyse the past and present situation of the company, to know the reasons of the situation nowadays. Through the

Constraints on Strategy of An Organizational Structure

7336 words - 29 pages business organization must establish organizational structures that are capable of handling novel, very rich, and very varied information flows. Cross-functional coordination and team decision processes are likely to be the most effective structuring of strategies that rely on renewal of resources and capabilities.A growth-oriented strategy is one that attempts to leverage the firm's existing portfolio of resources and capabilities to the greatest

Critically evaluate and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Customer Boycotts. Compare and contrast two consumer boycotts and discuss appropriate microeconomic theoretical models.

2588 words - 10 pages , asking consumers not to buy a specific product, or the products of a specific company, in order to exert commercial pressure. This is usually done to get the company to change behaviour, to cease an activity or to adopt a more ethical practice.For this essay I am going to discuss many advantages and disadvantages of consumer boycotts and also I have decided to compare and contrast coca cola with the Nestle boycott.There are various ways to make a

Marketing Research Review - Discuss the relationship between marketing research and marketing strategy and tactics.

864 words - 3 pages come up with a creative market segmentation strategy that could afford the business a competitive advantage over competition. It was important to identify the underserved niche and provide the right product into the market that would lead them into a profitable increase in business. The goal was to understand the customers' needs and develop a strategy to Attract, Satisfy, and Retain the target customer.The Communication group began to research

"Strategy without action is only a daydream, but action without strategy is a nightmare" Discuss the benefits of formal corporate planning in directing organisational action

1588 words - 6 pages IS STRATEGIC CORPORATE PLANNING RELEVANT IN THE 21ST CENTURY?This essay will discuss the benefits of corporate strategic planning. Firstly, we will look at what strategy is, and why strategic planning is important to an organisation. Secondly, what types of strategic models are used for planning, and finally given that organisations are increasingly complex and market dynamics are constantly changing is there a need for strategic corporate

Marketing Strategy: Define marketing, discuss some of the processes used, and how companies have used marketing to their success.

680 words - 3 pages define marketing, discuss some of the processes used, and how companies have used marketing to their success.Defining MarketingSimply put, marketing is about creating and keeping customers profitably. It is a process that starts with identifying customers finding out about their needs and wants, matching what your business can offer with what your customers want, and then effectively communicating and selling to the target customers while keeping

"Diversification is fundamentally a negative strategy.. Diversifiers are always running away from something." M.L. Kastens - Discuss

2427 words - 10 pages with diversification because he says look for an opportunity (in the external environment) and follow strategy to pursue it. He also suggests in his later work 1987 that"Strategic change is so rapid that firms must continually survey the product-market environment for diversification opportunities".In surveying the opportunity to diversify companies tend to run from problems within their existing business thereby engaging in diversification as a

Subject for this Essay should be under "Information Technology" I will discuss Army Kowledge Online and the Army Knowledge Management strategy

680 words - 3 pages technology system that I am familiar with and that will not present a breach in the security of our systems. I will focus particularly on the Army Knowledge Online system, which allows access to all Active Duty Army, Army Reserve, Army National Guard, Department of the Army Civilians, Retired Army, United States Military Academy Cadets, select ROTC Cadets, and Army sponsored guest accounts. I will also discuss the Army Knowledge Management strategy and

Aligning IT with Business Strategy

1157 words - 5 pages . However, as Charles Schwab grew, it’s not surprising that its IT problems grew as well. Charles Schwab approached the situation by spending loads of money on new IT projects rather than fixing the existing systems or starting fresh altogether. Eventually, the company found itself smothered in an over-complicated system that was eating 18% of revenue annually (Shpilberg et al., 2007). “IT’s effort to satisfy its various (and sometimes conflicting

Similar Essays

Hrm Strategy Essay

4035 words - 16 pages developments in the f ield of SHRM, some various def initions in the literature which describe the concept of strategic human resource management are as follow:Truss and Gratton (1994) states that SHRM is linking of HRM with strategic goals and objectives of firm to enhance business performance and to develop organisational culture that support innovation and flexibility.Schular and Walker (1970, cited in Truss and Lynda, 1994) states that, human

Training In Overall Organizational And Hrm Strategy

1971 words - 8 pages Training in Overall Organizational and HRM Strategy ‘Training is the planned provision to modify attitude, knowledge or skill behaviour through learning experience to achieve effective performance in an activity or range of activities. Its purpose, in the work situation, is to develop the abilities of the individual and to satisfy the current and future needs of the organisation.’ (Manpower Services Commission, 1981

Organizational Strategy Essay

1096 words - 4 pages content teaching people and giving them advice on how to start and maintain a bulk vending route I would be successful. My organizational strategy was to be the authority on bulk vending and when anybody searched for bulk vending help or tips, they would find my site. My strategy in the first year is to be a totally information site and not sell any hard goods, just give quality information that people can use to start a bulk vending business if

Business Strategy Models A Critical Review

3712 words - 15 pages Business Strategy - Critical Review (Strategy Models)It is the purpose of this paper to critically review several of the most important business models used by strategic managers in SBUs, we will review strategic models and frameworks proposed by the most influential business strategists and scholars and assess their values within today`s operating environment.Business strategy refers to the aggregated strategies of single business firm or a