Critically Evaluate Biological And Sociological Theories And Discuss How These Contribute To The Explanation For The Occurrence Of Crime

4534 words - 18 pages

MSc In Security & Risk ManagementMarch 2010 IntakeCritically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime.4150 wordsAre criminals born or are criminals made? This is a question that many criminologists have researched into and tried and come to a conclusive answer. However the majority are divided into two main schools of thought; those believing in the nurture methodology (made criminals) and the latter in the nature approach (born criminals). There are many theories as to how and why people commit criminal acts; this essay will critically assess two of these, biological and sociological. Firstly, it will be shown how different biological theories have come about and how they contribute to the 'who and why' in criminological theory. Secondly, we will look in detail at the more recent sociological theories and see how these are more adept in explaining the roots of the criminal mind. After looking into the two theories it will then be shown how these may play a part in the occurrence of crime.These two classes of theory in themselves have many sub theories which have developed over time, some new and some just different interpretations of previous ones. In such a discipline as criminology, with such a large range of empirically driven quantities, it would be useful to categorize and illustrate the numerous interpretations of theories. Criminal theories are classed in two main schools of thought, the positivist and classical approach, positivism is the search for the causes of crime using scientific method, as opposed to the classical approach, which relies upon free will as the main cause of crime.Biological theories:One of the founders of modern criminology and leaders, Cesare Lombroso (1835-1909), thought that people were born predisposed to antisocial behaviour (Bartol, 2005), Lombroso also held that many criminals had been born with certain physical attributes or stigmata such as large jaws, high cheek bones, fat lips and large ears, as well as other "atavistic" features. According to Lombroso, such people favour behaviour becoming that of primates than that of normal people in human society.Yond Cassius has a lean and hungry look he thinks too much; such men are dangerous (Julius Caesar, I.ii.194).In this study Lombroso observed the physical characteristics of prisoners and compared them to soldiers - looking for similarities such as heads, bodies, arms and skin (Criminology, Carrabine et al). His theory was later ridiculed by many, his methodology was flawed, had he looked further than the prison walls he would have seen such characteristics throughout the population. Questionably, Lombroso's samples included people with severe learning difficulties and people who came from poverty, he ignored the fact that they came from such backgrounds and that such factors may have been the reason for the physical defects rather than criminality Lombroso later adapted...

Find Another Essay On Critically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime

The best and worst theories that discribe why crimes happen (eg biological, psychological and sociological.

747 words - 3 pages The purpose of this paper is to discuss the three major theories of criminology. This paper will talk about the theories that best and worst describe why crime happens. The three major theories of crime are: biological, psychological and sociological. In further examining this paper you will see discussions of personal opinions of the author.The biological theory states that criminals are born and they are not made. I feel that the biological

Describe the biological explanation of crime. Identify key aspects of crime that are hard to explain in this way.

886 words - 4 pages generations of male criminals all possessing the rare gene defect (Genestories, BBC Science website). All of these findings are leading to explosive outcomes in society (especially from the victim's families) which has led some scientists in this field of work to call for it to be stopped.As far as explaining crime and why it happens, the biological explanation can not fully develop the answer. Although it can be seen as one theory it still has flaws

Describe the biological explanation of crime. Identify key aspects of crime that are hard to identify in this way.

676 words - 3 pages another career option, which may, when weighed up with the alternatives, seem a more attractive vocation. What is more likely is that crime can be attributed to a combination of some or all of these factors to varying degrees, of which the biological explanation is just one.(624 words)ReferencesMooney, G., Kelly, B., Goldblatt, D. and Hughes, G. (2000) DD100 Introductory Chapter. Tales of Fear and Fascination: The Crime Problem in the Contemporary UK, Milton Keynes, The Open University.The Open University (2000) DD100 An Introduction to the Social Sciences: Understanding Social Change, Introductory Block Introductory Workbook, Milton Keynes, The Open University.

Discuss two sociological theories of poverty and why it is important for social workers to develop a sociological approach to practice.

2128 words - 9 pages poverty. The Individualistic theory; which blames the responsibility of being poor with the individuals themselves, and the Marxist theory which views poverty as a social problem that has been produced and reproduced by structural forces in society. This assignment shall explain why it is important for social workers to develop a sociologic approach to practice and consider how these two theoretical perspectives contribute to social workers

In an essay response discuss how The Case of Lady Sannox, the Cask of Amontillado, Murder on the Orient Express and Playback contribute to your understanding of the crime fiction genre.

1151 words - 5 pages that a fitting punishment for an adulterous woman would be to destroy her beauty and sexuality. "The mouth will not be a pleasant one to kiss (after amputation), "comments Lord Sannox as the Turk. "Taken the veil, and that the world would see her no more", underscores cultural assumptions that people with non-normative bodies should hide them. The social attitudes and vales are reflected through this early crime fiction, which was a product of

Certain "social indicators" have been identified as underlying issues in the RCIADIC Report. Discuss how these indicators contribute to the over representation of Aboriginal people in custody

1701 words - 7 pages recommendations fell into five main areas; these are Health, Substance Abuse, Housing & Infrastructure, Education and Policing Practice and Targeting/ Judicial System. Despite these recommendations, the endorsement from the government and expectations of the Australian Indigenous community little has been done to improve living standards and over representation of Indigenous people in the Criminal Justice System.HealthThe gap between Indigenous

Critically evaluate and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Customer Boycotts. Compare and contrast two consumer boycotts and discuss appropriate microeconomic theoretical models.

2588 words - 10 pages Microeconomics Coursework EssayCritically evaluate and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Customer Boycotts. Compare and contrast either Coca Cola or Bacardi with another consumer boycott of your choice and discuss appropriate microeconomic theoretical models.Firstly to understand this question we need to understand what a customer or consumer boycott actually is. Well it is normally called by an organisation or a group of individuals

Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement: "It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any...

517 words - 2 pages International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller

With reference to selected management theories and drawing on specific examples, discuss why managers need to be aware of limitations and simplifications present in some of these theories.

4063 words - 16 pages achievements for their organization. Despite these similarities, there are a great number of differences between the two styles of leadership.Firstly, one of the clearest differences between these two styles of leadership is how decisions are made. The autocratic leader tends to control all things in the organization, and thus he makes all decisions without taking into consideration the opinion of his personnel. In contrast, the democratic leader

Using the Relevant Concepts, Theories and Models Introduced in the Module, Describe and Analyse any Recent Organisational Change, Discuss the Problems Encountered in the Process of Managing Change and...

3678 words - 15 pages implemented. The management was away from rest of employees and if somebody needs to meet the general manager, he had to make an appointment and wait for days. There were regular unhealthy conflicts between departments and inside each department. This was mainly because of negative attitude and poor communication between each other. Every employee tries to safeguard himself to avoid blame, and all of this was because of lack of trust.All of these

'Critically discuss one 'individual' OR one 'social' explanation of crime. In critically discussing your selected approach, reference a criminal justice initiative that illustrates your argument.'

1604 words - 6 pages as a manifestation of social pathology generated as a product of social structure itself; as opposed to explanations of individual pathology concerning psychological and biological traits. Social explanations of crime further diverge into the two distinct schools of consensus and conflict theories. Functionalist or consensus theory share a common structural explanation of causes of deviance; while interactionist or conflict theory primarily

Similar Essays

Q: Evaluate The Impact Of Humans On Evolution In Society And The Environment. Compare Darwin/Wallace And Lamarchin Theories Of Evolution. Discuss How Society Has Reacted To These Two Theories.

558 words - 2 pages humans have made an impact on the growth of these organisms, now while they are able to help us in our day to day lives they have also become a danger to people if given the right conditions.These factors have affected both society and the environment, firstly the environment has to pay because land is cleared and it is affected. Secondly there is an impact on society, because now such things as bacteria can affect people and it has been a

Labelling Theories' Contribution To The Sociological Understanding Of Crime And Deviance

1575 words - 6 pages Labelling Theories' Contribution to the Sociological Understanding of Crime and Deviance Becker is the main sociologist studying labelling theory on deviance, he argues that 'social groups create deviance by making the rules whose infraction constitutes deviance.' Meaning acts only become deviant when observers perceive it and define it as deviant. An example of this would be the act of nudity, it is accepted in the

Critically Discuss The Effects Of Psychological And Sociological Variables On Health And Illness

2998 words - 12 pages Critically discuss the effects of psychological and sociological variables on health and illnessThe purpose of this essay is to look at health and illness, identifying the sociological and psychological variables which affect them. In order to explore this area, I will discuss the contribution of sociological and psychological variables, comparing their meaning and highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. I will also be discussing the link

"Organisations Use A Range Of Selection Methods To Fill Job Vacancies. Discuss These Methods And Critically Evaluate Their Reliability And Validity."

2204 words - 9 pages of the candidate's characteristics. The disadvantages are that the statistical methods used in the interpretation may confuse a manager that is not familiar with these academic techniques. Another issue is that this method looks more accurate than it actually is so managers may come to the wrong decision by relying on the test results.Validity and reliability of the selection methodsBefore we start to critically evaluate each selection method in