This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Evaluate How Said's "Orientalism" Thesis And Huntington's "Clash Of Civilization" Thesis Apply To Asian.

992 words - 4 pages

The thesis of "Orientalim" was written by Edward W. Said in 1978 and the author defined the orientalism as a "European invention" and it is a western style for dominating, restructuring and have authority over the orient. It started since the beginning of nineteenth century until World War II and it adopted by France, Britain and American. Most westerner think the orient is seen as "separate, passive, eccentric, backwards" and it is with "a tendency to despotism". Actually these are all the particular form that western stereotypical understanding of Asian people, culture, and value. In Said's "Orientalism" thesis, he thinks the "Orient is an integral part of European material civilization and culture" and "orientalist expresses and represents that part culturally", but in fact he has already divided them into "orient" and "occident" and also labeling someone as an "orientalist". It sets up a dichotomous boundary between "us" and "them". The main objection to Said is we should not label people "as an orientalist or ethnocentrist or imperialist" , because it can create some effects, resulting in promoting stereotypical understanding and still remaining unaware of people's own fixed structures of orientation.The second article " the Clash of Civilization", was written by Samuel P.Huntington in 1993. As "world politics is entering a new phase", that the great divisions among humankind and the dominating source of international conflict will be the cultural. A civilization is the "highest cultural grouping of people and the broadest level of cultural identity people have short of that which distinguishes humans from other species. It is defined both by common objective elements, such as language, history, religion, customs, institutions, and by the subjective self-identification of people". These divisions are deep and increasing in importance. In this article, there also exist some problems with Huntington's notion of civilization which apply to Asia.The first problem is Huntington argues that civilization identity is not only real but also basic. In Huntington's view, religion as the central defining element of civilization and it is not same as language, culture, history and custom, as religion beliefs do not blend and overlap. "Even more than ethnicity, religion discriminates sharply and exclusively among people". He points out that a person can be half-French and half-Arab and simultaneously even a citizen of two countries, but it is more difficult to let a person be a half-Catholic and half-Muslim. This argument seems be true for Christianity and Islam, but actually it is not same with Confucianism and Buddhism. The author identifies many fundamentalist movements, such as Western Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism and Islam, but he does not identify any fundamentalist Confucian movement. In fact, Confucianism is not a religion. A person can be a Buddhist, but he/she also can have the belief of Confucianism. There is no clash and...

Find Another Essay On Critically evaluate how Said's "Orientalism" thesis and Huntington's "clash of civilization" thesis apply to Asian.

Orientalism in "Song of Roland". includes Edward Said's rhetoric

1572 words - 6 pages , Javanese: the list of philological works considered Orientalist is almost uncountable. Moreover, Orientalist studies apparently cover everything from the editing and translation of texts to numismatic, anthropological, archaeological, sociological, economic, historical, literary, and cultural studies in every known Asiatic and North African civilization, ancient and modern." (Orien. 52)The biggest historical problem with Orientalism is the

What Does Said Mean By Orientalism? Discuss Any Aspect Of Said's Work Orientalism,That You Find Most Appealing, And Give Your Own Insights On The Issue

1518 words - 6 pages Orientalism by Said PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 What does Said mean by Orientalism? Discuss any aspect of Said's work Orientalism,that you find most appealing, and give your own insights on the issue.Said, and the meaning of Orientalism from his point of view do not really make any sense. He had many different points of view of Orientalism and he could not find only one way to describe Orientalism, he had many different definitions. There are many

Critically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime

4534 words - 18 pages MSc In Security & Risk ManagementMarch 2010 IntakeCritically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime.4150 wordsAre criminals born or are criminals made? This is a question that many criminologists have researched into and tried and come to a conclusive answer. However the majority are divided into two main schools of thought; those believing in the nurture

Clash of Civilization

1288 words - 6 pages and culture as in relation to Islam and the West having reference to different arguments and visions presented in the following scholarly sources. Samuel P. Huntington in his book “ The Clash of Civilizations”has predicted that the source of conflict in the new world shall not be ideological or primarily economic, as the great divisions among humankind and dominating source of conflict shall be cultural.Although nation states will remain to be

Clash of Civilization

951 words - 4 pages Perbandingan Teori Samuel P.Huntington (The Clash of Civilization) dengan Edward W. Said (The Clash of Ignorance)Usai perang dunia, bukan lagi pertentangan antar beberapa blok maupun Negara. Dalam hipotesanya, Huntington memperkirakan bahwa sumber yang mendasari konflik di era baru tidak lagi sebuah ideology (isu HAM serta demokrasi liberal) maupun ekonomi (kapitalisme). Perpecahan diantara umat manusia dan sebagian sumber konflik berasal dari

Analysis Of Huntington's "Clash Of Civilizations"

1585 words - 7 pages different societies have different values, and explains how it is possible for them to clash over social values.In Huntington's clash of the civilizations thesis, his first of three main claims is that "culture matters" (Norris 135). Civilizations may differ in "history, language, … tradition," and the way they believe different groups should interact (Huntington). He believes the most important difference between civilizations is religion, and

Reasons to support thesis

2281 words - 9 pages Reasons to support thesis First of all, we will consider the very word motivation. Motivation can be defined as an incentive. When we discuss students having the motivation to learn, we may consider them having the incentive to learn. Do students today have the incentive to learn? Many people claim that they do not and that the lack of motivation is increasingly becoming worse and worse in today’s society. The belief that society has

Comments of Huntington's "The Clash of Civilizations

1171 words - 5 pages Samuel P. Huntington's paper "The Clash of Civilizations" defines the shifting of causes for friction between nations. He describes the changing of the guard, between secular ideological friction, such as democracy versus communism, to cultural and religious reasoning. Huntington's hypothesis is based heavily on examples of recent struggles between civilizations all over the world. I agree with Huntington's hypothesis because it is evident that

Comments Of Huntington's "The Clash Of Civilizations"

1183 words - 5 pages Samuel P. Huntington's paper "The Clash of Civilizations" defines the shifting of causes for friction between nations. He describes the changing of the guard, between secular ideological friction, such as democracy versus communism, to cultural and religious reasoning. Huntington's hypothesis is based heavily on examples of recent struggles between civilizations all over the world. I agree with Huntington's hypothesis because it is evident that

Commentary on Learning How to Formulate a Concise Thesis

1208 words - 5 pages would have on job opportunities in today’s globalized economy. This is to prevent myself from delving into say, the altruistic benefits of someone studying the humanities. In addition, I could have further modified it to be a debatable thesis statement. “Exposing students to the sciences would reap a greater benefit as it prepares them for an economic role seeing as how science is the main driving force for the economy and would definitely reap

Criticism of Huntington's Clash of Civilizations Theory

838 words - 4 pages their civilization as their own unique cultural values and reject those imposed unto them by the West (Huntington, 1996). Furthermore Henry Kissinger then suggests that the most power will then fall upon six major civilizations which are namely: Russia, Japan, United States, Europe, China and most probably India. This will then particularly lead to the rivalry of superpowers being replaced by the clash of civilizations. Conversely it then makes it

Similar Essays

Does The Current Conflict Between The West And Islam Confirm Or Contradict Huntington's Clash Of Civilization Thesis?

2604 words - 10 pages Samuel Huntington's thesis on "The clash of civilisations" of 1993 provoked a plethora of varied responses. A Professor at Harvard University, Huntington wrote in order to voice his predictions and warn the world of an upcoming clash of cultures, most notably between the West and Islam. The recent reaction in the Middle East to America's self-styled 'war on terrorism' provides a timely case study for this debate. While an affinity will

The Validity Of Samuel P. Huntington’s Thesis In “The Clash Of Civilizations”

1344 words - 5 pages The aim of Samuel P. Huntington’s “The Clash of Civilizations” was to provide an academic framework to understand almost all of the conflicts that had broken out since the end of the twentieth century, to include predicting the appearance of future conflicts. According to Huntington, there will be a clash of civilizations since the world has been in an unreasonable era since the end of the Cold War and the position of the nation-state has not

Critically Analyse China’s “Peaceful Rise” / “Peaceful Development” Thesis In Relation To The 2013 Chinese Defence White Paper

2287 words - 10 pages , especially in the role of security and defence. China attempts to allay these concerns, in part, by promoting a peaceful development thesis, and publishing more information. The latest Chinese Defence White Paper was released on 16 April 2013 and comprises of a preface, five specific chapters and a conclusion. The aim of this paper is to critically analyse China's "peaceful rise" / "peaceful development" thesis in relation to the 2013 Chinese Defence

Samuel Huntington's "Clash Of Civilizations" Essay

1178 words - 5 pages Samuel P. Huntington's paper "The clash of civilizations" defines the shifting of causes for friction between nations. He describes the changing of the guard, between secular ideological friction, such as democracy versus communism, to cultural and religious reasoning. Huntington's hypothesis is based heavily on examples of recent struggles between civilizations all over the world. I agree with Huntington's hypothesis because it is evident that