This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Evaluate The Claim That Discourse Analysis Could Become The Dominant Paradigm For Psychology In The Future.

1189 words - 5 pages

In The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, the sciences are described as “going through alternating periods of ‘normal science’, when an existing model of reality dominates a protracted period of puzzle solving and revolution, until the model of reality itself undergoes a sudden drastic change” (Kuhn, 1996. Pg 56). Also known as a ‘paradigm shift’ (Handa, 1986). The purpose of the current study is to define and analyse the theoretical concept of discourse analysis (DA) and its application as the potential new dominant paradigm in modern psychology.

Kuhn (1996), defined a paradigm a set of theoretical concepts and research, unified by a framework that describes what is/ isn’t accepted in a specific area of scientific research. Paradigms have two distinguished aspects, namely a set of core experiments that are exemplary and therefore likely to be reproduced and underpinning preconceptions that condition the evidence collected in the experiments. However early theorists considered paradigms conceptually inappropriate for the social sciences such as psychology compared to their natural science counterparts, citing that there are no paradigms in social science as the concepts are polysemic (Kuhn, 1996; Dogan, 2001). Paradigms have also been described as a perspective of the world or worldview (Fassinger, 2005), a term used to describe a specific set of experiences, beliefs and values that the individual uses in order to interpret reality.

However opposing theorists (Ponterotto, 2005) have highlighted that even though the broad groupings in the social sciences are not derived from paradigms present in the natural sciences, the individual sub-disciplines may still be underpinned by a paradigm or a research programme with similar research traditions. An effective example of this is highlighted in the contrast between two leading psychology theories, namely Personal Construct Theory (PCT) and Skinnerian behaviourisum (Kelly, 1963; Skinner, 1991). The most highlighted difference between the two theories is derived from their individual meanings and intentions. The meanings and intentions behind the theory are the core concerns of PCT, whereas the complete opposite is observed in Skinnerian behaviourisum as meanings and intentions have no scientific rigour as they cannot be directly observed. The validity of both theories is argued and supported, yet they are derived from contrasting paradigms, supporting the notion that paradigms do exist in social sciences (e.g. psychology).

Social scientists have coined the phrase “paradigm shift” to detonate a change in how an individual society organises and understands reality. A "dominant paradigm" refers to the values, or system of thought, in a society that are most standard and widely held at a given time (Gabbay, Woods and Thagard, 2006). Dominant paradigms are shaped both by the community's cultural background and by the context of the historical moment, they can be influenced in a variety of ways (Dynamic...

Find Another Essay On Critically evaluate the claim that discourse analysis could become the dominant paradigm for psychology in the future.

Evaluate The Claim That Recent Changes Within Schools Are The Main Factors Responsible For High Female Attainment

2069 words - 9 pages conscious messages in order to encourage and cater for the female student. These policies in theory would have raised female motivation and also given them the scope to excel. Teachers are now more sensitive about avoiding gender stereotyping in the classroom with various anti-sexist initiatives which have raised both teachers' and girls' consciousness.Another factor within schools that could have an impact is the increase in female role models

With Reference to at least three companies of your choice, critically evaluate Dunning's Eclectic Paradigm as a framework explaining the reasons why companies engage in Foreign Direct Investment

3043 words - 12 pages testability (Letto-Gillies 1992 pp 55, 124)".Dunning himself points out the future needs for adjustment of his paradigm in identifying three crucial variables in the paper "A Rose by any other Name.....?" These are technological change, the governance of the world trading et al system and the emergence of new players on the global environment. Dunning concluded that more attention was required to the OLI, especially regarding the interrelationships

Critically evaluate the argument that the so-called "crisis in masculinity" paradoxically furthers forms of hegemonic masculinity

2586 words - 10 pages resulted in the reinforcing idea of hegemonic masculinity. In order for men to view themselves as gendered subjects, they must ask themselves what defines them as men and society and thus the media must challenge the negative dominant discourse of masculinity which includes the act of rape, violence and aggression. I believe that today society is developing a deeper awareness of the equality of the two genders and also that we both are different

Describe and evaluate the claim that hypnosis is an altered state of awareness

1603 words - 6 pages be consciously aware of any pain when they submerged their forearm into the cold water. Results showed that most people in a conscious waking state who are simply role playing as opposed to being in a supposed altered state (hypnotised) can only keep their forearm submerged for around 25 seconds before they are compelled to withdraw. The hypnotised participants however could hold their forearm in iced water for significantly longer than simulators

Explain and evaluate Sartre's claim that emotion "is a transformation of the world... "

3323 words - 13 pages claiming that we can physically transform the world around us. Magic is meant to be taken as a process of the consciousness that changes the way in which we perceive the world.Sartre's central claim is that the phenomenology of our experience is the only constituent for the experience itself, and that we experience the world in a certain way, by which we are conscious of it. His theory of the intentionality states that all our conscious acts are of

Write a short piece about your own social identity. Drawing on this, answer the following question: 'Critically evaluate the claim that 'collective social identities are both inclusive and exclusive'

4321 words - 17 pages rationalizing human variation - 'race'. It was during this period that White European societies presented themselves as a model for the future development of humankind. Shouldering what Kipling writes about in his poem The White Man's Burden:'Child like subjects' and 'Half devil and Half child'.(Kipling, 1899 cited Bilton, Bonnet, Jones, Lawson, Skinner, Stainwoth, Webster, 2002 p.162)Stereotypes like this and the support of 'race' science would

Critically evaluate the assertion that "auditing e-business is no different from auditing any other business"

1777 words - 7 pages Critically evaluate the assertion that "auditing e-business is no different from auditing any other businessFor me to be able to answer the question I must first understand what e-business is and how different it is to traditional business. An e-business is the delivery of information, products/services or payments via telephone line, computer networks or any other means. It is the application of technology towards the automation of e-business

Critically evaluate the competitive advantage that can be gained by companies through IS/IT outsourcing.

913 words - 4 pages contractors who do the work of IT and other workers can find jobs that are needed in our country but also they will get better quality. Businesses that choose to outsource IT, either offshore or through a local contractor, will convert their fixed expenses and variable capital releases for use in other areas. This makes the business more attractive to investors, as the company has more capital to continue operations on income area. 2.6 Imitability

Q. Porter (2001) suggests that the Internet will increase rather than decrease the importance of strategic management in the future. Critically assess this viewpoint

1786 words - 7 pages Porter (2001) summarises the relative advantages of the Internet and how these are worthless without a strategic approach in his article. He uses his own five forces analysis to analyse the "underlying forces of competition" and states that this analysis is still necessary to "illuminate" areas of potential profitability for any company or in any industry. He suggests that using his value chain analysis should be the basis for exploration into

It is argued that the Activity Based Costing approach produces more accurate product cost information. Critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of this statement.

2296 words - 9 pages argued that it is people actually manage activities but not costs (Stickney, M and Weil, pp 153). The managerial advantages of ABC extend to include for one the benefits derived from "non-financial activity analysis". In this analysis the managers while also helping the accountants with the production, studied the result produced at the end of the "workflow analyses of the activities for which they were responsible". This analysis helped them gain

Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement: "It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any...

517 words - 2 pages International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller

Similar Essays

Using Examples, Critically Evaluate The Claim That Humanity Must Learn To Live With Environmental Hazards

2079 words - 9 pages merely teaches the nation to learn to expect aid in the future (Killick, 2004). In order to learn to manage environmental hazards, each individual nation must learn to adapt to and mitigate for them in their own way. Nations are able to adapt most efficiently to environmental hazards themselves, as they are equipped with tacit knowledge of their nation that international organisations may lack. There is, therefore, an individualistic facet to hazard

Critically Evaluate The Impact Behaviourism Has Had On Psychology

1444 words - 6 pages Critically evaluate the impact behaviourism has had on psychologyFor hundreds of years philosophers speculated about "the mind" and in around the 1880's the popular method of psychology dealt only with the conscious mind. The experiments carried out at this time were criticised for their lack of objectivity and by the 1920's a new brand of psychology emerged in the form of behaviourism.Psychology became a recognised discipline in around 1897

Evaluate Aristotle's Argument(S) For His Claim That Happiness (Eudaimonia) Is The Goal Of Human Life

1899 words - 8 pages Evaluate Aristotle's argument(s) for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life.In evaluating Aristotle's arguments for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life, I believe it is important to recognise the true problem at hand, which can be seen to be, does Aristotle succeed arguing that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life? I believe that overall Aristotle does not succeed in arguing this

Critically Evaluate The Value Of Academic And Applied Psychology In Facing The Challenges Of Life In The Twenty First Century

1601 words - 6 pages face of work has changed since the 19th century, and even before that with the Industrial Revolution. As outlined above, Globalisation can be seen negatively as it may force people of a culture to accept another ideal, but the idea of Globalisation has also impacted on the world positively, for example changing the face of work. Through Occupational Psychology (applied psychology), the work place has implemented changes that has slowly started in