This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Evaluate The Main Principles Of Legal Positivism And Natural Law.

3538 words - 14 pages

The history of "Natural Law" is extensive. Classical Greek Naturalism was the major doctrine until Christian Theologian Doctrine replaced it. As societies have moved away from the church "Natural Law" has been to some extent superseded by Positivism. We have been asked to critically evaluate these two schools of Jurisprudence.Greek NaturalismThe classical Greek philosophers believed that natural law was a moral order, which was superior to human law and one that knows no bounds either in space or time. It decreed that people should be communal and that man-made regulations for communities were inferior to nature's laws.Aristotle (384 -322 BC) believed that humans were inherently good and teleological, designed by nature with specific goals in mind. Anything, which interfered with this, should be considered to be bad. He spoke about the relationship between fact and value, what is and what ought to be. Cicero in the first century BC perpetuated these viewsJudao-ChristianChristian Theologians such as Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) believed that God lay down the rules for society and that these were superior to temporal law. Man-made law should accord with God's law. He argued that there were four kinds of law: Eternal, Natural, Human and Divine Law.Aquinas confirmed St Augustine's premise that there is no law unless it is just . If human law conflicts with natural law according to Aquinas it is not lawful and may be disobeyed.Natural law jurists argue there is an intrinsic link between law and morality. However, positivists argue it is flawed because it is based on prejudice and value judgments. Homosexuality in some societies is considered unnatural so is immoral. Similarly it is morally wrong to kill yet in certain circumstances there are exceptions, e.g. wars. The Abortion Act 1967 is an example of a Positive Law versus Natural Law argument. To pro-life supporters it is morally wrong but to Positivists it is lawful, see R v Smith (John). Another example is the Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority where a mother brought a case in respect of doctors advice about the contraception pill to under sixteen year old girls.Thomism maintained the status quo; this left it open to revolutionary argument designed at radically changing society. If the social and political system of a country does not afford basic human rights and protection then that "legal system" could be said to lack morality. Rousseau . (1712-1778) argued for developing peoples rights and potential. Hobbes (1588-1679) for a "the social contract" whereby citizens gave up some liberty for protection and Locke (1632 -1704) for the respect of property rights. This became known as "Enlightenment Naturalism or "The Age of Reason". The theories elucidated that individuals get together to form a social group and make rules, which benefit the majority within that group.More recently the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms is based on natural law principles....

Find Another Essay On Critically evaluate the main principles of legal positivism and natural law.

Similar Principles of the Natural and Economic Environments

1029 words - 4 pages Similar Principles of the Natural and Economic Environments By examining Darwin's theories of evolution, which explain the process by which the phenomenon of evolution occurs, we get a grasp of a broad picture of the natural world with all its relationships and dynamics. Likewise, Adam Smith explains the economic world of Laissez-Faire capitalism in abstract, holistic terms, creating a general picture of its components. In studying both

Compare and Contrast 7 of the Main Ethical Principles

4261 words - 17 pages ? Regardless of the answer to these questions, it is easy to see that the answers can be contradictory and confusing, leaving somewhat of a mess of the Divine Command Theory. The second important theory in Religious Ethics is the Natural Law Theory, the dominating force in Christian theology, it has three main points: 1. Everything in nature has a specific purpose. 2. Everything in nature is designed as it ought to be, and acting against it would

Critically evaluate the environmental content of the Chancellor's recent budget

2405 words - 10 pages not increased overall. Any new green tax introduced should be balanced by a reduction of tax on labour. Many policy makers favor using environmental taxation to reduce taxes on labour. It is hoped that is it will provide a "double dividend" and is one of the key arguments in favor of fiscal instruments to reduce environmental problems.Throughout Europe there has been a growing emphasis on taxing labour while taxing natural resources has been

Critically evaluate of Internationalisation theory

671 words - 3 pages Critically evaluate of Internationalisation theoryOne of the prominent trends in the contemporary world is claimed to be globalisation. The term entails many different meanings and perspectives for global business. There are at least the four viewpoints concerning the business of internationalization: Transaction Cost Theory, Uppsala Module, Internationalisation from a Network Perspective and International Product Life Cycle Theory (IPLC

Critically evaluate the use of lifestyle analysis in consumer marketing

2166 words - 9 pages and public to marketer through information used to identify and define marketing opportunities and problems; generate, refine, and evaluate marketing actions; monitor marketing performance; and improve understanding of marketing as a process."5. Consumer lifestyle measurementThe basis on which a firm decides the segmentation of its consumers will be determined by repeated refinement as consumers respond to market offerings through purchases and

Critically Evaluate Existing Practices of Dubai Bank in Uae and The Relationship of Its Practices and the Recruitment

2527 words - 10 pages IntroductionWe will critically evaluate existing practices of Dubai bank in UAE and the relationship of theory of practices and the recruitment. Since its launch in September 2002, Dubai Bank has challenged traditional banking practices by placing service, transparency and convenience at the forefront of its operations and introducing unique products and services to the market. On January 1, 2007, the Bank became a Shari 'a compliant financial

Critically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime

4534 words - 18 pages MSc In Security & Risk ManagementMarch 2010 IntakeCritically evaluate biological and sociological theories and discuss how these contribute to the explanation for the occurrence of crime.4150 wordsAre criminals born or are criminals made? This is a question that many criminologists have researched into and tried and come to a conclusive answer. However the majority are divided into two main schools of thought; those believing in the nurture

Critically evaluate the role of the major news agencies in the production and flow of international news

1699 words - 7 pages 9. Critically evaluate the role of the major news agencies in the production and flow of international news.As the news media has rapidly developed into a modern, high-tech mass communication industry, it is playing an increasingly important role in different aspects: political, economy, social life, the development and peace between nations. Culture and beliefs flow across territorial boundaries, people in different countries can share ideas

Strengths and Weaknesses of Biological Positivism

2488 words - 10 pages Biological Positivism has both its strengths and weaknesses, it changed the way of criminological ideas and opened up new theories that were based on scientific facts rather than philosophical ideas like in Classicism. It also highlighted the importance of looking into peoples genetic make-up as research such as Brunners' research into the extra 'Y' chromosome which led to the idea that genetic defects in a family can cause abnormal behaviours

Critically Evaluate the Value of Academic and Applied Psychology in Facing the Challenges of Life in the Twenty-First Century

1601 words - 6 pages In the 21st Century, many problems face the people of today with academic and applied psychology facing those problems. One of the main problems that people face today is the idea of Globalisation. Globalisation is an ever growing process around the world, which has been an ever-lasting process throughout time and into the 21st century. Globalisation is described as “a process of international integration arising from the interchange of

Outline the development of the World Trade Organisation and critically evaluate its role in the twenty first century

1261 words - 5 pages The World Trade Organisation (WTO) came into being on the 1st January 1995. It is based in Geneva, Switzerland and was created by the Uruguay Round negotiations. It is the successor to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) established in the wake of the Second World War. While the WTO is still young, the trading system that was originally set up under GATT is already 55 years old. With 144 member countries, the WTO has six main

Similar Essays

Natural Crime Vs. Legal Positivism Essay

2932 words - 12 pages It has long been understood that there is a difference between law and justice. The Robinson text describes Legal Positivism and Natural Law and indicates the differences between the two are the unjust positive laws. This essay will examine and understand these differences on a very basic level. The essay first looks to understand what positive law and natural law mean, and then look at what is meant by the law of nature. In my reading, positive

Comparing Natural Law To Legal Realism In The Case Of Carlton Versus Walkovsky

1034 words - 4 pages In the case of Carlton vs. Walkovzsky, I will discuss facts, main legal issues, majority decisions and reasons for the dissent. This case took place on September 26, 1966 in the court of Appeals of New York. Judge Fuld J wrote the majority decision, while Judge Keating wrote the dissenting decision in the case. I will be applying Natural Law and Legal Realism to the case to argue my position, and ultimately prove that the theory of Natural Law

Critically Discuss And Evaluate The Following Statement: "It Is Quite Clear That An Individual State Cannot Create International Law. Nor Are The Acts Or Statements Of A Single State Of Any...

517 words - 2 pages International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller

Describe And Critically Evaluate The Psychoanalytical Approach

1176 words - 5 pages Describe and Critically Evaluate the Psychoanalytical ApproachPlan:1.Introduction2.Methods and Discoveries3.Model of Personality4.Stages5.Therapies6.Criticisms, Evaluations and Research7.ConclusionThe psychoanalytical approach is a controversial doctrine based on the system of psychoanalysis developed by Sigmund Freud. Freud was primarily interested in investigating the unconscious mind through the study of dreams, mental illness and everyday