This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Reading And Analyzing Essay

1058 words - 4 pages

Research journals and the information provided within the pages of these articles must be critically analyzed and read. There is a series of steps in completing both tasks. However, at the start it is vital to ensure that the journals, topic information, and authors are all credible. This process is also necessary to make sure that the credibility of this information is professionally supported and held to a scholarly standard. In support of my research topic, I selected an article that I have deemed a credible source. I will demonstrate through a ten-step process of critically analyzing a journal article. The title, Math Wars 2: It’s the Teaching, Stupid, by John Marshall, published in the Phi Delta Kappan (2006). The analysis used is a procedure or guideline provided by the Olin & Uris Libraries (2009).
Once I have established the articles validity and scholarly integrity I will continue with an evaluation of the researcher’s responsibility, critically reading and understanding the information, which supports the area under study. I will demonstrate this procedure in seven stages that involves the critical reading of research articles.
In accordance with the Olin & Uris Libraries (2009), the initial appraisal of critical analysis consist of checking the author, date of publication, edition or revision, publisher, and title of journal. First, I started with checking the author’s credentials. I found John Marshall’s affiliation in the reference list which stated the following:
John Marshall has been developing curricula for many years; he was involved in the production of Minnesota’s K-12 Math Framework and has taught Elementary School Math Methods classes at the University of South Florida, St Petersburg (Marshall, 2006).
Mr. Marshall also has other published works which were documented in this article’s reference list. The publishing of this information in this article denotes that the article is a peer reviewed or profession periodical. The Phi Delta Kappan is an accepted peer reviewed journal among many academic institutions. Also, the date of the publication is located on the face page along with the copyright information.
Next, the source and information within this article is current and relevant to the topic under study. This is the first and only publications of this article; this makes the ideas fresh and new. However, there are several other articles referenced on this topic which makes this a topic of interest among the professional, scientific community. The publisher of the Phi Delta Kappan is known for accepting articles that are reviewed and have met scholarly standards.
Finally, the journal or periodical writing style is intended for a professional audience. The research information is factual with an accepted method of research technique. After careful review of this article, I have decided that this article is credible and supports my research topic. At this point, I have performed most of the work included...

Find Another Essay On Critically Reading and Analyzing

educational psychology - reflection paper

975 words - 4 pages world today, as it is very easy to simply believe what we are told rather than learn for ourselves. By guiding my future students, I will provide for them the opportunity to construct their own education, while also discovering and composing their own worldview. This course has taught me much about my future career as a teacher. The reading and portfolio essays have allowed me to think critically about the content, and have strengthened my desire to become an educator. There is nothing I desire more than to help those around me, and this course has helped me to better understand how I will be able to do just that.

Critical Thinking Essay

539 words - 2 pages PAGE 3 Jayson BacottPHI-10511/23/14Benjamin PerlinCritical ThinkingIn academic, professional and sometimes in daily human life there is talk about critical thinking, the professor of an educational institution may ask of his/her students to think critically when it comes to completing assignments, or the term may be heard in professional circles, the office manager will try to instill in the people working under him/her to think critically when

Discuss the Role of Organization

532 words - 2 pages The role of organizing in the critical thinking process, in essence, ties everything together. Without organization, there would be chaos, possible mayhem, and certain disorder. Organization takes all of the valid points and thoughts produced while critically thinking, and presents those thoughts in a pattern that surges effortless.Organization is applied in many different ways, depending on who you are, what your precise "style" is, and what

The Agency by Y.S Lee

1199 words - 5 pages experiences. Historical detail in Y.S. Lee’s The Agency generates a believable plot line that is simplistic for a reader to understand and makes the reader analyze and think critically about the Victorian era of Britain. There exists a believable plot in The Agency because of the balance that exists between fact and fiction and Y.S. Lee’s use of necessary anachronism. In order to legitimize the fiction, historical details are used. The merging of fact

Email Practice

963 words - 4 pages the understanding of the actual material. The Q stands for question and is the second step in studying which involves identifying important information. The first out of the three R’s is the third step in studying which stands for read, and requires reading. This reading though, is done for understanding, not for speed. The second out of the three R’s is the fourth step in studying and stands for recall. In this step, it is important to try and

The Problem of Aliteracy

2245 words - 9 pages develop vocabulary, and help children think critically “thus, if the child has problems with a particular word, the context of the illustration may help him to identify it,” (MacDonald) so this develops problem-solving skill unknowingly that is crucial later on in life. The simplicity of Dr. Seuss books may cause children to turn away from it because their parents are bored reading the Dr. Seuss books to them. “But as Bruno Bettelheim has

The Page Vs. The Screen

596 words - 2 pages "There are dualities within each duality," (Shlain, pg. 431). Perhaps this quote is true in that most everything in this world has a polar opposite. Many contrary terms are easy to recognize and usually have a simple effect on life such as off and on, stop and go, light and dark. However, there exist dualities in which the effects are more difficult to recognize. In reading chapter 35 of The Alphabet and the Goddess, it is shown that the

UIII Examine the Role of Critical Thinking

673 words - 3 pages unfamiliar one. Critical thinking requires that the person understand the basic concept of a theory if s/he is to think critically about that theory. The converse ideation where critical thinking precedes basic understanding is fallacious. This makes critical thinking process to be predictable. Paul and Elder (2002) highlight the next stage of critical thinking as the need to expand basic understanding. This can be acquired through domain of

Thinking Critically Simulation

1178 words - 5 pages Thinking Critically PAGE 6 Thinking Critically SimulationWith the introduction of management-driven protocols, employees have been empowered to independently evaluate problems and make choice decisions. That level of practice requires the employee to process a great deal of information about the problem, to make decisions about appropriate actions to initiate, to assess the effectiveness of the actions, and to implement necessary changes to

Making a Good Decision

588 words - 3 pages incompetent actions or systems. Critical thinking includes the element skills of analyzing arguments, making inferences expending inductive or logical reasoning, judging or assessing, and making decisions or solving problems. Critical thinking involves both mental skills and characters. These characters, which can be seen as attitudes or behaviors of mind, include open- and fair-mindedness, interest, flexibility, a tendency to seek

A Critical Study of Media Reaction to September 11

1319 words - 5 pages this reality.  We need to be discerning with the information we take in, be able to critically analyze it, and eventually make intelligent and informed judgements.  Hence, to do a critical study of media culture with reference to the events transpiring after the September 11 attack, we need Cultural Studies.      Cultural Studies gives us the methods for analyzing the media.  It gives us the pedagogical tools necessary to critically

Similar Essays

Critically Analyzing The Main Issues In The Case Study Using Relevant Theories Related To Organization And Management

1825 words - 7 pages Critically Analyzing the Main Issues in the Case Study Using Relevant Theories Related to Organization and Management This case study deals with the Oticon’s organizational change, a Danish firm specialised in hearing aids. Due to an instable environment, the firm has transformed the organisation of the structure in order to be competitive in an international market and consequently it has changed the work, the hierarchy

Improving Reading Comprehension And Critical Thinking Skills In Middle School Students

1573 words - 6 pages also important that students know how to critically think before, during, and after reading. From a media specialist point of view I can see the importance of collaborating with teachers in order to provide lessons where reading comprehension and critical thinking skills are emphasized in the lesson. I also see a benefit of the media specialist to co-teach in lessons that incorporate the support of reading comprehension and critical

Ways Of Reading And Jane Tompkins

1216 words - 5 pages of the thought process of which I use when analyzing a reading. " Strong readers often read critically, weighing, for example, an author claims and interpretations against evidence-evidence provided by the author in the text, evidence drawn from other sources, or the evidence that is assumed to be part of a reader's own knowledge and experience."(p.12) The easy way to read a text is to observe the general plot and to formulate ideas about the

In Defense Of Literacy Essay

1020 words - 5 pages In “In Defense of Literacy,” Berry explains, that we live in a country that everyone has the privilege to have an education, that it is ridiculous to have to defend literacy yet he still has to do so. Literacy, is the ability to read and write. As well as the ability to think critically. If we didn't have the ability to think critically, reading and writing would just be skills, to move words around. Anyone that’s ever read and written  knows