This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critically Discuss And Evaluate The Following Statement: "It Is Quite Clear That An Individual State Cannot Create International Law. Nor Are The Acts Or Statements Of A Single State Of Any Consequence To International Law."

517 words - 2 pages

International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller interstate networks are more effective at creating law than large internatioanl players - transnational networks and less power to the states means that due to the interaction between different invidiuals from various states would create inernational law rather than a single state.-regulator networks - networks of financiers and bankers and transnational networks of regulators and transnational networks of goverment (made out of poeple from all sectors of work) - financial crisis involved the IMF, world bank etc. - G8/G20a lot now goes beyond the state and a lot of internatioanl law is beginning to be created through movements like 'make poverty history' etc - look at complexity theory and networks.It is often argued that the structure of international law is such that it is not possible for an independent state to pass or create it itself; complexity theory is often referenced in these cases. Complexity theory, fundamentally, dictates that organisations and states are within a complex and dynamic system of interaction and relationship. The very nature of this shows that small interstate networks are more effective at creating international law than...

Find Another Essay On Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement: "It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."

State and evaluate Aristotle’s function argument that happiness is an objective feature of the characteristic activity of human being

794 words - 4 pages we always seeking for it. And that’s why happiness is an objective feature of the characteristic activity of human being. Some people say that the highest good is not something final. However, the following thought-experiment will show that those people who believe the highest good is not something final are not true. If we already achieve the highest good, what else we need to do? I already prove that happiness is the highest good and it’s

Consider and discuss the following statement: "In any organizational change it is inevitable that there will be 'winners' and 'losers'; conflict between individuals and groups is only to be expected."

2957 words - 12 pages your organization, do not aim for effectiveness and efficiency (such as downsizing), not settle for minor adjustments, nor implement only what other organizations are doing. Real change occurs when people think differently and believe in the impossible. It takes courage to make a real change.By using Kurt Lewin famous 'unfreeze--change--freeze' model, the organizational change can be described as the following steps. The first step of any change

The Aim of Public International Law

2260 words - 9 pages consequently he affirmed that "a state can only have for enemies other states, and not men." (Contrat Social, Bk.I, cap.4). It was the state itself which was concerned with regulating the individuality of man and, before an individual could bring about a claim against a state, it was imperative that he or she convince his or her state to forward the case.This is no longer so today as international law is increasingly becoming concerned with the

It is argued that the Activity Based Costing approach produces more accurate product cost information. Critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of this statement.

2296 words - 9 pages sophisticated technology available (Cagwin, D. and Bowman, M.J. 2002, Cooper 1988). Therefore as stated by Sello and Jasinski 1996 is it true that ABC cannot be supported as a stand-alone system, except for in large companies, which are well staffed and equipped with knowledge in terms of ABC?This point can further be emphasised by the decline in the percentage of ABC users in 1999 in comparison to the growth of nil- 20% in 1987-1994. The result also

Is International Law Really Law?

2242 words - 9 pages Zealand also wanted compensation from France when they found out that they were involved. Usually in such a case as this, where a state sends its agents abroad to commit acts which are illegal under international or municipal law of the targeted country, it is customary for the state to take responsibility for the act and issue some form of restitution. Both countries could not come to an agreement so they sought the United Nations to help them come

Evaluate the Successes and Failures of One Single Party State.(Stalin's USSR)

1353 words - 5 pages of citizens the first step of breaking their will.As historian Richard Freeborn points out: “It is probably no exaggeration that the First Five Year Plan represented a declaration of war by the state machine against the workers and peasants of the USSR who were subjected to greater exploitation than any they had known under capitalism.”However, by the mid-1930s upon the second (FYP), things were improving as benefits such as healthcare

“The competitive position of a company is determined by the industry structure in which it competes.” Critically evaluate this statement.

4509 words - 18 pages Strategy, a so small word but with such great importance as good handling can lead a company either to prosperity or to total disaster. Strategy is a term that cannot be easily explained in a few words as it involves planning, decision making, achievement of goals and consideration of environmental factors (Nollet, et. al. 2005). Strategy is very important as it is a means through which the company will try to experience financial growth, will

Taxation; Find two articles that discuss the local, state, or federal taxation of a good

710 words - 3 pages A fuel tax, also known as a gas tax, is a sales tax imposed on the sale of fuel. In most countries, the fuel tax imposed on fuels which are intended for transportation. Fuels used to power agricultural vehicles, and/or home heating oil which is similar to diesel is taxed at a different, usually lower, rate. The fuel tax is imposed on a federal rate with each state allowing their own subjective amount to this rate.In the United States, the fuel

State and International Assessment

898 words - 4 pages State and International Assessment Assessment is the driving force behind every aspect of teaching today. There is an increasing focus on grades, as well as a growing concern for US performance, in schools compared to others abroad. As a result, standards of learning have not only been developed for each state, but are now being strictly enforced as well. This has caused much controversy over the effectiveness and legitimacy of the standards

Critically evaluate Porters Diamond Theory and discuss in what way it helps international trade

2076 words - 9 pages A model that attempts to explain the competitive advantage some nations or groups have due to certain factors available to them. The Porter Diamond is a model that helps analyze and improve a nation's role in a globally competitive field. The model was developed by Michael Porter, who is recognized as an authority on company strategy and competition; it is a more proactive version of economic theories that quantify comparative advantages for

International Law and Municipal law

5804 words - 23 pages of the monism theory where states are in an obligation to ensure that their municipal law are compatible with international law. He concluded that as a result of development in international conventional and customary law, fundamental human rights of individual are beyond the power of any single State to determine and confer. The effect of international rule of law in municipal law can be seen where the municipal law is weak, non-existent or

Similar Essays

International Law And Its Implication On The Modern State

1507 words - 6 pages supreme authority such as the one that is present in municipal law compels international law to reflect the general consensus of all that take part in it. This is done so that they all feel a collective responsibility to take action when it is violated. In contrast to domestic law, where the individual is the primary participator, international law focuses on states and international governmental organizations as actors. In international law, a state

Describe And Evaluate The Claim That Hypnosis Is An Altered State Of Awareness

1603 words - 6 pages Cold Pressor Test (CPT) involving participants submerging their forearm into iced water and trying to keep it there for as long as they possible can has been used to try to resolve whether hypnosis is or is not an altered state of awareness. Initially, participants get the sensation of coldness; this is very quickly followed by a tingling sensation, which is quickly followed by pain that gets increasing stronger the longer the forearm stays in the

The Rule Of Law Is A Doctrine That, When Followed Within A State, Provides Guarantees That All Will Be Subject To The Law, That The Law Will Be Enacte

2386 words - 10 pages “The Rule of Law is a doctrine that, when followed within a State, provides guarantees that all will be subject to the law, that the law will be enacted through democratic means and that the law is morally good.” – Discuss with reference to the United Kingdom The Rule of Law is a theory encompassing much debate over what it is and what a state needs to do to or have to claim that it follows the Rule of Law. With

Torture Is A Violation Of International Law

1625 words - 7 pages torture because they are all “jus cogens.” The term “jus cogens” is the Latin form of higher international laws, and a law that permits torture can never be conceded by any country (Cohn). Under the international law, torture is illegal because it is considered a violation to human rights. The world has domestic legal systems which also prohibits torture. “Article 3 of the Geneva Convention states that all manner of murder, mutilation, cruel