Critically Discuss The View That 'universal Welfare Provision Can Only Ever Be Wasteful And Lead To Welfare Dependency'. Give Examples To Illustrate Your Points.

2091 words - 8 pages

Key Concepts in Social PolicySXP1004Critically discuss the view that 'Universal Welfare provision can only ever be wasteful and lead to welfare dependency'. Give examples to illustrate your points.For this assignment, in the hope of covering the above statement the writer will discuss what the word welfare means and how we came about in the 1940's to implement a modern welfare system. Also, the writer will look how the effects of the thatcher government have changed the welfare system and made the state more dependable on welfare provision than had previously been seen under previous governments.So what is Welfare and how did it come about?The word 'Welfare' basically means 'Well-being' and is also defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as 'Health, Happiness and Prosperity'. Welfare also refers to the range of services which are provided by the government and charity organisations to help people through times of poverty, sickness, childhood and old age.Welfare Provision in Britain has it's roots in the old poor laws which were first introduced in 1598 to help combat the effects of poverty and continued right up until 1920's. The first of these laws to lay down any guide lines was the poor laws of 1601. These introduced a compulsory poor rate, brought about the creation of 'overseers' of relief and set up provisions for introducing the poor to work ( They also made the local parish's the basic unit of administration, but they failed to set up a mechanism through which this could be enforced. The result being that the poor laws operation was inconsistent between different areas.During the 18th and 19th centuries industrialisation expanded quickly and this was to become known as the industrial revolution. It led to development of towns, rapid population growth and the first real examples of unemployment, all of which resulted in the increase in poor relief rates. In 1834 the poor law commission act was passed which emphasised that there should be less eligibility for paupers than workers with regards to relief. They stated that there should be no outdoor relief given to the very poor, instead if they needed help they would have to enter the workhouses, which were much hated during the 19th century. These workhouses conditions were very servere, the idea being that people would rather seek work than enter them ( In the early 20th century, government tried to move away from the poor laws, by introducing such schemes as national insurance, means tests and health care provisions. It was not really until the Liberal Government came into power in the early twentieth Century that the need for better provisions was addressed from a more moral stand point. They introduced such things as Unemployment insurance and Health insurance and tried to abolish the Old poor law systems in the hope of providing better provisions, but it was not until 1928 that the poor laws ended and were replaced by The local Government Act of 1928, which...

Find Another Essay On Critically discuss the view that 'Universal Welfare provision can only ever be wasteful and lead to welfare dependency'. Give examples to illustrate your points.

Our Future in Harms/( What are your views towards abortion? Give examples to justify your points

727 words - 3 pages Mathew ManosEnglish 101Mr KhanJuly 30,2003Our Future in HarmsDo you want to kill or witness the murder of an innocent unborn child? Are you willing to make a decision that will be on your consciousness? This is the type of decision that will weigh on a persons mind and soul. In recent years, abortion has been a controversial topic in the United States. We live in a society that teaches us the wrong morals. Imagine yourself in a womb and you are

Comment on the pros and cons of privatization of social welfare services in Hong Kong society. Use the “LINK-REIT” as an example to illustrate your answer

4273 words - 17 pages Topic 6: Comment on the pros and cons of privatization of social welfare services in Hong Kong society. Use the "LINK-REIT" as an example to illustrate your answer.IntroductionThe Link-Reit (Real Estate Investment Trust) has long been a controversial issue ever since its launch. The issue in fact concerns the privatization of welfare services. The purpose of this paper is to review the worthiness of privatization in the midst of conflicts of

Explain why is it important to analyse deviance in society. Using examples to illustrate your answer, discuss what such an analysis can tell us about the social and political implications of deviance

1372 words - 5 pages universal, and actually helps maintain social order to a certain extend. To understand the importance of deviance in society, we must first determine the functions of deviance in a social context. Firstly, deviance elucidates shared values and norms. The establishment of a margin between acceptable behaviour and deviant behaviour helps sustain morality. With the absence of deviance, there would not be conformity in society. Secondly, by addressing

Comparing Welfare Provision in Germany and England

1704 words - 7 pages , as discussed, welfare provision will be needed. We have seen the differences between the German and the English welfare state and examined that the extend to which both states provides for provision differs. As a result we can say that problems have hardly changed and new challenges have to be dealt with. Welfare provision is a fundamental part of a state and therefore necessary because it provides social freedom


1357 words - 5 pages The Misconceptions that Romanticism Can Lead To Romanticism, one of the styles of writing that Mark Twain despises, can be most often seen throughout the majority of Sir Walter Scott's novels. Chivalry, adventure, and honor are what are most often written on. In these novels, the writer will make the language very eloquent and melodramatic, which in some cases can lead the readers to create and form false identities. Twain blames Scott for

'Abortion is never justified'. Do you agree? Give reasons to support your answer and show that you have thought about different points of view. You must refer to Christianity in your answer

1568 words - 6 pages have abortions because of their one-child-per-family policy. This policy is in place to help stop the countries overpopulation problems. Now in the UK a legal termination of a pregnancy can be carried out only if two doctors agree that the woman is less than 24 weeks pregnant, AND that continuing would involve a risk to the mothers mental or physical state, OR that continuing would involve a risk to mental or physical damage to any children

Reflect on the Prejudice shown in the world and how can we right these wrongs. Use examples to put through your points

824 words - 3 pages its hatred towards Jews and different colored people. Our society is abused with such hatred based upon peoples' beliefs and origins and it seems millions arefighting each other for no relevant reason at all.I do believe that we can greatly reduce the amount of prejudice in our world today, yet I do not think that it will ever completely go away. Society has seeminglycome to except all races, religions, and genders, and supposedly has achieved

Whether your for or against that failure can lead to a more interesting and better life

759 words - 4 pages permanent unless you choose to let be, failure is also stepping stones that are necessary in life to achieve things, as well as how you learn experience without failure in life nothing would be knowledgeable. Failure is a good because in order to move forward there has to be effort put forth and that creates the want to in a person that makes them want to achieve succeeding. Failure in one’s life is just a detour; it’s only permanent if chosen to let it

Discuss Bazin's idea that 'realism in art can only be achieved through artifice'. What are the implications for film of his approach? Make reference to films in your answers

1570 words - 6 pages ', believing that the essential aim of filmmaking is the representation of the real world, he argues that the film, in order to fulfill its destiny of remaking the real world, will inevitably have to apply certain styles and techniques. He claimed that the need to apply artifice to give the illusion of transparency generated a creative tension that was crucial to the work of art. (pp 339. The cinema book) He argued that that films can only be understood

Evaluation of the View that Coastal Systems are too Complex to Ever be Completely Manageable

2370 words - 9 pages Evaluation of the View that Coastal Systems are too Complex to Ever be Completely Manageable Of all the earth's natural environments, the coast is the most rapidly changing and dynamic. It can be defined in several ways, but at its simplest, it is the place where land and sea meet and interact. The coast is under numerous pressures due to its pull for economic activity, settlement, recreation and wildlife. Its form is

Has the welfare state created a dependency culture

1779 words - 7 pages of the welfare state rather than from personal inadequacy. He is particularly critical of 'universal welfare provision': the provision of welfare for all members of society regardless of whether they are on low or high incomes. Examples of universal provision in Britain include education, health care, and child benefits. Marsland believes that such benefits have created a' culture of dependency'. He says ' the expectation that society, the state

Similar Essays

Critically Discuss The Rationales Underpinning ‘Universal’ And ‘Selective’ Models Of Welfare Provision.

1032 words - 5 pages , the difference amongst the two is the former are the methods of welfare, whereas the latter are principles of welfare (Buckmaster, 2009). This essay will firstly identify and discuss the rationales underpinning universal and selective models of welfare provision and provide examples of each. This will continue into a brief discussion and comparison of universal and selective models of welfare provision. The universal model of welfare is described

Discuss How The Study Of Comparative Culture May Be Of Value To International Business. Illustrate Your Answer With Examples

1457 words - 6 pages considers other as strangers that can not be trusted, not easy friend, a lot of it is unknown and not clever. Meanwhile, the group is just the opposite. Uncertainty and anxiety will affect the ability to process information as they ability communication results. They failed to pay attention to the means of communication in the process of obtaining the desired result. Examples of cultural differences. In the appointment Americans keep time and will avoid

Discuss The Ideas About The Responsibilities Of The Individual That These Three Examples Might Be Used To Illustrate

1449 words - 6 pages . If there is not a unanimous agreement in the group, the 'general will' can be determined by a vote. Rousseau reasons that Man desires to be free, and this can only occur when the 'general will' prevails. This passage asserts that if an individual has voted in a manner which is against the majority, he must accept that he made a mistake and be happy that the 'general will has been obtained, freedom is preserved and that the individual will have

"Accounting As A Discipline Has No Theory". Critically Evaluate This Statement And Provide Examples To Illustrate Your Argument

1993 words - 8 pages future accounting theories.Moreover, other images which Solomon and Tinker debate about were created for domination of theory and practice of accounting. Solomon, a traditionalist, advocates neutrality or objective as opposed to the view of Tony tinker, a radical thinker. In addition, image that influences accounting theory could be partial or one-side results from view of reality can be produced partially and rather one-sidedly. In other words