Criticism Of Goldsmith’s, She Stoops To Conquer

807 words - 3 pages

Criticism of Goldsmith’s, She Stoops to Conquer

In reading T.G.A. Nelson's critical essay "Stooping to Conquer in Goldsmith, Haywood and Wycherley" I have to say I that I was pretty scared. Drawing Freud to anything can really be scary according to almost anyone though, certainly in early criticism of "She Stoops to Conquer." As Bernard Harris says, "we should not discount unconscious forces in any comedy", but then he immediately drops the subject saying that "Goldsmith's main interest lies elsewhere."(325) The main focus of Nelson's essay seemed to be on the difficulty that certain men seemed to find "in achieving a satisfactory sexual relationship with a woman resembling the mother. "(319) This essay will look at what Nelson has to say about this Freudian ideology and bring to light my comments on the subject.

Nelson begins by looking into some of Freud's essays and applying them to the characteristics describing the "Restoration rake. "(320) One example is how there is compulsive repetition in his relationships. Passionate attachments are formed again and again creating a long line of lovers. The preference for married women is also there, where another man claim the right of possession of her and yet the rake prefers her to one who is "disengaged. " Taking Goldsmith's play, Nelson uses it as the clearest example of Freud's theory. In his play, the character Marlow is very forthright in his dealings with those in a lower station, but with women of quality he becomes shy. Evidently, women of low social standing fail to qualify as 'modest women' for him and this fits closely into "Freud's description of the sufferer of selective impotence. "(322) Reading further it's found that the reason Marlow is so shy with those of high society is his lack of experience.

Where could I have learned that assurance you talk of? My life has been chiefly spent in college, or an inn...I don't know that I was aquainted with a single modest woman - except my mother - but among females of another class you know. . . (II. 13 .12-16)
According to Nelson, the mentioning of Marlow's mother along with modest women draws a connection between two: a connection that when made, draws into it Goldsmith's own feelings. "Indeed, the Freudian explanation for Marlow's shyness appears much more plausible than the pragmatic one based on the circumstances of his teenage years." (322) If Marlow had been living in colleges and inns, social opportunities would've been great, and interim periods at home...

Find Another Essay On Criticism of Goldsmith’s, She Stoops to Conquer

A Reader-Response Criticism of How I Learned to Drive

1826 words - 7 pages description of events that are close to her in the present, is structured like a play and her running commentary is filled with humor, satire, etc (like she is a comedian making a joke in poor taste). This manner of narration implies Li’l Bit has an attitude of dissociation, or a detachment from from the events that she describes to the audience. The act of molestation is itself dramatized in such a way that it takes on the appearance of fantasy, losing

Northfrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism as applied to Dickinson's poem #465 (I Heard a Fly Buzz)

1148 words - 5 pages Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism illustrates that literature without a narrative can still be classified according to his various modes. By assessing the world of the speaker, you can learn the speaker's situation and assess which mode the speaker is classified in. This is true of Emily Dickinson's poem number 465. Dickinson, although never actively speaking in the poem, describes in a lyric voice her own last link between consciousness and

An analysis of Alice Walker's poem "Be Nobody's Darling", and how she uses literary devices to enhance the overall meaning

654 words - 3 pages Lester Julius" is an order directed towards the individual to break free of societal molds, but only by its use of extensive imagery and an assertive tone is her poem able to convey its meaning to its full extent.Walker's fervent belief in the value of individuality is reflected in her use of images that draw out a deeper meaning in her work. By using her extensive imagery, the ideas she presents become vividly depicted and are easy to relate to. In

In the novel Frankenstein, Mary Shelley attempts to shape the values of her society more than she attempts to reflect them.

1444 words - 6 pages In the novel Frankenstein, Mary Shelley attempts to shape the values of her society more than she attempts to reflect them.In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, Shelley exhibits what she considers many flaws in the workings of the human mind. Victor Frankenstein is an anti-hero, his temperament is opposite in many ways to the ideals of romanticism. He is a complete megalomaniac, incapable of thinking about anything but himself. He is a scientist, a

Choose a form of literary Criticism to which 'Paste' by Henry James can be giving a succesful reading.

2037 words - 8 pages This essay will be using the liberal humanist approach to literary criticism when considering Paste by Henry James. Thus nothing will be considered other than the text as it appears on the page. F.R Leavis remarks upon the importance of this in The Common Pursuit:the fashionable admirers of James, who, indeed, assumed them to be the supreme expression of his genius, but seem quite incapable of suggesting either any intelligible grounds for the

Gather Together in Maya's Name. Speaks of the author Maya Angelou and how she allows her followers to witness her metamorphosis through different aspects of motherhood

1008 words - 4 pages By consistently weaving the theme of motherhood into her literature, MayaAngelou creates both personal narratives and poems that the reader can relate to.Her exploration of this universal theme lends itself to a very large and diverseaudience. Throughout Angelou's works, she allows her followers to witness hermetamorphosis through different aspects of motherhood.Well-worked themes are always present in Angelou's works- self-acceptance, race, men

Once it was a Golden Land. An analysis of the life of Aung San Suu Kyi and the hero she has come to symbolize.

1164 words - 5 pages Today, Aung San Suu Kyi is the most important figure in Burma. Aung San Suu Kyi was born in Yangoon, Burma in 1945, and is still living. She lived as a middle class citizen growing up, because her father, General Aung San, played a popular and important role in the Burmese government. She tried to change the military run government of Burma. She was educated at the University of Oxford, and gained an honorary doctor of law degree at the American

Overcoming Mount Redcloud My Creative Writing teacher wanted us to write a paper over something we had experienced, but she wanted it in the form of fiction.

1379 words - 6 pages yourself up. You'll need it." She looked around the room for a few seconds. "Here. You'll need these too." She said as she tossed Jordan's hiking boots over to her side of the hotel room. Joy, Jordan thought. Another fun-filled day of hiking up that hideous trail with the icky tarantulas and huge scorpions as well as other crawly creatures. She was a city girl, and her and The Great Outdoors didn't get along very well. They just couldn't see eye to

Real GDP is increasingly criticized for its alleged failure to adequately measure the standard of living. To what extent do you think this criticism is valid?

2450 words - 10 pages Real GDP is increasingly criticized for its alleged failure to adequately measure the standard of living. To what extent do you think this criticism is valid?Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is defined by John (1999) as the total market value of all the final goods and services produced within a nation's borders in a given time period. Each goods and services produced and brought in the market has a price. The price of the total output is called as

To what Extent Can “All My Sons” be Seen as a Criticism of “the American Dream” and the American Way of Life?

2092 words - 9 pages the new luxuries that he has been welcomed with comes from as he feels the war was not there to make money from, yet this is ironic as he doesn’t realise the extent of his father’s actions. When Chris enlightens Ann with his thoughts, she reassure him by saying “there’s nothing wrong with your money… you should be proud” and this perhaps can help him believe in his fathers innocence which he was starting to doubt as she obviously believes in it

Escape from Oppression - An essay which uses two literarty works to explore the theme of women's oppression from a feminist perspective (using feminist criticism)

1290 words - 5 pages her husband has forced on her for the many years she has been subjected to it. Minnie finally rejects her husband's absolute power over her, which is another example, although extreme, of a woman rejecting the role of the suppressed female.Bressler, Charles E. Literary Criticism. (3rd ed.) Upper Saddle River New Jersey: Pearson Education, Inc. 2003Schwiebert, John E. Reading and Writing from Literature. (2nd ed.) Boston New York: Houghton Mifflin. 2001

Similar Essays

She Stoops To Conquer Essay That Analyzes The Use Of Satire Withing The Work She Stoops To Conquer.

539 words - 2 pages She Stoops to Conquer does indeed satisfy the definition of satire given, "the use of instruments such as sarcasm, irony, wit, and humor in literary compositions that hold up follies and vices for criticism, ridicule, and scorn." Within the play, Goldsmith uses the different characters and their relationships with one another to "hold up" the issue of the differences of the various classes that existed during the era in which She Stoops to

Deception Breeds Love From She Stoops To Conquer By Oliver Goldsmith.

507 words - 2 pages Deception Breeds LoveDeceit… Passion… Lust… Love… Tradition… She Stoops to Conquer by Oliver Goldsmith- a comedy of sorts, satirizing 18th Century Englishmen and rife with the deceit, depicts the ironic journey of one man and the conquering powers of love. Through microcosmic methods of characterization and the fusion of ancient and current writing methods, Goldsmith depicts the absurdity of a life enslaved by the laws

Criticism Of Democracy As A Criticism On How To Live One’s Life

1090 words - 4 pages The majority of Socrates’ criticism of democracy in the Republic deals with how he ideally thinks a society should be structured. However, if individuals witnessing this dialogue in fifth century Athens were considering this argument simply in terms of how a government should run, they would be missing Socrates’ main point. For Socrates is actually discussing something much more personal to his audience through means of the republic, their

Metaphoric Criticism Of Huxley’s Hyperion To A Satyr

772 words - 3 pages Metaphoric Criticism of Huxley’s Hyperion to a Satyr In the 1800’s, slavery was a common practice in the southern United States. This discrimination caused a greatdeal of tension between people who believed in slavery and those who were against it. The Civil War broke out as a result of this prejudice. In the 1800’s, the discriminatory nature of man immensely hindered the advancement of our society. Hyperion to a Satyr is a