This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Criticisms Of Descartes Meditations Concerning The Existence Of God

2406 words - 10 pages

My intent in this essay is to illustrate that the arguments regarding the existence of God and the fear of deception in Descartes’ Meditations on First Philosophy, are quite weak and do not justify his conclusions. To support these claims, I will begin by outlining two specific meditations and explain the proposed arguments. Later, I will critically analyze his arguments, revealing unjust conclusions. Doubts surrounding the text include the suggested characteristics of God, the condition of perfection, and the nature of deceit. A wrap up will include a discussion on whether or not Descartes (also referred to as Renatus) succeeded in his project.
The bulk of Descartes’ arguments in regards to the existence of God occur within meditation three. Having previously stripped himself of all material knowledge, all that Renatus can be certain of is his own ideas and that he is a “thinking thing” (35). Being a “thinking thing” speaks to his ability to create ideas, and is really all that proves his existence to himself. Although he stresses that the ideas that he conceives in his mind cannot be false, it is determined that his application of those ideas in the form of judgments are subject to error (37). Furthermore, his ideas are categorized as being innate, adventitious, and manmade. Innate ideas are instinctual, uninfluenced truths; which is contrasted by adventitious ideas that are learned through experience. The third process of thought is made-up ideas, such as imagination (38). These forms of ideas are necessary to the text because they are essentially the only things known to exist, and to categorize them is to define their origin. The strain is placed on understanding objective reality: the application of ideas influenced by external factors. To specify, its application to God (an idea within in the realm of objective reality as opposed to finite reality) (40).
The argument Renatus intends to make with this ideology is that every effect must contain the same properties as its cause, and vice versa (41). This point is the precursor to his first proof of the existence of God. The understanding is that a rock could not have been a rock unless the forces, by which it was created, also contained the qualities of a rock (41). Alternatively, as much as a substance can only exist as a result of something of equal perfection, for an idea to be derived from a cause different from its effect, the idea would have been created from nothingness. Therefore, because an idea is not (nor cannot be) nothing, it must always be the case that reality follows this cause and effect relationship (41).
Upon elaboration, Renatus suggests that were he to have an idea that is so objectively real, that its reality is in fact greater than he, than he could not have caused it (42). This implies that a greater being, such as God, must have caused it. Renatus is quick to conclude that, because of God’s characteristics, which are definitely ideas much more...

Find Another Essay On Criticisms of Descartes Meditations Concerning the Existence of God

The Existence of God: the Arguments of Locke and Descartes

1366 words - 5 pages Descartes believes that God's existence is clear and distinct. God exists because the thought of God is derived from a "completely clear and distinct" idea from within his being (which he concedes is a thinking being). Having come from distinct thoughts, the idea of God can therefore never be considered a falsity. From this very distinct idea of God comes everything else that one grasps distinctly and clearly. He states, "From the fact

Descartes proof of God. This examines Descartes' argument for the existence of God

1282 words - 5 pages The intention of this paper will be to examine Descartes' argument for the existence of God. First, I will review Descartes' proof for the existence of God. Then, I will discuss some consequences that appear as a result of God's existence. Finally, I will point to some complications and problems that exist within the proof. Descartes' proof of the existence of God occurs in the Third Meditation. He builds his entire argument upon his proof in

Rene Descartes In Proving the Existence of God

1332 words - 5 pages René Descartes tried using reason alone to prove the existence of God, and that the soul is separate from the body. In theMeditations, he starts out by doubting completely everything and then progressively explains human existence, and then theexistence of God. By using reason, he also attempts to prove that the soul is separate from the body. Although Descarteshad some very excellent points, it is impossible to prove the existence of God

Descartes' Fifth Meditation This essay provides insight into Descartes' Fifth Meditation and the existence of God

629 words - 3 pages In his Fifth Meditation, Descartes' attempts to once again prove the existence of God. He comes up with a number of examples that relate aspects from the material world in order to further his belief that God really does in fact exist. He states his theories favoring God's existence, most notably in his second ontological argument. At the same time he also presents several possible objections that could come into play, and refutes them

Existence of God. A look at Rene Descartes' theory

1307 words - 5 pages with all the modern technologies and the development of sciences, we still do not have a definitive answer to the question 'does God exist?'Among many philosophers and scholars who have tried to answer this question, we shall look upon Rene Descartes' theory on the existence of God. In terms of believers and non-believers, Descartes would be one of the believers. Before we go any further, we must ponder upon several questions. What is God? Does God

Descartes: The Father of Modern Philosophy on the Existence of God

1137 words - 5 pages Descartes' book Meditations is a work in which he attempts to achieve absolute certainty about three issues: the soul as "a thinking thing" distinct from or without a body, the belief that God exists, and the belief that the external world exists. I am interested in the impact that these ideas have on the question of a rational belief in God.Initially after reading portions of Descartes work, I am led to believe that thinkers build on what

Assignment 1: Sketch briefly Descartes’ proof for the existence of God. What possible objections can you raise against this proof?

880 words - 4 pages 1. Introduction Descartes’ argument for the existence of God relies on the untenable notion of a substance of perfection and that it can be predicated of God. In this essay Descartes’ arguments for the existence of God will be briefly expounded, and then objections against his methodology employed in order to establish the proof of God, will be discussed. 2. Proof of God God takes on a crucial place in Descartes’ philosophy. He was certain of

Analysis on Descartes' God existence proof

893 words - 4 pages The objective of this paper is to examine Descartes' argument for the existence of God. To do this we firstly have to review Descartes' proof of God existence. And after this we will see what objections can his theories hold.Descartes set out to build a set of arguments designed to prove God's existence. His goal in proving God's existence had to be incontestable, there could not be any doubt. Descartes started by renouncing all his beliefs, so

Comparing Knowledge in Descartes’ Meditations on First Philosophy and Hume’s An Enquiry Concerning

923 words - 4 pages Comparing Knowledge in Descartes’ Meditations on First Philosophy and Hume’s An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Rationalists would claim that knowledge comes from reason or ideas, while empiricists would answer that knowledge is derived from the senses or impressions. The difference between these two philosophical schools of thought, with respect to the distinction between ideas and impressions, can be examined in order

The Meditations of Rene Descartes

700 words - 3 pages good. His First Meditation will end with Descartes seemingly troubled over the nature of God. The meditations continue with his questioning of almost everything important to existence. Rene seemed unable to admit anything as truthful. The mind is something of great weakness and error, Descartes would say. He would continue and urge us not to trust what we see because there is no way of being certain about anything. Methodological doubt was

Descartes’ Ultimate Purpose of the Meditations

1836 words - 7 pages Descartes’ Ultimate Purpose of the Meditations My initial approach to René Descartes, in Meditations on First Philosophy, views the third meditation’s attempts to prove the existence of God as a way of establishing a foundation for the existence of truth, falsity, corporeal things and eventually the establishment of the sciences. When viewed in this light, Descartes is accused of drawing himself into a ‘Cartesian circle

Similar Essays

Descartes And The Existence Of God

1181 words - 5 pages Descartes and the Existence of God Once Descartes has realized that he can know with certainty that “I exist” is true, he continues to build on his foundation of truths. The truth about the nature of God, proof of God’s existence, and the nature of corporeal objects are considered, among others, after Descartes proves his existence. Descartes’ principal task in the Meditations was to devise a system that would bring him to the truth. He

Descartes Proof For The Existence Of God

1542 words - 6 pages whole are undeniable. In his work he was very modest, always states himself no more gifted than anyone, but we can feel arrogance in his conclusions. For example, only his method would deliver humanity, he will complete the debate of God’s existence, his judgment is right to describe characteristics of God, etc. I think Descartes succeeded in some parts of his proof for the existence of God, but failed in proving God’s existence from a logical point of view. The fact that there are educated men of all religions proves that anybody can be right in his own description of existence of God. Rene Descartes, Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy.

Descartes' Proof For The Existence Of God

4707 words - 19 pages Descartes' Proof for the Existence of God Many readers follow Descartes with fascination and pleasure as he descends into the pit of skepticism in the first two Meditations, defeats the skeptics by finding the a version of the cogito, his nature, and that of bodies, only to find them selves baffled and repulsed when they come to his proof for the existence of God in Meditation III. In large measure this change of attitude results from a

Descartes Argument For The Existence Of God

1209 words - 5 pages Descartes employs what is known as an ontological argument to prove the existence of God. Saint Anselm who lived during the 11th century first formulated this type of argument. Since then it has proved popular with many philosophers including Rene` Descartes. Even though ontological arguments have lost popularity with modern philosophers there has been some recent attempts to revive them. Descartes formulation is regarded as being one of the