Critique Final Essay

646 words - 3 pages

Adriana Szeltner23 September 2014W1 W131Critique Final"The Stanford Prison Experiment" by Philip G. Zimbardo raises troubling questions about the ability of individuals to exist repressive or obedient roles, if the social setting requires these roles. Philip G. Zimbardo, professor of psychology at Stanford University, began researching how prisoners and guards assume submissive and authoritarian roles. Considering the riots and outbreaks that took place and how they might effect the subjects, the data being collected holds no relevancy.Prisoners are taken from their own homes, without warning, and taken to the local police station. The officers do not place the subjects in a real prison, only in a prison setting, and therefore the environmental and situational variables of a real prison are not present. For example in a normal prison, prisoners are not blindfolded when they enter the prison. Zimbardo argues though that prison is a confusing and dehumanizing experience and that it was necessary to enact certain procedures to put the prisoners in the proper mind-frame. The mock prison represents an attempt to simulate the psychological state of imprisonment.The warden speaks to the prisoners stating that "The rules are posted in each of the cell and if follow all of these rules and keep your hands clean, repent for your misdeeds, and show a proper attitude of penitence, you and I will get along" (Zimbardo 107). Within a short time both guards and prisoners were settling into their new roles, the guards adopting theirs quickly and easily. Within hours of beginning the experiment some guards begin to harass prisoners. The guards behave in a brutal and sadistic manner, apparently enjoying it and other guards join in. "Rule number one: Prisoners must remain silent during rest periods, after lights are out, during meals, and whenever they are outside the prison yard... Seven: Prisoners must address each other by their ID number only. Eight: Prisoners must address the...

Find Another Essay On Critique Final

Forgiveness Therapy Essay

1054 words - 4 pages on alternative individualized treatment based on routine therapy techniques. This article was the first to question the effectiveness of Forgiveness Therapy as a main factor of relapse prevention. Critique of the Title Upon reviewing this article and evaluating the titles it can be determined that the title is sufficiently specific. According to Pyrcazak (2008), a title should not only be specific but concise. The title Effects of

Films Essay

986 words - 4 pages become part of the vast machine devoted to commercial and communal taste, feeling, and desires which has led 20th century critics to publish a "John Doe" commodified critique, when the main objective is to sell the film.Film criticism is the analysis and evaluation of films and as a rule can be divided into two broad areas, academic criticism by film scholars and journalistic film criticism that appears regularly in newspapers and magazines. In

The Feminist Approach

2280 words - 9 pages discussed. The écriture feminine scholars Julia Kristeva, Hélène Cixous and Luce Irigaray shall be drawn upon in order to make the arguments of the feminist critics more clear, but also to offer their own critiques to feminist studies, and how they are manifested within the context of literature. Overall, this paper shall argue that the feminist understanding of the critique of literature is required to further the feminist agenda of equalized

A Deconstructionist Critique of Chopin’s The Awakening

527 words - 2 pages A Deconstructionist Critique of Chopin’s The Awakening The multiplicity of meanings and (re)interpretations informing critical studies of The Awakening reveal a novel ripe for deconstructionist critique. Just as Chopin evokes an image of the sea as symbolic of Edna’s shifting consciousness (“never ceasing, whispering, clamoring, murmuring, inviting the soul to wander in abysses of solitude,”138), likewise the deconstructionist reading of a

Is Postmodernism a continuation or critique of Mod

3824 words - 15 pages Is Postmodernism a continuation or critique of Modernism ? Postmodernism can be seen as both a continuation and critique of modernism. The difficulty in presiding between a continuation and a critique is that postmodernism , as with modernism, has a scope wider than the arts alone. To answer the question accurately one must consider important factors such as culture and historical periodising amongst a whole host of things. Postmodernism is

A Perception and Motivation Study Among Married Adults

1426 words - 6 pages Research Article Critique: Forgiveness: A perception and motivation study among married adults Abstract The article is endeavors to observe the possible correlation between general forgiveness (actually forgiving) and perceptions of forgiveness (a belief in the concept). This is a summary analyzing the credibility of the article. The summary includes a brief overview and critique of the title, abstract, literature review

Froude’s Terrible Reputation and Unexpected Obituaries

1471 words - 6 pages he did critique harshly he also balanced this to remain neutral with praises such as offering on final praise to close the article “Throughout his literary life he appeared as a high-minded, earnest and dignified man of letters” (James Anthony Froude). This was the common pattern of the obituaries with the critiques there were praises and compliments which effectively either made the articles neutral or more positive. The syntax and tone

American Idol

890 words - 4 pages faculties and the way of life for a particular people. My goal will be to critique the ideal of image on American Idol and discuss how people may or may not get though based on looks alone. In the entertainment industry, images of the “perfect” people are portrayed as women being skinny, tan, and firm and men being handsome, muscular, and original. Judges Randy, Paula, and Simon critique contestants on American Idol mostly based on their image

Leadership Practices

947 words - 4 pages PURPOSE The Background Paper that follows is meant to allow a basic understanding of the Topic Assigned for the Management in Practice as well as to critique and provide an honest evaluation of the approach used so far. It is would also allow for the incorporation of various suggestions to improve the focus and scope of the Topic assigned by the company.FORMAT The format followed for the accomplishment of the above given purpose is listed below

Limits and Challenges of the Feminist Critical Approach

3325 words - 13 pages , including but not limited to literary criticism, is steeped in the patriarchal roots of society, so that offering a true feminist discourse in this language becomes difficult. The final theorist to discuss on her own is Luce Irigaray, and her text entitled “Sexual Difference”. Irigaray offers a critique in this particular work of the entire concept of “subject” and “discourse” within the field of academia, also due to the influence and limitations

Piaget

1790 words - 7 pages This book report will focus on Piaget by Margaret A. Boden. It was published by the Harvester Press Limited in association with Fontana Paperbacks in 1979, in Sussex. It serves as an outline for Jean Piaget's theoretical work in psychology, biology and philosophy, and then offers a critique into the validity, importance, and influence of his ideas. This book report will offer a summary of the major themes outlined by Boden in her book, and then

Similar Essays

Animated Film Critique For Lightwave 3 D Animation Class. A Look At "Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within"

778 words - 3 pages John J. WaldDecember 5th 2001Animation Workshop IAnimated Film CritiqueAfter watching "Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within" on DVD, I can assuredly say that I was very impressed. This feature length animated story used the latest technology in modeling, design/creation of characters and sets, lighting, special effects and motion tracking, all for the purpose of creating a very new kind of narrative story. Based on the story line of the highly

The Development Of Karl Marx's Critique

2499 words - 10 pages consciousness.” As we can see, this is a quite different conception of the human dynamic than the one of his early texts; nevertheless, it is in part a consequence of his critique of philosophy and his experience of the social conflicts at the time. 5. The construction of a new “Science”. A final comparison point between Marx’s both critiques, rest in the fact that, in the critique of philosophy, he was working within a framework which was not

The Manifestation Of Violence In Antigone

2073 words - 9 pages in the realm of means, not of ends” (1921:277) and relates violence to law and justice. This means that violence is the development of a violent act, not the act itself. Both texts agree that violence is a process not a specific event. This essay will examine and apply, in theatrical terms, the discussions of Arendt and Benjamin, in relation to Antigone. Antigone in Context To apply On Violence and Critique on Violence to the play Antigone, the

Adorno And Horkheimer's Dialectic Of Enlightenment

3175 words - 13 pages Adorno and Horkheimer's Dialectic of Enlightenment 'Myth is already enlightenment; and enlightenment reverts to mythology' (Dialectic of Enlightenment XVI) Adorno and Horkheimer's obscure and nihilistic text Dialectic of Enlightenment (DoE) is an attempt to answer the question 'why mankind, instead of entering a truly human condition, is sinking into a new kind of barbarism' (DoE, p.xi). The result is a totalising critique of