Critique Of Hardy's Dissertation Essay

921 words - 4 pages

This paper reviews Hardy’s (2008) dissertation on perceptions of school counselors and school administrators with the respect to the roles of school counselors as they implement the New York Comprehensive School Counseling Model. This critique will examine the problem and purpose of the study, literature review, methodology and conclude with discussion and summary.
The Problem
(Hardy’s, 2008) study focused on two problems. The first concern focused on “the ambiguous role definition of actual practice for school counselors since New York State school counselors responsibilities are defined by local school district administration instead of the components of the New York State Model. In addition, a second problem is the understanding by school personnel of the school district’s conditions and their readiness towards the implementation of the New York State Mode” (p.2-3).
The Purpose
The purpose of the study was to “examine actual and preferred school counselor practice as well as perceptions of school counselors and administrators towards a comprehensive school counseling program in New York State”(p.3).
The Literature Review
Hardy’s literature review gives a historical overview regarding school counseling dating as late as 1950’s until the present. Hardy described the importance of organizations such as American School Counseling Association and Educational Trust participation regarding the transformation of school counseling program as well as, the school counselor’s role within elementary, middle and high school settings. ASCA and Educational Trust organizations are responsible for establishing parameters that most districts and states follow. Hardy’s related literature describes the old adage views regarding what do counselors do all day. Hardy’s highlights the benefits of comprehensive school counseling program that allows parents, students, teachers and administrators the opportunity to describe how their students are different because of the school counseling program. In addition to the outcome mentioned above Hardy believes that New York State model will establish appropriate activities and duties for all school counselors to follow. Hardy provides it readers and reviewers with the following information regarding appropriate school counseling duties such as individual and group counseling, large group guidance and consultation with stakeholders versus inappropriate duties such as, lunch, bus and recess duty, clerical duties, discipline students and supervising detention halls. Reportedly, New York State model will provide administrators and districts with a clear and defined role for all practicing school counselors. Lastly, Hardy believes that school counselors and principal’s readiness to implement comprehensive program per the results received from the study. Hardy, hypothesized that “school counselor’s readiness to implement the state model will significantly explain the variation among the scores for preferred...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Hardy's Dissertation

Tess of the d’Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy

1757 words - 7 pages nor his intentions, he uses him for his skill in attempt to climb the social hierachy. Despite Hardy's bitter critique of Christian ideals of Victorian thinking [6] he ironically appears a source of much of Tess' hardship. He allocated to her self-defeating 'seductive beauty', with 'peony lips’ and a ‘deep red mouth’ which reveals, as Kristen Brady claims, ‘he derives an almost sadistic pleasure from Tess’ suffering, and that he violates her with

Ipads in the Primary Classroom Essay

1338 words - 6 pages preschool teacher's story. Young Children, 67(3), 36-41. doi: O'Mara, J., & Laidlaw, L. (2011). Living in the iworld: Two literacy researchers reflect on the changing texts and literacy practices of childhood. English Teacher: Practice and Critique, 10(4), 149-159. doi: Government of Alberta. School Technology Sector, Alberta Education. (2011

New Historicism

1604 words - 6 pages heroine who is seduced by the son of her employer and who thus is not considered pure and chaste women by the rest of the society. This novel form a new definition of women virtue, this novel came as a sign of resistance against many social and religious behaviors, including struggles of religious belief. The novel also reflects Hardy's preoccupation with social class that in the time when the novel is written there was calashes between classes where

The Death of the Author

2259 words - 9 pages The concept of ‘the Death of the Author’ was proposed by, French philosopher and literary theorist, Roland Barthes in his essay with the same title. He proposed a paradigm shift in the way that authorship should be viewed by the ‘Critic’. In opposition to the classical model of critique, Barthes proposed that the focus should be on the readers experience and interpretation; he proposed the idea of ‘readerly’ and ‘writerly’ texts. Rather than

The Life and Work of Mary Crawford: A Feminist Psychologist

1489 words - 6 pages PhD from the University of Delaware in 1975 (Crawford 2001). While in pursuit of her Ph. D.; Crawford was collecting data for her dissertation and would have her first opportunity to change psychology. The overseeing professor of the lab that she worked in decided only certain graduate students would have access to the animals (Crawford 2001). It just so happened that all other male graduate students were given access, however, she was the only one

Karl Marx

2443 words - 10 pages . Even for those who do not agree with Marx on his prescription for the world, his determination to improve the conditions of the oppressed is a model we should all strive to emulate. “To Make the World Philosophical”, provides excerpts from Marx's doctoral dissertation and his preparatory materials. “For a Ruthless Criticism of Everything Existing”, is a letter published in Deutsch-Französische Jahrbücher in 1849. It suggests the notion

grad school essay

1182 words - 5 pages I have often been asked by architecture students and professionals visiting Chandigarh on how it feels having grown up and educated from this city - a single stroke, paradigm shifting undertaking by the father of modernism himself. I reply with an inherently paradoxical answer. While on one hand it has served as a major source of my exposure towards architecture and urbanism, alongside shaping my perception and critique of urbanity, it has also

Equilibrium and Econometrics

976 words - 4 pages , Gerson P. (1995). Cartels, Cooperation and Rivalry. XXIII Annual Meeting of the Brazilian National Association of Post-graduate Courses in Economics, December. LIMA, Gerson P. (1992). “Une Analyse Critique des Fondements Théoriques et Empiriques de la Courbe d’Offre”. PhD dissertation, University of Paris X. MARSHALL, Alfred (1890). Principles of Economics

Finding identity and Appropriation Art

1032 words - 5 pages show a translation of cultures, a clash of east and west such as the symbolic artefacts of a globalism. The old Japanese culture and Western (American) consumerism discorded creating a bold, erotic and entertaining art works that combined reality with unreality, wit with critique and past with the present. B3 – YASUMASA MORIMURA Feminism, Finding identification, Gender identity Consumerism 1. Influence of appropriation by the post-modernist

How To Write A Book Report

759 words - 3 pages to see. However, she disagrees with his choice of case study. All in all, Rosen finds Intintoli's book most useful for novices, but not one that advances our ability to critique soap operas very much.Taking Soaps Seriously: The World of Guiding Light. Michael Intintoli. New York: Praeger, 1984. 248 pp.Ever since the U.S. public began listening to radio soaps in the 1930s, cultural critics have explored the content, form, and popularity of daytime

The "New Woman" in Cecil B. DeMille's "The Cheat"

2095 words - 8 pages notion of the `new women' to critique society in the era. While the film does not deny Edith the freedom that had come to be associated with the idea, it elucidates "[o]ne of the dangers of the modern urban culture [namely] the disappearance of traditional methods of knowing social status and presumed moralities associated with that status", a hazard which "meant [women's] decreased privatisation at the cost of their increased commodification

Similar Essays

Analyse The Poetry Of Thomas Hardy

2352 words - 9 pages rather than an event that "When I set out for Lyonnesse" becomes a universal love poem to all and for all that have ever loved or have hoped to love. While much of Hardy's work focus upon the irrationality of war, the transience of life and the destructive progress of time, "When I set out for Lyonnesse" is different in many respects, depicting great personal happiness, fulfilment and love, a transforming and memorable moment in the poets life, a

An Investigation Into The Usefulness Of Twitter For Enhancing Delegate Experience

1652 words - 7 pages , whilst there are a growing number of events utilising and employing its own social media use, along with comprehensive academic background discussing the subject, this dissertation has identified a lack of knowledge within literature and in application where conferences and the social media channel Twitter are concerned. Created in 2006, Twitter is essentially a communication tool that allows users to post and read each other’s messages

The Doctoral Journey: Benchmarks Of The Doctoral In Education Journey

941 words - 4 pages needs to foster the environment where education issues are examined and discussed with critical and analytical focus. Also important is that directional feedback from the instructor/facilitator is given to help the discussion and the students recognize points that may otherwise be missed. The courses must provide the core study that will be needed for the doctoral students to begin to choose and study the topic of their dissertation, and provide

Reflections Of Peace And Nationalism In Sri Lankan Literature

885 words - 4 pages nature of extrajudicial killings in the island. The critique leads to several questions: To what extent did postcolonial literary studies comfortably accommodate the genre of ‘literature of conflict’ to denote the faithful portrayal of violence and war? What, if any, are the possibilities for what we term ‘literature of conflict’ to point out ways in which peace can be imagined in nations such as Sri Lanka where the ethnic war has become the