This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique Of Hume's Analysis Of Causality

3251 words - 13 pages

Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality

Hume's analyses of human apprehension and of causality were the most penetrating up to his time and continue to have great influence. Contemporary Spanish philosopher Xavier Zubiri (1893-1983) has examined both and identified three underlying errors: (1) the failure to recognize that there are three stages of human intellection, and especially that the first, primordial apprehension, has quite unique characteristics; (2) the attempt to place an excessive burden on the content of impressions while ignoring what Zubiri terms their 'formality of reality'; and (3) the failure to recognize that functionality, not causality, is the basis for most of our knowledge. Causal chains in general cannot be adequately known, and therefore are not and cannot be the basis of our knowledge of the external world. Only in the area of persons and morality does causality play a critical role.

I. Introduction

Causality has been a pivotal concept in the history of philosophy since the time of the Ancient Greeks. After David Hume, however, many have questioned whether there is (or can be) any metaphysical meaning of causality, or valid inferences based upon it. Xavier Zubiri (1898-1983) has rethought and reformulated the question of causality in light of its historical roles, well-known criticisms, and relevant contemporary knowledge. In doing so, he has achieved a unique perspective on the subject which should be of great interest to those concerned with causality and any of its applications.

II. Hume's critique of causality

The figure of David Hume looms large in the philosophical tradition of English-speaking countries; and his two famous analyses, of human apprehension and of causality, were the most penetrating up to his time, and continue to have great influence. As the culmination of British empiricism, Hume's work is especially important because he realized the importance of analyzing human apprehension both as a step in the development of a comprehensive philosophy, and in connection with the problem of causality. This task Hume undertook in his Treatise of Human Nature, Book I. In Part IV, he is concerned to establish a reason or explanation for our belief in the independent and continuing existence of external things or 'bodies', for upon this all causal reasoning about such things must ultimately rest. As is well known, Hume argues that such belief must either come from the senses, reason, or what he terms 'imagination'; and he dismisses the first two, leaving only the last, where he attributes the belief to coherence and constancy of impressions. (1)

For the present study, details of Hume's argument are not as important as his basic assumptions. One of those assumptions, never explicitly stated but always lurking just beneath the surface, is that all reasoning and understanding of the external world comes from the mind working on the content of sensible impressions, be they pains, pleasures, colors,...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality

David Hume's Of the Standard of Taste

646 words - 3 pages that of the objectivists, who would argue that the quality of art can be measured by a set of principles, that there is a universal standard outside of individual taste that can be used to measure the quality of art and to make an unbiased critique on a piece of artwork. This paper aims to unite objectivism and subjectivism in aesthetic judgments through the ideas presented in the essay “Of the Standard of Taste” by 18th century philosopher David

Phantom Limb Phenomenon: The Effects of Unattributed Causality

2460 words - 10 pages , especially, PLP occurs (Nicolelis, 2008). While normal sensations of touch and pain are known to stem from the somatosensory system, phantom limb sensation and pain are not as obvious in their origin and remain largely illusive and debated by researchers. As a result of this unattributed causality, it can be argued that subsequent research and understanding of when amputation phantom sensations or pains appear, the prevalence of this occurrence

Critique of Post-Modern Philosophy and Analysis

1374 words - 5 pages PAGE PAGE 8 CRITIQUE OF A POSTMODERN PHILOSOPHY AbstractIn this paper I am going to explore how useful psychoanalysis when viewed from the feminist theory. As women experience the social world differently, there exists different feminist point of view within the feminist tradition. This is what brings us to look at Freud's (1977) work, the founder of 'psychoanalysis' and to look at the criticisms that have been made of his work, and I also

Analysis and Critique of Brave New World

911 words - 4 pages Analysis and Critique of Brave New World The novel opens in the Central London Hatchery and Conditioning Centre, in the years A.F., or After Ford. Ford is the God-surrogate, a corruption of the name Freud, the controversial psychosexual psychologist. The Director of Hatcheries and Conditioning is leading a tour group of young students around a lab. He explains the scientific process by which human beings are fertilized and custom-made

David Hume's Argument Against Belief in the Existence of Miracles

2170 words - 9 pages argues that it is impossible to deduce the existence of a deity from the existence of the world, and that causes cannot be determined from effects. One of the most important aspects of Hume's argument is his understanding of probability. Hume states that belief is often a result of probability in that we believe an event that has occurred most often as being most likely. In relation to miracles this suggests that miraculous events should be

Hume's Conflict between Causal Reasoning and Existence of External Objects

1199 words - 5 pages Hume Conflict between Causal Reasoning and Existence of External Objects In this essay I will be discussing a very important conflict that Hume reflects in the conclusion of Book I, A Treatise of Human Nature. The thesis of this essay is to analyze the "conflict" between causal reasoning and the continued existence of external objects. Now, to be more specific I should say that I am inclining on Hume's side about the conflict being real

Analysis of Kant´s the Critique of Practical Reason

2828 words - 12 pages , the rational genius, who made the knowledge and the mind to exist on the level of the God. Kant, the creator of the first scientific model of the creation of the stars and planets came to the position of limits of practicality morality. «The Critique of Practical Reason» is the second after «Critique of Pure Reason» work of Kant. In it he describes the «practical activity» contrasted to the prudent practicity. The philosophers of Modern Times

Culture of Critique

927 words - 4 pages , if Deborah Tannen of the New York Times is correct, our understanding of what it means to argue may be very different from what it once was; a “culture of critique” has developed within our media, and it relies on the exclusive opposition of two conflicting positions (Tannen). In her 1994 editorial, titled “The Triumph of the Yell”, Tannen claims that journalists, politicians and academics treat public discourse as an argument. Furthermore, she

Critique of Rescuing Policy

1373 words - 6 pages idealistic. Furthermore, his depiction of a future where both the government and the public hold ownership and responsibility for issues and for solving them doesn’t follow along with current trends. Decreasing voter turnout, lack of government engagement directed towards the public, and a lack of public trust and responsibility all point towards a future without inter-collaboration and communication. Therefore, although this critique agrees with Lenihan’s analysis of the present, based on evidence from current realities, it also questions the plausibility of Lenihan’s future taking shape.

Critique of Female Circumcision

804 words - 3 pages Critique of Female CircumcisionIn this infinitely diverse world filled with a myriad of equally distinct cultures, it is often difficult to understand things that are unfamiliar to us. Furthermore, our point of view is skewed by the context of our own surroundings making it difficult of view other cultures objectively. Those who practice female circumcision view it as sacred, while others outside are quick to pass judgment on excision and call

The Problem of Evil in Hume's Dialouges on Natural Religion and "Candide"

1398 words - 6 pages sufficient to understand evil within a creation of a good God. Voltaire leaves the problem without any concrete solution, but being a Deist, he doesn't go as far as Hume in using it to undermine the divinity. The consequence of Hume's argument is that because the attributes of God are incomprehensible, we cannot use reason to deduce anything about Him or his moral nature. Without knowing that, the idea of God does not signify very much. Voltaire would

Similar Essays

David Hume's Critique Of The Belief In Miracles

1721 words - 7 pages In explaining Hume's critique of the belief in miracles,we must first understand the definition of a miracle. TheWebster Dictionary defines a miracle as: a supernatural eventregarded as to define action, one of the acts worked by Christwhich revealed his divinity an extremely remarkableachievement or event, an unexpected piece of luck. Therefore,a miracle is based on one's perception of past experiences,what everyone sees. It is based on a

An Analysis Of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

4432 words - 18 pages An Analysis of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion ABSTRACT: Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779) may be read in the way Cleanthes (and Philo as well) reads Nature, as analogous to human artifice and contrivance. The Dialogues and Nature then are both texts, with an intelligent author or Author, and analogies may be started from these five facts of Hume's text: the independence of Hume's characters; the non

David Hume's Theory Of Knowledge Essay

842 words - 3 pages to distinguish between feelings and thoughts. Feelings are only impressions made upon the body, and thoughts arrive from impressions; for nothing can be thought that has not been experienced. The meaning of ideas is more important than their truth. Belief results from ideas and assumptions, which are recollected from previous knowledge. Hume’s analysis of causal relation is that everything that happens beyond what is available to memory rests

The Causality And Development Of Bulimia

1054 words - 4 pages There are several different theories about the causality and development of bulimia. Bulimia may have a genetic and hereditary component aswell as a socio-environmental component. Other psychological factors involved include mood disorders and substance abuse in families of people with bulimia. One aspect of the biological perspective suggests that people with bulimia have a low serotonin level which is a brain