Critique Of Infant Determinism Essay

813 words - 3 pages

Critique of Infant Determinism


Do experiences during early years solely determine later development? In the second chapter of his book "Three Seductive Ideas" (1998), Kagan questions the overemphasis on the first two years of an individual's life. While not doubting its importance, Kagan suggests that perhaps more crucial to human development is the construction of experience, perception, and comparison of ourselves to others which begins during the fifth or sixth year of life. His argument is a valid one, regarding the fact that infant determinism overrates the importance of first two years in a person’s whole lifetime. As Kagan argues, infant determinism is rather a political theory that conceals the effect of social class on development (Kagan, 1998, p.89).
People who advocate infant determinism says that interactive play and secure attachment between a mother and a baby during the very early years are what lead to well-being in adulthood (Waters and Cummings, 2000, p.164). By assuming that the first two years determine the rest of the development, infant determinism blocks the possibility of society being the major influence on human development. It puts less emphasis on the impact of social interactions that a person goes through for his or her lifetime. However, human is a social animal: how can the first two years, such a mere amount of time for any perceptive socialization, be accounted for the rest of the life? Kagan argues it is not until five to seven years old when a child starts to learn some social responsibilities (Kagan, 1998, p.109). Moreover, our brain and mind are not a closed system: Kagan says, “the brain is still growing for the first two years of life” (Kagan, 1998, p.115). It is influenced constantly by various outside factors and is shaped gradually. Therefore it is the interpretation of on-going experiences that affects the development. By interpretation it means learning about social environment, broadening perception toward the world and recognizing one’s identity, which all will greatly influence the development. According to Kagan, children begin to interpret their experiences in the third or fourth years (Kagan, 1998, p.113). From that time the memories are likely to last: experiences in the first two years are hardly recallable in adulthood (Kagan, 1998, p.115).
Yet the reason that infant determinism is popular is because it covers up the problems that come from social class membership (Kagan, 1998, p.147). Kagan points out, “Those who favor...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Infant Determinism

Discuss the way in which power relations are rooted in the whole social - Philosophy, politics and ethics - essay

1606 words - 7 pages , impacts upon everything and is within everything. Whereas, for Marx, he uses material determinism to map out history how power is related to the social. Material determinism is, ?the theory that all cultural and social movements and ideas are brought about by changes in economic and other material conditions.?[footnoteRef:4] This can be seen in Marx?s The Communist Manifesto, ??historical relations that rise and disappear in the progress of

Religion and War Essay

1620 words - 6 pages the thought of Vonnegut towards no responsibility and suggest that Paul Lazzaro is justified for killing Pilgrim based on determinism. If it was pre-destined for Lazzaro to take revenge on Pilgrim, then it is not his fault for Pilgrim's death (Chabot 211). As far as the Tralfamadorians feelings towards free will and determinism, they told Pilgrim they can not prevent any wars including their own wars on Tralfamadore. The Tralfamadorians can not

Summary of Immanuel Kant's Life

1463 words - 6 pages significance. During the last twenty-five years of his life, however, Kant left a mark on the history of philosophy that is rivaled only by such towering giants as Plato and Aristotle. Kant's three major works are often considered to be the starting points for different branches of modern philosophy: the Critique of Pure Reason (1781) for the philosophy of mind; the Critique of Practical Reason (1788) for moral philosophy; and the

Behaviorism - A Methodological Proposal of Explaining the Behavior

3364 words - 13 pages (determinism). We know man as an autonomous being (one whose choices are the result of decisions made, on our part, freely). The person is then responsible. If the actions are beneficial then the individual is entitled to credit. If the result of the actions are harmful, then the individual is should be justifiably blamed. person --> determined choices --> actions --> responsible --> praised or blamed This is a myth and the

Critical Theory of Technology

1089 words - 5 pages see this latter argument—arguing for a “return to nature”—as utterly impractical given the depths to which said technologies have embedded themselves within modern society, but he takes issue with the notion that technology could be inherently imbued with any one value, bias, etc. This critique of technological criticism speaks to a distinction that Feenberg sees between instrumental and substantive theories of technology. Feenberg outlines these

The Wrapped Golf Ball: A Marxist Literary Criticism

1256 words - 5 pages veritable upper-class man, thus the idea of determinism in the Marxist theory. The divergence of Dexter’s inner and outside attributes leads him to face the conflict of identity and the deception of his dream. Dexter thinks that he belongs to high society and matches Judy’s social-economical status. However, their relationship is insane since what Judy actually needs is not materialistic satisfaction, but rather the care from a man who cherishes her

Race and Its Importance to Contemporary Sociey

1156 words - 5 pages comments (overheard, deliberate, taunts, jokes, intimidating comments and threats) “I just got called “Black slut” . It also included Behavioural racism (ignoring, patronizing and segregation), Harassment and assault, denial of identity and Macro-Level Racism (lack of concern and cultural dominance). Furthermore the report concluded that the aboriginal population suffered from poor levels of health with high rates of infant mortality, diabetes

Comparison of the Three Major Sociological Theories

1817 words - 7 pages . The realisticslant of positivism is also known as determinism. The positivist knows that a reality is'out there' to be defined and categorized. The hard sciences from the time of Newtonand Decartes have traditionally relied on the positivistic approach. The positivist hopes tobe able to approximate 'reality' in a detailed generalization or theory on how realityoperates. The theories of a positivist generally take the form of cause and effect

Humanism & Shakespeare

828 words - 3 pages and recognized around this same time. Richard Mallette states that in writing Hamlet, Shakespeare concentrates on Hamlet's irresolvable internal debate between salvation and his conscience, the work figuratively interrogates the Calvinist belief in providential determinism - that the faithful will be saved and all others will be condemned to hell. Patrick Grant states that the Shakespeare tragedies embody an exhaustive end-phase of Renaissance

Why the law of damages is more favourable to commercial interests than personal interests

4293 words - 17 pages arguments that are derived from within a particular framework of perception and are literally incapable of being challenged from any external framework of perception. This paper will attempt to provide a critique of the law of remedies that will transcend the particularity of specific disciplines by arguing that damages for personal injury and death are indefensibly favourable to commercial interests, both from an economic point of view and a

The Evolution of Speed Through Technology

1640 words - 7 pages The Evolution of Speed Through Technology Virilio and Gleick use speed as an analytic tool/concept to understand post-contemporary society. Both authors trace the evolution of speed through technology. However, Virilio sees the evolution of speed through war and Gleick analyses speed through the evolution of "time". Virilio?s technological military determinism in ?Speed and

Similar Essays

Free Will And Determinism Essay

679 words - 3 pages that we do have free wills. Neither one of these theories can be proven to be true with absolute certainty. They both try to however to critique each other's theory.First, hard determinists argument goes something like this. Every event (or state of affairs) must have a cause. Human actions (as well as the agent who gives rise to those actions) are events. Therefore, every human action (including the agent himself) is caused. Hence determinism

William Blake, Innocence Vs. Experience Essay

897 words - 4 pages in two series of texts, Song of Innocence and Songs of Experience. Thus, the difference between these two series of texts was that Song of Experience explored more of the dark side of society; however, Songs of Innocence explored more of the innocent side of human society. Both of these texts were a critique of human society. In the texts The Lamb, The Tyger, The Chimney Sweeper, and Infant Sorrow critique society with innocence and experience

Baron D'holbach And William James On Free Will And Determinism

1645 words - 7 pages Baron d'Holbach and William James on Free Will and Determinism 3. Discuss the issue between Baron d'Holbach and William James on free will and determinism? Before we can discuss the issue between Baron d'Holbach and William James we have to know the definitions of the items the issue is about. Free will according to the Encarta encyclopedia is "The power or ability of the human mind to choose a course of action or make a decision

Should We Doubt The Concept Of Free Will?

1607 words - 7 pages acting under free will. Another argument against the concept of free will deals with the school of thought labeled determinism. The concept is simple enough to understand. According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, “Determinism, in philosophy, is theory that all events, including moral choices, are completely determined by previously existing causes.” Basically, people who believe in determinism have the world view that all prior events and