This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique Of Johnson’s Quantitative Research Article

4118 words - 16 pages

An article called “The Use of Music to Promote Sleep in Older Women” was published in the twentieth volume of the Journal of Community Health Nursing in 2003. It was written by Julie E. Johnson, who is the dean and a professor for the College of Nursing at Kent State University in Ohio. She is a registered nurse who holds a PhD and is a member of the FAAN. Being a member of the FAAN suggests that she has contributed to the field of nursing in a positive way. Johnson’s article attempts to find out whether listening to music at bedtime positively affects the sleeping habits of older women suffering from insomnia. She tested this by observing fifty-two older women for twenty nights in total; ten nights to establish a baseline and ten nights to see how music affected the women. There didn’t seem to be any conflict of interest in the study, mainly because Johnson worked for a school and no company was benefiting from her research conclusions. She was not trying to promote the use of any specific tool to help sleep, like someone working for a drug company might do. Johnson publishing the article in a community nursing journal seems appropriate because many community nursing patients are older adults. The following essay will be a critique of the quality of Johnson’s research process in her study of whether music promotes sleep in older women.

The title of the article, “The Use of Music to Promote Sleep in Older Women”, is clearly stated at the top of the first page of the article. Although it gives the reader some information about the article, it is not very specific about the variables involved or the population of the study. For example, one would have to read to the end of the second page of the article before finding out that participants could choose their own music. The title would not necessarily have to list every genre of music chosen, but just stating, “The Use of Client Chosen Music…” would be a little more specific. Also, the population is simply called “older women” in the title. After reading the article, one would know that the population of the study was actually women over 70 who suffered from chronic insomnia. If the article could be renamed, “The Use of Client Chosen Music to Promote Sleep in Women Over 70 Suffering from Chronic Insomnia”, it would provide the reader with much more information at first glance. Regardless of the specificity of the title, the topic remains relevant to nursing because many patients a nurse typically sees fall into this age category. It is not uncommon for older adults to have sleeping difficulties, which, if not treated, could end up triggering physical problems or even alter mental status. If a nurse could intervene with simple teachings to promote sleep, they could provide an easy and inexpensive solution to their patients sleep problems.

Like the title of the article, the abstract is also fairly vague. It just barely makes it for the appropriate length...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Johnson’s Quantitative Research Article

Nursing Article Critique: A Quantitative Analysis

1245 words - 5 pages the article important or significant for the practice of health care? Yes  No N.B.: Despite the absence of a statistically significant correlation between agitation behaviours in dementia patients and olfactory aromatherapy intervention, the study supports further research in cutaneous absorption methodology. Do the findings resonate (seem correct and familiar) with you and your practice? Yes  No • If yes, why

Quantitative Research Critique Essay

644 words - 3 pages Introduction The focus of the article by Spurlock and Hunt (2008) was on an empirical study researching whether the HESI Exit Exam possesses any usefulness in predicting pass-rates on the National Council Licensure Examination for registered nurses. The authors identify the variables of the study as HESI Exit Exam scores and NCLEX-RN outcomes, emphasizing the relationship between the variables as being previously determined by research

Quantitative Research Article Review

1997 words - 8 pages Quantitative Research Article Review The quantitative research article that I chose to review was a study completed by Dougherty and Thompson (2009), found in Research in Nursing & Health. Very few researchers have focused their study on the impact of cardiac arrest and ICD implantation on a patient’s intimate partner. What little is known about caregiving responsibilities and caregiver burden after a cardiac illness or event has previously

Nursing Research Article Critique

993 words - 4 pages disproving previous beliefs or confirming newly found data and methods. Moreover, research in itself contains its own process with a methodological approach. Of the notable methods, quantitative research is often used for its systemic approach (Polit & Beck, 2006). Thus, the use of the scientific method is used, which also utilizes the use of numerical data (Polit & Beck). Here, researches make use of creating surveys, scales, or placing a numerical

Research Article Critique

870 words - 4 pages In the article, Patterns of Hospital Resource Utilization of Children with Leukemia and CNS tumors: A Comparasion of Children Who Survive and Those Who Die Within 3 Years of Diagnosis, Hendrickson, Rimar (2009) a quantitative analysis was used to identify if there was a financial correlation between children with Leukemia and CNS tumors during 3 years after treatment, and a financial correlation between the children who lived and the children

Nursing Research Article Critique

1678 words - 7 pages action in providing appropriate interventions to decrease the risk of nurses that can develop eating disorders (King et al.). In addition, they also suggest that management should be mindful of the stress that can ensue during a shift. Evaluation of the Use of the Scientific Method Keith A. King and colleagues makes use of developing a quantitative study, thus utilizing the scientific method, by doing so allows them approach their research

Qualitative Research Article Critique

1435 words - 6 pages Qualitative research is "the investigation of phenomena, typically in an in-depth and holistic fashion, through the collection of rich narrative materials using a flexible research design" (Polit, Beck, and Hungler, 2001, p 469). Qualitative researchers focus on the descriptions and deeper meaning associated with the data collected. Another way to define qualitative research is to describe it as a type of research that involves interpreting non

Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages , group 3, and group 4, meaning that the result obtained by group 2 (Direct CF + W) was not significantly different from the control group. Critique of the method There are several points worth discussing in this article. The first and the most important one is the integration of the ‘mini lesson’ in the treatment given to group 1. As the researcher had explained, this mini lesson comprised of explaining “the rules and examples that the students

Critique of article

598 words - 3 pages This article is a literature review of how conceptual and empirical studies have furthered the understanding of the processes of improving parental involvement based model proposed by Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler. The Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler model focused on the construct of parental motivation for involvement. It included: (1) active role construction for involvement and positive self efficacy, (2) perception of invitations for involvement

The Nature of Quantitative Research

1332 words - 5 pages The Nature of Quantitative Research Quantitative Research Defined: According to Huysamen (1997), "descriptions of quantitative research typically discern a cycle of successive phases of hypothesis formulation, data collection, analysis and interpretation." Using a deductive approach, quantitative research seeks to establish facts, make predictions, and test hypotheses that have already been stated. A large part of the data analysis of

Critique of Term Paper Article

856 words - 4 pages Becker, Margraf, Rinck, and Roth wrote one of the articles that I found, the emotional Stroop effect in anxiety disorders: General emotionality or disorder specificity? The main idea of the research study is to understand cognitive attention predispositions by demonstrating Stroop task with anxiety participants. Stroop task were repeatedly uses on patients that have anxiety or other disorders such as panic, obsessive-compulsive, social phobia

Similar Essays

Critique Of Quantitative Research Article Essay

790 words - 4 pages Dr. Karrie Hendrickson published an article in 2009 analyzing patterns of hospital resource utilization of children with leukemia and CNS tumors. Dr. Hendrickson used quantitative research as her means of analysis. In her article, Dr. Hendrickson specifies the population as children ages 0 to 19 years diagnosed with cancer at a large north-eastern hospital between fiscal years 2000 and 2004. Specifically, she focused on children diagnosed with

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

1627 words - 7 pages Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention

Quantitative Study Article Critique Essay

1436 words - 6 pages Quantitative Study Article Critique This paper is a critique of an article written by McKinney and Jones (1993) entitled: “Effects of a Children’s Book and a Traditional Textbook on Fifth-grade Students’ Achievement and Attitudes toward Social Studies”. In their research the authors examined the effects of a children’s book and a traditional social studies textbook on knowledge acquisition and attitudes toward social studies and the textbook in

Quantitative Article Critique Essay

981 words - 4 pages The purpose of the article I reviewed by Lykeridou, Gourounti, Deltsidou, Lautradis, and& Vaslamatzis (2009) was to examine women’s level of depression, perceived anxiety, and overall stress related to infertility while receiving fertility treatments. It w as hypothesized that the etiology of an infertility diagnoses wouldwill affect female’s psychological vulnerability. The variables that were looked at in the study were infertility diagnoses