Critique Of “On Classrooms, With And Without Computers”

807 words - 3 pages

In the article "On Classrooms, With and Without Computers," Clifford Stoll argues that having computers in classrooms may be detrimental to a students ability to learn and that only a live teacher can inspire children to learn. Stoll's purpose in writing this article is to persuade his readers that computers in classrooms should not be allowed. By providing relevant real world examples and using a reader-oriented style of writing, Stoll is able to present a convincing essay to the reader about why computers in classrooms may hinder a child's learning. Stoll begins his article by asking himself, "What's wrong with this picture"(259). After he asks himself this question, he explains to the readers "only a live teacher in the classroom can bring about the inspiration of learning"(259). Stoll believes people will buy into the hype that computers are the best way to learn in the classroom. He wants people to realize that many students who do not have a live teacher in the classroom are not very successful in learning. He also believes that by using computers, children will lose the chance of actually experiencing what they are taught. Stoll advises these students that the best way to learn about something is to actually experience it on their own and that computers can never let a person have that live experience. Even though computers can link students from different countries, Stoll believes that these students may be using these computers to talk about topics that are not relevant to what they are studying.Throughout Stoll's essay, he provides many real-world examples of how computers have hindered a child's learning capability. In one such example, Stoll points out "Professor Domoto's classes began with twenty-six students. By year's end, over half had failed or dropped out"(260). This class never actually met their teacher in person. So, if the students needed help learning how to "use the correct writing posture, or the way to hold a brush-pen or chopsticks"(260) the professor had no way of actually helping the student in person. It is very difficult to learn a certain subject if a student does not have a person to help them. All the computer can do is spit out a correct answer but cannot help the student logically get the answer. Therefore the student will know the answer but will not have the ability understand how he/she got the correct answer. Stoll...

Find Another Essay On Critique Of “On Classrooms, With And Without Computers”

With and without the state in

1793 words - 7 pages world does not provide resolutions their desolate existence and to help alleviate the conditions of daily life.The distance between the state, the outer world and the people, the inner world, creates an ignorance that the state refuses to attend. It is widely known the two factors for the makeup of a civilization lies in the people and the state or the state and its people. Without one or the other to depend on, reliance hinders stability. The

The Impact of Computers on Society Today

749 words - 3 pages Computers have made such an enormous impact on our society today. There isn't a place where you can turn where there isn't a computer involved. In the present time, most businesses rely on computers and it's similar technology. This field of technology has been so advanced within the past few years that it has been the primary tool in successful businesses. Not only does it make daily annoying tasks easy with a click of a button, it also makes

Comparative Study of SAR from Mobile Phones With and Without Headset

1114 words - 4 pages mobile phone and study has been done under various situations. Further work is being done on the measurement of SAR when mobile phones are used with headset and without headset. Index Terms— Radiation, Base station, SAR, Antenna, Radiated Power, Conical Log Spiral Antenna I. INTRODUCTION Cell phone technology has revolutionized the telecommunication scenario in India. Due to its several advantages, cell phone technology has grown

Effect of computers on human society

756 words - 4 pages usages of computers have really caused lack of social confidence. Before the popularity of personal computers, children and adults would maintain their regular interactions, rather than being dependent on computers. Interacting with others is an important thing; this involves in the exchange of different ideas from different people, and helps to maintain social confidence. Professor Lee Cheng Ean of School of communication, Taylor’s University

Politics of and Without Difference

1471 words - 6 pages Politics of and Without Difference The sociological concepts of "Politics of Difference" and "Politics Without Difference" are more similar than their names suggest, but they are at the same time extremely different. Both political ideals come from progressive civil rights principles beginning during the Enlightenment in Europe and evolving throughout The Civil Rights Movement in the United States in the 60's. The fundamental basis of the two

Advertisement critique with description and analysis.

931 words - 4 pages letters emblazoned with a mix of mirror-image and haze seem make the words appear as if they are just about to reach out and grab you.The photograph of the woman's mouth on the top left corner of the page says to me that that this advertisement is directed towards young and middle-age adults. The face of a woman signifies feelings of youthfulness, freshness, and innocence. There is also a blatant hint of sexuality in the photograph with the woman

The Evolution and Applications of Quantum Computers

1335 words - 5 pages they will carry even smaller parts and eventually get to a point where logic gates are so minute that they are built out of a handful of atoms. On the atomic level matter adheres to the rules of quantum mechanics, which are different from the conventional rules that govern the properties of orthodox logic gates. So if computers are built smaller in the future, quantum technology must act as a substitute for or enhance what we have now. Quantum

The History and Future of Computers

976 words - 4 pages and some universities; this was because of their immense size and price. Today with falling computer prices and the opportunity to access larger networks, the amount of computers has grown from just 10% in 1986 to 25% in 1994. Also, of the 25%, 34% of them were equipped with modems, which allow for connection to on line services via telephone lines.The primitive start of the computer came about around 4000 BC; with the invention of the abacus, by

The History And Development Of Computers

2250 words - 9 pages , scientists fit even more on that chip, reducing the size of the computer even more. Also, an operating system was added to computers, which allowed the machines to run more than one program at the same time, with a central program that "monitored and coordinated the computer's memory." (Jones, 6) Although computers were faster and could store more data than ever before, they still were extremely difficult to program. In 1951, mathematician Grace Hopper

Past, Present, and Future of computers

1749 words - 7 pages itself and is the most integral part of the CPU in modern computers. It is a single chip which allows all that happens on a computer. Integrated circuits, a microchip which is layered with it's own circuitry, also provide a much more manageable memory source. The only reason magnetic tape backups are used today is because of the space which is needed in order to backup an entire computer. Memory for todays computers consist of RAM or ROM. ROM is

Hip Rotation Range of Motion in People with and Without Low Back Pain Who Participate in Rotation-Related Sports

2786 words - 11 pages studies of hip rotation and LBP, the measurement of interest has been either active or passive end range hip rotation with and without low back pain. The results from the reports shows active hip rotation motion and low back pain mixed. In past research work authors found that women with low back pain had limitation of active hip lateral rotation than women without low back ache. Research on passive hip rotation motion and LBP reported no differences

Similar Essays

The Potential Impacts Of Upcoming High Stakes Testing On The Teaching Of Science In Elementary Classrooms Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages using a questionnaire that was designed by the researchers. The procedures used to create this instrument were not included in the study. However, it was noted that time was a factor that prevented piloting and validation of the questionnaire. Details of the instrument included that it was a three-part instrument with 16 questions. Part I asked for demographic information and part II was designed to collect data on frequency and methods of

The Problem Of Using Touch Screen Devices In Classrooms Instead Of Computers

1358 words - 6 pages Introduction This literature review project examines research studies related to the problem of replacing computer in K12 education with touch screen devices. The project involves studies that show different results on engagement of the students in using different technologies. Theory/ Rationale Although there is not yet much empirical data on the relative benefits of touchscreen computers compared to desktop and laptop models, “learning

Observation Of Preschool And Elementary Classrooms

1735 words - 7 pages beings, who are shaped by the culture around them. Vygotsky believed that children were shaped by their interactions with others, skills learned from others, the artifacts that children interact with, and the values of the larger society that they belong to. Vygotsky stressed continuous, quantitative changes and largely focused on the relationship between language and thought. He believed that there were three stages of internalized speech. In the

On The Development Of Quantum Computers And Cryptography

1526 words - 7 pages On the Development of Quantum Computers and Cryptography In 2010, the United States government, after accessing encrypted files by means of physical intervention, exposed ten Russian sleeper agents; in 2013, the United States government, without any means of physical intervention, surreptitiously collected and promptly decrypted many previously encrypted (Wood). Within this decade, concerns regarding the dubious security of