This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique Of Christmas Time In Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol

2830 words - 11 pages

Critique of Christmas Time in Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol

An audience member's gleeful first-hand account of Charles Dickens's public reading of "A Christmas Carol" unwittingly exposes an often overlooked contradiction in the story's climax: "Finally, there is Scrooge, no longer a miser, but a human being, screaming at the 'conversational' boy in Sunday clothes, to buy him the prize turkey 'that never could have stood upon his legs, that bird'" (96). Perhaps he is no longer a miser but, by this description, Scrooge still plays the role of a capitalist oppressor, commanding underlings to fetch him luxuries. While Dickens undoubtedly lauds Scrooge's epiphany and ensuing change, "A Christmas Carol" also hints at the author's resentment for an industrial society's corrupted notion of the "Christmas spirit."
Through instances of goodwill which Christmas provokes, Dickens suggests that Christmas is only an interruptive exception from the otherwise capitalistic calendar. Even when Scrooge becomes altruistic, as in the above scene, his philanthropy still operates under the guise of capitalism, measured in economic terms and aimed ultimately at providing himself with pleasure.

Dickens subtly turns his critique of ephemeral and selfish "holiday time" to the reader. The straightforward, Aristotelian structure of the narrative and the constant foreshadowing and repetition reduce any potential anxiety about the story's outcome. The main cause for anxiety over the conclusion of any sentimental tale is to identify with the protagonist in some way. Although Scrooge is a caricature with whom few would commiserate (or admit to so doing), Dickens's Three Spirits lure us into sympathy with the miser while simultaneously engendering empathy in him. But the production of Scrooge's humanity is just that, a manufactured, nearly focus-group mode of voyeurism that attacks Scrooge at his most vulnerable and solipsistic‹either forcing upon him visions of his harm to others or, more saliently, of his own past and future selves at their lowest. For Dickens, the altruism Christmas breeds is a false exercise in guilt-reduction, and the pat ending of "A Christmas Carol" reinforces this; the satisfaction of listening to a story whose conclusion is never imperiled (and grows more knowable with each year's retelling) spares the reader the self-examination Scrooge endures that a darker turn might provoke.

Christmas is only a bright spot if the rest of the year is comparatively dark, and Dickens exposes this contrast through Scrooge's nephew's optimistic ruminations on
'Christmas timeŠas a good time: a kind, forgiving, charitable, pleasant time: the only time I know of, in the long calendar of the year, when men and women seem by one consent to open their shut-up hearts freely, and to think of people below them as if they really were fellow-passengers to the grave, and not another race of creatures bound on other journeys.' (8-9)

The nephew's breakdown...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Christmas Time in Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens

1724 words - 7 pages A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens In this essay I intend to write about Ebenezer Scrooge who is the key character of the astonishing novel written by Charles Dickens one of greatest English novelist of he Victorian period. He wrote and published ‘a Christmas carol’ in 1843. Charles Dickens’s also well know stories such as ‘Oliver twist’. Dickens was born on the 2nd February 1812 in London port Hampshire. He moved from his birth

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

1294 words - 5 pages A pill bug is an insect that forms a hard shell around its soft flesh whenever startled or scared. Just like this pill bug, humans guard themselves from anything that hurts them without realizing that they are shutting out the most precious moments of their lives. Ebenezer Scrooge, the main character of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens, is a cold man. He finds what he defines as true happiness in the form of money and wealth. At first he

Redemption in A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

1917 words - 8 pages Redemption in A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens Introduction Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas carol reflecting on the society that he live in the Victoria Era. During the reign of Queen Victoria Britain became one of the most Industrialised countries in European. From Britain Factories, mills, shipyards came products ranging from steam locomotives, to textiles and ship, while coal miners toiled deep below the ground to produce

Scrooge in A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens

1292 words - 5 pages A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens Scrooge is represented from the beginning as a miserable old man being described as a "squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner!" I think this a perfect description of him in one sentence. People know Scrooge well and avoid him, this suites Scrooge because he does not like other people and not a big fan of being sociable. The name 'Scrooge' was

A Christmas Carol Critique

1238 words - 5 pages I saw A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens on Saturday, November 9th 2013, produced by the Trinity Repertory Company at 206 Washington Street in Providence Rhode Island, performed in the Elizabeth and Malcolm Chace Theatre on opening night of the season. Charles Dickens also wrote the famous Oliver Twist and A Tale of Two Cities. When A Christmas Carol was published in 1843, Christmas was just coming into vogue as a popular holiday. The play was

Theme Analysis of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens and the Movie Christmas Cupid

741 words - 3 pages gift baskets. Sloane gets the Vice President position and the guy she should have been with from the beginning. Dickens achieved his goal of conveying the Christmas Spirit in A Christmas Carol. As did director Gil Junger in Christmas Cupid. The theme of the Christmas Spirit will forever be preserved because of A Christmas Carroll and all of it’s adaptations. Works Cited 1. Dickens, Charles. Christmas Stories. New York: Books, Inc. USA 2. Christmas Cupid. Dir. Gil Junger. Perf. Christina Milian, Ashley Benson, Chad Michael Murray, Jackée Harry, Ashley Johnson, and Burgess Jenkins. ABC Family, 2010. TV Movie.

Use of Ghosts to Change Victorian Society in A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

5204 words - 21 pages Use of Ghosts to Change Victorian Society in A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens 'A Christmas Carol' is a novel by Charles Dickens, written in the Victorian era about a man named Ebenezer Scrooge. The book was written to remind people that we should all be kinder and more generous towards one another, and keep the spirit of Christmas all the year, not only in the Christmas season. Scrooge is a representation of most

Scrooge's Transformation in Dickens' A Christmas Carol

2310 words - 9 pages people sing Christmas and Christian songs, so this is meant to be a time where people have fun and are united with family and friends. Ebenezer Scrooge is the major character, the miserly owner of a London counting-house, a nineteenth century term for an accountant's office, in the story, A Christmas Carol written by Charles Dickens. Charles Dickens born February 7th 1812 – 9th June 1870 is a highly remarkable novelist who had a vision to change

Dickens' Use of the Supernatural in A Christmas Carol

3729 words - 15 pages Dickens' Use of the Supernatural in A Christmas Carol A Christmas Carol is built upon numerous contrasts: rich and poor, family and loneliness, generosity and miserliness, affection and cruelty, past, present and future. Most of these contrasting forces are brought to light within the character of Scrooge himself. The compulsive, lonely, miserly man, who eats his abstemious meals in the shadows, emerges from his cold

Dickens' Presentation of Scrooge in A Christmas Carol

3327 words - 13 pages Dickens' Presentation of Scrooge in A Christmas Carol The novel 'A Christmas Carol', by Charles Dickens was written in 1843 and reflects poverty in Victorian times where poverty and ill health was very common. The book was published a week before Christmas and was presented in a small gold and crimson book - the perfect Christmas gift. Dickens wishes to use the character of scrooge to make the reader see that being

"A Christmas Carol" by Dickens

1759 words - 7 pages gathering of people to celebrate the occasion. The dress in the time period seemed to be top hats, slacks, vest, and a coat. From the movie that we watched, the style seemed very formal. When speaking to another person, it was speaking in proper English, never a 'Yo' or a 'Whaz up'. This is because of the time period and the slang we use now had developed with our generation. Although very different, it is very ,much alike. A Christmas Carol was a very good book and a lesson to be learned by all, and in the words of Tiny Tim, 'God Bless Us, every one' (130) !

Similar Essays

Charles Dickens: A Christmas Carol Essay

1835 words - 7 pages Charles Dickens: A Christmas Carol ‘A Christmas Carol’ written by Charles Dickens tells the story of a man named Ebenezer Scrooge who is taught the true meaning of Christmas and is shown the errors of his ways. ‘A Christmas Carol’ was published in 1843, this was a time of social and political unrest. Dickens motivation for writing this story was to encourage employers to treat workers well, he uses the Christmas Carol

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Essay

1174 words - 5 pages In the novel A Christmas Carol, by Charles Dickens, the main character Scrooge encounters many new experiences. These experiences cause him to feel forgotten emotions such as joy, remorse and fear. Scrooge encounters joy throughout the novel in multiple ways. Scrooge acquires joy from the pleasant experiences in his past including memories of his old friends and family. Scrooge also rediscovered his lost emotion of remorse. He begins to realize

Analysis Of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol

3534 words - 14 pages Analysis of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Charles Dickens, one of the greatest novelists in the English language, was born in 1812 into a middle-class family of precarious economic status. His father was a clerk in the Navy Pay Office at the time of Dickens's birth; by the time Charles was ten, however, his father was in debtor's prison, a victim of bad luck, mismanagement, and irresponsibility. In order to help support the

Charles Dickens And A Christmas Carol

764 words - 3 pages Born in 1812 Charles Dickens grew up in a small town in London.   Dickens grew up in a poor family.   His family, sent to debtors∙ jail before he became old enough to fend for himself, convinced him to find work and stay out of the jail.   Dickens worked anywhere, from law offices to newspapers as a young child. (∜New Standard Encyclopedia∝ D-155)   A Christmas Carol, written