This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique On The Nursing Article Critical Care Patients’ Experience Of The Helmet Continuous Positive Airway Pressure

2784 words - 11 pages

This assignment aims to critically analyse a chosen nursing research article “Critical care patients’ experience of the helmet continuous positive airway pressure” by Dimech (2011) and was published in the Journal of Nursing in Critical Care (JNCC). It will examine both the strengths and limitations of the study by weighing various elements of the research undertaken and its value and implication for nursing practice. It will use a critiquing tool by (Ryan, 2007) (see Appendix 1).

Evidence based practice (EBP) is to offer the best care possible to individual patients and use professional judgement to determine nursing care in order to improve patient outcome and even save lives (Moule and Hek, 2011). The Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC, 2008) stipulates that nurses have responsibility to utilise the best available evidence and keep their knowledge up-to-date in order to provide high standard care and practice. In this case, nurses need to be able to critically evaluate ideas and experiences and apply what they have learnt to inform nursing practice (Straus, 2005). Similarly, Walker (2005) suggested that nurses need to consider the dynamic interaction of beliefs and value systems affecting the patient’s experience of healthcare. This is relevant in the case of helmet CPAP.

According to Coughlan et al. (2007) it is necessary to ascertain credibility of a piece of research recognising it’ values to nursing practice. For instance, the main elements that need careful scrutiny and analysis are the method, data collection, data analysis, findings and recommendations. Other indications of how dependable the research article may be include where the journal article was published, where the research took place and the background of the authors. However, Conkin Dale (2005) suggested that such measures should not be taken in isolation to justify credibility of research papers.

This article by Dimech is published in a peer-reviewed journal (JNCC). Which means it is being reviewed by experts in the field. Palatnik (2012) stated that Nursing in Critical Care is a peer review journal that presents the latest practical clinical and professional information in a clear, concise, hands-on approach, which critical care nurses can use in day-to-day practice. Also, the study was undertaken within an acute NHS Foundation Trust which means it is relevant to can be used to improve practice within NHS Trust.

The title of the article is effectively worded to ensure that readers correctly understand the nature of the research and whether it is relevant to them as justified by (Marshall, 2005). Also, Polit et al., (2010) stated that title is an important means in ascertaining the research design used as it may feature a research question that is to be answered, or a hypothesis to be proven. In this case, the title of this article made a clear identification of the patient lived experience of helmet CPAP. Perhaps the title could have identified that the...

Find Another Essay On Critique on the Nursing Article Critical care patients’ experience of the helmet continuous positive airway pressure

Quality care of patients in hospitals and the current nursing shortages

1215 words - 5 pages levels and nurse to patient ratio allows the prospective family to view the interaction of the nurse with his/her patients. In order to see how many patients a nurse sees in one shift, ask the nursing supervisor or a nurse manager.Through talking to staff and observing their verbal and nonverbal actions can be an indicator of care. This way you are not just viewing hospital statistics you can hear real opinions. On a general medical surgical level, a

Qualitative Article Critique on Palliative Care

1156 words - 5 pages used? A grounded theory approach was used in this qualitative research design to better understand the views of palliative care nurses on euthanasia (Wester, 1987; Kuyper & Wester, 1998). In this article, face-to-face interviews were used involving an interview guide. The data was grouped into concepts according to significant passages, then the concepts were grouped into categories for continuous comparison, then the data was ordered

Nursing Article Critique: A Quantitative Analysis

1245 words - 5 pages the article important or significant for the practice of health care? Yes  No N.B.: Despite the absence of a statistically significant correlation between agitation behaviours in dementia patients and olfactory aromatherapy intervention, the study supports further research in cutaneous absorption methodology. Do the findings resonate (seem correct and familiar) with you and your practice? Yes  No • If yes, why

Critical Thinking Article Summary and Critique

526 words - 2 pages PerceptionThe author through this article has clearly understood and revealed the reasons for the poor language education curriculum. He believes that the Indonesian students are left behind due to the lack of variety and process in the their curriculum. The author also mentions reconstructing the perception of the essence of the language education, especially on the part of teachers, bureaucrats and college professors. The article also

Critical Thinking Article & Critique - Forensics - MGT350 -Critical Thinking

612 words - 2 pages to develop and test a number of hypotheses. Allowing them to work with scenarios...will stimulate them to think and reason though questions, ideas, and the information gathered (Palevitz, 10).The article, "Forensics and Critical Thinking," explores the premise that children and high school students exposed to forensics, the evidenced-based, objective investigation in which science permeates, may become be future dangers to society (Palevitz, 10

A nursing report based on a research article 'evaluating a palliative care education project in nursing homes'

1178 words - 5 pages This report is based on a research article, ' Evaluating a palliative care education project in nursing homes', by Froggart (2000). The author of the article Katherine Froggart, who is the head of MacMillan Practice Development Unit, Centre for Cancer and Palliative Care Studies, discusses the establishment of a 2-year palliative education pilot project in nursing homes.The aim of her project was to address the palliative care needs of residents

Critical Thinking Article Summary and Critique for MGT350

664 words - 3 pages purpose of the summary and critique of this article is to engage in asking critical questions and examining some of the ideological assumptions. To verify one understands the message to reduce uncertainty and to ask for confirmation.ReferencesAlwasilah, A.C. (2002). Critical Thinking Crucial to Global Success. JAKARTA POST, 05/02/2002. Retrieved October 15, 2003, from EBSCOhost database (Business Source Premier) on the World Wide Web: http://www.apollolibrary.com/

Using your past and present experience of nursing practice settings consider situations where you have helped to care or interact with children

1647 words - 7 pages Whilst on clinical placement, in Critical Care, I cared for a male patient who had a 9 year old daughter with Cystic Fibrosis. The girl will be referred to as Ellie throughout this essay, in order to maintain confidentiality, as recommended by the Nursing and Midwifery Council (2002).Ellie has a 5 year old brother and an 11 year old sister and lives with her mum and dad. Her dad was my patient and had been admitted to Critical Care routinely

Positive Arguments for Euthanasia: Touching on ethical views and the views of terminally ill patients

514 words - 2 pages they realize death is near, they wish to have total control over the process. In addition when a person relies on continuous care from another person, they feel that they have lost their independence, which can be considered as a loss of personal dignity. (www.religioustolerance.org)Binner 2There are two interesting ethical issues pertaining to euthanasia. The first issue examined is the Physician's Oath, which states, "Follow that system of

Pressure Ulcers in Patients in the ICU

1751 words - 7 pages Introduction Pressure ulcers are a significant problem in those with complex illnesses or injuries which require admission into the Intensive Care Unit (ICU). Many ICU patients suffer from pressure ulcers. According to Shahin, Dassen and Halfrens (2009) “patients in the ICU have a 50% higher chance of developing a pressure ulcer as compared to patients on any other unit in a facility” (p. 370). ICU registered nurses (R.N.s) blame the

The Negative Impact of Narcotic Regulations on Long Term Care Patients

1467 words - 6 pages supposition that this a problem at least some of the time. Pain is a significant issue in long-term care patients. It is reported that at least 71% of elderly Residents living in long-term care facilities experience pain on a daily basis(Yukari, Noriko, & Okamoto, 2010). Pain is defined as the patient’s described experience to actual or potential tissue damage (Yukari, Noriko, & Okamoto, 2010). It is an issue in the care of any patient, because pain

Similar Essays

Nursing: Providing The Best Possible Care For Patients

1605 words - 6 pages where they will need to collaborate their critical creative thinking skills with other medical professionals. My nursing philosophy is based on a holistic view of the person, health, environment, nursing, and interprofessional teams. I believe it is important to practice patient-centered care in order to maintain the person’s autonomy, promote health, provide a safe and healthy environment, follow nursing values, and work effectively in

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

993 words - 4 pages value on it subjects (Polit & Beck). In the end the resulting data is neutral and statistical. However, like all things its approach is not perfect, yet, it has the ability to yield valuable data. Summary of Critiqued Article For nursing, research has played a major role in the way clinical practice is done. Research has allowed nurses to provide appropriate care to patients. It allows them to perform their job by providing them the tools and

Health Care And Medical Needs Of The Elderly/Article Summaries On Positive And Negative Effects Of Aging

586 words - 2 pages infants, walk on our two feet throughout the “prime” of our lives, and when we become old we depend on a cane. As we age we find that we change, both in positive and negative ways, and even of we fail to recognize this fact, the society that we live in does not fail in bring this fact to out attention.An article that seemed to be widespread publication just a couple of weeks ago was an article about the sex lives of the elderly. The

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

1678 words - 7 pages . Moreover, the positive note of the study is that it discusses the situation in statistical data, allowing it to be transferable to nurses across the nation. As the light may shine on the on the importance of decreasing the level of stress that nursing can have, it overshadows other poor coping skills that nurses may turn to like drug abuse and sadly, even patient negligent. In the end, through this study, they can work to improve awareness that can