Critique Paper On Article Debating Obesity In The Us Northridge, Dc Comp Assingment

898 words - 4 pages

Kauffman 1
Randy Kauffman
Mr. Shrock
DC Composition
21 December 2017
Critique
In the article “Thinking Sociologically about Sources of obesity in the United States” Robert L. Peralta argues that we live in a society obsessed with thinness and it is the fault of the fat people that they are fat (200-210). Peralta claims that as medical researchers start to target obesity as a disease, they tend to place emphasis on the proximate factors of illness such as overeating instead of distal factors like the density of fast-food in a given neighborhood touched by racism and socioeconomic marginalization (200). He then continues to discuss the effects caused from the unequal distribution of resources along with the social and psychological origins of obesity (Peralta 200-210). Peralta effectively concludes his article by highlighting our understanding on social and psychological orientations and their impact on the overall approach to the public health problem obesity.
Peralta begins his writing by stating “we live in a society obsessed with thinness in which individual blame is assigned readily or that it is the fault of the fat people as to why they are fat (200). Peralta continues this thought of society’s impact on the obese population throughout the article and clearly emphasizes it by resonating it with the value and belief system of Western Culture. In other words, is the ability of the individual to control his or her personal fate and the importance of doing so (201). Marshall H. Becker, a professor of health education at the University of Michigan, addresses this issue in his article “A Medical Sociologist Looks at Health Promotion” by stating “Personal control over longevity is often substantially limited by society where we only discuss the risk factors engaging in the risk of undesirable health outcomes” (Becker, 1993). Both Becker and Peralta would certainly come to an agreement in terms of who is to blame for the increasing population of obese people. Dealing with the sociological side of things, Peralta later argues that factors such as race, gender, socioeconomic status, and other stressful life events of a social nature effect the factors involving a person’s relationship to others. When it comes to social conditions, Marshall Becker would also agree with Peralta on this topic from the same article by stating “Direct relationships between individual’s physical environment and socioeconomic status and their morbidity, mortality, and general health status fall within the realm of social conditions” (Becker, 1993).
In the same way Peralta successfully highlights the main reasons he believes society plays a major role in the obesity epidemic, he highlights the resource allocations and the results caused from unequal resource distribution (203-205). Obesity rates are highly affected by three major factors: the geographic availability of nutritious foods and unhealthy food options, the time,...

Find Another Essay On Critique Paper on article debating obesity in the US - Northridge, DC Comp - Assingment

Maternal Perspectives and the Affect on Childhood Obesity in the Mexican American Population: An Article Review

873 words - 3 pages PAGE Maternal Perspectives and the Affect on Childhood Obesity in the Mexican AmericanThrough research conducted in the San Antonio, Texas area, Martina Raquel Gallagher studies and presents how maternal perspectives on lifestyle habits put children of Mexican descent at risk for obesity. Obesity is a national problem that often begins in childhood and carries over into adulthood (Must et al., 1999). This is true even more so for children of

Overivew of Childhood Obesity in the US

2659 words - 11 pages In 2012 CDC statistics show that over “35 percent of adults in the United States of America are recorded as obese (30kg/m2) and 32 percent of children.” The obesity rate has doubled since 1971.” Not only is epidemic growing in numbers of victims but also in expenses. The United States spend spent 147 billion dollars in 2008 on expenses medical costs yearly and that does not include the fight against the problem. “In 2003 over 300,000

Critique of Term Paper Article

856 words - 4 pages Becker, Margraf, Rinck, and Roth wrote one of the articles that I found, the emotional Stroop effect in anxiety disorders: General emotionality or disorder specificity? The main idea of the research study is to understand cognitive attention predispositions by demonstrating Stroop task with anxiety participants. Stroop task were repeatedly uses on patients that have anxiety or other disorders such as panic, obsessive-compulsive, social phobia

Children Obesity Issue in the US

862 words - 3 pages with the wrong kind of calories and not the correct amount of nutrients can deregulate the immune system. The poor diet is affecting on immune system capability to protect us and keep us safe. The rapid growth of manufacturing of canned food, packaging and distribution raised concern about a variety of consumer goods, attention focused first upon milk. “In urban areas the local dairy, whose cattle once fed off its grass of small open fields and

The role of increasing obesity rates in the US and its affect on Society

1054 words - 5 pages Social factors play very important role in our society,Through the influence of these factors, Obesity is one of main concern in US. The growing obesity rates in the US and it's affect on consumer culture is debating towards our future. Studies have suggested that the obesity is social distributed , into different social groups, some other factors such as martial status is linked cross-sectionally with obesity ( Sobal J, Raushenbach BS

Reflection Paper on Living in the Land of Promise Article

1168 words - 5 pages they sow here on Earth, they will reap on heaven. Moreover, I believe that in light of all these, Trust is a major thing in living a happy life. Trust in the Lord is the most important of all. This trust should always be kept in our heart that no matter how many obstacles and struggles we hurdle along the way, this will keep us going. Having this trust as our armor, is enough to let us get by with the daily suffering we experience. Because

Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages , group 3, and group 4, meaning that the result obtained by group 2 (Direct CF + W) was not significantly different from the control group. Critique of the method There are several points worth discussing in this article. The first and the most important one is the integration of the ‘mini lesson’ in the treatment given to group 1. As the researcher had explained, this mini lesson comprised of explaining “the rules and examples that the students

Article Critique on CSI Plagiarism

686 words - 3 pages educational leaders. This essay will review and criticize Bauman’s new approach on dealing with fraudulent students, as well as evaluate the weakness or the strengths of the article. Right at the beginning of the article, Bauman leaves the perception of himself being astonished in face of the student’s reaction when they received low grades in papers where plagiarism was detected. Some came from the category of students who neglect studies, just

The Potential Impacts of Upcoming High-Stakes Testing on the Teaching of Science in Elementary Classrooms-Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages appreciate the research. Information was analyzed, evaluated and used to support the collected data in the conclusion portion of the paper. The variables addressed included the impact of the independent variable, impending high-stakes science testing, and its effect on the teaching of science, which was the dependent variable. This data was focused on teacher concerns and perspectives of the issues. They were not operationally defined in the

the real problem in George Saunder's "puppy" - English comp - paper

506 words - 3 pages Dhanya Tenny ENG 130 Professor Thoreen October 12, 2017 “ Don’t Look Back, Don’t look back” or “ Perfect” The real issue in George Saunders' Puppy In George Saunders’ short story “Puppy” we meet Marie, a mother of two in a suburban family, who prides herself on being such a great mother. Marie had a hard childhood because she grew up in a abusive family; she was greatly influenced by her past. When her mother mentions that she may be spoiling

Book Report on Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle" - Georgia Southern University, US Comp - Book Report

1483 words - 6 pages Brandon Sellers Downs Honors US Comp November 30, 2017 Book Review of Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle The Jungle is a highly provocative, concerning, dark, and gruesomely vivid story about a family of Lithuanian immigrants who try to make a better living for themselves working in the meatpacking industry of “Packingtown,” Chicago. The main character, Jurgis, tries desperately to bring wealth and happiness to his family in a place that he was told

Similar Essays

Obesity In The Us Essay

1859 words - 8 pages this epidemic while others believe it to be a individual’s problem (“Diet, Nutrition and Wellness: Obesity,” 2013, Feb 11).The government has already set limits to what schools can set on their menus, however, due to some schools’ lack of funding in lunch programs; they have resorted to selling junk food like Dorito’s, and beef jerky, in order to make a profit more easily(“Updated: Junk Food in Schools,” 2007, March 27). They take advantage of the

Child Obesity In The Us Essay

797 words - 4 pages fries over fruit that is why the number of obese children is growing. If society goes on ignoring this problem then the future of America will pay a major price. These obese children will turn into obese adults and fall victim to more serious diseases such as diabetes. Let us stop this problem before it grows to that point. States are off to a good start with the laws in place to help fight against obesity in youth but have not given enough effort

Childhood Obesity In The Us Essay

1280 words - 6 pages Physicians and researchers did numerous studies on children’s habits and lifestyles as an important part of society. Currently, children face big problems with obesity. As a result, researchers have learned that healthy habits could have an impact on the future of every child and get a better understanding of how children perceive healthy eating. Researchers have proved and would like to emphasize that obesity has tripled in Canada in recent

Article Critique On Gmo Essay

694 words - 3 pages Article Critique on GMOPOL 1113Prof. Marija NaumoskiFall 2014By Sachet KhanalEverybody enjoys eating ice cream on a hot summer day, and having pan cakes for breakfast, but most of us don't bother thinking about what is in our food or how it was made. A lot of food available for sale are genetically modified, but as these foods do not have to be labeled, we will not know whether the food we buy is genetically modified or not. In an article titled