This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critiquing A Quantitative Study Essay

1840 words - 7 pages

Andrzejowski, J.; Hyle, J.; Eapen, G.; Turnbull, D. (2008), refers to review of literature of previous publications, such as the study by Vanni and colleagues. This study showed an notable effect of prewarming, but was flawed both by inadequate power (10 patients per group) and by having a control group that was significantly hypothermic before anesthetic induction. Two additional studies also showed a smaller decrease in core temperature during surgery after a period of prewarming, but neither study warmed patients intraoperatively A large randomized trial of prewarming, by Melling and colleagues involved more than 400 patients. Their study looked for differences in postoperative complications and showed a significant decrease in postoperative wound infections in patients who were prewarmed either locally or systemically. The authors suggested that prewarming improved peripheral circulation in the preoperative period, thus increasing tissue oxygenation (Andrzejowski, Hyle, Eapen & Turnbull, 2008).
Theoretical of Conceptual Framework
A theoretical framework was not clearly spelled out in this research article; however research on prewarming patients in the surgical setting can be easily based on the Neuman Systems Model. This model focuses on client assessment and response to environmental stressors which is consistent with the practice of prewarming surgical patients. In this model, human beings are described as systems that consciously and unconsciously create their environments both within and around themselves (Avlward, 2010). Prewarming patients is a primary prevention intervention in relation to the Neuman Systems Model. When patients arrive in the preoperative holding area, they usually are not hypothermic. If nurses apply forced-air warming before a patient experiences stress from being cold, then the lines of defense are not activated and an optimal state of health can be maintained.

The study consisted of seventy-six adults, ASA physical status I and II patients, who were undergoing general anaesthesia for elective spinal surgery, were sampled. The patients were grouped by using a computer-generated randomization: a prewarmed group and a nonprewarmed group. Of the 76 patients recruited, eight patients were excluded due to surgical cancellations. Data were therefore complete for 31 patients in the prewarmed group and 37 in the non-prewarmed group. Patient characteristics, operating room environmental temperatures, core temperatures at induction, duration of surgery, and infused fluid volumes were comparable between the groups. There was also no significant difference between the groups in the proportion of patients undergoing cervical or lumbar spine surgery, or in the ratio of male:female patients
Protection of Human Research Participants
When doing a controlled study you have to make sure you are not withholding treatment from anybody. In addition, it is the responsibility of the researcher to ensure the protection...

Find Another Essay On Critiquing a Quantitative Study

Ethics in Nursing Research Essay

2112 words - 8 pages ethical conduct or misconduct of the research teams involved. This report will attempt to determine if ethical issues or concerns are evident in the information provided in each document.Overview of Quantitative ArticleThe quantitative article, "Effect of a nursing-implemented sedation protocol on the duration of mechanical ventilation", is a study in which the practice of protocol-directed sedation during mechanical ventilation is compared to non

Critiquing Phenomenological Research Essay

612 words - 3 pages provided a descriptive structure. While the interdisciplinary group was responsible for the patterns of phenomenon it is ultimately the researchers then used these patterns to interpret and analyze the data. Using the existential ground of body, time, world, and other people the researchers grouped the data into specific categories. The final piece of critiquing a phenomenological research study is to assess whether the research meets the

Reasearch in suicide

665 words - 3 pages screening questions, compared to using the SIGNS appraisal tool which uses only tick boxes to appraise the research and unable to write your findings next to the appraisal sections of the tool (Signs, 2014). The skills of critiquing research is invaluable, being able to critically appraise a study is essential for evidence base practice (EBP) and also enable one to develop academically. ‘Critical appraisal is the process used to evaluate the scientific

Evaluating a Health Promotion Website

858 words - 3 pages In order to provide the best possible care for the patients in their care nurses should determine the most effective and accurate handover. Therefore, Analizing the level of data retained or lost from employing different handover methods is crucial. Here the above paper with be critiqued using the step-by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 1: quantitative research (Coughlan, Cronin and Ryan, 2007). In defining quantitative research

Northcentral's Expectation

1670 words - 7 pages important part of developing the concept paper. The concept paper provides the framework for the structure and content of the dissertation proposal. This paper will review the expectation of the quantitative and the qualitative design in some parts of the concept paper. These are the purpose of the study, the research question, and the research method. A discussion of the best practice suggestions for using the quantitative method based on

A Quantitative Approach to Evaluating Caring in Nursing Simulation

1427 words - 6 pages Clarification of the research question is at the end of the opening section and states that the study was “designed to evaluate the use of a quantitative instrument to measure caring in the nursing simulation environment.” This question is consistent with the problem statement of evaluating the correlation between caring and nursing simulations. Ethical Considerations All participants in this study were fully aware that the study was to be

Quantitative and Quality Research

884 words - 4 pages the attention is only in accepting the meticulous of the case (b) Instrumental case study: Here the attention is in accepting something big than the case (c) Collective case study: Here the attention is in discussing and evaluating different cases in a single research study. Quantitative Research: Quantitative Research is all about pre-analyzing and framing a data sample into detailed explanation of the material. The quantitative research

reaction paper

1176 words - 5 pages operation and recognizing different experiences. He also suggested that religion should allow experiential evidence to verify or reject its truth claims. Science and religion need to give up a little for reconciliation. Another ill phenomenon in the science community is that most research adopts a quantitative approach. Although quantitative methods have its strengths, they are unable to provide reflective and insightful explanation to study

Research Methods For Practice (How Myocardial Infarction (MI) Affects the Quality of Life Of Patients

3018 words - 12 pages is important to recognise that critiquing does not necessarily mean being negatively critical. Critiquing is more about looking for strength and weakness in a study in light of the reader's knowledge and manner in which the research has been presented.The writer's interest in this area developed whiles on a branch placement on a Coronary Care Unit in one of the teaching London hospitals. Being allocated patients and caring for them holistically

Characteristics of Qualitative and Quantitative Methods

937 words - 4 pages quantitative research is replication. To be replicable, the data acquired in an experiment must be trustworthy, for instance, the same result must be found if the study is replicated. Furthermore, if observations are not repeated, the descriptions and explanations will consider being undependable. (Hughes, 2010) Some other comparisons about quantitative and qualitative research are that in a quantitative research, the researchers seek to provide

Sexual Satisfaction and Sexual Health Among University Students

1936 words - 8 pages When critiquing the article, Sexual Satisfaction and Sexual Health Among University Students in the United States, there are many aspects to address. Beginning with the authors’ written purpose and their choice of preexisting literature and its relevance to the study. This analysis will also examine the sample population, the accuracy of its representation and biases. Followed by a discussion of the research design and threats to validity and

Similar Essays

Research Proposal: The Effect Of Extra Curricular Activities On Academic Performance: A Quantitative Study

2756 words - 11 pages activities in an effort to enhance academic performance. Methodology Introduction The purpose of this study is to examine the effects of participation in extra curricular activities on student academic performance at Solanco High School. According to Creswell’s descriptions in his text Educators as Researchers (Creswell, 2005), the research will involve a quantitative study of student athletes. “Quantitative research uses methods

Evaluation Of A Quantitative Study Uo P Mythology Essay

1172 words - 5 pages thinking can have its pros and cons, yes having contact with their children is easy today which allows the parent to know where their child is at all times, however the con the action of those who are bullying are starting as young as in the fifth grade. This also gives them a different avenue to bully and the child being bullied feels there is no escape when this begins (Moreno, 2014). The following came from a qualitative research study, that

Reporting The Findings From Research

790 words - 3 pages Reporting the findings from research is an essential part of the research process (Meadows, 2008). After a study is complete, researchers usually write a paper to present research findings. The paper might be sent to a scientific journal to be considered for publication or presented at some conference. Indispensable prerequisite for the publication is to ensure the appropriate audience by choice of relevant publisher. As some journals (e.g

Research In Nursing Essay

1743 words - 7 pages and relatives towards witnessed resuscitation in adults intensive care units. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Research design The overall approach in this study is a quantitative. Within this quantitative research data are collected through questionnaire to assess their views. It is not possible to obtain patient’s thoughts and feelings of their concepts inclusion of witnessed