Critiquing Chicago Police General Order (Rules) To The Eleven Standards Found In "Broken Windows And Police Discretion".

850 words - 3 pages

The Chicago Police Department has many policy statements that police officers and their supervisors need to know. These policy statements are called General Orders (G. O.). These orders are numbered by the year they are established, and by how many were established in that year. So, for example, G. O. 86-08 means it was established in 1986 and that it was the 8th order established that year. G. O. 86-08 (a) initiates a "Protection of Life" policy relative to the use of deadly force by police officers, (b) sets forth Department policy regarding a police officer's use of deadly force, and (c) establishes guidelines controlling the use of deadly force by police officers.When critiquing this general order to the eleven standards found in "Broken Windows and Police Discretion" you find that this policy does not meet all eleven standards. The first standard, which states that a policy should recognize the complexity of police work, is not met in the black and white pages of the City's general order on deadly force. While in the police academy, when police officers are first introduced to general orders, senior police instructors teach the deadly force policy by reading the general orders to the new police officers. These instructors recognize the complexity of police work and tend to enhance the general orders by telling "war stories". These "war stories" can paint a picture that will make the general order come to life.The second standard is to acknowledge that police will use discretion. Although this standard is not spelled out in the general order, it is implied. The general order states that police officers may (not must) resort to the lawful use of firearms under certain circumstances.The third standard is to recognize and confirm how police work is conducted. This standard is met under the department "protection of life" policy. This policy recognizes how the City of Chicago is more restrictive in the application of the use of deadly force by police officers than that allowed by the Illinois Revised Statutes. This is confirmed in the policy when it states that it does not allow police officers to use deadly force to prevent an arrest from being defeated by resistance or escape merely because the offense committed or attempted is categorized as a Forcible Felony.The fourth standard is to advance a set of value that may be applied to the substantive work issue at hand. The general order does state that police officers will not unreasonably endanger themselves to conform to this policy.The firth standard is to put forward existing research, facts,...

Find Another Essay On Critiquing Chicago Police general order (rules) to the eleven standards found in "Broken Windows and Police Discretion".

Police Discretion Essay

1481 words - 6 pages -enforcement decisions (Goldstein, 1960) Full enforcement of the law is not possible due to various reasons, a limitation of officer time, and a limitation of investigative devices. In some instances the police may choose not to enforce the law in order to allow a confidential informant to gather information on another suspect. This is an exchange relationship where both parties have the opportunity to gain some benefits by their interaction (Cole

Police Discretion and the Use of Force

2202 words - 9 pages subject to an officer’s discretion. The culture of force is detrimental to a department. The Los Angeles Police Department in the 1980s and 1990s would act on a tip and destroy homes by breaking toilets, ripping sofas, and spray painting “LAPD Rules!” on the walls. These acts by the Los Angeles Police Department prove the culture of the department will have an influence on the individual officer (Pollock, 2010). Police departments have use

The Discretion of the Police

829 words - 3 pages In this paper, I will be writing about Police Discretion. I will start by defining Police Discretion then briefly discuss the use of discretion in domestic disturbances, minor misdemeanors, and traffic enforcement. I will also discuss the application of police discretion, the provisions it uses and how it is currently practiced. At the end of these brief descriptions, I will then present the myth that exists in regards to police discretion

Police Discretion and the Ethics of Accepting Gratuities

2052 words - 8 pages implemented procedures that limit the amount and type of gratuities accepted by officers. A perfect example of a police department taking the steps necessary to prevent officers from accepting gratuities is the Flagstaff, Arizona Police Department. Inside the published Rules and Regulations and General Orders (pg. 24) of the Flagstaff Police Department, specific regulations regarding gratuities can be found. Specifically, the regulations state

Police Discretion: Necessary or Unfair?

1351 words - 6 pages interpretation of officer discretion is different among officers and varies depending on a situation. Officer discretion is an action that has been among the police force for many years; though there are down sides to the exercise, there is plenty of evidence that proves officer discretion is necessary for policemen and women to do their jobs. History of Officer Discretion Officer discretion was discovered by the American bar Foundation in 1956. The

"It might be thought that UK police discretion is tightly constrained by legal rules. At times it is but more frequently it is not" Discuss in the context of Stop and Search

3419 words - 14 pages rules and how they make the discretionary decisions they do. Sanders and Young set out six important criteria that influence discretion, possibly overriding the constraints imposed.1.Personal Factors: police officers share the same human traits as the rest of society. They may feel pressured into particular discretionary decisions in order to justify themselves. They are target led despite suggestion to the contrary and may well wish to improve

The Broken Windows Theory Set The Standards of Law Enforcement

1480 words - 6 pages Introduction: Many experts look at experts’ looks at data and research. Great experts find out and test their research. Traditional old concepts of police work caused many to venture and test anything. George Kelling and James Q. Wilson analyzed and tested their hypothesis. I will break down their “Broken Windows Theory” and how this has changed law enforcement today. Topic I. The Broken Windows set the standards for law enforcement. A

To what extent does modern technology pose new challenges for the police in balancing liberty and order concerns.

2835 words - 11 pages fingerprints when the fingerprint bureau was formed back in 1901. But at what cost say civil liberty organisations. Is the polices desire to catch every criminal clouding the thought process when it comes to balancing liberty and order concerns?The police would argue that the benefits far outweigh the inconvenience to the public and if you are law abiding then you have nothing to worry about. The Government has invested substantially in policing. Since

Police in the Movies

2135 words - 9 pages Hawke plays a special operations cop, “Sal,” who has resorted to stealing drug money in order to take care of his family; Richard Gere plays “Eddie,” a burnt-out cop who retires in 7 days; and Don Cheadle plays “Tango,” an undercover vice cop that is too caught up in the game. Essentially, every police officer archetype is present and accounted for. Movies like “Brooklyn’s Finest” influence the public to make rash assumptions about the police

Compstat and the Police

1431 words - 6 pages their tactics to combat crime. The method has also been adopted by other law enforcement agencies. Other agencies including Los Angeles police department and Philadelphia police department. For example, Bill Bratton took it to Los Angeles Police Department, John Timoney brought it to Philadelphia and Gary McCarthy broaden compstat in Chicago (BJA, 2012). In conclusion, compstat as a model can be viewed in differently. From a Police

The broken windows theory and community policing and how they relate to each other.

3038 words - 12 pages , working in a proactive partnership with citizens to identify and solve problems" (Trojanowicz and Bucqueroux, 1994, 1). This helps promote mutual trust and cooperation between the community and the police officers, at the same time it helps empower neighborhoods in danger of being overwhelmed by crime, drugs, and the general fear of crime. The broken windows theory, a hypothesis created by James Q. Wilson and George L. Kelling in 1982, determined

Similar Essays

The Core Function Of Police In Reference To Wilson And Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

2848 words - 11 pages The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis In considering whether the core function of the Police should be to maintain order, there are a number of issues, both historic and current, which need to be taken into consideration. For example, the maintenance of what constitutes “order” can be interpreted differently by different communities i.e. urban and rural. The expectations of

'the Core Function Of The Police Should Be To Maintain Order.' Discuss With Particular Reference To Wilson And Kelling's 'broken Windows' Thesis.

2371 words - 9 pages radically from the first policemen that patrolled the streets in the 19th century and criminologists have recently played a large part in influencing police strategies. Recently, a return back to the early days of maintaining order has seemed to have emerged with the appearance of the 'broken windows' theory, an approach to policing that emphasizes creating and maintaining orderly public spaces. suggesting that continuing urban decay of a community

Police Discretion Essay

1353 words - 5 pages policy – then the idea of controlled discretion may seem to be a self-contradiction” (Gottfredson p.276). Discretion can be used in many different situations. I will be discussing discretion used in dealing with the mentally ill, drunk driving, disorderly conduct, the use of force, and domestic violence. If a police officer uses his/her discretionary power correctly, not only will it help the police officer in their situation, it will help the

Police Discretion Essay

1735 words - 7 pages precisely because we believe that permitting the use of judgment in some situations can lead to better results than setting up an inflexible set of rules, policies, and procedures that cannot be altered because of circumstances" (Cohen, n.d, p.92). Society gives police officers the power to make rational decisions that the average citizen could not. Sometimes we say we give to much power to law enforcement, and some say we do not give enough. Either way discretion is used in the majority of law enforcement actions everyday.ReferenceCohen, H. (n.d.). Handled with Discretion: Ethical Issues in Police Decisions. Lanham, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.