Crittenden Compromise Essay

1883 words - 8 pages

What Was the Crittenden Compromise, Why Was It Written, and Why Did It Fail? The Crittenden Compromise was more or less a last ditch effort to avert secession of the Southern states and the likely ensuing civil war. The mid-nineteenth century was a time when many people had their own views of slavery (the main cause of secession), and how Congress should handle it. Northern abolitionists wanted an end to slavery; however, southerners were opposed to such a drastic measure. In the midst of Senatorial confusion and congressional debate arose the Kentucky Senator, John Jordan Crittenden, with his proposal. Initially brought to the Senate floor on December 18, 1860, the compromise met with mixed reviews. Crittenden was willing to amend his compromise to suit his colleagues' ideas, but it was not enough, and the proposal was ultimately unsuccessful because of a variety of reasons, leading to the deterioration of Southern unity and loyalty towards the Union. During the 1850's, the growing debate over slavery was nearing a definite boiling point. The controversy culminated with the election of Abraham Lincoln to Presidency in 1860. A major issue that was being tossed around during compromise talks was the 36°30' line, established by the Missouri Compromise in 1820. This compromise said that Maine would be admitted to the Union as a free state as long as Missouri would be admitted as a slave state, and that the remainder of the Louisiana Purchase north of this line would be free, and south of it would be slave. The restoration of this line for the remaining territories, and also guaranteeing the protection of slavery south of this line were major components of the Crittenden Plan. South Carolina was perhaps the most aggressive in their efforts for secession. They held strong beliefs that the North was deliberately trying to hurt Southern business and at the same time violating the laws of the Constitution. South Carolinians felt a number of states including Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Illinois (among others) were enacting laws that either negated acts of Congress or rendered attempts at executing them useless. The constitutional article in question is Article 4, which states: No person held to service in one state, under the laws thereof, escaping into another shall, in consequence of any law or regulation therein, be discharged from such service or labor, but shall be delivered up, on claim of the party to whom such service or labor may be due.The South (especially South Carolina) was angry that too many of their slaves had escaped to the North and were being permitted to live free, despite Article 4. The South felt powerless to stop these actions and hence moved for secession, and eventually seceded on December 20, 1860. Charles O'Conor, a prominent lawyer in the South, stated: ...If the South cannot otherwise protect itself against the aggravated spirit of the North, a real necessity for this act...

Find Another Essay On Crittenden compromise

Reconstruction Essay

1656 words - 7 pages South Carolina and six more Southern states later accompanied South Carolina. In a final attempt to keep the Union together, Senator John J. Crittenden wrote up the Crittenden Compromise. It called for permanent existence of slavery in the slave states and basically gave in to Southern states’ demands. However, it failed when the Republicans refused to accept it. Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation paved the way for reform movements to free all

Events Leading up to the Civil War

1773 words - 7 pages 1787- In 1787 the Northwest Ordinance was passed. It helped form new states and governed them. Then the confederate government had almost no control. The United States went into a depression, farmers had their land taken away, shays rebellion came, and slavery became a topic of debate. This led to the constitutional convention. Many plans were proposed, but only compromises were accepted. Two important compromises were the Great Compromise

The Exceptional Presidency of Abraham Lincoln

973 words - 4 pages territory deciding whether or not there would be slavery) and the Crittenden Compromise (which would allow slavery above the 36-30 marker) demonstrating his unyielding belief that slavery’s expansion must be stopped, which helped to set up the imminent abolishment of the entire institution in the United States. Abraham Lincoln’s presidency is marked by his exceptional management of the decisive domestic issues that he faced during his reign. He went

Was War Against The Confederate States of America Justified?

1660 words - 7 pages itself and sending troops to attack Fort Sumter. Lincoln was posed with a weighty decision, to either form a compromise with the South, allow the CSA to secede, or commence a civil war. The first option, a compromise, was not possible simply because the South would not accept any compromise presented to it. After South Carolina seceded in December of 1860, the government scrambled to find a solution to conflict. John J. Crittenden proposed a set


2727 words - 11 pages , p.330) from expanding into any more territories. Lincoln had no intention of attacking slavery were it already existed but he wanted slavery to “die a gradual death” (Oates, p.331). Lincoln made it clear that he was going to stand by this when he rejected the Crittenden Compromise proposed by Kentucky Senator John J. Crittenden. Crittenden sought to stop the secession of southern states from the union by extending the 36 30 line, Lincoln

Abraham Lincoln, 16th president of the United States, who steered the Union to victory in the American Civil War and abolished slavery

2410 words - 10 pages steps to secede from the Union. Declaring that secession was illegal but that he had no power to oppose it, President James Buchanan preferred to rely on Congress to find a compromise. The success of this effort, however, depended on Lincoln, the president-elect, who was open to concessions but refused to countenance any possible extension of slavery. Thus, the Crittenden Compromise, the most promising scheme of adjustment, failed, and a new Southern

How inevitable was the Civil War?

2720 words - 11 pages with slavery as more states entered the Union and swayed the balance of free and slave states. The Crittenden Compromise, which was a last ditch effort to the expansion question, was negotiated after seven states had already seceded. It proposed to divide the country into slave and free zones with an amendment to the Constitution, but it failed because it still allowed for the expansion of slavery. Once again issues became mingled and no real

The American Civil War

2593 words - 10 pages which resulted in in its retreating. On January 9th in the same year, Mississippi declared its secession from the Union. On the following day, January 10th, Florida also announced that it had seceded from the union.  Alabama also declared its secession from the Union on January 11th. On January 16th, the Crittenden compromise was presented for approval by the senate. The aim of the pact was to reduce the level of tensions between both the North

Examining the Civil War

2797 words - 11 pages and come up with solutions. Kentucky senator Jon Crittenden tried to propose that the Missouri Compromise line should be extended to California. North of the line slavery was illegal and south of the line it would be federally protected (Davidson et al, 2001, p. 413).Outbreak of WarWhen Lincoln took the Presidential Office he received word from Major Robert Anderson of Fort Sumter that they were in dire need of supplies or the fort would have to

The American Civil War

6804 words - 27 pages their populations, a total of 48.8% for the six. Outgoing Democratic President James Buchanan and the incoming Republicans rejected secession as illegal. Lincoln's inaugural address declared his administration would not initiate civil war. Eight remaining slave states continued to reject calls for secession. Confederate forces seized numerous federal forts within territory claimed by the Confederacy. A peace conference failed to find a compromise

The American Civil War

6804 words - 27 pages their populations, a total of 48.8% for the six. Outgoing Democratic President James Buchanan and the incoming Republicans rejected secession as illegal. Lincoln's inaugural address declared his administration would not initiate civil war. Eight remaining slave states continued to reject calls for secession. Confederate forces seized numerous federal forts within territory claimed by the Confederacy. A peace conference failed to find a compromise

Similar Essays

Crittenden Compromise Essay

1710 words - 7 pages On December 18, 1860 Kentucky Senator John Crittenden, offered the Crittenden Compromise as a last ditch effort to end the Civil War. It, like many other compromises before it, tried to make a compromise between the North and the South about which United States territories should and should not have slavery. The Compromise of 1850, and the Missouri Compromise were two previous compromises that had been passed that dealt with slavery in the

Causes Of Civil War And Reconstruction

1228 words - 5 pages attempting to avert war, changing his course. At any rate the question of the forts was still unsettled when Lincoln was inaugurated, and meanwhile there had been several harmless efforts to reunite the sections, notably the Crittenden Compromise offered by Sen. J. J. Crittenden. Lincoln resolved to hold Sumter. The new Confederate government under President Jefferson Davis and South Carolina were equally determined to force out the Federalist.In

Chap 2 Essay

1157 words - 5 pages not confined to any area or group. Southern Unionists such the Senator from Kentucky John C. Crittenden and other political allies were making last ditch efforts at compromise to preserve the Union. The Crittenden Plan was modified to be palatable to Republicans but still could not gain acceptance. Another meeting of Unionists was planned but the attack on Fort Sumter derailed possible comprises. In the Southern states many of the men

The Bloody Civil War Essay

1001 words - 4 pages war. Compromise was not an option. There would be no resolution until blood was shed.[1] The Union army led an invasion, an invasion on American soil. Subsequently, the march between Americans, in the bloodiest war, caused brother to fight against brother, father against son. The Union army had to have a justifiable cause.[1] In July of 1861, Congress passed the Crittenden-Johnson Resolutions, declaring support for a war “to defend and