Cross Culture Leadership Approaches Essay

8655 words - 35 pages

Cross-Cultural Approaches to Leadership Zeynep Aycan
Arabs worship their leaders-as long as they are in power!
-House, Wright, and Aditya (1997, p. 535)
The Dutch place emphasis on egalitarianism and are skeptical about the value of leadership. Terms like leader and manager carry a stigma. If a father is employed as a manager, Dutch children will not admit it to their schoolmates.
-House et al. (1997, p. 535)
The Malaysian leader is expected to behave in a manner that is humble, modest and dignified.
-House et al. (1997, p. 535)
The Americans appreciate two kinds of leaders. They seek empowerment from leaders who grant autonomy and delegate authority to subordinates. They also respect the bold, forceful, confident, and risk-taking leader as personified by John Wayne.
-House et al. (1997, p. 536)
AUTHOR'S NOTE: The author wishes to thank Peter Smith and Mark Peterson for their feedback and suggestions on earlier versions of this chapter.
Smith-Ch-13.qxd 2/22/2008 9:16 PM Page 219

For Europeans . . . everything seems to indicate that leadership is an unintended and undesirable consequence of democracy.
-Graumann and Moscovici (1986, pp. 241-242)
Indians prefer leaders who are nurturant, caring, dependable, sacrificing and yet demanding, authoritative, and strict disciplinarian.
-Sinha (1995, p. 99)
A s captured in the above quotations, leadership, as seen through the eyesof followers, cannot be studied without taking into account the effect ofcultural context. To remain key players in the global economy, organiza- tions invest in developing leaders who have competencies to understand and manage diversity both at home and globally. While globalization offers numerous opportunities for cross-border synergies for multinational enterprises, leadership challenges can work against realizing such potential (Bartlett & Ghoshal, 1998; Bartlett, Ghoshal, & Birkinshaw, 2004; Peterson & Hunt, 1997). Organizations strive to find the "one best way" of managing people, and they often export leadership theories and development programs, whose effectiveness may be specific to a particular nation or cultural context, to other contexts. However, as stated by Steers, Porter, and Bigley (1996), "no nation or culture has a monopoly on the best ways of doing something. This is especially so when it comes to understanding motivation and leadership at work" (p. 423). Cross-cultural leadership research helps organizations understand the cultural contingencies under which certain leadership approaches work better than others.
Although leadership is one of the most widely researched topics in the literature, it is only recently that attention has been shifted to the effects of the cultural con- text on leadership. This is evident from recent reviews on the topic (e.g., Ayman, 2004; Bass, 1997; Dorfman, 2004; Gelfand, Erez, & Aycan, 2007; House et al., 1997) and a special issue of Leadership Quarterly (Peterson & Hunt, 1997). The past...

Find Another Essay On cross-culture leadership approaches

Discuss the contention that national cultures are converging and thus cross cultural sensitivity is no longer applicable

1575 words - 6 pages Discuss the contention that national cultures are converging and therefore cross-cultural sensitivity is no longer applicable.The above brief has proved to present a broad array of approaches in confirming or refusing the contention of converging national cultures. This essay shall concern itself with the study of the extent to which, organisational and societal cultural values have converged, with a particular emphasis on the operations of

Leadership Challenges in the Multicultural Workplace

1256 words - 6 pages centralization focused on top management in terms of decision making. Values, beliefs or ethics are varies from country to country and culture to culture. Different culture appreciates and priorities different leadership style and approach. It is more difficult for a leader to influence the followers in cross-cultural workplace. There are two types of leadership behaviors such as individualism and collectivism. The leadership behavior in the east will


3579 words - 14 pages Full Range Leadership Model Vs. Models of Organizational Behavior: Cross comparison of military leadership models and civilian models of Organizational BehaviorXXXXXXX1MGT 6671Executive SummaryIn light of recent force management measures implemented by the Department of Defense, military personnel are being forced into an unfamiliar battleground, the civilian world. Military members have been accustomed to a specific lifestyle. Members endure

Management and Leadership Paper

1080 words - 4 pages have the organization in their mind at all times.There are several styles of leadership and along with that come diverse traits and approaches to leadership. Bateman-Snell's book, Management: The New Competitive Landscape defines supervisory leadership as "behavior that provides guidance, support, and corrective feedback for day-to-day activities of work unit members." The same book defines strategic leadership as "gives purpose and meaning to

The Impact of Leadership Behavior on Organizational Commitment

4971 words - 20 pages case when psychological empowerment is high, whereas transactional leadership focused on in- role performance and less focus on the novel activities and is found to be negatively related to the innovative behavior of the followers. Transformational leaders are more innovative than transactional leaders and adopt more novel approaches of doing work (Bass, 1985). Jean Lee (2005) studied the behavioral and relational perspective of leadership and

Org Life Cycle

2023 words - 9 pages maintain a small-company philosophy while still a part of a very large bureaucracy. There are cross-functional task forces and teams and a high performance culture. The crisis in this stage is the need for revitalization. This is necessary because after a while, the organization shifts out of alignment with the environment, so it has to go through a stage of streamlining and innovation (Daft). During this time, top managers are often replaced

Cross Cultural Psychology

1084 words - 4 pages dimensions of culture: the normative (standards for behavior), the cognitive (knowledge and beliefs), and the material (tangible objects). An elaboration on each of these dimensions helps us to better comprehend the nature of culture.The difference with cross cultural psychology is that it does not focus on how parents and friends impact human behavior but instead culture has a powerful impact on an individual's actions. Cultural psychology seeks to

bussiness assignment

2201 words - 9 pages leadership is the source of poor decisions on investments and credit systems that could not be sustained. The impact of poor leadership at the organizational level affects other organizations, the government, and regulators and for multinational, the effect is international (Gatti et al., 2012). This has resulted in new approaches to organizational leadership and a renewed discourse on leadership in a global market. Organizations are shifting from


8081 words - 32 pages ISSN 1831-9351 Occupational Safety and Health culture assessment - A review of main approaches and selected tools TE-W E-11-005--EN -N Written by the following members of the Topic Centre: Lieven Eeckelaert (Prevent, Belgium), Annick Starren & Arjella van Scheppingen (TNO Quality of Life, The Netherlands), David Fox (Health & Safety Laboratory, United Kingdom), Carsten Brück (KOOP, Germany) Reviewed by Markku Aaltonen (FIOH

Creative Leadership

792 words - 4 pages Theory This chapter include theories, useful for this project, of leadership and creativity, imaginization. In addition, I try to discuss what are perspectives of leadership, how people understand it. As a result, this way should help me answer into problem formulation. First of all, according to Matthew R. Fairholm, (Fairholm, 2004) there are two different approaches to studying leadership. First one and the most popular is a focus on the

External/Internal Factors of the Red Cross

1535 words - 6 pages the basic requirements for survival and the rebuilding of a community. This can only be accomplished by the use of proper planning, organization, leadership, and control.The Red Cross is a worldwide company and must follow the four basic functions of management; in order for the business to run smooth it needs to plan. For instance, currently the Red Cross is attending to a natural disaster in Haiti after two large earthquakes. Red Cross has to

Similar Essays

Cross Cultural Essay

1099 words - 5 pages the group as a whole. When applying this to a cross-cultural model, the Michigan study correlates with a collectivist culture while the Ohio State study depicts an individualistic culture. It is crucial to understand the contingency theory when analyzing how effective behavioral theories of leadership are in other countries. The contingency theory states that there is no best way to organize a corporation, lead a company, or make decisions

Gary Yukl's Leadership In Organizations Essay

1983 words - 8 pages moderately accessible language. From the first, introductory, chapter about the nature of leadership, Yukl writes what is essentially an academic text, but with a clarity accessible to a practising manager with a serious interest in the subject area. The research approaches are broadly outlined in terms of the characteristics of a leader, a follower, and the situation. The research theories have been classified into the five approaches

Leadership Essay

3781 words - 15 pages divided into two major parts: classical approaches and contemporary approaches. "Many of these approaches developed simultaneously, and they often had a significant impact on one another. Some approaches were a direct reaction to the perceived deficiencies of previous approaches. Others developed as the needs and issues confronting managers changed over the years." (Batman & Snell, 1996, 31) The evolution of leadership thought and action has also

Human Essay

1243 words - 5 pages behaviors is varied. Cross-cultural psychologists try to focus on two approaches how are cultures are alike and how they are dissimilar. Cross cultural psychology focuses on the cultural issues within a generation." For instance cross cultural studies have proved that the symptoms of most psychological disorders vary from one culture to the next, and has led to a exploration of what constitutes normal human sexuality" ( N.A., 2001). Culture shapes