Csi Effect Essay

1270 words - 5 pages

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation was introduced to viewers in October 2000. Since that time, the franchise has added two versions in major metropolitan areas, now addressing crime scenarios in Las Vegas, Miami and New York City. Based on the most recent Nielsen ratings for primetime television shows, the CSI franchise claimed approximately 35 million viewers during the 2010 – 2011 viewing season. The popularity of forensic science drama on television has led officers of the court to voice opinions that there is a “CSI effect” which alters the juror pools and outcomes of criminal trial proceedings. The differences between made for television fiction and actual crime solving are many and when jurors consider themselves pseudo-experts those lines may get blurred in the courtroom.
Jurors have unrealistic ideas of evidence processing. ”Such programs give the impression that forensic laboratories are fully staffed with highly trained personnel, stocked with a full complement of state-of-the-art instrumentation and rolling in the resources to close every case in a timely fashion.” (Houck 85) Forensic laboratories face funding deficits, not enough suitably trained staff and the consistent advancement of technology. University of Maryland forensic scientist Thomas Mauriello estimates that about 40 percent of the forensic science shown on CSI does not exist. Carol Henderson, director of the National Clearinghouse for Science, Technology and the Law at Stetson University College of Law, told a publication of that institution that jurors are “sometimes disappointed if some of the new technologies that they think exist are not used.” (Houck 87) Investigators often have to explain to victims that it is not possible to collect a sample of a fiber and have that fiber analyzed to determine what it came from, where the fiber had been previously or in some cases, even where the item may have been purchased in a retail store. This particular scenario is played out in the CSI franchise with regularity. The fictional crime scene investigators have success with this in matching everything from nail polish colors to duct tape and being able to locate the retailer who sold it through credit card receipts. Unfortunately real life investigations do not have these capabilities with high tech equipment and flashing lights and laboratories are facing increasing backlogs of materials to analyze.
Forensic science has been around as far back as 44 B.C. when the physician of Julius Caesar determined that only one of the twenty three stab wounds he suffered was fatal. Causes of death, identification by fingerprinting, photographing of crime scenes and DNA profiling are all methods of forensic science. When DNA evidence was first introduced in a criminal case in the United States in 1987, prosecutors’ main concern was educating the jurors with the terminology and having experts testify in language that the general public could understand. Today, due to television,...

Find Another Essay On CSI Effect

Crime Scene Investigation Essay

1773 words - 7 pages college students studying forensic science. Recently however, despite its many achievements several newspapers and magazine articles began warning about the impact the shows influence is having on our criminal justice system; they referred to the phenomenon as the CSI Effect. Max Houck, Director of the Forensic Science Initiative at West Virginia University, explains the CSI effect as “basically the perception of the near-infallibility of forensic

the verdict is in Essay

2368 words - 10 pages , they paint highly unrealistic views of how a crime lab and criminal justice system works (Harriss). The methods displayed on these shows are observed by viewers as what would seemingly take place in real life, creating a problem when it comes to the courtroom. This problem is known as the CSI effect, a phenomenon where a juror’s decisions to either convict or acquit a defendant depends heavily on the presence or absence of scientific or forensic

Lit Review

1047 words - 5 pages trying to provide a dramatic effect for people to enjoy. Next is the crime fiction programs, which encompasses all of the popular CSI shows, Bones, Castle, etc. The focus of this show has shifted to take almost a 180, where the attention falls on the drama of the characters. What does the love life of the firearm specialist and the homicide detective have to do with the murder of a teenager near the lake? Juror Expectations in the Courtroom

Jurors and Prosecution

1655 words - 7 pages shows are the least harmful, as they use real life cases in their episodes. However, they are so heavily edited and narrated, that the focus shifts from the case, to trying to provide a dramatic effect for people to enjoy. These shows still manage to warp the amount of time it takes to find, deliver, and process evidence so they can be admissible in court. The second level contains the crime fiction programs, which encompasses all of the popular CSI

Argument Paper

1495 words - 6 pages based off crime reports, witness statements, and the help of great Hollywood writers. It is from these shows that the concept, "The CSI Effect" has been created. This phenomenon is the idea that these shows that falsely portray our criminal justice system-the public, specifically jurors, will have a misconception of legal tactics and procedures. The concern though, where is the line drawn from reality to fiction in television? People can easily see

Media Relations: Macro Structural Level

1597 words - 6 pages the available studies. Does media influence exists in our society? Some say that it does but is there empirical evidence that proves it exists. An example of media influence is the CSI effect, the CSI effect is the exaggerated portrayal of forensic science on crime television shows like CSI: Crime Scene Investigation. These shows influence public perception about how crime scene investigations are run and what forensic scientists do. The

Guantanamo Bay in Regards to The U.S. Constitution

989 words - 4 pages Guantanamo Bay, which is located in Cuba, because it was supposedly out of the United State's legal jurisdiction zone. In June 2004, the federal government ruled that Guantanamo Bay was in the United State's jurisdiction, and that the writs of Habeaus Corpus would be placed in effect for all prisoners. The Writs of Habeas Corpus gives prisoners the chance to detest their unlawful imprisonment, in hopes that they can be released. It does not examine

A Cross-Layer Adaptive Modulation and Coding Scheme for realistic OFDMA-based Systems

2615 words - 10 pages A Cross-Layer Adaptive Modulation and Coding Scheme for realistic OFDMA-based Systems Abstract—In this letter, we investigate Adaptive Modulation and Coding schemes (AMC) in fast mobility environment with realistic conditions. We argue that feedback Channel State Information (CSI) are outdated and suffer estimation errors for most mobile channels especially fast users. Therefore, ignoring such conditions in AMC scheme design can be

Juveniles Without Justice

1135 words - 5 pages Juveniles Without Justice The Supreme Court has helped shaped the Juvenile Justice System for over fifty years but began to take its biggest effect in the 1960s. They make sure that the law is applied the same to everyone based on their legal status and have a great influence on American society. Kent vs. United States was the first major juvenile case heard by the Supreme Court. In the case a minor by the name of Morris Kent Jr. was charged

Forensic Science and its Growing Popularity

2927 words - 12 pages question in a court of law, as it relates to the law (http://home.earthlink.net/~thekeither/Forensic/forsone.htm). There are different areas of forensic science, and different jobs that people do. There is the crime scene investigator, as shown in the hit television show CSI: Crime Scene Investigation. They search a crime scene, collect evidence, tag/bag evidence, and analyze it. Forensic photographers take pictures at crime scenes. Forensic

The Use of Forensic Evidence in Investigation

3195 words - 13 pages Nearly anyone you ask would be familiar with the television show CSI. The crime lab is colorful and high-tech with all of the fun toys and machines that analysts use to test the ever abundant amount of forensic evidence from every crime scene. It makes for an exciting drama that you cannot help but get immersed in—it also gives us a false illusion, however, creating what has been dubbed as the “CSI effect” (Baskin, 2011). This effect describes

Similar Essays

Csi Effect Essay

843 words - 4 pages the other investigators solve crimes by using sophisticated machines like a mass spectrometer and comparison microscopes etc. Each of the characters specialized in different areas of science such as blood spatter analyst, audio video expert, hair/fiber expert, and material/element analyst. The “CSI effect” was coined after this show, because people who watch it began to think they were educated in the different forensic sciences. Jurors began to

Forensic In Pop Culture: The Csi Effect

2367 words - 9 pages ? Findings by the journal show that the CSI Effect “shapes prosecutor discretion in many ways, which includes reliance upon 'credible' (compelling) witnesses (including forensic personnel and victims).” Methods. For my study, I conducted a short questionnaire on Survey Money in order to determine the average person's television viewing habits and how likely they were to use what they've seen on television to help them in court. It consisted of basic

The Effect Of Csi 300 Index Futures Trading On The Chinese Stock Market

989 words - 4 pages In this paper, we discuss the effect of CSI 300 index futures trading on the Chinese stock market. Specifically, we focus on the two topics (1) price volatility and efficiency of market, and (2) the arbitrage trading 5.1 On market volatility and efficiency I introduce the research result on the market volatility and efficiency in the Korean market. Two approaches have been used to analyze the effect of index futures trading on stock market

Tv Violence: How Tv Shows (Elmo's World, Dbz, And Csi) Effect People

641 words - 3 pages was Elmo's World, Dragon Ball Z, and CSI. These shows had very little in common (beyond the obvious use of characters and plot lines). Elmo's World was more about trying to keep the child's attention by using "interaction", Elmo asks a question to the viewer, pauses, and then says a generalized answer, giving the illusion that Elmo could hear the viewer, changing camera angles semi-frequently, to keep eyes refocusing and keep their head in the