Ct Os And The Public Sphere Essay

2086 words - 8 pages

We as a team do not agree that Community Treatment Orders (CTO) is a way to maximize the liberty of persons diagnosed with psychiatric illnesses by ensuring the continued participation in community living

First of all, the effectiveness of CTO's has only not been proven it also undermines people's basic human rights. This debate will indicate that we are firmly against CTO's as a way of community involvement, and we do not believe that they maximize a person's liberty at all. Our issues are simple, CTO's are imbedded within the medical model that basically uses drugs to integrate people with mental health conditions into our society. We stand firm to express our views against why CTO's are not beneficial to people with mental health conditions because it looks at people with these conditions as patients who require treatment. Any social model will tell you that in order for people to be integrated into society, aspects such as social, emotional, physical being of a person is important to work on. Medication as a treatment for these people should not be the premise of them being integrated back into society. A treatment such as medication does not teach a person to socialize in society.

Bill 68 proposes amendments to the Mental Health Act that would allow persons needing psychiatric treatment to live outside of a psychiatric facility under a community treatment order.� The criteria that must be met before a physician may issue a community treatment order are set out under section 14 of the Bill (proposed subsection 33.1(2) of the Act).� Community treatment orders may only be issued for persons who, during the three-year period prior to the order, were patients in a psychiatric facility on two or more separate occasions or for a cumulative period of 30 days or more, and who, on examination, have been found to be suffering from mental disorder that if not treated would likely result in the person causing himself, herself or another person serious bodily harm or in substantial mental or physical deterioration of the person or serious physical impairment of the person. Once the order is issued the person subject to it under the obligations set out in subsection 33.1(6) respecting attendance at appointments with the issuing physician and others providing treatment under the plan and compliance with the terms of the order (e-laws.gov.on.ca.) This may initially sound great, however as you will read CTO's are in fact harmful for those diagnosed with a psychiatric illness to obtain any kind of liberty in the community.

CTO or Community Committal have also been described as "leash laws" and "hospitalization without walls" as the Bill is a coercive measure and forces people to take medication or they are threatened to be hospitalized. You may wonder how a Bill such as this could be passed (The No Force Coalition) Those that are in agreement with this law may try convincing you that...

Find Another Essay On CTOs and the public sphere

Jürgen Habermas’ The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere

2229 words - 9 pages In this essay I will discuss Jürgen Habermas’ “The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: Inquiry into a category of bourgeois society” (1962), and the ideas presented surrounding the public sphere. What I will investigate is whether or not the post-modern phenomenon of new media (e.g. the internet) could in fact present a new-wave of public sphere, or is just another platform for mass-media. I will also explore the public sphere model

What did habermas mean by the "public sphere"?

1457 words - 6 pages What did Habermas mean by the Public Sphere? Is this concept at all useful for understanding the role of the mass media in contemporary society?Jurgen Habermas by many is considered the most influential thinker in Germany; his ideas of the "public sphere" were developed in the enlightenment era of the eighteenth century and were considered revolutionary. These ideas in some parts of the world are still highly regarded and have become an integral

Influence of Religion on Political Decisions in the Public Sphere

2277 words - 9 pages Influence of Religion on Political Decisions in the Public Sphere A religion can refer to a specific cultural system of beliefs, which establishes symbols that relate humanity to moral values and spirituality. Religions in most instances draw humanity to the worship and total reliance of a deity (Vries 46). Religions are designed under a set of traditions, symbols, narratives, and sacred histories which attempts to give life its meaning

The West Wing: Characters and Political Sphere

1971 words - 8 pages Presidents feelings. Leo leaves the President’s office worried looking about how he is responding to the loss of Morris and the actions the President mentioned. According to Auster, The West Wing presents current and information related to politics, to educate its public, Auster states “news cycle hides or highlights information” (39) as to what is being shown on the show, educating its public of strategies and news events in the political sphere. This

Title: Analysis of the Role of Media in Society Considering the Idea of the Public Sphere.

2266 words - 9 pages sphere which mediates between society and state, in which the public organizes itself as the bearer or public opinion, accords with the principle of the public sphere" (Habermas, 1964: p.50). Media also provide for the public a space to express their opinions. According to McGuigan(1998), "the ideal of a domestic system of mass communication can be called 'the public sphere'"(p.91). In this sense, media have the similar functions with the public

Genetic Engineering and the Public

1035 words - 4 pages “Public” “Stakeholders” “Experts” and “Citizens”? The word public often gets thrown around, and in various contexts. For this website we have used a narrow definition similar to the National Academia Press Article in regards to public participation in environmental assessments. The public in this regard is composed of people who are a part of an institutionalized decision making process, and utilize in place mechanisms to express opinions. [3

Human Subconcious. Analysis of the two books "Sphere" and "The left hand of darkness" by Ursula K. Le Guin, and the movie "Enemy mine"

1196 words - 5 pages conflicts, crimes and other problems occur very often. We don't really realize it but mostof these problems are due to our lack of understanding each other and even ourselves... In thissense, we could say that humans are not aware of their own blindness. To prove this I'll beanalyzing two books we read (Sphere & The Left Hand of Darkness) and a movie we saw(Enemy Mine) trying to see what kind of ideas each story shows about human nature.In a first

Serving the Public and the Animals

915 words - 4 pages Serving the Public and the Animals From childhood, most of us have fond memories of going to the zoo. We were entertained by the variety of animals that we were not able to see on a regular basis. Visitors of a zoo get to see exotic, and local animals of that area. Going to a zoo gives children and adults a chance to learn about different animals. Certain zoos also promote the conservation of endangered species. To people of all

Information Literacy and the Public Library

1684 words - 7 pages “providing information literacy support”, and “they have the opportunity to foster the lifelong learning of their communities” (p. 157). The public library has great strengths when it comes to providing information literacy programming. Public libraries have been considered the place to go for continuing education for an extremely long time. Public libraries reach a large range of people on a daily basis. Harding (2008) points out that the library “has a

The Public Presidency Communications and Media

545 words - 3 pages In the chapter entitled “The Public Presidency Communications and Media,” Matthew Eshbaugh-soha argues that media coverage is extremely essential for presidential governance. However, it is challenging to control and adjust to serve presidential purposes, for it is driven by different motives. A president’s goal is to increase coverage surrounding him to obtain support for his policies, while the media wants to sell the best headlines to

media and its influence on the public

1568 words - 6 pages The media is a huge form of communication and source of information in the United States; on one side of the dispute are the beliefs that the media is too opinionated. On the other side are the beliefs that the media is just a simple informer that just reports the facts. The main issue for both of these beliefs is: does the media affect opinions on the issues from opinionated reports, or does it just report the facts that public may already

Similar Essays

The Public Sphere Essay

1161 words - 5 pages The Public Sphere So many definitions are there of the public sphere. One can range from a scale as small as a township to a scale as large as a national government. In the earlier post-revolutionary days of the United States, just what the United States actually was and what it meant were still being defined. Now that the revolution was over, words such as nationalism and patriotism must be

Privatizing The Public Sphere Essay

1603 words - 6 pages Privatizing the Public Sphere The privatization and fragmentation of space in post-industrial urban America is a widespread social problem. As society becomes even more globalized as a result of technological advances, the rampant spread of a privatized public realm is ever-increasing. Public space is needed as a center in which to bring people together to share a common place. It is within public spaces that public life unfolds and

Jürgen Habermas: Public Sphere And Media Sphere

1297 words - 5 pages Habermas’ Public sphere: from the 18th century to today societies Public sphere is a necessary concept to understand our connected world. All the more today with new technologies, we are inter-connected and share a lot through Internet. Jürgen Habermas has conceptualized the public sphere as a place where debates take place and ideas are shared. It is useful in understanding our very connected societies. The question is to acknowledge

The Public Sphere Of Athenian Women

1970 words - 8 pages Women are often excluded from discussion when looking at all periods of history from ancient Greece to our own Canadian history. The lack of sources pertaining to women was likely caused by the traditional view that women are, in some ways, inferior to men. Athenian women are usually studied in two domains: the private sphere and the public sphere. Many studies acknowledge that women are consumed by the family and remain in the home. However