This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Cultural Competence And Informed Consent In Health Care: “Confronting A Fetal Abnormality”

2116 words - 9 pages

“Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see”—Mark Twain. Health care is a profession that should epitomize kindness. Cultural competence, being open-minded to other cultures, is essential for effective and kind healthcare in our current multicultural population. This case analysis will examine the ethical dilemmas, moral theories, principles, alternative actions, and give a recommendation about the morally best action for the case “Confronting a fetal abnormality” by Karen Peterson-Iyer.

At first glance, this case might appear to be ethically sound and the conduct of Dr. Fox was that of a normal Western doctor. However, upon further analysis a large number of issues arise. The debate over whether to inform Leyla about her diagnosis in the above case arises from the conflicting cultural norms between Leyla’s family and the attending physician. One of the main ethical questions is: was it necessary for Dr. Fox to disregard the family’s wishes, religion and cultural norms. By refusing to wait for Mr. Ansari to pray, insisting on telling Leyla himself and interrupting Mrs. Ansari’s prayer, Dr. Fox was insensitive to the patient and family’s religious and cultural needs. Furthermore, insisting on telling Leyla himself, even though he noticed that she was stressed and her family informed him that she was too vulnerable at the time to handle her diagnosis, brings up issues of competence. There is also the issue of informed consent and confidentiality when Dr. Fox employs the friend as a translator without her or Leyla’s authorization. In addition, instead of providing options in the prognosis, Dr. Fox gives a recommendation and does not discuss any other possible prognoses.
Moral Theories and Principles:
Cultural competence is very much a utilitarian paradigm. Dr. Fox’s actions would be a violation of utilitarian custom, specifically the greatest happiness principle that actions are right in proportion they promote happiness, wrong if they bring forth the reverse of happiness. Dr. Fox’s actions did not weigh the interest of the majority; his actions did not result in the greatest amount of happiness to the greatest number of people. Furthermore, if we apply rule utilitarianism to the situation, wherein we accept a rule that states that doctors should disregard religious, cultural views and family wishes, this rule would never be accepted because it does not produce the most good for the most people. (Collier & Haliburton, 5-10)
We would come to similar conclusions that Dr. Fox’s actions were ethically unsound if we apply Kant’s categorical imperative; this test asks that we not make exceptions when doing what is morally required. Dr. Fox violated this by authorizing the friend as a translator and violating Mrs. Ansari’s autonomy. Under normal circumstances, in which there is no communication barrier, Dr. Fox would have informed the patient himself. In this situation, the patient’s, autonomy and confidentiality were...

Find Another Essay On Cultural competence and informed consent in health care: “Confronting a fetal abnormality”

Asian Cultural Diversity and Health Care

1001 words - 5 pages The Asian culture on health care is very interesting and different from western medicine. It is not just drawing blood and finding too many white body blood cells in the blood stream therefore saying there is an impurity. Asian health is more about balance of the body’s mechanics. They believe the mind and body work together, in synchronization in a balanced state. They use a practice called yin and yang, which is hot and cold. The use of

Humanities: Health & Medicine: Case studies Incorporating cultural assessment in the care of families

1806 words - 7 pages verified before taken action (Kumpter, Alvarado, Smith &, Bellamy, 2002). Possible strategies for a successful interview include having an interpreter who is knowledgeable in health care terminology, conducting formal and informal interviews of all family members, and being sincere and honest about the nurse's objectives and the client's needs.Other things to take into consideration are the differences in communication styles, physical space

Informed Consent in Canada

1753 words - 7 pages consequences of not having the treatment.These provisions of the Act are of considerable assistance in understanding the requisite elements of informed consent, the matters in respect of which disclosure should be made to obtain informed consent, and the justifiable presumptions about the scope of consent to treatment that may be made by the health-care practitioner. Section 11 of the Act makes it clear that a healthcare practitioner is obliged to

Informed Consent and Abortion

1963 words - 8 pages Handle Petitions to Waive Parental Consent for Abortion. Iowa L. Rev., 88, 75. Spear, H. J. (2004). Regarding abortion: informed consent or selective disclosure? In nursing forum (Vol. 39, No. 2, pp. 31-32). Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Wenger, A. A. (2006). Fetal Pain Legislation. Journal of Legal Medicine, 27(4), 459-476. Woman's Right to Know Act. (n.d.). NC Department of Health and Human Services. Retrieved April 10, 2014, from

Informed Consent in Healthcare

1828 words - 7 pages The Doctor and Patient relationship aspect of Medicine has changed drastically in the last twenty years. It has evolved from paternalism (the doctor makes the decision for the patient) to shared decision making where the patient is considered an equal partner in his/her own health related decisions. Informed consent is the cornerstone for this view. When a patient or a research subject makes an autonomous decision after understanding, the risks

Informed Consent and Full disclosure

2765 words - 12 pages activity in battery as the fitting hypothesis of recuperation when such consent has not been acquired. A secondary item of informed consent concerns the prerequisite that the consent really given be a knowing consent. Before the operation, the specialist ought to illuminate his patient of the way of the disease, the way of the operation, the conceivable dangers included and the doable choices, so that the patient may keenly choose whether to

Influence of culture on health care practices: How nurses can incorporate cultural sensitivity into their practice

1547 words - 6 pages desire to achieve mutually agreed upon health care goals if the nurse is culturally competent. The purpose of this essay is designed to show the cultural competence in the nursing profession by providing a guide that is useful for implementing cultural sensitivity in nursing education and practice.Diversity. It is a word that means something different to each and every person. Bacote, 2003 asserts that the changing demographics and economics of our

Diversity and Cultural Competence in Family Therapy

2007 words - 8 pages Diversity and Cultural Competence in Family Therapy A therapist will face problems, issues and client troubles everyday. The professional must understand how their client relates to the world around them. These feelings and ideas affect how the client sees the problem and how they respond to their situation. Their actions, in turn, have bearing on individual thoughts, needs, and emotions. The therapist must be aware of the

Cultural Competence in Counseling

697 words - 3 pages Cultural Competence in Counseling Case Study: Jia The case study involves Jia, a 21-year-old Asian American female who immigrated to the United States from China at a young age. The counselor is a 54-year-old Multiracial American who grew up as a foster child living with numerous cultures throughout her life. Cultural Differences between Client and Counselor Many cultural differences lie amid the client and the counselor. The client grew up

Cultural Diversity and Defining Abnormality

851 words - 3 pages in another and therefore psychologist must consider this fact before making a diagnosis. Although the deviation from statistical norm and deviation from ideal mental health definitions are affected by cultural differences as I will discuss briefly later, it is the other two definitions which are affected on a larger scale. The deviation from social norms approach to defining abnormality is a relatively basic

Isolation and confronting the cultural norms in Philip Larkin

3102 words - 13 pages Larkin is than free to question the values of cultural norms based around a the normality of a strictly sexual relationship. The reader’s expectations, indicated by the poems title, would be that the couple are partners in a symmetrical relationship, where discourse and sex would accompany one another. However, Larkin gives no indication that the two talk, only the notion that it should be easy to do. Mazid, again draws clear lines between

Similar Essays

Informed Consent, Refusal, And Competence Essay

1388 words - 6 pages . If all else fails it may be necessary to obtain a court order for care. If the patient is refusing to consent to medical care, the reason behind the refusal is first and fore most. If it has something to do with religious beliefs and the patient has been deemed competent, the doctor must respect the wishes of the patient and attempt to come up with alternate methods of care. An exception to this would be acceptable only in times of

Cultural Competence And Patient Care Outcomes

2149 words - 9 pages competence which includes cultural awareness and cultural sensitivity. Possible Defects in Patient Care Sally actions could cause eruptible damage to Miguel. In order to better understand, it is important to discuss the Hispanic culture. Hispanics have a strong sense of faith. Most Hispanics are Roman Catholics. God plays an important role in determining health care decisions. (Polan & Taylor, 2011). It was inappropriate

Cultural Diversity In The Health Care Setting

2083 words - 9 pages Cultural Diversity in the Health Care Setting Cultural diversity in the health care setting is increasing each year. Knowing how to care for patients of different religious and spiritual faiths is essential to providing high-quality, patient-centered care. The author of this paper will research three lesser-known religions; Taoism, Sikhism and Shamanism. Through this paper, she will provide a brief background on each of the three religions and

Cultural Differences, Health Care And Language

852 words - 4 pages take an important decision such as health treatments. Cultural values are some of many Latino cultural issues that can affect the relationship quality of health care for the Hispanic population in the United States. Personalismo, familismo, spiritismo, respeto and sympatia are some of these values. The first value, personalismo, is a more friendly and appropriate physical interaction with the care giver which is welcomed by the Latino patient. A