Cultural Relativism Vs. Ethnocentism Which Is More Objective?

1023 words - 4 pages

To view one’s own culture as the universal by which all others are judged would be ultimately subjective, as our perceptions of cultural differences are shaped largely by our immersion in our own culture. An ethnocentric approach stems from judging an alternate culture in relation to one’s own pre-conceived cultural values, held to be superior; the parallax phenomenon, the inability to escape our own biases, prevents objective analysis of different cultures. A cultural relativist maintains the post-modernist view that there is no moral or cultural high-ground with which to judge one culture in relation to another, thus each culture must be understood from its own perspective, and within its own context. Some practices may appear bizarre when observed cross-culturally, however, in their own cultural context, they seem quite natural. A relativist approach has its limits, and these boundaries are drawn at cross-cultural universals. Practices such as female genital mutilation and cannibalism are abhorrent from an ethnocentric, western point of view; however relativist thinking requires greater analysis and debate as to whether such abhorrence is purely ethnocentric, or whether such practices break cross-cultural universals. Marriage practices, which vary widely in different cultures require a culturally relativist understanding in order to prevent subjective criticism.
Fundamental to ethnocentrism is the notion of fallibility; there is no infallible, moral or cultural ‘high-ground’ by which all cultures and practices may be judged. Our moral perceptions have their basis in social conditioning and our enculturation into a specific culture (Spiro, 1986, p260) and so objectivity can only arise from distancing the observer from his or her preconceived ideas of what is correct and what is morally acceptable. The key to distancing oneself from one’s preconceptions is through relativism; thorough knowledge and understanding of one’s own values and the ‘subtle value-laden assumptions [that] creep into sociological research’ (Weber, 1949, as cited in Jureidini & Poole, 2003, p68).
Social prejudice and a human propensity for ethnocentrism cause observers of a culture other than their own to judge such practices and beliefs as peculiar, yet ‘many of our own practices are peculiar when viewed through the lenses of other cultures’ (Karp, 1990, p74-75, cited in Schultz & Lavenda, 2005, p24). In the Trobriand Islands, the native people’s fear of female sexual power and pollution would seem alien and bizarre from any externally ethnocentric outlook (Glass, 1988, p56). This view would be essentially subjective, as it relies upon the biases of the observer; the judgement is superficial and does not require any further understanding of the context of the Trobriand’s fears. From a cultural relativist’s perspective, the subject requires contextual understanding before judgement. The Islanders’ history of attack from rival Dobu islanders with a propensity for...

Find Another Essay On Cultural Relativism vs. Ethnocentism - which is more objective?

Bretton Woods vs. Protest – Which is More Effective in the Fight Against Global Injustice?

2563 words - 10 pages Bretton Woods vs. Protest – Which is More Effective in the Fight Against Global Injustice? The highlight of the anti-globalization movements came in 1999, when protesters lined the streets of Seattle, the location of a meeting of the World Trade Organization (WTO). A theme had been building, and it seemed to come to a head at Seattle: wherever the WTO, International Monetary Fund (IMF), or World Bank met, protesters would follow

The Scientific Account of Inductivism vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

1023 words - 4 pages being applied to most Earth-bound phenomena - in other words, phenomena with speeds insignificant compared to the speed of light. Chalmers then claims that science is objective. (Chalmers, 1976) This further implies that inductive inference in itself is objective. Falsificationists disagree with this view. They reason there are two ways in which induction could possibly be justified: either priori or posteriori, in other words, logically or

Philosophy: Reason vs. Revelation, Asses the extent to which faith is more valid if based on reason rather than revelation

762 words - 3 pages Faith is a belief that God exists and a trust in him. Some believe thatfaith should be based on reason and others that it should be based on revelation. There are two types of revelation. Propositional revelation is direct communication between God and humanity, during which truths about religion are conveyed. In many cases these are in the form of holy books, the Bible, Qur'an and the Torah for example. However that authority may come through

Spain Vs. Portugal: Which Colonial System Was More Effective?

753 words - 3 pages Spain vs. Portugal: Which Colonial System Was More Effective? Spain and Portugal can be considered two of the greatest colonial powers in history, each having ruled their respective empires for more than three centuries. These imperial powers owed their accomplishments to different concepts of organization and ultimately the Spanish method was more successful. The Spanish administrative system was well organized, making land grants and

Kehde’s vs. Bandana’s. Which is better?

898 words - 4 pages Barbeque in the Midwest is taken very seriously, and there are several fantastic restaurants around. I dined at two of the finest in Sedalia. It was an extremely close race, but of the two, I preferred the mouth-watering food of Bandana’s Barbeque. When it comes to a unique atmosphere, it is pretty hard to beat the setting of Kehde’s Barbeque. The restaurant is an old train car called the “Kehde Flyer” which truly makes it one of a kind. It

Cats Vs. Dogs: Which is better?

1359 words - 6 pages dog owners are physically healthier that cat owners. For me, the reason for this is that most dogs are very playful, hyper and active. Cats are lazy. They just hide and take a nap. They will only go outside when they want to. Dog owners walk more than cat owners. The reason why is that they take their dogs for a walk. I also see people running or sometimes, even swimming with their dogs. I do not see people running or swimming with cats. Cats

Craft Unions Compared to Industrial Unions: Which is more effective?

1888 words - 8 pages With the advent of an industrialized working class in the mid nineteenth century, and more complicated and permanent forms of labour relations, workers formed networks to turn their shared experiences, problems, and interests into a collective political and economic force for change. These organizations came to be known as labour unions (Godard 86). Although "unions" are often spoken of as single entities, in reality, no one union is responsible

The Journey or The Transformation: Which is More Important?

1979 words - 8 pages transformation is more about the transformation, or the journey itself. Although the transformation is the end result on who we are to be, the path that leads us there, the journey we humans take on is the most influential aspect of the journey of transformation, as seen through the ideas of action, devotion, and knowledge taken out from excerpts of the Bhagavad Gita. The Bhagavad Gita is the song of the god Krishna, created in order to spread

Public vs. Private Schools - Which is Best for a Child

2135 words - 9 pages . The debate over which is better is a battle that has gone on since private schools were first introduced as an alternative. It seems most people are of the opinion that private schools are superior; the issue is simply if it is worth the money. However, this may not be the case. Therefore, how does one gauge the superiority of a school? This very difficult question has no easy answers. The most common and maybe the only way that researchers can

Corrections: Rehabilitation Is More Effective Than Retribution vs

1550 words - 6 pages assault is common, isolation is a mental challenge and the overall environment is an emotional nightmare. Prison is a very unhealthy place for anyone but even more of a detriment to our most vulnerable members of prison society; youth offenders, those with low IQ’s and mental retardation. Life without parole is in essence negating a person from existence without actually killing the individual. It is considered a mercy to be given life with the

Which is more effective at bringing about political change, political parties or social movements?

1621 words - 7 pages The purpose of this essay will be to determine whether New social movements or New politics parties are more effective with bringing about change with a focus on green politics. I will look at the structures of a political system that enables Green political parties to gain representation. Often Green political parties start from grassroots social movements, which can make it difficult to separate the influence that they have on policy change

Similar Essays

Wood Vs. Steel Which Is More Environmentally Friendly?

616 words - 3 pages For over many years mankind has tried to make are world more eco-friendly efficient. People have discussed many different examples like gas vs. electricity, paper vs. plastic, or even wood vs. steel. All these objects have something in common and that is that they all benefit society in some kind of way. People have done research about one of the examples more specifically, wood vs. steel and found pros and cons for both. Steel is more

What Exactly Is Cultural Relativism In Metaethics? Is Cultural Relativism True? Can Cultural Relativists Uphold The Principle Of Cultural Tolerance?

2125 words - 9 pages Metaethics is a branch of ethics that explores normative ethical questions concerning what it means be 'good'; the existence of objective and absolute values; the source of our values; and the nature of our moral judgments. Cultural relativism is a theory within the domains of metaethics which attempts to answer these questions, but in doing so raises its own problematic questions, such as whether or not we can be culturally tolerant and not

(Educating Rita Willy Russell) Russell Uses The Contrast Between Frank And Rita's Cultural Backgrounds To Make Both Comic And Serious Points. Which Of These Do You Find More Effective?

1293 words - 5 pages Educating Rita deals with many cultural issues. Some of these are addressed in a serious manner, while others are presented humorously.By such cultural issues, the play is given an ambiguous tone, with a mood which is serious yet in many places comic. By examining examples of both comic and serious points we may understand more clearly which are more effective, and central to the play, as a whole.~At very beginning of Educating Rita, the

"What Exactly Is "Cultural Relativism" In Metaethics? Is Cultural Relatisim True? Can Cultural Relativists Uphold The Principle Of Cultural Tolerance?

2380 words - 10 pages relativist knows that in doing this he allows the concept of standard moral principles that all societies must adhere to which thus weakens his claims.Even in its objectives cultural relativism is incorrect. When looked upon as a whole, cultural relativism's main objective is to promote tolerance. Tolerance is the idea that one must be accepting of another person's beliefs, values, principles even if they stand in conflict of one's own. If all