Darwin’s Evolutionary Gender Theory Flaw Essay

1736 words - 7 pages

Darwin was a product of his time and with his time came the ideas of sexism and racism which were clearly integrated into his theories. There are some facets of Darwin’s theory about the differences in men and women which can be explained by biology but overall, it is clear that his theory is based on the sexist ideas prevalent in the 1800s. Women are expected to be caring, selfless, maternal, and submissive while men are expected to be dominant, aggressive, successful and confident. Most of Darwin’s theory relating to the differences in men and women can be explained by social expectations which have shaped what is acceptable in society.
Recent studies show that women are seen as the emotional sex across cultures (Crawford and Unger). Darwin says, “[w]oman seems to differ from man in mental disposition, chiefly in her greater tenderness and less selfishness; and this holds good even with savages…” (Darwin 234). This is simply an observation of socially imposed standards which Darwin considers evolutionary traits. Darwin’s assumption on mental dispositions leading to differences in male and female attitudes can be explained by the stereotypes instilled within people. Gender stereotypes begin to form in children by age five and are typically completely ingrained by the end of adolescence (Crawford and Unger). Women are expected to be tender and caring for others, as well as submissive. Although none of this is to say that stereotyping is bad, as it is a normal process, it just explains why this is because of social factors and not biological ones.
A study was conducted to see people’s reactions to angry and sad faces of men and women. When these two faces were blended together, as in, the angry woman and sad woman were blended together, as well as the men, people saw sadness more in women’s faces than anger and the opposite for men (Crawford and Unger). This shows stereotypes at work. Another study found that women who were scared during horror movies were more sexually attractive to men, while men who showed no fear were more sexually attractive to women (Crawford and Unger). Granted, this is not necessarily an example that could be applied to Darwin’s time, but the concept of women being scared and men overcoming their fear is still important to understand.
Psychologist Jean Baker Miller theorized that because women are subordinate in society, they develop to reflect this (Crawford and Unger). So, in order to survive, they must be adaptive to their position. However, this development is carried through social influences rather than biological ones. Women thus become intuitive because they must be aware of behaviors so they can react appropriately. This explains Darwin’s assumption that “[i]t is generally admitted that with woman the powers of intuition, of rapid perception, and perhaps of imitation, are more strongly marked than in man…” (Darwin 234). Although Miller’s theory has been questioned because it does not encompass cultural...

Find Another Essay On Darwin’s Evolutionary Gender Theory Flaw

Genetics and Human Sexuality Essay

1574 words - 7 pages principle of Darwin’s evolution theory. Biologically it is impossible for two organisms of the same genetic gender to reproduce. The existence of life without reproduction is the subject of some speculation. The biological study of how the origin of life led from non-reproducing elements to reproducing organisms is called abiogenesis. Abiogenesis is the natural process by which life arose from non-living matter such as simple organic compounds

The Evolution of High Heels Essay

1488 words - 6 pages . Therefore, the principle underlying, function and structure of high heels remains unchanged among individual high heels. Such features are inherited and passing from generation to generation. Darwin suggested such variation is prominent to every new species formed. Conclusion Darwin’s Theory of Evolution gives the foundation of evolutionary biology, proposing the mechanism of evolution. By studying the development of high heels, they shows

Social Darwinism: An Ideology for Mass Murder

1098 words - 5 pages In 1859, a new philosophy promoting the theory of evolution was introduced to the world by Charles Darwin in his book, The Origin of Species. In this work, Darwin espoused humans evolve by struggling through a process of natural selection, rather than by the influence of a divine creator. Darwin’s view of this evolutionary struggle came to be described simply as “survival of the fittest.” Although Darwin cannot be blamed for the Holocaust

Critical Review: Bradley A. Thayer, Bring in Darwin: Evolutionary theory, Realism, and International Relations

1203 words - 5 pages In Thayer’s article, he makes an attempt to incorporate Darwin’s Evolutionary Theory into the international security studies. The article tries to answer a central question that what are the implications of Evolutionary theory to realist theory of international security and in what way can peace be achieved if warfare is part of human nature? This paper agrees with Thayer that Evolutionary theory provides a scientific theory foundation for

Bio Literary Task

1664 words - 7 pages Introduction Research question – How has the study of DNA fingerprinting and modern genetics supported Darwin’s Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection, thus making it the most widely accepted mechanism for evolution to date? The aim of this scientific report is to provide evidence on how DNA fingerprinting and modern genetics have supported Darwin’s Theory of Evolution. Aspects such as the use of DNA fingerprinting and the study of genetics

Contradiction Between the Theory of Evolution and the Bible

1171 words - 5 pages The Origin of Species. This book was the beginning of what we know about evolution, and it was controversial. The book brought disputations between devoted christians and darwinists on the validity of evolution. During that period of time, most Europeans believed that the world was created by God in seven days and thought evolution was challenging the existence of God. Darwin’s theory of evolution challenges traditional beliefs by contradicting the

The Process of Evolution

1375 words - 6 pages natural selection (15).Genetic drift will continue until the involved allele is either lost in the population or is the only allele presents it the population (16).Genetic drift causes a new population which is genetically distinct from its original population, which led to a hypothesis that genetic drift plays in a role of the evolutionary mechanism. The theory of evolution and the mechanisms as scientist knows as today, were originally not

The Evolution of Sex

2520 words - 10 pages the past 600 million years. Next, a discussion on Darwin’s theories of natural selection and sexual selection and their role in evolutionary theory will be presented. In addition, this paper will include a thorough examination of the different forms of reproduction; the history, current state, and future of human sexual reproduction; and various other interesting topics relating to the evolution of sex. Reproduction Wilson (1975) notes that an

Charles Robert Darwin and his Revolutionary Ideas

1306 words - 6 pages (www.britannica.com). It went through six revisions during Darwin’s lifetime. Interestingly, Darwin created his theory of Natural Selection much earlier than its publication, but kept it secret, save a few people, due to the religious views of the time. In fact, Darwin stated that “believing in evolution was like ‘confessing a murder’” (as cited, www.britannica.com). There were also other manuscripts written by Darwin that were never published or

Teaching Origins in 20th Century American Public Schools

6468 words - 26 pages scientist who found a basic flaw or a genuine, deep gap in evolutionary theory would be an overnight celebrity." This is the case science has built for evolution, and why scientists, educators, and many Americans feel that evolution must be taught in public schools. Creationists, as we will see, have built many cases against evolutionary theory, and against the soundness of teaching it in schools. A Catalogue of Today’s Creationists

galapagos islands

958 words - 4 pages each developed differently, according to the ecosystem of the island. Moreover, the finches on the Galapagos Islands was twofold they played a pivotal movement on Darwin’s original theory of biological evolution, through the idea of natural selection due to environmental conditions and introgressive hybridization. The research, Darwin performed and the species he had brought back to England from his expedition were noteworthy to the

Similar Essays

Short Essay: Darwinism In Psychology

812 words - 4 pages field, evolutionary psychology. Today, evolutionary psychology is an emerging, and still growing, field. Darwin’s evolutionary theory provided the framework to develop a new perspective, and thus field, in psychology. By applying Darwin’s approach and theories to psychology, we have created a new way at looking at the evolution of humanity and human behavior Evolutionary psychology is the study of psychological human adaptions to physical or

Darwin's Theories Vs. The Fossil Record: A Philosophic Challenge

1300 words - 5 pages been observed— not even in bacteria. This leaves a gaping and inexplicable hole in Darwin’s theory; there is no scientific evidence for its foundational pre-supposition that primary speciation could occur through natural selection. Mounting scientific research on embryos and vestigial organs further undermines the evolutionary theory. Evolution claims that in a vertebrate, the embryonic stage is the similar among all organisms. Famed scientist

A Philosophic Challenge Essay

1156 words - 5 pages were capable of flying. (Werner 101). Fish provide yet another counterexample. Each fish family originated suddenly in the fossil record, creating a challenge for the gradual change evolution suggests (Werner 96). If evolutionary theory is in fact valid, there would be fossil records to demonstrate the transformation from invertebrates to current day vertebrate fish. Darwin’s speculations on evolution simply are not supported by the fossil record

Theory Of Evolution’s Effect On Humanity

1499 words - 6 pages Genesis seems incompatible with the gradual evolution of humans and other organisms by natural processes. Independently of the biblical narrative, the Christian beliefs in the immortality of the soul and in humans as “created in the image of God” have appeared to many as contrary to the evolutionary origin of humans from nonhuman animals” (Ayala). Scores of religious groups were shaken up over Darwin’s work, and originally denounced his theory as