This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

David Abraham And The Weimar Republic

4327 words - 17 pages

David Abraham

"Grave Offenses" vs. "Tendentious Misconstruals" The David Abraham Case
The historical field concerning the Weimar Republic, Germany's parliamentary government during the interwar years, is not only an extremely sophisticated area of study, but an extremely competitive one as well. In the early eighties, a much heated and unprecedented scholarly dispute arose surrounding The Collapse of the Weimar Republic, written by David Abraham - at the time, a fledgling historian and assistant professor at Princeton University. Nazi seizure of power from the Weimar Republic has long intrigued scores of historians. Various models have been constructed in an attempt to explain how an entity such as the Nazi movement came to power over such an industrially, culturally, and socially advanced society such as Germany's (Notes from Jamie van Hook 2/14).
One such model, and the one used in Abraham's book, seeks to illustrate the role of capitalism, German industrialists, in the fall of the Weimar Republic (Notes from Jamie van Hook 2/14). More specifically, Abraham attempts to decipher: "how did Germany's divided economic elites attempt to articulate a national agenda around which they could unite, how and from whom was popular support won (if it was); how could the institutionalization of accord first work and then fail?" Initially, the book received favorable reviews; it was called "imaginative and interesting" and "distinguished, " among other praises. But alas, high praises gave way to harsh, uncivil criticisms. Abraham was attacked for having a "fanatical attachment to his preconceived notions " and a "complete insensitivity to and lack of interest in what actually took place in the past. " The controversy ultimately ended with David Abraham being effectively ostracized from the historical community.

So how did Abraham's book go from being deemed "the most important book on 20th century Germany written in the last 15 years " to being called "fraudulent? " What was the reasoning behind Abraham's downward spiral? Why did the events surrounding Abraham escalade into an academic crucifixion rather than culminating in nothing more than a passionate academic debate? Abraham's Marxist-like viewpoints might have something to do with it. Here, the word "Marxist-like" is used because although Abraham himself acknowledged the pronounced Marxist influences in his book, he had hoped his work would be distinguished from "recent Marxist scholarship and debates. " However, the situation calls for more complicated reasoning; after all, Abraham was not the only "Marxist" historian. Jon Wiener points out that if Abraham had written a Marxist study about the Weimar Republic that did not discuss the role of businessmen, Henry Turner would probably not have bothered to check his footnotes. If he had written a Marxist theoretical essay on the Weimar Republic that did not include archival evidence, Turner would not have been interested. Jon Weiner concludes:...

Find Another Essay On David Abraham and the Weimar Republic

Collapse of the Weimar Republic Essay

1555 words - 6 pages Collapse of the Weimar Republic “On 2 August 1934, President Hindenburg died. Within an hour of his death Hitler announced that the offices of chancellor and president were to be combined and that he was the new head of state. Hitler’s adolescent dream of becoming Fuhrer of the German people had been realized” President Hindenburg’s death marked the official end of the Weimar Republic, a democratic ‘experiment’ that had lasted since

The Collapse of the Weimar Republic

835 words - 3 pages The Collapse of the Weimar Republic There are a various number of reasons for the downfall of the Weimar republic and the establishment of the one party rule, including Hitler's appeal, however it was his consolidation of power 1933-1934 which was largely responsible for the collapse of the Weimar regime. Factors such as the Enabling Act of 1933, the Reichstag fire, the use of the SA, and the banning of all

The Fall of the Weimar Republic

1412 words - 6 pages The Weimar Republic would have continued to be a functional government far longer than achieved if not for the defeat of WWI, the economic burdens imposed by the Versailles Treaty, and the flawed Article 48 which all contributed to the down fall of Germany’s first attempt at a legitimate Democracy. This paper will argue that the societal, economical, and constitutional aspects all played a role in the hopeless Democracy Germany attempted which

The Fall of the Weimar Republic

822 words - 3 pages Fall of the Weimar Republic>> 1) Background> * The fall of the Weimar Republic goes hand in hand with the> rise of Hitler and the Nazi regime> * The Weimar Republic came into existence after WWI and> promised to give democracy, freedom of speech, return to the 8-hour> workday, and improvements in social security.> * The more power Hitler got, the closer he got to becoming a> complete dictator which would obviously put

The Failure of the Weimar Republic

2064 words - 8 pages The Failure of the Weimar Republic The Weimar Republic survived to years of greater internal peace from the mid-1920s, when the political problems were covered, until exposure by the economic and political crises of 1929, Hitler’s appointment as German Chancellor in 1933 was more or less the most important event of the 20th century. The most direct causes for the collapse of the first German democracy must be

The Culture of the Weimar Republic

607 words - 2 pages The Weimar Republic was struggling with lots of political problems, so it had to take the culture seriously, if it did not want it to be forgotten by their own society. The most productive city in arts and sciences in the 1920s was Berlin - the capital of the Republic. At this time German artists made important cultural contributions in making new movies. American movies became popular in Germany because the stories were simple, there were lots

Weimar Republic- The Weimar Republic Was An Overall Failure And Created The Right Social, Political And Economic Conditions For The Rise Of Extremist Groups Like The Nazi Party

1540 words - 7 pages The Weimar Republic!Even though the Weimar Republic had a high point from 1924-1929, it was overall a failure and created the right social, political and economic conditions for the rise of extremist groups like the Nazi party.There were many factors that contributed to the failure of the Weimar Republic of Germany. These includedThe unresolved defeat of Germany 1918 in WW1- where the German government signed an armistice on behalf of Germany

Structural Problem of the Weimar Republic

1448 words - 6 pages On January 1933 Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Weimar Republic in Germany, six months later he consolidated power and became dictator. What follows is an account of the steps Hitler took to consolidate power. On February 27th 1933 The Reichstag, the parliamentary building in Germany is burned to the ground by arsons. A Dutch Communist by the name of van der Lubbe is caught in the act. In addition to this two other suspects with Communist

Immediate problems facing the Weimar Republic

540 words - 2 pages The Weimar republic was a democratic government in Germany created shortly after the first Great War (1919). It was named after the city in which the constitution was first created. This new government was meant to be the best solution for the Germans, but it was a failure because of the inefficiency of the constitution, various rebellions and the invasion- Inflation crisis in 1923.The first problem faced by the Weimar republic was its

Collapse of the Weimar Republic and the Rise of the Nazis

1382 words - 6 pages Collapse of the Weimar republic/ Rise of the Nazis This essay will examine how the lack of effective opposition and the weakness of the Weimar, was a major factor in the Nazis rising to power between 1919 and 1933. On the 28th of June 1919, a peace treaty, also known as the treaty of Versailles, was signed, ending the First World War. The treaty had a humiliating effect causing great resentment. Germany had no choice but to accept the

Discuss the successes and failures of the Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929

2051 words - 8 pages The Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929 had many successes and failures, starting in chaos and ending in relative stability. However, due to individual perspective these successes and failures were often viewed as both successes and failures- not either. Class, political leanings and other moralistic beliefs, primarily influenced the individual's perspectives. Overall, due to the relative stability, (the aim of any government) primarily achieved

Similar Essays

The Weimar Republic Essay

854 words - 3 pages The Weimar Republic The Weimar Republic was created in Germany in 1918 as a result of widespread socialist unrest. A liberal constitution was drawn up in 1919. There was extensive instability in Germany around this time. The Weimar government had trouble pleasing right and left wing parties because, at this time, Germany was very polarised politically. Hitler dissolved the republic in 1933. But was it doomed from it's

The Weimar Republic Essay

856 words - 3 pages The Weimar Republic was formed shortly after World War 1 by the victorious allied powers. The allies believed it was necessary to set up a new government in Germany. This new government was plagued by social, political, and economical problems. The country was constantly in conflict with itself due to the fighting between the Left and Right wings of the government. Try to expand your sentences. They are mostly 'subject verb object'. The

The Weimar Republic In Germany Essay

593 words - 2 pages The Weimar Republic first began after the devastation Germany experienced in World War 1. Germany needed an organized government to recover money, land, and respect from the other European countries. The Weimar Republic proved to be the answer, and although it first came under intense dislike and scrutiny, it later led Germany into economic prosper. Although it overcame one crisis, it could not survive the second crisis encountered in 1929

Artists In The Weimar Republic Essay

923 words - 4 pages Weimar CultureIn the period after the First World War, the Weimar republic was in a deep political struggle. However, its culture was flourishing. The culture was already present in pre-war Germany, but the Weimar Republic and its promotion of free thinking allowed these ideas to surface. Among the many great cultural achievements are the art and literature, and these survived because of the emigration of the artists to the United States.The art