David Foster Wallace’s Essay Consider The Lobster

1727 words - 7 pages

Consider the Audience

The gluttonous lords of the land capture those who are unable to defend themselves, boil the captives alive, and then feast on their flesh. Could this be the plot of some new summer blockbuster? It could be, in fact, but for now we will focus on how this depiction of events compares to David Foster Wallace’s essay, “Consider the Lobster,” which starts as a review of the Maine Lobster Festival, but soon morphs into an indictment of not only the conventions of lobster preparation, but also the entire idea of having an animal killed for one’s own consumption. Wallace shows great skill in establishing ethos. In the essay, he succeeds in snaring a receptive audience by laying out a well-baited trap for an audience who was looking for something else altogether, but he ultimately fails to keep hold of much of his catch.
The piece in question was written for and published in Gourmet magazine. Presumably, the readers of that publication have already made up their minds about what they like to eat. A philosophical treatise on animal rights is probably not high on their reading list. In order to suck these readers in, Wallace hides his disdain for the subject matter inside cynical and ironic language. In his opening sentence, Wallace refers to the Maine Lobster Festival as “enormous, pungent, and extremely well-marketed” (252). This is an effective turn of phrase in that each reader assigns his or her own values to those adjectives. While an optimist sees in his mind’s eye a large, aromatic party filled with revelers from all over the continent, a pessimist pictures a crowded, stinky mess which has sold out for the money. Wallace draws them both in with his careful use of language.
The words “optimist” and “pessimist” need further exploration. In the above example, they represent the two aspects of Wallace’s audience. Unfortunately, the words themselves are not a perfect fit for the duality of the readership. For our purposes, we will say that most of the Gourmet readers are probably in the “optimist” crowd, but they are also the omnivores typical of the Standard American Diet: they will eat anything so long as it is expertly prepared and tasty. The “pessimists” are the segment of Wallace’s readership who are actually most receptive to his arguments. The reasons behind any particular reader’s membership in this group are numerous: the reader may be a vegetarian, or opposed to the typical method of lobster preparation, or may just be opposed to commercial fishing and/or commercialized food festivals. The specific reasons are not important; what is important is that Wallace does not have to fight to keep this audience: he just has to keep from alienating them. It is the optimists for whom he must fight.
Wallace must tread a careful path in the opening four pages of his article. In this stage, if his language is too negative, he will lose the optimist majority, but if he caters to that portion of his audience...

Find Another Essay On David Foster Wallace’s essay Consider the Lobster

Write an essay that compares and contrasts JK Rowling's novel Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone with its film adaptation. You should consider matters of form and technique in your essay.

953 words - 4 pages The novel, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, is a great success. People from all over the world are crazy about it. Due to the popularity of the novel, a film was produced in correspondence to the literacy text. In this essay, the matters of form and techniques used in the novel and its film adaptation will be compared and contrasted.Novel and film creates different impact on people. Reading of the novel requires imagining of the scene

everyone should get check-ups regularly By david george this essay is about why everyone should get physician aided check-ups regularly and some of the psychological effects that might occur.

533 words - 2 pages Everyone should get check-ups regularlyThrough time people have become more and more afraid of physicians. This results in fewer and fewer doctor or dentist visitations. This is not a good habit to fall into. Everyone should get regular doctor and dentist check-ups. The reason for this is to prevent loss of teeth, diseases, and many other things.Firstly, if you started to loose your teeth this would be a very unattractive thing. Many people try

Behind the Scenes: the Lobster

1114 words - 5 pages David Foster Wallace, and award winning novelist, student of Harvard University, essayist, and professor, is the author of “Consider the Lobster,” which is an essay that was posted in Gourmet Magazine in 2004. This essay observes the yearly Maine Lobster Festival and explains how it can and possibly is a violation of animal rights, but more specifically , lobster rights. The article has a very broad audience, which can include animal right


1039 words - 5 pages Lobster Festival, the lobster population would continue to grow and chaos would be brought into their living environment causing the food chain to become unbalanced. David Foster Wallace’s “Consider the Lobster” is mostly about lobsters and how they get treated by the people who cook them. He first begins by talking about the Maine Lobster Festival where lobsters are the main attraction to tourists who pay a visit there. The lobsters are all cooked on

The Ethics of Killing an Intelligent Species

1852 words - 7 pages research of chimpanzees, Jane redefined what it meant to be a human; she observed the social behavior and emotions of chimps, characteristics thought to be unique to humans.  This discovery changed the way people regarded their primate relatives and lead to more humane treatment of nonhumans. In David Foster Wallace’s essay Consider the Lobster, he addressed the moral and ethical considerations when killing an animal.  Part of the justification for

The Rough Life of a Lobster

1260 words - 6 pages damaging to both lobster populations and the image of humanity as a whole and should no longer continue in our society. Works Cited Foster, Wallace. “Consider the Lobster.” Mercury Reader. Compiled by Marisa Carlson. Ed. Jancie Neuleib, Kathleen Shine Cain, and Stephen Ruffus. Boston: Pearson, 2014. 159- 177. Print “The Luckiest Lobster.” Radiolab. WNYC Radio, 12 July 2010. Web. 27 April 2014

Good People, by David Foster Wallace

1027 words - 4 pages David Foster Wallace’s “Good People,” is a very touching, powerful story about a young, unwed, Christian couple facing an extremely difficult decision and the moral and religious implications that may result. As the story begins, we are allowed into the head of Lane Dean, a college student, as he sits on a park bench with his girlfriend, Sheri. Lane and Sheri find themselves faced with an unplanned pregnancy, which causes them to battle with

Knowledge: The Educated Fellow vs. The Working Fella

901 words - 4 pages novelist, David Foster Wallace said in his 2005 Kenyon Commencement Speech: “a liberal arts education is not so much about filling you up with knowledge as it is about ‘teaching you how to think.’” Wallace’s notion, in other words, suggests what he believes to be the true value of a post-secondary, liberal arts education. That it consciously guides us in choosing how and what to perceive in certain situations, in turn allowing us a choice in

Comparison Essay of Two Resturants

1123 words - 4 pages factors of choosing a place to eat. In this essay I will compare and contrast two of the world's most renowned restaurants Denny's and Red Lobster. Red Lobster and Denny's are two typical food service establishments. Red Lobster, however offers a wide menu selection, a specific purpose, exuberant atmosphere, and excellent service that keeps customers coming back.Red Lobster was founded in 1968 by Bill Darden at the age of 19. Mr. Darden opened

Scotland’s Superman; William Wallace

2360 words - 9 pages was knighted and made Guardian of Scotland, the first individual to hold this office. After the death of Alexander III in 1286, the Scots, fearful of civil war, placed the government of the nation in the hands of men known as ‘custodes’ or ‘Guardians’. When we consider the composition of the first Guardians – two bishops, two earls, and two barons – we begin to understand the nature of Wallace’s achievement. (Crann Tara) After the awful pummeling

Lifelong Learner

952 words - 4 pages whispers during naptime, I quickly ensured that every child and teacher in my pre-school class was well-informed about this reproductive quirk unique to the seahorse. The website of a famous liberal-arts college cites a quote from alumnus David Foster Wallace’s Infinite Jest: “’’ I read,’ I say, ‘I study and read. I bet I’ve read everything you’ve read. Don’t think I haven’t. I consume libraries. I wear out spines and ROM-drives. I do things like

Similar Essays

Consider The Lobster, By David Foster Wallace

1670 words - 7 pages I really value health that I wouldn't mind spending a lot of money on it especially when it comes to food. I'm a health buff but I am not trying to be a Vegan but reading Consider the Lobster by David Foster Wallace makes me curious in some way. Suppose that animal does feel the pain and suffers like human being? Boiling lobster to be specific, when you're about to cook them, do they somehow suffer, feel the pain, or have this

Child Abuse An Essay About The Books"A Child Called It" And "The Lost Boy." Written By David Pelzer

757 words - 3 pages care field. David Pelzer shares his experiences as a victim of child abuse in his autobiographies "A Child Called It," and "The Lost Boy." Without the interference of his school nurse, it is possible that Mr. Pelzer would not have survived his childhood.Signs of child abuse are actually very easy to see. Some of the many signs of child abuse are; aggressive, disruptive, and sometimes illegal behavior; anger and rage, or feelings of sadness or

David Williamson. Essay Dealing With Themes/Ideas In Williamson's "The Club" And "The Removalists"

1898 words - 8 pages Part AIn his play The Club, David Williamson presents numerous Australian attitudes of the 1970s. However, many of these attitudes are still relevant and fairly accurate representations of Australian attitudes in the 1990s, although some of course have changed somewhat over the time since the play was written nearly twenty years ago.Tradition plays a very important part in The Club. Each of the characters of course has his own ideas and

This Essay Is About "What Makes A Meaningful Life" And "Why Are We Here?" In Reference To The Movie "Contact" With Jody Foster.

628 words - 3 pages Early on, Ellie was curious about communicating to far away lands. Her father, Ted, helped arouse her interest in distant communication by showing her how to use a HAM radio. She asks her dad if it could be possible to talk to someone on the moon with her radio. He says "Well, if it's a big enough radio, I don't see why not." This leads her to question if it could be possible to talk to her mom if she had such a radio. Ellie's mother died when